Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / ClassicalMythology

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Also, let's face it. Zeus had to chose between Hera (his wife and well known bombshell when she was mad), Athena (his favourite daughter and very creative with revenges) and Aphrodite (the GODDESS OF BEAUTY.) Even for the king of gods who is overpowered even against all of the rest, that was NOT a comfortable situation to be in. No wonder he first stalled judgment and then bailed altogether. He probably hoped the ladies would just calm down if he refused to decide for a while.

to:

*** Also, let's face it. Zeus had to chose choose between Hera (his wife and well with a known bombshell temper problem who ''already'' did horrible things to people related to Zeus when she was mad), mad at him), Athena (his favourite favorite daughter and very creative with revenges) revenge) and Aphrodite (the GODDESS OF BEAUTY.) (whose love powers allow her to jerk Zeus around just as easily as anyone else who wasn't a virgin goddess). Even for the king of gods who is overpowered even against all of the rest, that was NOT a comfortable situation to be in. No wonder he first stalled judgment and then bailed altogether. He probably hoped the ladies would just calm down if he refused to decide for a while.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Just because he is TheSmartGuy doesn't mean he is physically unimpressive. Think of Odysseus as the Ancient Greek version of Batman: a careful and savvy planner, but also well-trained and at peak condition. Supernatural feats like holding up the sky may truly necessitate the strength of someone like Heracles (who is pretty much Ancient Greek Superman), but stringing a battle-bow, however sturdy, is hardly outside the realm of what men can feasibly do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** From a modern perspective, Apollo is basically a slightly lackadaisical, dorky, but sentimental and overly romantic teenage pretty-boy. Basically he’s the kind of precocious guy who tries too hard to woo people, but comes onto them so strongly that it circles around to being unappealing. He probably could settle pretty easily for someone who actually likes him, except he’s always too fixated on the kinds of people who don’t.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The TLDR version of the story is that Archimedes proved that the crown ''was'' diluted by the dishonest goldsmith using cheaper silver than the amount of gold that the king paid for. The density of a golden crown with silver mixed in was less than that of a lump of gold of the same weight, so the differences between them became clear whether they displaced different amounts of water when they were tossed in or whether they were balanced on a scale then put in water. (UsefulNotes/Galileo confirmed that the latter method would work, as some scholars question whether the bathtub story is true.) The real question is what the king did to the crooked goldsmith.

to:

** The TLDR version of the story is that Archimedes proved that the crown ''was'' diluted by the dishonest goldsmith using cheaper silver than the amount of gold that the king paid for. The density of a golden crown with silver mixed in was less than that of a lump of gold of the same weight, so the differences between them became clear whether they displaced different amounts of water when they were tossed in or whether they were balanced on a scale then put in water. (UsefulNotes/Galileo (UsefulNotes/{{Galileo}} confirmed that the latter method would work, as some scholars question whether the bathtub story is true.) The real question is what the king did to the crooked goldsmith.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Regarding the girdle, the reason Eurystheus sent Heracles to get it was because his daughter wanted to possess it. The other labors were done for the sake of killing or humiliating Heracles with seemingly impossible tasks, but this one actually had a clear-cut reason behind it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Baleful Polymorph is no longer a trope


* Gods turning their enemies into {{baleful polymorph}}s I get but they also transform people out of pity or as a reward. Wouldn't being stuck as a sunflower forever be a FateWorseThanDeath?

to:

* Gods turning their enemies into {{baleful polymorph}}s {{Forced Transformation}}s I get but they also transform people out of pity or as a reward. Wouldn't being stuck as a sunflower forever be a FateWorseThanDeath?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, some versions of the myth read that Zeus wed Aphrodite off to Hephaestus to punish her for her pride in refusing all of the other gods.

Added: 1033

Changed: 10

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is Hera never depicted having at least some resentment towards Hermes? In almost every case when Zeus has a child from an affair, [[WomanScorned she either torments the mother]], [[AffairBlameTheBastard the child]] or both. Other gods aren't exempt from this as she tried to stop Leto from giving birth to Artemis and Athena. While Zeus was able to keep the affair secret until Hermes was born, it still doesn't explain why she's never shown to have any beef with Hermes or his mother Maia who Zeus had the affair with.

to:

* Why is Hera never depicted having at least some resentment towards Hermes? In almost every case when Zeus has a child from an affair, [[WomanScorned she either torments the mother]], [[AffairBlameTheBastard the child]] or both. Other gods aren't exempt from this as she tried to stop Leto from giving birth to Artemis and Athena. Apollo. While Zeus was able to keep the affair secret until Hermes was born, it still doesn't explain why she's never shown to have any beef with Hermes or his mother Maia who Zeus had the affair with.with.
** One reason is because she would surely hold less power over another god than she would a comparatively feeble demigod. Screwing over mortals is probably a lot easier for her. And unlike, say, Heracles or Perseus, the gods Hermes, Artemis and Apollo are worshiped for their individual merits and attributes rather than their parentage. "Atremis, goddess of the hunt" doesn't have as strong of an association with Zeus's infidelity as "Heracles, the mighty son of Zeus." That's probably why one triggers Hera much more than the other.
* Why in Tartarus did Zeus think marrying Aphrodite to Hephaestus would help stop other gods from fighting over her? Given Hephaestus isn't one of the heavy hitters and Zeus himself is a chronic adulterer, why would he think the plan would work?
** Because the prize for fighting over her was specifically her hand in marriage, which is what giving her to Hephaestus held off. It was not meant to keep the other gods from sleeping with her on the side, since Aphrodite is already keen to allow that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why in Tartarus did Zeus think marrying Aphrodite to Hephaestus would help stop other gods from fighting over her? Given Hephaestus isn't one of the heavy hitters and Zeus himself is a chronic adulterer, why would he think the plan would work?

to:

* Why in Tartarus did is Hera never depicted having at least some resentment towards Hermes? In almost every case when Zeus think marrying Aphrodite has a child from an affair, [[WomanScorned she either torments the mother]], [[AffairBlameTheBastard the child]] or both. Other gods aren't exempt from this as she tried to Hephaestus would help stop other gods Leto from fighting over her? Given Hephaestus isn't one of the heavy hitters giving birth to Artemis and Athena. While Zeus himself is a chronic adulterer, was able to keep the affair secret until Hermes was born, it still doesn't explain why would he think she's never shown to have any beef with Hermes or his mother Maia who Zeus had the plan would work?affair with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why in Tartarus did Zeus think marrying Aphrodite to Hephaestus would help stop other gods from fighting over her? Given Hephaestus isn't one of the heavy hitters and Zeus himself is a chronic adulterer, why would he think the plan would work?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Cronus was often described as having ruled over a Golden Age of mankind wherein the people of the world lived peacefully and prosperously. In those myths, his only glaring flaw was that he sought to devour his children to keep them from overthrowing him. Once the Olympians are firmly established and in power, there'd be no harm in letting him rule over the paradise of Elysium, especially since it lessens the risk of any bitter feelings developing in the future.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Wait, why on earth would Zeus & Hades let ''Cronus'' of all people rule over ''[[{{Heaven}} Elyseum]]''? At least in the tradition of Creator/{{Hesiod}} (see ''Literature/WorksAndDays''), Cronus is described as later ruling over the demigods after he was released from his bonds. ''Why?'' Zeus and Hades were mistreated by Cronus, why would they not only release him but have him rule over heroes? Did Cronus have some [[HeelFaceReturn off-screen change of heart]] that Hesiod forgot to mention? Did Zeus just forgive him off-screen for everything? What happened?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He's also the god of disease, remember? Zeus knows that he's carrying. Do ''you'' want to [[BrainBleach bang]] Papa [[TabletopGame/{{Warhammer}} Nurgle]]?

to:

** He's also the god of disease, remember? Zeus knows that he's carrying. Do ''you'' want to [[BrainBleach bang]] Papa [[TabletopGame/{{Warhammer}} Nurgle]]?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He's also the god of disease, remember? Zeus knows that he's carrying. Do ''you'' want to [[BrainBleach bang]] Papa [[TabletopGame/{{Warhammer}} Nurgle]]?

Added: 449

Changed: 995

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That or she was thinking "Oooh I ask him to prove himself and he's dithering, he is definitely hiding something, better stick to my first request." As to why she doesn't think of other ways Zeus could prove himself, well, Hera put a bee in her bonnet and she specifically mentioned asking to see Zeus in his divine form to make sure so makes sense Semele would connect the two. As for feeling bad for Zeus... yes he was in an impossible situation (even if he had brought up "Hey don't you think this sort of thing is what Hera, you know, my notoriously jealous wife, would love you to think and ask of me? Think for a minute please...", Semele would have seen it as trying to derail the topic) though remember he was cheating on his wife with a woman, who in some versions at least was his own priestess.

to:

** That or she was thinking "Oooh I ask him to prove himself and he's dithering, he is definitely hiding something, better stick to my first request." As to why It's possible she doesn't think of other ways Zeus could believe his claim that she'll be killed trying to look upon his true form, and thinks it's a bluff to keep him from having to prove himself, well, Hera put himself. If not that, hubris is a bee common theme in the myths. If she really thought she was being courted by the king of the gods, and was carrying his child, her bonnet and she specifically mentioned asking to see Zeus in his divine form to make sure so makes sense Semele would connect getting a bit of a big head about the two. As for feeling bad for Zeus... yes he was in an impossible situation (even if he had brought up "Hey don't you think this sort of thing is what Hera, you know, my notoriously jealous wife, would love you to think and ask thinking she can survive something "ordinary mortals" couldn't isn't necessarily out of me? Think for a minute please...", Semele would have seen it as trying to derail the topic) though remember he was cheating on his wife with a woman, who in some versions at least was his own priestess.question.


Added DiffLines:

** Considering there aren't any surviving depictions of the petrification through which we could see whether the clothes were turned to stone in the original myths, it's possible they did imagine that only the victim's own body was affected back in ancient times. Whether that's the case, nowadays it's likely done differently so that the mood of the scene isn't tainted by the inherent comedy of seeing a statue fully dressed with a set of clothes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In what myth did Gaia plot Cronus's downfall, or express upset that he and his kin were imprisoned? In the story of the Titanomachy, it was Cronus's wife, Rhea who started his downfall when she plotted to save Zeus from being devoured.

Top