Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Cloverfield

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Well, that, and maybe it's just that they were regular people, and not everybody just knows first-aid. I know, many people do, but to just assume that ''when a person is bleeding the people with them will always make bandages out of clothing and administer all the first aid that they need'' is too much to ask of the general population.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The bluray special feature Jossed that; it states that the boat didn't explode at that point and would not explode for several hours. Maybe Clover ruptured a lot of gas manes or something?

to:

*** The bluray special feature Jossed that; it states that the boat didn't explode at that point and would not explode for several hours. Maybe Clover ruptured a lot of gas manes mains or something?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** ''Sneaking up''? It had just batted their helicopter out of the sky! They got so disoriented by the crash they sort of forgot or assumed he had gone. He may have stayed put.

Added: 201

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This has already been asked, and nobody has a solution.Maybe Clover was resting in the park after knocking the chopper down, and the movement from the chopper got it's attention.

to:

** This has already been asked, and nobody has a solution. Maybe Clover was resting in the park after knocking the chopper down, and the movement from the chopper got it's attention.


Added DiffLines:

** Hud was Rob's friend. Marleena was Lily's friend. Lily went with Rob, so we get all four. Still a bad plan, but if you bought Hud and Lily's following Rob, Marleena was not all that much further.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*I have a problem with the whole "lets go save Rob's Girlfriend" plan. Not that Rob thought it was a good idea or that his friend's followed him, but that Marleena also went with them. She makes it very clear in the beginning that she doesn't know Rob, and by extension Beth, from Adam and it is also implied that she doesn't know any of them very well so why go with them? You can argue that you'd feel safer in a group, but that falls apart when you realize that she doesn't actually know them and she believes their plan is horribly unsafe. She could have easily joined the mass exodus of people leaving the city when they were in that alley. However, instead of giving a legitimate reason for why she would stay the camera cuts away for a few seconds and she is seen following them where ever they are going. Lazy writing on the part of the screenwriters.
*This is a relatively new problem when it comes to Kaiju movies, because usually they surround either the monster or people who have some reason to be looking for the monster or to be hunted by the monster. While Manhattan is not a large place, it is certainly big enough that the monster would not be everywhere you were by sheer happenstance. There were at least 3 situations where the monster just happened to be where they were or where they needed to go. This of course doesn't apply to when they were in massive groups of people, like on the bridge, but when they were just in their little group. It seemed unrealistic that the monster would be drawn by whatever little noise they would be making.

Changed: 1299

Removed: 106

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




















* These were young women 18-30 we're typing about here. At their ages they can climb mount everest in high heels. It's the over 30 women who have to creatively hide their age related inability to wear high heels all night.
** Does not reflect this female troper's experience. Some women don't feel discomfort in heels, even cheap ones. Some feel lots, even in quality ones. It has nothing to do with age. This Troper's mother wears heels much more than she does.
** And that's not even mentioning that it's extremely hard to run for your life in strappy high-heels, much less over debris, gravel, on a slanted-roof, etc. Even if a woman in comfortable is them, they're very impractical shoes.

to:

* *** These were young women 18-30 we're typing about here. At their ages they can climb mount everest in high heels. It's the over 30 women who have to creatively hide their age related inability to wear high heels all night.
** *** Does not reflect this female troper's experience. Some women don't feel discomfort in heels, even cheap ones. Some feel lots, even in quality ones. It has nothing to do with age. This Troper's mother wears heels much more than she does.
** *** And that's not even mentioning that it's extremely hard to run for your life in strappy high-heels, much less over debris, gravel, on a slanted-roof, etc. Even if a woman in comfortable is them, they're very impractical shoes.shoes.

































* What bugs me is 18 freakin' minutes at the beginning wasted to establish that someone would be carrying a camera around for the remaining 66 minutes. "Duh! I'm documenting this!" Then there's the extremely long shot with the Mountain Dew cooler brightly lit (by comparison with the rest of the room) and perfectly clear almost dead-center while they were discussing what to do next at one point. Oh, and Marlena sitting there looking bored and completely unconcerned as she asked how bad her wounds were. And them yanking Beth off of the spike that was impaling her - and which would have been the only thing keeping her from bleeding to death (and I couldn't spot any blood on her after that, either). But what bugs me most is that I wasted 84 minutes of my life on this movie today, plus the time it took to go to the library, check it out, and take it home. Thank the gods I wasn't one of those poor souls duped into paying $12 at the theatre or, even worse, $20 to actually buy the DVD... I'll admit there was one decent part, though: near the end where the monster was staring at the idiot (ie, Hud) and lunges. Pity, though, that after all the mangly chewy noises, he's spit right back out, even though you'd think a critter that big wouldn't need to bother chewing something so small...
** Dude, this ain't the place to [[ComplainingAboutShowsYouDontLike Complain About Movies You Dont Like]].

to:

* What bugs me is 18 freakin' minutes at the beginning wasted to establish that someone would be carrying a camera around for the remaining 66 minutes. "Duh! I'm documenting this!" Then there's the extremely long shot with the Mountain Dew cooler brightly lit (by comparison with the rest of the room) and perfectly clear almost dead-center while they were discussing what to do next at one point. Oh, and Marlena sitting there looking bored and completely unconcerned as she asked how bad her wounds were. And them yanking Beth off of the spike that was impaling her - and which would have been the only thing keeping her from bleeding to death (and I couldn't spot any blood on her after that, either). But what bugs me most is that I wasted 84 minutes of my life on this movie today, plus the time it took to go to the library, check it out, and take it home. Thank the gods I wasn't one of those poor souls duped into paying $12 at the theatre or, even worse, $20 to actually buy the DVD... I'll admit there was one decent part, though: near the end where the monster was staring at the idiot (ie, Hud) and lunges. Pity, though, that after all the mangly chewy noises, he's spit right back out, even though you'd think a critter that big wouldn't need to bother chewing something so small...
** Dude, this ain't the place to [[ComplainingAboutShowsYouDontLike Complain About Movies You Dont Like]].


Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Plus only Marlena had the pipe, and she dropped it when she got bit. The rest of them were more concerned with getting to safety than grabbing a weapo.


Added DiffLines:

*** I was watching the bluray special feature for the movie, and one of the facts it brings up is that there's a theory that pouring water might have caused a reaction which "accelerated the deaths of [Marlena] and other victims." So perhaps the salivia is meant to kill them slowly, but it being mixed with H2O ends up making them explode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The bluray special feature Jossed that; it states that the boat didn't explode at that point and would not explode for several hours. Maybe Clover ruptured a lot of gas manes or something?


Added DiffLines:

*** Also, valuable real estate? I don't think anyone is going to buy half-destroyed and parasite-infected apartments any time soon. Not to mention that eventually Clover might have decided to move out of Manhattan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What bugs me are the interruptions when the camera stop recording and show those TastesLikeDiabetes moments. My reason is that right at the begging we are told that the recording was found and that is, IIRC, from a SD memory card and not form a video tape, and some how the new video is recorded over old video, and i don't think that, if the SD card had suffered damage, the process to recover the data would have overwrite one video over the other.

to:

* What bugs me are the interruptions when the camera stop recording and show those TastesLikeDiabetes moments. My reason is that right at the begging we are told that the recording was found and that is, IIRC, from a SD memory card and not form a video tape, and some how the new video is recorded over old video, and i don't think that, if the SD card had suffered damage, the process to recover the data would have overwrite one video over the other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* What bugs me are the interruptions when the camera stop recording and show those TastesLikeDiabetes moments. My reason is that right at the begging we are told that the recording was found and that is, IIRC, from a SD memory card and not form a video tape, and some how the new video is recorded over old video, and i don't think that, if the SD card had suffered damage, the process to recover the data would have overwrite one video over the other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** I have a hard time buying that the only 'safe flight path' would be the one right next to the huge bombardment of the huge monster. This isn't so much a battleground as tracking and shooting a moving target, which then means that anywhere away from said target is a certified safe zone. They still fly right alongside it, and low enough to be within reach of the monster. That pilot was just asking for it, and it's the kids' bad luck that they were flying with him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***That's due to ExecutiveMeddling. The filmmakers were forced to keep a PG-13 rating, as it would make more money. Hence the GoryDiscretionShot as opposed to full-on explodiness. Although honestly, it seems more disturbing behind the screen, since you don't know exactly what happens to Marlena, just that it's horrible and there's a lot of spewing blood involved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added a justification

Added DiffLines:

*** Maybe the Clovers fed on each other, or at least the smaller individuals. It'd make some sense, since nothing else is bigger.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Even shoes with heels can be better than shoes that ''don't fit''. Too loose, and you'll slip constantly. Too small, and your feet go numb.

Added: 309

Removed: 128

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How about the noisy monster rampaging through the city almost the entire movie...and then creeping up Ninja-style in the park?
** This has already been asked, and nobody has a solution.Maybe Clover was resting in the park after knocking the chopper down, and the movement from the chopper got it's attention.



* How about the noisy monster rampaging through the city almost the entire movie...and then creeping up Ninja-style in the park?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Apparently, Clover overturned a boat made of Explodium.


Added DiffLines:

**** Or it's an ancient life form that didn't evolve our rapid reproduction or mortality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


<<|ItJustBugsMe|>>

to:

<<|ItJustBugsMe|>><<|ItJustBugsMe|>>
* How about the noisy monster rampaging through the city almost the entire movie...and then creeping up Ninja-style in the park?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Joking aside, a lot of Staten Island is paved-over landfills. That may have kept it away.

Added: 199

Changed: 609

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One of the things that made Jurassic Park scary was that there was a chance the dinos might escape to the mainland. I suppose Clover and Godzilla just skipped that step for the sake of the scary.



* It bugs me that the movie let way too many things go unanswered and then (depending on who you talk to) either [[WordOfGod tried to use the ARG and interviews to fill in the gaps after the fact;]] or [[GodNeverSaidThat didn't,]] and they were well and truly [[AssPull yanking plot points out of their rectums.]] I get what they were trying to do; I know that your average person in that kind of survival situation wouldn't have access to those answers. But it seems like they took the "We don't have to explain ourselves lulz" excuse and ran with it, to the point where ''nothing'' makes sense and the plot is impenetrable simply for the sake of being impenetrable.

to:

* It bugs me that the movie let way too many things go unanswered and then (depending on who you talk to) either [[WordOfGod tried to use the ARG and interviews to fill in the gaps after the fact;]] or [[GodNeverSaidThat didn't,]] and they were well and truly [[AssPull yanking plot points out of their rectums.]] I get what they were trying to do; I know that your average person in that kind of survival situation wouldn't have access to those answers. But it seems like they took the "We don't have to explain ourselves lulz" excuse and ran with it, to the point where ''nothing'' makes sense and the plot is impenetrable simply for the sake of being impenetrable. Hell, the whole thing smacks of either ViewersAreMorons or AssPull; remember what a big deal JJ made out of the fact that the title was only a placeholder and that he'd be releasing the ''real'' title any day now, only to reveal that they decided to stick with Cloverfield because "the fans already know it by that name and we don't want to confuse them"? Bullshit, Mr. Abrams. Either you think so little of your fans that you don't trust them to know the difference, or you never thought of anything better and you were trying to covering your ass [[{{Lost}} (not that that would be without precedent).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Is the manga ''ever'' going to be released in the US as anything other than a Godawful scanlation?
* It bugs me that the movie let way too many things go unanswered and then (depending on who you talk to) either [[WordOfGod tried to use the ARG and interviews to fill in the gaps after the fact;]] or [[GodNeverSaidThat didn't,]] and they were well and truly [[AssPull yanking plot points out of their rectums.]] I get what they were trying to do; I know that your average person in that kind of survival situation wouldn't have access to those answers. But it seems like they took the "We don't have to explain ourselves lulz" excuse and ran with it, to the point where ''nothing'' makes sense and the plot is impenetrable simply for the sake of being impenetrable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* What do you suppose caused that massive explosion early on in the movie? The one that Liberty statue's head is flung out of? Most of the scenery gorn throughout the movie is consistent with structural damage brought on by things hitting buildings, monsters knocking into them, etc, and things that tend to catch fire... catching fire. But where did that giant pyrotechnic come from?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Its worth noting that New Yorkers refer to Manhattan as "the city", so leaving for Brooklyn would be thought of as evacuating the city.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I think it needs saying.

Added DiffLines:

** It bugs me that after going to all the trouble of making a film from a handheld perspective, they deliberately missed the opportunity to show some really graphic gore with an exploding person. If they'd done it on camera it would have made the film into really High Octane Nightmare Fuel. Instead they decided to opt for a behind the screen discretion shot. Face-palm...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Okay, thanks! I assume that scene wouldn't confuse me as much if I was a NYC resident?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Weapons designed to destroy armored vehicles aren't necessarily very useful on a gigantic animal. Kinetic energy penetrator ammunition (such as the "Silver Bullet" used by the Abrams tank) is far more efficient on hard targets than soft ones. High explosive anti-tank ammunition probably wouldn't even detonate as Clover's skin is too different from vehicle armor, and even if it did it has a very concentrated "pin-prick" effect. Canister rounds would probably be the best choice, but then you need to fire at close range and it would still take a lot of them to bring down a creature of that size.


Added DiffLines:

** They were trying to get off Manhattan Island by the nearest route, which happened to be the Brooklyn Bridge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Imagine you are a giant monster. Would ''you'' want to eat a guido? Or would you swim a little further to get something tastier?

Changed: 123

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Okay, maybe I expressed myself poorly. What I was trying to say was that ''before'' they went off to save Beth, during the "Let's go to that Whateveritsnameis Bridge!" scene, I was completely confused as to where the main characters and the crowd they were part offwhere heading, and I got the impression that they were heading to a ''different'' part of NYC instead of trying to get ''out'' of the city. That scene is kind of hard to follow for me. Also, I don't remember the helicopters being a factor in that scene where they're crossing the Nameescapesmeatthemoment Bridge, so maybe that's why it struck me as stupid - I dunno, it made more sense to me that they'd go for the nearest way out of NYC.

to:

*** Okay, maybe I expressed myself poorly. What I was trying to say was that ''before'' they went off to save Beth, during the "Let's go to that Whateveritsnameis Bridge!" scene, I was completely confused as to where the main characters and the crowd they were part offwhere heading, and I got the impression that they were heading to a ''different'' part of NYC instead of trying to get ''out'' of the city. That scene is kind of hard to follow for me. Also, I don't remember the helicopters being a factor in that scene where they're crossing the Nameescapesmeatthemoment Bridge, so maybe that's why it struck me as stupid - I dunno, it made more sense to me that guess I thought they'd go for the nearest way get out of NYC.NYC on foot by walking northwards. Probably not a good idea either.

Changed: 140

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Okay, maybe I expressed myself poorly. What I was trying to say was that ''before'' they went off to save Beth, during the "Let's go to that Whateveritsnameis Bridge!" scene, I was completely confused as to where the main characters and the crowd they were part off where heading, and at one point I got the impression that they were heading to a ''different'' part of NYC instead of trying to get ''out'' of the city. That scene is kind of hard to follow for me. Also, I don't remember the helicopters being a factor in that scene where they're crossing the Nameescapesmeatthemoment Bridge.

to:

*** Okay, maybe I expressed myself poorly. What I was trying to say was that ''before'' they went off to save Beth, during the "Let's go to that Whateveritsnameis Bridge!" scene, I was completely confused as to where the main characters and the crowd they were part off where offwhere heading, and at one point I got the impression that they were heading to a ''different'' part of NYC instead of trying to get ''out'' of the city. That scene is kind of hard to follow for me. Also, I don't remember the helicopters being a factor in that scene where they're crossing the Nameescapesmeatthemoment Bridge.Bridge, so maybe that's why it struck me as stupid - I dunno, it made more sense to me that they'd go for the nearest way out of NYC.

Changed: 63

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Okay, maybe I expressed myself poorly. What I was trying to say was that ''before'' they went off to save Beth, I was completely confused as to where the main characters and the crowd they were part off where heading, and at one point I got the impression that they were heading to a ''different'' part of NYC instead of trying to get ''out'' of the city. That scene is kind of hard to follow for me. Also, I don't remember the helicopters being a factor in that scene where they're crossing the Nameescapesmeatthemoment Bridge.

to:

*** Okay, maybe I expressed myself poorly. What I was trying to say was that ''before'' they went off to save Beth, during the "Let's go to that Whateveritsnameis Bridge!" scene, I was completely confused as to where the main characters and the crowd they were part off where heading, and at one point I got the impression that they were heading to a ''different'' part of NYC instead of trying to get ''out'' of the city. That scene is kind of hard to follow for me. Also, I don't remember the helicopters being a factor in that scene where they're crossing the Nameescapesmeatthemoment Bridge.

Added: 532

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Wow. This isn't ignorance of NYC geography, this is just not paying attention, and blaming the movie for it. They were headed for a building in NYC to the guy's girlfriend, and then they went to the helicopters in an attempt to evactuate like everybody else. Not complicated at all.

to:

** Wow. This isn't ignorance of NYC geography, this is just not paying attention, and blaming the movie for it. it. They were headed for a building in NYC to get the guy's girlfriend, and then they went to the helicopters in an attempt to evactuate like everybody else. Not complicated at all.all.
*** Okay, maybe I expressed myself poorly. What I was trying to say was that ''before'' they went off to save Beth, I was completely confused as to where the main characters and the crowd they were part off where heading, and at one point I got the impression that they were heading to a ''different'' part of NYC instead of trying to get ''out'' of the city. That scene is kind of hard to follow for me. Also, I don't remember the helicopters being a factor in that scene where they're crossing the Nameescapesmeatthemoment Bridge.

Top