Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / DOOM

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Considering the Film/EvilDead2 quote, no. Doomguy is basically Ash if he went completely insane (hell, the box cover is essentially Film/ArmyOfDarkness), and he literally quoted Ash. You don’t write a serious work and have your protagonist make a reference to one of the most legendary horror comedy films about a badass-dumbass with a shotgun and a chainsaw while he’s also acting like a badass-dumbass with a shotgun and a chainsaw.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** [[AWizardDidIt Hell magic.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dead link


** This troper always interpreted it as going back to Earth, and he mentioned it on the main page until it was deleted for Administrivia/{{Natter}}. Basically, [=McNeil=] said "Welcome, ''home''", not paradise, not "a better place", just ''home''. So, going back to Earth is probably the most logical conclusion. And it's not like it's impossible. [=McNeil=] disabled life support to power the teleporters, and the Doomguy in Doom 3 managed to get back from Hell, so it's possible RoE Doomguy teleported back to Mars, and then him and [=McNeil=] simply teleported back to where their ships are and left for Earth. Why id didn't [[ShowDontTell show it]], however, is [[FridgeLogic beyond me]].

to:

** This troper always interpreted it as going back to Earth, and he mentioned it on the main page until it was deleted for Administrivia/{{Natter}}. Basically, [=McNeil=] said "Welcome, ''home''", not paradise, not "a better place", just ''home''. So, going back to Earth is probably the most logical conclusion. And it's not like it's impossible. [=McNeil=] disabled life support to power the teleporters, and the Doomguy in Doom 3 managed to get back from Hell, so it's possible RoE [=RoE=] Doomguy teleported back to Mars, and then him and [=McNeil=] simply teleported back to where their ships are and left for Earth. Why id didn't [[ShowDontTell show it]], however, is [[FridgeLogic beyond me]].



*** There's an ad for gravity generators in RoE elevators.

to:

*** There's an ad for gravity generators in RoE [=RoE=] elevators.



*** Yes, the above is correct. It's hard to tell looking at the actual box, but if you look at [[http://dudelol.com/oldimgs/high-resolution-doom-cover-art.jpg a high resolution version]], you can clearly see that ab spot has been torn away. And the guy in the background has an identical uniform, and his abs are covered.

to:

*** Yes, the above is correct. It's hard to tell looking at the actual box, but if you look at [[http://dudelol.com/oldimgs/high-resolution-doom-cover-art.jpg a high resolution version]], version, you can clearly see that ab spot has been torn away. And the guy in the background has an identical uniform, and his abs are covered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Probably a case of SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale. That and it's possible the starport is [[SpaceCompression WAY bigger than it appears in game.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It could also be because while Hell and demons exist with in the Doom universe [[DevilButNoGod there doesn't seem to be any God or Heaven]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why do some levels, such as E2M4 (which takes place on the Deimos base) have things like a room with a pool of blood and demonic statues drooling blood into the pool? That sort of thing would make sense in Hell but why would it be in the (human made) base? I do remember on Doom II one of the text crawls says something about the demons bringing their own reality with them. Does this mean they somehow change the areas they occupy to be more like Hell?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The first part of Doom II's plot. Are we really supposed to believe that the demons were not only able to hold the entire population of Earth hostage, but that liberating one spaceport would be enough to get everyone off the planet at once? Even if the demonic invasion cut the Earth's population down to size, Earth is still pretty big, with countless places where people could be holed up. That means Doomguy would still have go all over the world to rescue all the people that are at the mercy of the demons before he could put them on a spaceship. Wouldn't it have made more sense if Doom II took place on Mars instead of Earth, given that there wouldn't be that many people living on the planet other than UAC personnel, and they'd probably all live in one city, anyway?

to:

* The first part of Doom II's plot. Are ExcusePlot aside, are we really supposed to believe that the demons were not only able to hold the entire population of Earth hostage, but that liberating one spaceport would be enough to get everyone off the planet at once? Even if the demonic invasion cut the Earth's population down to size, Earth is still pretty big, with countless places where people could be holed up. That means Doomguy would still have go all over the world to rescue all the people that are at the mercy of the demons before he could put them on a spaceship. Wouldn't it have made more sense if Doom II took place on Mars instead of Earth, given that there wouldn't be that many people living on the planet other than UAC personnel, and they'd probably all live in one city, anyway?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The first part of Doom II's plot. Are we really supposed to believe that the demons were not only able to hold the entire population of Earth hostage, but that liberating one spaceport would be enough to get everyone off the planet at once? Even if the demonic invasion cut the Earth's population down to size, Earth is still pretty big, with countless places where people could be holed up, so you'd still have go all over the world to rescue all the people that are at the mercy of the demons. Wouldn't it have made more sense if Doom II took place on Mars instead of Earth, given that there wouldn't be that many people living on the planet other than UAC personnel, and they'd probably all live in one city, anyway?

to:

* The first part of Doom II's plot. Are we really supposed to believe that the demons were not only able to hold the entire population of Earth hostage, but that liberating one spaceport would be enough to get everyone off the planet at once? Even if the demonic invasion cut the Earth's population down to size, Earth is still pretty big, with countless places where people could be holed up, so you'd up. That means Doomguy would still have go all over the world to rescue all the people that are at the mercy of the demons.demons before he could put them on a spaceship. Wouldn't it have made more sense if Doom II took place on Mars instead of Earth, given that there wouldn't be that many people living on the planet other than UAC personnel, and they'd probably all live in one city, anyway?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The first part of Doom II's plot. Are we really supposed to believe that the demons were not only able to hold the entire population of Earth hostage, but that liberating one spaceport would be enough to get everyone off the planet at once? Even if the demonic invasion cut the Earth's population down to size, Earth is still pretty big, with countless places where people could be holed up, so you'd still have go all over the world to rescue all the people that are at the mercy of the demons. Wouldn't it have made more sense if Doom II took place on Mars instead of Earth, given that there wouldn't be that many people living on the planet other than UAC personnel, and they'd probably all live in one city, anyway?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The ending splash screen for Episode 4 shows the Marine exiting the burning building from the end of Episode 3. Between that and the ending text it's pretty clear that Thy Flesh Consumed takes place on Earth (presumably inside that very building complex) immediately after he returns there from Hell, making it more of a prequel episode of Doom 2 than a fourth episode of Doom 1. Not that any of this is reflected in the abstract, gameplay-oriented level architecture in the episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The real answer is that it doesn't exactly fit anywhere in the story chronology as defined in the original two games, being a handful of levels attached to the "Ultimate" edition of the game as a sort of technicality to get boxed copies of Doom into retail stores. If you really need it to have a place in the story you can consider it a flashback to Doomguy's journey back out of Hell (i.e., taking place after the killing of the Mastermind in Dis but before Doomguy reaches the portal back to Earth). Alternatively, this episode can be looked at as Doomguy's battle to escape the zone that he first arrives in on Earth, the area having been hellishly twisted and reworked as the initial site of the demons' invasion. Or heck, you can even decide this episode is a hyperspace dream that Doomguy has while teleporting back from Hell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Because succubi can create cambions? As in demon-human hybrids?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Since the movie makes a horrible science experiment the source of the "demons" as opposed to Hell in the games, they probably decided to emphasize the laboratory nature of the facility. Rodents tend to be in great supply in such environments, and monkeys kind of make sense to have around. Dogs - actually, I figured some of them to be pets that got loose or forgotten in the chaos.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The original VideoGame/{{Doom}} explains this by saying that the nameless space marine stood outside the base as a sentry while all his comrades went in. Since in the original, the demons apparently have to kill you first and ''then'' make you a zombie, he wasn't affected.

to:

** The original VideoGame/{{Doom}} ''VideoGame/{{Doom}}'' explains this by saying that the nameless space marine stood outside the base as a sentry while all his comrades went in. Since in the original, the demons apparently have to kill you first and ''then'' make you a zombie, he wasn't affected.



** If you think about it, the Hell of Doom probably isn't the exact same Hell we're thinking of (the Abrahamic place of eternal torment for sinners). What's referred to as Hell is really another dimension of beings that have been to Earth before and seek to reclaim their long lost home from humanity, and have haunted the nightmares of man since the beginning. Of course, that's just a theory. A [[WebVideo/GameTheoryWebShow Game Theory]].

to:

** If you think about it, the Hell of Doom probably isn't the exact same Hell we're thinking of (the Abrahamic place of eternal torment for sinners). What's referred to as Hell is really another dimension of beings that have been to Earth before and seek to reclaim their long lost home from humanity, and have haunted the nightmares of man since the beginning. Of course, that's just a theory. A [[WebVideo/GameTheoryWebShow Game Theory]].''WebVideo/GameTheory''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Doomguy's a catholic, according to the novels. His soul's been saved,therefore he can NoSell possession.

Added: 126

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the movie, apart from StupidEvil, why would you test something like C-24, thats theorised to give people superhuman abilities on DEATH ROW INMATES?

to:

* In the movie, apart from StupidEvil, why would you test something like C-24, thats theorised that's theorized to give people superhuman abilities on DEATH ROW INMATES?INMATES?
** You test experimental drugs on volunteers, and if there's a chance of painful death, you test on people who GotVolunteered.

Added: 19

Changed: 89

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In th eoriginal Doom, what does the letter E stand for in [=E1M1=]? I'm assuming the M stands for map, making it, ? 1 Map 1.

to:

* In th eoriginal the original Doom, what does the letter E [=E1M1=] stand for in [=E1M1=]? I'm assuming the M stands for map, making it, ? for?
** Episode
1 Map 1.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In th eoriginal Doom, what does the letter E stand for in E1M1? I'm assuming the M stands for map, making it, ? 1 Map 1.

to:

* In th eoriginal Doom, what does the letter E stand for in E1M1? [=E1M1=]? I'm assuming the M stands for map, making it, ? 1 Map 1.

Added: 122

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This troper always interpreted it as going back to Earth, and he mentioned it on the main page until it was deleted for Administrivia/{{Natter}}. Basically, McNeil said "Welcome, ''home''", not paradise, not "a better place", just ''home''. So, going back to Earth is probably the most logical conclusion. And it's not like it's impossible. McNeil disabled life support to power the teleporters, and the Doomguy in Doom 3 managed to get back from Hell, so it's possible RoE Doomguy teleported back to Mars, and then him and McNeil simply teleported back to where their ships are and left for Earth. Why id didn't [[ShowDontTell show it]], however, is [[FridgeLogic beyond me]].

to:

** This troper always interpreted it as going back to Earth, and he mentioned it on the main page until it was deleted for Administrivia/{{Natter}}. Basically, McNeil [=McNeil=] said "Welcome, ''home''", not paradise, not "a better place", just ''home''. So, going back to Earth is probably the most logical conclusion. And it's not like it's impossible. McNeil [=McNeil=] disabled life support to power the teleporters, and the Doomguy in Doom 3 managed to get back from Hell, so it's possible RoE Doomguy teleported back to Mars, and then him and McNeil [=McNeil=] simply teleported back to where their ships are and left for Earth. Why id didn't [[ShowDontTell show it]], however, is [[FridgeLogic beyond me]].


Added DiffLines:

* In th eoriginal Doom, what does the letter E stand for in E1M1? I'm assuming the M stands for map, making it, ? 1 Map 1.

Added: 1069

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How come the [[BigBad Icon Of Sin]] can't create spiderdemons and cyberdemons? Ok I know the ''real'' reason but what's the in universe one? and if he didn't create them who did?

to:

* How come the [[BigBad Icon Of Sin]] can't create spiderdemons and cyberdemons? Ok Ok, I know the ''real'' reason but what's the in universe in-universe one? and And if he didn't create them, who did?
** Presumably the effort required to create
them who did?is far greater than it is for the rest of demonkind. We just see a [[DamageSpongeBoss bucket of Hit Points that hurts a lot,]] but they're probably meant to be the leaders of the demons, and such likely require much more focus and concentration to create.
* Where exactly are you during the first game's fourth episode, Thy Flesh Consumed? The last episode ended with you stepping through a portal onto earth, where you see a city burning, and the rabbit head on a stick. The ending text for the fourth episode isn't quite clear, stating you killed a bunch of demons in vengeance for your pet rabbit. So, clearly you got back to earth, and saw you dead pet. But since Doom 2 is you fighting through earth, where are you in Episode 4? Did you decide to dive back into hell to kill more demons in a berserk rage? Is there some sort of compound on earth that held the portal you stepped through, strangely populated with only the original demons? Even the wiki is uncertain what the premise of the episode is supposed to be.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There's a certain subset of Christianity (mainly the part that protests everything) that believes that any media that depicts people succeeding without ''explicitly'' asking for and receiving God's aid, and giving Him full credit for their victory, is atheist propaganda. They prefer to assume that humans are incapable of achieving anything without divine intervention, and to suggest otherwise is teaching kids that they don't need God.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Formatting.


*** There's references to tongues as levers, which may have been what confused the guy saying there were two demoncock references. As to why they stopped at one... they didn't think it'd be funny again? That said, they did manage to fit in a huge pulsating vagina that the protagonists have to pass through, where they manage to make fun of religion. "Do you ever feel like you've been born again?"
*** Here's the other one, in a later section entirely. Never mind that it reads like a different version of the same one:

to:

*** ** There's references to tongues as levers, which may have been what confused the guy saying there were two demoncock references. As to why they stopped at one... they didn't think it'd be funny again? That said, they did manage to fit in a huge pulsating vagina that the protagonists have to pass through, where they manage to make fun of religion. "Do you ever feel like you've been born again?"
*** ** Here's the other one, in a later section entirely. Never mind that it reads like a different version of the same one:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
formating


There's references to tongues as levers, which may have been what confused the guy saying there were two demoncock references. As to why they stopped at one... they didn't think it'd be funny again? That said, they did manage to fit in a huge pulsating vagina that the protagonists have to pass through, where they manage to make fun of religion. "Do you ever feel like you've been born again?"

to:

There's ***There's references to tongues as levers, which may have been what confused the guy saying there were two demoncock references. As to why they stopped at one... they didn't think it'd be funny again? That said, they did manage to fit in a huge pulsating vagina that the protagonists have to pass through, where they manage to make fun of religion. "Do you ever feel like you've been born again?"



It's a artifact from the art being done based on the Doom Bible. The game was planned to be set on a massive base on Tai Tanga by Tom Hall but tech limitations stopped that and id moved the bases to the moons of mars but kept the assets the Tech base Computer textures' keep the reference to the old location.

to:

It's **It's a artifact from the art being done based on the Doom Bible. The game was planned to be set on a massive base on Tai Tanga by Tom Hall but tech limitations stopped that and id moved the bases to the moons of mars but kept the assets the Tech base Computer textures' keep the reference to the old location.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
formatting


//The entire room was constructed of that black, oily, ulcerating wood. There was one object in the room, placed at dead center: a bas relief of a demonic monster more horrible, or more ridiculous, than any we'd fought. Every physical attribute of the thing was exaggerated so that it almost seemed to be a cartoon. The largest protuberance of all was its penis, sticking out at a 45-degree angle.
//"They've got to be kidding," said Arlene.//
//"I hate to bring it up, but that's probably another switch," I suggested.//
//"I've handled worse," she admitted.//

to:

//The -->The entire room was constructed of that black, oily, ulcerating wood. There was one object in the room, placed at dead center: a bas relief of a demonic monster more horrible, or more ridiculous, than any we'd fought. Every physical attribute of the thing was exaggerated so that it almost seemed to be a cartoon. The largest protuberance of all was its penis, sticking out at a 45-degree angle.
//"They've -->"They've got to be kidding," said Arlene.//
//"I
Arlene.
-->"I
hate to bring it up, but that's probably another switch," I suggested.//
//"I've
suggested.
-->"I've
handled worse," she admitted.//



//The wall had a switch, a full-body bas relief of a cloven-hoofed alien. And it wasn't his tongue that required flicking. My face flushed. "Um, you'd better take this one, PFC Sanders//
//"And here I thought you were [[WesternAnimation/YellowSubmarine a born lever-puller]]."//

to:

//The -->The wall had a switch, a full-body bas relief of a cloven-hoofed alien. And it wasn't his tongue that required flicking. My face flushed. "Um, you'd better take this one, PFC Sanders//
//"And
Sanders
-->"And
here I thought you were [[WesternAnimation/YellowSubmarine a born lever-puller]]."//"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
formatting


//The entire room was constructed of that black, oily, ulcerating wood. There was one object in the room, placed at dead center: a bas relief of a demonic monster more horrible, or more ridiculous, than@@ @@any we'd fought. Every physical attribute of the thing was exaggerated so that it almost seemed to be a cartoon. The largest protuberance of all was its penis, sticking out at a 45-degree angle.

to:

//The entire room was constructed of that black, oily, ulcerating wood. There was one object in the room, placed at dead center: a bas relief of a demonic monster more horrible, or more ridiculous, than@@ @@any than any we'd fought. Every physical attribute of the thing was exaggerated so that it almost seemed to be a cartoon. The largest protuberance of all was its penis, sticking out at a 45-degree angle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

It's a artifact from the art being done based on the Doom Bible. The game was planned to be set on a massive base on Tai Tanga by Tom Hall but tech limitations stopped that and id moved the bases to the moons of mars but kept the assets the Tech base Computer textures' keep the reference to the old location.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* How come the [[BigBad Icon Of Sin]] can't create spiderdemons and cyberdemons? Ok I know the ''real'' reason but what's the in universe one? and if he didn't create them who did?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the movie, apart from StupidEvil, why would you test something like C-24, thats theorised to give people superhuman abilities on DEATH ROW INMATES?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Badass is no longer a trope.


*** And on that note, if he's that {{Badass}}, adding an obvious flaw in his armor is simply to make it all the more obvious to the monsters that he's a badass.

to:

*** And on that note, if he's that {{Badass}}, badass, adding an obvious flaw in his armor is simply to make it all the more obvious to the monsters that he's a badass.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** One of the level designers for Classic Doom, Sandy Petersen, was/is a practising Mormon and used similar logic to justify his involvement - (paraphrasing) "it's OK because they're the bad guys, and it's our job to destroy them"

Top