Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / DoomEternal

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Most of the ARC revers the Slayer as a guardian angel if not a god, so I doubt that. [[WatsonianVsDoylist My Watsonian side]] says that the Slayer wanted to give the grunt a reminder that he's the only one who can really handle this and to stay out of his way. My Doylist side says that they probably originally intended for this part to happen earlier on in the game and that this would be how you got the Plasma Rifle, but changes to the gameplay flow and narrative structure shunted it too late in the campaign. It was a great moment (one that they showed in the initial gameplay blowout at QuakeCon 2018 to thunderous applause) that they clearly spent a lot of time perfecting and they couldn't stand taking it out.



** I’d like to add a line of dialogue from Hayden. While in Taras Nabad, he mention something about how Argent D’Nur has fallen, and how Earth will be different, “”this time””.

to:

** I’d like to add a line of dialogue from Hayden. While in Taras Nabad, he mention something about how Argent D’Nur has fallen, and how Earth will be different, “”this time””.
“this time”.




to:

** One of the codexes describes Urdak's location as being on another plane of existence/dimension like Hell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** All demons are the corrupted and remade husks of he souls of those taken by Hell. The Icon works with Hell for the same reason that all other demons do.



* What is the connection between Samuel Hayden and [[spoiler:Samur Maykr]]?

to:

* What is the connection between Samuel Hayden and [[spoiler:Samur Maykr]]?Samur Maykr?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Is Urdak AnotherDimension like Hell or just another planet?

to:

* Is Urdak AnotherDimension like Hell or just another planet?planet?

* What is the connection between Samuel Hayden and [[spoiler:Samur Maykr]]?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If the Icon Of Sin is the Betrayer's son, why does he cooperate with the demons if they made him this way? Shouldn't he hate them just as much as the Doomslayer?

to:

* If the Icon Of Sin is the Betrayer's son, why does he cooperate with the demons if they made him this way? Shouldn't he hate them just as much as the Doomslayer?Doomslayer?

*Is Urdak AnotherDimension like Hell or just another planet?

Added: 163

Changed: -24

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I’d like to add a line of dialogue from Hayden. While in Taras Nabad, he mention something about how Argent D’Nur has fallen, and how Earth will be different, “”this time””.

to:

** I’d like to add a line of dialogue from Hayden. While in Taras Nabad, he mention something about how Argent D’Nur has fallen, and how Earth will be different, “”this time””.time””.

* If the Icon Of Sin is the Betrayer's son, why does he cooperate with the demons if they made him this way? Shouldn't he hate them just as much as the Doomslayer?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Maybe the Dark Lord?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I’d like to add a line of dialogue from Hayden. While in Taras Nabad, he mention something about how Argent D’Nur has fallen, and how Earth will be different, ‘’’this time’’’.

to:

** I’d like to add a line of dialogue from Hayden. While in Taras Nabad, he mention something about how Argent D’Nur has fallen, and how Earth will be different, ‘’’this time’’’.“”this time””.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's heavily implied even in ''2016'' that the Slayer came from an alternate Earth, as the UAC scientists noted how the Slayer's Praetor armor appears to be of Earth origin, but can't trace its source. ''Eternal'' also shows that both the Argent D'Nur empire and Hell spanned across multiple dimensions, so it's not out of the question the Slayer happened to find his way over from an alternate Earth through Hell.

to:

** It's heavily implied even in ''2016'' that the Slayer came from an alternate Earth, as the UAC scientists noted how the Slayer's Praetor armor appears to be of Earth origin, but can't trace its source. ''Eternal'' also shows that both the Argent D'Nur empire and Hell spanned across multiple dimensions, so it's not out of the question the Slayer happened to find his way over from an alternate Earth through Hell.Hell.
** I’d like to add a line of dialogue from Hayden. While in Taras Nabad, he mention something about how Argent D’Nur has fallen, and how Earth will be different, ‘’’this time’’’.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Is this the same earth the Slayer is from? it is now confirmed that the slayer is the original Doomguy, but in the original games hell had already invaded earth once, so is this an alternate earth that has yet to be subjected to that fate or did everyone just collectively forget that fact?

to:

* Is this the same earth the Slayer is from? it is now confirmed that the slayer is the original Doomguy, but in the original games hell had already invaded earth once, so is this an alternate earth that has yet to be subjected to that fate or did everyone just collectively forget that fact?fact?
** It's heavily implied even in ''2016'' that the Slayer came from an alternate Earth, as the UAC scientists noted how the Slayer's Praetor armor appears to be of Earth origin, but can't trace its source. ''Eternal'' also shows that both the Argent D'Nur empire and Hell spanned across multiple dimensions, so it's not out of the question the Slayer happened to find his way over from an alternate Earth through Hell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** On the pragmatic end the people said guard works for are not exactly friends of the slayer, and while its unlikely do to the current demon situation best not to risk being shot in the back

to:

** On the pragmatic end the people said guard works for are not exactly friends of the slayer, and while its unlikely do to the current demon situation best not to risk being shot in the backback

* Is this the same earth the Slayer is from? it is now confirmed that the slayer is the original Doomguy, but in the original games hell had already invaded earth once, so is this an alternate earth that has yet to be subjected to that fate or did everyone just collectively forget that fact?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That's kinda the point. It is a vindictive move on his part toward the arrogant guard. Remember that the majority of the first mission was done by the Slayer solely to scare the piss out of the other Hell Priests. He is a vindictive person.

to:

** That's kinda the point. It is a vindictive move on his part toward the arrogant guard. Remember that the majority of the first mission was done by the Slayer solely to scare the piss out of the other Hell Priests. He is a vindictive person.person.
** On the pragmatic end the people said guard works for are not exactly friends of the slayer, and while its unlikely do to the current demon situation best not to risk being shot in the back
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That's kinda the point. It is a vindictive move on his part toward the arrogant guard.

to:

** That's kinda the point. It is a vindictive move on his part toward the arrogant guard. Remember that the majority of the first mission was done by the Slayer solely to scare the piss out of the other Hell Priests. He is a vindictive person.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** It could have very well been possible that Hayden teleported the Slayer to the Temple of Doom, given how Hayden seems to have a surprisingly deep amount of knowledge regarding Maykr and Sentinel technology. The Slayer was probably absent during the initial demonic invasion of Earth because he was still trying to get the Temple of Doom operational. Even at the beginning of the game, the Temple of Doom is only running at minimal capacity.




to:

** It may have been the corpse of a previous Khan Maykr. However, the main meta reason is that it serves as {{Foreshadowing}} about the true nature of the Maykrs, as they heavily resemble demons themselves both in appearance and motivation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why does the Slayer take the plasma gun off the soldier in the Phobos base? It seemed pragmatic in the trailer, but he already has a plasma gun at that point, so it seems more vindictive in game.

to:

* Why does the Slayer take the plasma gun off the soldier in the Phobos base? It seemed pragmatic in the trailer, but he already has a plasma gun at that point, so it seems more vindictive in game.game.
** That's kinda the point. It is a vindictive move on his part toward the arrogant guard.

Added: 197

Changed: -4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What’s up with that giant naked Maykr corpse in the pool in the the room just before the boss fight with Khan Maykr?

to:

* What’s up with that giant naked Maykr corpse in the pool in the the room just before the boss fight with Khan Maykr?Maykr?

* Why does the Slayer take the plasma gun off the soldier in the Phobos base? It seemed pragmatic in the trailer, but he already has a plasma gun at that point, so it seems more vindictive in game.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Given that VEGA seems to come to the realisation that [[spoiler: ''he'' is The Father]], it points to some sort of connection between VEGA, Samuel Hayden, and [[spoiler: Samur Maykr]].

to:

** Given that VEGA seems to come to the realisation that [[spoiler: ''he'' is The Father]], it points to some sort of connection between VEGA, Samuel Hayden, and [[spoiler: Samur Maykr]].Maykr]].

* What’s up with that giant naked Maykr corpse in the pool in the the room just before the boss fight with Khan Maykr?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What happened to "The Father" of the Maykr homeworld?

to:

* What happened to "The Father" of the Maykr homeworld?homeworld?
** Given that VEGA seems to come to the realisation that [[spoiler: ''he'' is The Father]], it points to some sort of connection between VEGA, Samuel Hayden, and [[spoiler: Samur Maykr]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Where did Samuel Hayden shunt the Doom Slayer off to following ''VideoGame/Doom2016'', and how did he return?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It is stated in the codex that the Hell Priests use a lot of bizarre and strange Hell magics to render many of their warriors immune to conventional weaponry and also to disrupt technology and infrastructure. The enslaved hellbeasts holding up their citadels, for example, are completely immune to outside attack. This means that they would need far fewer warriors than you'd think, especially since so much of the damage Hell is inflicting on earth is caused by demonic terraforming and transformation of the landscape.

to:

** It is stated in the codex that the Hell Priests use a lot of bizarre and strange Hell magics to render many of their warriors immune to conventional weaponry and also to disrupt technology and infrastructure. The enslaved hellbeasts holding up their citadels, for example, are completely immune to outside attack. This means that they would need far fewer warriors than you'd think, especially since so much of the damage Hell is inflicting on earth is caused by demonic terraforming and transformation of the landscape.landscape.

* Who is the mysterious voice that lets out the BigNo following the Khan Maykr's demise?

* What happened to "The Father" of the Maykr homeworld?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Nekravol levels state that the corpses of people killed by demons and harvested for Argent Energy will eventually become demons as well. That plus the indications that demons can reproduce fine on their own, and that Hell is a really big place, seems to be it.

to:

** The Nekravol levels state that the corpses of people killed by demons and harvested for Argent Energy will eventually become demons as well. That plus the indications that demons can reproduce fine on their own, and that Hell is a really big place, seems to be it.it.
** It is stated in the codex that the Hell Priests use a lot of bizarre and strange Hell magics to render many of their warriors immune to conventional weaponry and also to disrupt technology and infrastructure. The enslaved hellbeasts holding up their citadels, for example, are completely immune to outside attack. This means that they would need far fewer warriors than you'd think, especially since so much of the damage Hell is inflicting on earth is caused by demonic terraforming and transformation of the landscape.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** We have seen several demons that have explicitly been killed by the slayer before(the Cyberdemons, Doomhunters, and the Icon of Sin) so it seems they can simply resurrect there dead to form a truly endless legion

to:

** We have seen several demons that have explicitly been killed by the slayer before(the Cyberdemons, Doomhunters, and the Icon of Sin) so it seems they can simply resurrect there dead to form a truly endless legionlegion
** The Nekravol levels state that the corpses of people killed by demons and harvested for Argent Energy will eventually become demons as well. That plus the indications that demons can reproduce fine on their own, and that Hell is a really big place, seems to be it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Same place as Chaos in TabletopGame/Warhammer40000. It's also possible that lesser demons have some sort of resurrection abilities, or there are other areas of Hell and Hell Dimensions the hero doesn't visit in the first one. They also rely heavily on Blitzkrieg style tactics...and possibly have a lot of forces 'offscreen'.

to:

** Same place as Chaos in TabletopGame/Warhammer40000. It's also possible that lesser demons have some sort of resurrection abilities, or there are other areas of Hell and Hell Dimensions the hero doesn't visit in the first one. They also rely heavily on Blitzkrieg style tactics...and possibly have a lot of forces 'offscreen'.'offscreen'.
** We have seen several demons that have explicitly been killed by the slayer before(the Cyberdemons, Doomhunters, and the Icon of Sin) so it seems they can simply resurrect there dead to form a truly endless legion
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Same place as Chaos in Warhammer40K. It's also possible that lesser demons have some sort of resurrection abilities, or there are other areas of Hell and Hell Dimensions the hero doesn't visit in the first one. They also rely heavily on Blitzkrieg style tactics...and possibly have a lot of forces 'offscreen'.

to:

** Same place as Chaos in Warhammer40K.TabletopGame/Warhammer40000. It's also possible that lesser demons have some sort of resurrection abilities, or there are other areas of Hell and Hell Dimensions the hero doesn't visit in the first one. They also rely heavily on Blitzkrieg style tactics...and possibly have a lot of forces 'offscreen'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Quoth Dr Egon Spengler: "People die every day."

to:

** Quoth Dr Egon Spengler: "People die every day.""
** Same place as Chaos in Warhammer40K. It's also possible that lesser demons have some sort of resurrection abilities, or there are other areas of Hell and Hell Dimensions the hero doesn't visit in the first one. They also rely heavily on Blitzkrieg style tactics...and possibly have a lot of forces 'offscreen'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Where do the legions of hell get their warriors from?
** Overrunning an 8 billion strong technologically advanced civilization is no mean feat (let alone practically overnight), and it's implied that hell consumes inhabited worlds on a regular basis. They must have a massive pool of fighters to draw from, but Hell itself is a bleak and blasted wasteland with barely any resources and any world they do consume is apparently wrecked to the point of uselessness. If that wern't enough, the forces of hell are [[WeAreStrugglingTogether constantly duking it out with each other]] when no other outlet for aggression presents itself. That said, most people don't play DOOM to ponder the finer points of infernal logistics, but [[CatharsisFactor butchering hellspawn is even more satisfying knowing just how much time and effort went into their creation.]]

to:

* Where do the legions of hell Hell get their warriors from?
** Overrunning an 8 billion strong technologically advanced civilization is no mean feat (let alone practically overnight), and it's implied that hell Hell consumes inhabited worlds on a regular basis. They must have a massive pool of fighters to draw from, but Hell itself is a bleak and blasted wasteland with barely any resources and any world they do consume is apparently wrecked to the point of uselessness. If that wern't weren't enough, the forces of hell Hell are [[WeAreStrugglingTogether constantly duking it out with each other]] when no other outlet for aggression presents itself. That said, most people don't play DOOM ''DOOM'' to ponder the finer points of infernal logistics, but [[CatharsisFactor butchering hellspawn is even more satisfying knowing just how much time and effort went into their creation.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Overrunning an 8 billion strong technologically advanced civilization is no mean feat (let alone practically overnight), and it's implied that hell consumes inhabited worlds on a regular basis. They must have a massive pool of fighters to draw from, but Hell itself is a bleak and blasted wasteland with barely any resources and any world they do consume is apparently wrecked to the point of uselessness. If that wern't enough, the forces of hell are [[WeAreStrugglingTogether constantly duking it out with each other]] when no other outlet for aggression presents itself. That said, most people don't play DOOM to ponder the finer points of infernal logistics, but [[CatharsisFactor butchering hellspawn is even more satisfying knowing just how much time and effort went into their creation.]]

to:

** Overrunning an 8 billion strong technologically advanced civilization is no mean feat (let alone practically overnight), and it's implied that hell consumes inhabited worlds on a regular basis. They must have a massive pool of fighters to draw from, but Hell itself is a bleak and blasted wasteland with barely any resources and any world they do consume is apparently wrecked to the point of uselessness. If that wern't enough, the forces of hell are [[WeAreStrugglingTogether constantly duking it out with each other]] when no other outlet for aggression presents itself. That said, most people don't play DOOM to ponder the finer points of infernal logistics, but [[CatharsisFactor butchering hellspawn is even more satisfying knowing just how much time and effort went into their creation.]]]]
** Quoth Dr Egon Spengler: "People die every day."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Overrunning an 8 billion strong technologically advanced civilization is no mean feat (let alone practically overnight), and it's implied that hell consumes inhabited worlds on a regular basis. They must have a massive pool of fighters to draw from, but Hell itself is a bleak and blasted wasteland with barely any resources and any world they do consume is apparently wrecked to the point of uselessness. If that wern't enough, the forces of hell are [[WeAreStrugglingTogether constantly duking it out with each other]] when no other outlet for aggression presents itself. That said, most people don't play DOOM to ponder the finer points of infernal logistics, but [[CatharsisFactor butchering hellspawn is even more satisfying knowing just how much time and effort went into their creation.]]
* What powers the Chainsaw? You're picking up fuel canisters to use it but not only are you not on a planet that shouldn't have petroleum products, Earth's energy crisis should have meant that anything that uses gasoline can't exist anymore anyway (and if it's Argent-powered, it shouldn't need fuel in the first place given how crazy-good Argent energy is, supposedly).

to:

** Overrunning an 8 billion strong technologically advanced civilization is no mean feat (let alone practically overnight), and it's implied that hell consumes inhabited worlds on a regular basis. They must have a massive pool of fighters to draw from, but Hell itself is a bleak and blasted wasteland with barely any resources and any world they do consume is apparently wrecked to the point of uselessness. If that wern't enough, the forces of hell are [[WeAreStrugglingTogether constantly duking it out with each other]] when no other outlet for aggression presents itself. That said, most people don't play DOOM to ponder the finer points of infernal logistics, but [[CatharsisFactor butchering hellspawn is even more satisfying knowing just how much time and effort went into their creation.]]
* What powers the Chainsaw? You're picking up fuel canisters to use it but not only are you not on a planet that shouldn't have petroleum products, Earth's energy crisis should have meant that anything that uses gasoline can't exist anymore anyway (and if it's Argent-powered, it shouldn't need fuel in the first place given how crazy-good Argent energy is, supposedly).
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Overrunning an 8 billion strong technologically advanced civilization is no mean feat (let alone practically overnight), and it's implied that hell consumes inhabited worlds on a regular basis. They must have a massive pool of fighters to draw from, but Hell itself is a bleak and blasted wasteland with barely any resources and any world they do consume is apparently wrecked to the point of uselessness. If that wern't enough, the forces of hell are [[WeAreStrugglingTogether constantly duking it out with each other]] when no other outlet for aggression presents itself. That said, most people don't play DOOM to ponder the finer points of infernal logistics, but [[CatharsisFactor butchering hellspawn is even more satisfying knowing just how much time and effort went into their creation.]]

to:

** Overrunning an 8 billion strong technologically advanced civilization is no mean feat (let alone practically overnight), and it's implied that hell consumes inhabited worlds on a regular basis. They must have a massive pool of fighters to draw from, but Hell itself is a bleak and blasted wasteland with barely any resources and any world they do consume is apparently wrecked to the point of uselessness. If that wern't enough, the forces of hell are [[WeAreStrugglingTogether constantly duking it out with each other]] when no other outlet for aggression presents itself. That said, most people don't play DOOM to ponder the finer points of infernal logistics, but [[CatharsisFactor butchering hellspawn is even more satisfying knowing just how much time and effort went into their creation.]]]]
* What powers the Chainsaw? You're picking up fuel canisters to use it but not only are you not on a planet that shouldn't have petroleum products, Earth's energy crisis should have meant that anything that uses gasoline can't exist anymore anyway (and if it's Argent-powered, it shouldn't need fuel in the first place given how crazy-good Argent energy is, supposedly).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Overrunning an 8 billion strong technologically advanced civilization is no mean feat (let alone practically overnight), and it's implied that hell consumes inhabited worlds on a regular basis. They must have a massive pool of fighters to draw from, but Hell itself is a bleak and blasted wasteland with barely any resources and any world they do consume is apparently wrecked to the point of uselessness. If that wern't enough, the forces of hell are [[WeAreStrugglingTogether constantly duking it out with each other]] when no other outlet for aggression presents itself. Granted, nobody plays DOOM to ponder the details of infernal logistics, but [[CatharsisFactor butchering hellspawn would be even more viscerally satisfying with the knowledge of just how much time and effort went into their creation.]]

to:

** Overrunning an 8 billion strong technologically advanced civilization is no mean feat (let alone practically overnight), and it's implied that hell consumes inhabited worlds on a regular basis. They must have a massive pool of fighters to draw from, but Hell itself is a bleak and blasted wasteland with barely any resources and any world they do consume is apparently wrecked to the point of uselessness. If that wern't enough, the forces of hell are [[WeAreStrugglingTogether constantly duking it out with each other]] when no other outlet for aggression presents itself. Granted, nobody plays That said, most people don't play DOOM to ponder the details finer points of infernal logistics, but [[CatharsisFactor butchering hellspawn would be is even more viscerally satisfying with the knowledge of knowing just how much time and effort went into their creation.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Where do the legions of hell get their warriors from?
** Overrunning an 8 billion strong technologically advanced civilization is no mean feat (let alone practically overnight), and it's implied that hell consumes inhabited worlds on a regular basis. They must have a massive pool of fighters to draw from, but Hell itself is a bleak and blasted wasteland with barely any resources and any world they do consume is apparently wrecked to the point of uselessness. If that wern't enough, the forces of hell are [[WeAreStrugglingTogether constantly duking it out with each other]] when no other outlet for aggression presents itself. Granted, nobody plays DOOM to ponder the details of infernal logistics, but [[CatharsisFactor butchering hellspawn would be even more viscerally satisfying with the knowledge of just how much time and effort went into their creation.]]

Top