Follow TV Tropes

Following

History HeadScratchers / YugiohArcV

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Probably to make them less over-powered.

to:

** Probably to make them less over-powered.over-powered.
** Yeah, but that's normally done when they are made into real cards. It's odd to have the in show cards weaker than the real cards
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why are so many cards in this series given different effects, and often somewhat more restrictive effects. Battleguard King only being able to use his effects with Battleguards as oppose to more general warriors, the Level 5 or higher restriction of Odd Eyes and Dark Rebellion Dragons, etc etc?

to:

* Why are so many cards in this series given different effects, and often somewhat more restrictive effects. Battleguard King only being able to use his effects with Battleguards as oppose to more general warriors, the Level 5 or higher restriction of Odd Eyes and Dark Rebellion Dragons, etc etc?etc?
** Probably to make them less over-powered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Magicians can be in circuses and can fit the fun theme.

to:

** Magicians can be in circuses and can fit the fun theme.theme.
* Why are so many cards in this series given different effects, and often somewhat more restrictive effects. Battleguard King only being able to use his effects with Battleguards as oppose to more general warriors, the Level 5 or higher restriction of Odd Eyes and Dark Rebellion Dragons, etc etc?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Himika did make an off-hand mention of wanting to punish Yuya for embarrassing her school.



** That's the current theory, yes. In the opening, you can see Yusho standing next to a monster that looks like a stage magician, with marking similar to Odd-Eyes Dragon. All three cards may have been given to Yuya by him.

to:

** That's the current theory, yes. In the opening, you can see Yusho standing next to a monster that looks like a stage magician, with marking similar to Odd-Eyes Dragon. All three cards may have been given to Yuya by him.him.
** Magicians can be in circuses and can fit the fun theme.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Before they got Pendulumed, Why did Yuya have the original Magicians in his deck? They didn't fit his deck theme. Were they given to him by his father or something?

to:

* Before they got Pendulumed, Why did Yuya have the original Magicians in his deck? They didn't fit his deck theme. Were they given to him by his father or something?something?
** That's the current theory, yes. In the opening, you can see Yusho standing next to a monster that looks like a stage magician, with marking similar to Odd-Eyes Dragon. All three cards may have been given to Yuya by him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Yes, it's the new default. I doubt the Numbers will ever appear but I guess they thought that overlay network looked so cool, they'll just make it for evey Xyz in the show now. Also fridge brilliance when you read that Xyzs are made form anti-matter.

to:

** Yes, it's the new default. I doubt the Numbers will ever appear but I guess they thought that overlay network looked so cool, they'll just make it for evey Xyz in the show now. Also fridge brilliance when you read that Xyzs are made form anti-matter.anti-matter.
* Before they got Pendulumed, Why did Yuya have the original Magicians in his deck? They didn't fit his deck theme. Were they given to him by his father or something?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He just watched the conditions he was when he pendulum summoned, but it's unlikely the camara was able to record the specific cards he used nor the places the cards needed to be put to be able to pendulum summon (notice that in his duel with Yuzu he tried to use other cards instead of the two magicians and he also puts them in the wrong places).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Actually, if one looks at the poster where Yuya reads off the Summon courses in Episode 3, there's clearly a blue column next to the purple (Fusion), white (Synchro), and black (Xyz) columns, so they do have a Ritual course. The above-mentioned "not part of the Extra Deck" thing probably means it's just not as popular.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** For that matter, what gives a duel school the authority to mass produce cards? We aren't talking about Industrial Illusions that created the game, this is just a school that can teach people how to duel. And if they can indeed mass produce them legally (say, having the rights to produce the cards, like having bought out I2) why do they need Yuya? Reiji already knows exactly how the cards work, and it's not like someone can have a patent on a type of summon (that we know of) so why not just make their own pendulum monsters if they have that option?


Added DiffLines:

*** But what keeps Yuya from going "LOL I quit" and just leaving the school in general? I mean, it doesn't appear to be mandatory to attend a dueling school as Gongenzaka doesn't attend one, and they aren't competing over forcing Yuya to join the school, they're taking the school itself. I don't really see how Yuya is in any way inclined to remain with the school if he doesn't want to, and You-Show doesn't OWN pendulum summoning, Yuya is just the only person who has pendulum monsters. He could leave whenever he wants, or just quit right before the last guy loses, so the school still doesn't get pendulum summoning.
** What I don't get is why isn't LDS being more diplomatic in their approach? I mean, they don't need the school or Yuya, as far as I can tell, they just need the rights. Why make a challenge you might not win when you could just offer Yuya a ton of money for the details on pendulum summoning? Even if he said no (which he probably would) they never even consider that approach. I mean, at least Kaiba offered to trade for the Blue-Eyes before he took it from Grandpa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The experimenting thing might be a good explanation since episode 9 shows that he doesn't necessarily need the two wizard cards to make a pendulum summon.

to:

** The experimenting thing might be a good explanation since episode 9 shows that he doesn't necessarily need the two wizard magician cards to make a pendulum summon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So, is the black hole Overlay Network the new default? because in Zexal, that was only supposed to be for the Numbers and other plot-important Xyz monsters; everyone else had a red swirl.

to:

* So, is the black hole Overlay Network the new default? because in Zexal, that was only supposed to be for the Numbers and other plot-important Xyz monsters; everyone else had a red swirl.swirl.
** Yes, it's the new default. I doubt the Numbers will ever appear but I guess they thought that overlay network looked so cool, they'll just make it for evey Xyz in the show now. Also fridge brilliance when you read that Xyzs are made form anti-matter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Remember that this was due to those dealing the injuries being a massive jerkass (though that begs the question of why Shuzou didn't complain. Himika likely didn't, well, because evil.) Turbo Dueling is also at far faster speeds and requires the operation of a vehicle. Also note that Action Duels can only occur in certain locations, and this is likely the very reason Duel Schools exist - so that the graduates can Action Duel legally. Most Action Fields probably aren't as dangerous as Dark Town either. On top of that, I wouldn't be surprised if there were safety protocols. Then again, considering who invented it, I wouldn't e surprised if there weren't, either.

to:

** Remember that this was due to those dealing the injuries being a massive jerkass (though that begs the question of why Shuzou didn't complain. Himika likely didn't, well, because evil.) Turbo Dueling is also at far faster speeds and requires the operation of a vehicle. Also note that Action Duels can only occur in certain locations, and this is likely the very reason Duel Schools exist - so that the graduates can Action Duel legally. Most Action Fields probably aren't as dangerous as Dark Town either. On top of that, I wouldn't be surprised if there were safety protocols. Then again, considering who invented it, I wouldn't e surprised if there weren't, either.either.
* So, is the black hole Overlay Network the new default? because in Zexal, that was only supposed to be for the Numbers and other plot-important Xyz monsters; everyone else had a red swirl.

Added: 671

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** WHo knows? Given that they're also making a comeback in the OCG/TCG, they might appear later.

to:

** WHo Who knows? Given that they're also making a comeback in the OCG/TCG, they might appear later.



* Why are children (or anyone for that matter), even allowed to play in Action Duels? Depending on where you are when something happens to one of your monsters (as seen in several episodes), either player could be seriously injured or even killed. 5D's turbo dueling required heavy licensing and safety regulations, yet Action Duels require nothing.

to:

* Why are children (or anyone for that matter), even allowed to play in Action Duels? Depending on where you are when something happens to one of your monsters (as seen in several episodes), either player could be seriously injured or even killed. 5D's turbo dueling required heavy licensing and safety regulations, yet Action Duels require nothing.nothing.
** Remember that this was due to those dealing the injuries being a massive jerkass (though that begs the question of why Shuzou didn't complain. Himika likely didn't, well, because evil.) Turbo Dueling is also at far faster speeds and requires the operation of a vehicle. Also note that Action Duels can only occur in certain locations, and this is likely the very reason Duel Schools exist - so that the graduates can Action Duel legally. Most Action Fields probably aren't as dangerous as Dark Town either. On top of that, I wouldn't be surprised if there were safety protocols. Then again, considering who invented it, I wouldn't e surprised if there weren't, either.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why are children (or anyone for that matter) even allowed to play in Action Duels? Depending on where you are when something happens to one of your monsters (as seen in several episodes) either player could be seriously injured or even killed. 5D's turbo dueling required heavy licensing and safety regulations, yet Action Duels require nothing.

to:

* Why are children (or anyone for that matter) matter), even allowed to play in Action Duels? Depending on where you are when something happens to one of your monsters (as seen in several episodes) episodes), either player could be seriously injured or even killed. 5D's turbo dueling required heavy licensing and safety regulations, yet Action Duels require nothing.

Changed: 102

Removed: 101

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why are children (or anyone for that matter) even allowed to play in Action Duels? Depending on where you are when something happens to one of your monsters (as seen in several episodes) either player could be seriously injured or even killed.
5D's turbo dueling required heavy licensing and safety regulations, yet Action Duels require nothing.

to:

* Why are children (or anyone for that matter) even allowed to play in Action Duels? Depending on where you are when something happens to one of your monsters (as seen in several episodes) either player could be seriously injured or even killed.
killed. 5D's turbo dueling required heavy licensing and safety regulations, yet Action Duels require nothing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He'd probably be under contract to do so if LDS took over. Also note that Reiji has claimed to have a near-complete understanding of Pendulum monsters now, possibly to the point that they can be mass-produced.

to:

** He'd probably be under contract to do so if LDS took over. Also note that Reiji has claimed to have a near-complete understanding of Pendulum monsters now, possibly to the point that they can be mass-produced.mass-produced.
* Why are children (or anyone for that matter) even allowed to play in Action Duels? Depending on where you are when something happens to one of your monsters (as seen in several episodes) either player could be seriously injured or even killed.
5D's turbo dueling required heavy licensing and safety regulations, yet Action Duels require nothing.

Added: 534

Changed: 330

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Even if the You Show Duel School loses to LDS and the latter absorbs him, what makes them think that Yuya would just willingly tell them all the deets on Pendulum summoning? And unless they can get to mass-producing Pendulum cards instantly, it would be hard to teach about them when only one or two people can use them.

to:

** WHo knows? Given that they're also making a comeback in the OCG/TCG, they might appear later.
* Even if the You Show Duel School loses to LDS and the latter absorbs him, what makes them think that Yuya would just willingly tell them all the deets on Pendulum summoning? And unless they can get to mass-producing Pendulum cards instantly, it would be hard to teach about them when only one or two people can use them.them.
** He'd probably be under contract to do so if LDS took over. Also note that Reiji has claimed to have a near-complete understanding of Pendulum monsters now, possibly to the point that they can be mass-produced.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why wasn't Ritual Summoning given a course at LDS? Granted, Ritual monsters don't come from the Extra Deck, but they're a unique summoning method that's rarely seen.

to:

* Why wasn't Ritual Summoning given a course at LDS? Granted, Ritual monsters don't come from the Extra Deck, but they're a unique summoning method that's rarely seen.seen.
* Even if the You Show Duel School loses to LDS and the latter absorbs him, what makes them think that Yuya would just willingly tell them all the deets on Pendulum summoning? And unless they can get to mass-producing Pendulum cards instantly, it would be hard to teach about them when only one or two people can use them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For both the above points, it's implied/stated that LDS have been hoarding the special summoning methods to themselves. Sora claims it's normal where he comes from, suggesting that his home might be beyond their reach for now.

to:

** For both the above points, it's implied/stated that LDS have been hoarding the special summoning methods to themselves. Sora claims it's normal where he comes from, suggesting that his home might be beyond their reach for now.now.
* Why wasn't Ritual Summoning given a course at LDS? Granted, Ritual monsters don't come from the Extra Deck, but they're a unique summoning method that's rarely seen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The experimenting thing might be a good explanation since episode 9 shows that he doesn't necessarily need the two wizard cards to make a pendulum summon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* For that matter why is Fusion Summoning a big deal? It's been part of the game since the games inception and is one of the most basic things in the game.

to:

* For that matter why is Fusion Summoning a big deal? It's been part of the game since the games inception and is one of the most basic things in the game.game.
** For both the above points, it's implied/stated that LDS have been hoarding the special summoning methods to themselves. Sora claims it's normal where he comes from, suggesting that his home might be beyond their reach for now.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Because they're morons? The Dark Duelist did say that their dueling (specifically Shingo's) didn't have the "sharpness of a blade or the precision of a bullet".

to:

** Because they're morons? The Dark Duelist did say that their dueling (specifically Shingo's) didn't have the "sharpness of a blade or the precision of a bullet".bullet".
*For that matter why is Fusion Summoning a big deal? It's been part of the game since the games inception and is one of the most basic things in the game.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why did Shingo's buddies make such a big deal about Xyz Summoning? They say that the class on it is one of the highest level in their schcool, but the rules for it are pretty simple, and everyone should at least know the basics.

to:

* Why did Shingo's buddies make such a big deal about Xyz Summoning? They say that the class on it is one of the highest level in their schcool, but the rules for it are pretty simple, and everyone should at least know the basics.basics.
** Because they're morons? The Dark Duelist did say that their dueling (specifically Shingo's) didn't have the "sharpness of a blade or the precision of a bullet".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Notice that he replicates the conditions exactly as they were in his duel against Ishijima. It would take a fair number of duels to get the exact same hand (in many of them, he was likely testing other Pendulum Monsters, like Odd-Eyes and the Entermate ones) especially as, since it's offscreen, he won't have super drawing skills. Though the number is a little extreme. It's also likely that due to the odd nature of the Summon, he hasn't joined the dots when it comes to Scales and Levels (which, considering having something in between a number is a new concept for the game, is not that far-fetched.)

to:

** Notice that he replicates the conditions exactly as they were in his duel against Ishijima. It would take a fair number of duels to get the exact same hand (in many of them, he was likely testing other Pendulum Monsters, like Odd-Eyes and the Entermate ones) especially as, since it's offscreen, he won't have super drawing skills. Though the number is a little extreme. It's also likely that due to the odd nature of the Summon, he hasn't joined the dots when it comes to Scales and Levels (which, considering having something in between a number is a new concept for the game, is not that far-fetched.))
*Why did Shingo's buddies make such a big deal about Xyz Summoning? They say that the class on it is one of the highest level in their schcool, but the rules for it are pretty simple, and everyone should at least know the basics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And in the case of Neos it actually was a legitimate card, it just got sent into space.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Yep. There is a very short list of cards that have been used bu multiple people, even after 1000 episodes, so people just rolled with it when they have never seen E-Hero Neos or ZW - Tornado Bringer before, but Yuya pushed it by creating his own card type, which is what made everyone call BS on him.

Added: 953

Changed: 436

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Yuya mentions having watched recordings of his duel, so how did it take him three hundred duels to replicate Pendulum summoning? Did he not take the time to examine his cards? Or even just pay attention to the words he spoke (something to the effect of "Now I can summon any monster from level 2 to 7!")? Is this just another case of IdiotHero?

to:

** By most of those incredibly broken standards, they are often supernatural/unrevealed to the general public. This is likely why Pendulum Summoning is an issue, but it's more the case that only Yuya so far is capable of performing it.
* Yuya mentions having watched recordings of his duel, so how did it take him three hundred duels to replicate Pendulum summoning? Did he not take the time to examine his cards? Or even just pay attention to the words he spoke (something to the effect of "Now I can summon any monster from level 2 to 7!")? Is this just another case of IdiotHero?IdiotHero?
** Notice that he replicates the conditions exactly as they were in his duel against Ishijima. It would take a fair number of duels to get the exact same hand (in many of them, he was likely testing other Pendulum Monsters, like Odd-Eyes and the Entermate ones) especially as, since it's offscreen, he won't have super drawing skills. Though the number is a little extreme. It's also likely that due to the odd nature of the Summon, he hasn't joined the dots when it comes to Scales and Levels (which, considering having something in between a number is a new concept for the game, is not that far-fetched.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I can get why Pendulum summoning would be broken in the real world, considering all the archetypes out there that could abuse the crap out of the instant special summon thing, but by the standards of the various Yugioh animes (ESPECIALLY after the brokenness that was Don Thousand) it's ridiculously tame, so how can the characters really consider Pendulum summoning to be so OMGSUPERUNBEATABLE?

to:

* I can get why Pendulum summoning would be broken in the real world, considering all the archetypes out there that could abuse the crap out of the instant special summon thing, but by the standards of the various Yugioh animes (ESPECIALLY after the brokenness that was Don Thousand) it's ridiculously tame, so how can the characters really consider Pendulum summoning to be so OMGSUPERUNBEATABLE?OMGSUPERUNBEATABLE?
* Yuya mentions having watched recordings of his duel, so how did it take him three hundred duels to replicate Pendulum summoning? Did he not take the time to examine his cards? Or even just pay attention to the words he spoke (something to the effect of "Now I can summon any monster from level 2 to 7!")? Is this just another case of IdiotHero?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I can get why Pendulum summoning would be broken in the real world, considering all the archetypes out there that could abuse the crap out of the instant special summon thing, but by the standards of Yugioh series in general it's ridiculously tame, so how can the characters really consider Pendulum summoning to be so OMGSUPERUNBEATABLE?

to:

* I can get why Pendulum summoning would be broken in the real world, considering all the archetypes out there that could abuse the crap out of the instant special summon thing, but by the standards of the various Yugioh series in general animes (ESPECIALLY after the brokenness that was Don Thousand) it's ridiculously tame, so how can the characters really consider Pendulum summoning to be so OMGSUPERUNBEATABLE?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* I can get why Pendulum summoning would be broken in the real world, considering all the archetypes out there that could abuse the crap out of the instant special summon thing, but by the standards of Yugioh series in general it's ridiculously tame, so how can the characters really consider Pendulum summoning to be so OMGSUPERUNBEATABLE?

Top