Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Funny / TerribleWritingAdvice

Go To

OR

Added: 89

Changed: 153

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JP notes that a lot of isekai stories fall into the HaremGenre, and begins with a grim historical description of harems before realizing that he's reading off his history notes.
* JP demonstrates how shallow the harem cast is by presenting a table with an assortment of physical attributes. Just roll dice to mix-and-match the physical appearance of each character and your harem is done! Personality? They have none other than "is in love with the protagonist."

to:

* JP notes that a lot of isekai stories fall into also feature elements of the HaremGenre, and begins with a grim historical description of harems before realizing that he's reading off his history notes.
* JP demonstrates how shallow the harem cast is by presenting a table with an assortment of physical attributes. Just roll dice to mix-and-match mix and match the physical appearance attributes of each character and your harem is done! Personality? They have none other than "is "[[SatelliteLoveInterest is in love with the protagonist.protagonist]]."



** He later adds that there is a way to expand on the protagonist's character to make him more sympathetic: by [[HerosSlaveHarem contributing to slavery]]. JP's tone stumbles a bit as he [[WhoWritesThisCrap double-checks his script]].

to:

** He later adds that there is a way to expand on the protagonist's character to make him more sympathetic: by [[HerosSlaveHarem contributing to slavery]]. JP's tone JP stumbles a bit as he [[WhoWritesThisCrap double-checks his script]].



* When he goes into talking about shipping etiquette and ShipToShipCombat, he sets up a hypothetical example of shippers who are fans for a show made for children. From the way he says "show made for children" you can already tell how much shipping such characters repulses him. And the comments cannot agree on which show he's talking about!

to:

* When he goes into talking about shipping etiquette and ShipToShipCombat, he sets up a hypothetical example of shippers who are fans for a show made for children. From the way he says "show made for children" you can already tell how much shipping such characters repulses him. And It's such a prevalent phenomenon that the comments cannot agree on which show he's talking about!



* JP starts the video reading off his character sheet which is rife with SelfDeprecation.



* Now that he's established the characters of a [=LitRPG=] story, he needs a setting, and what better setting than the common Tolkeinesque HighFantasy? Don't worry, it's not a lazy copy-paste, because he's added catgirls!

to:

* Now that he's established the characters of a [=LitRPG=] story, he needs a setting, and what better setting than the common Tolkeinesque HighFantasy? MedievalEuropeanFantasy? Don't worry, it's not a lazy copy-paste, because he's added catgirls!



* On the concept of using the game mechanics in the story, he gleefully tosses aside the brainpower needed to spin them into an interesting story and just uses it because it's cool. The result is a combat log where [[TheGoomba a normal rat]] hits the protagonist for [[DivideByZero an erroneous]] amount of damage that spills out and injures the party, the game world, and the multiverse.

to:

* On the concept of using the game mechanics in the story, he gleefully tosses aside the brainpower needed to spin them into an interesting story and just uses it because it's cool. The result is a combat log where [[TheGoomba a normal rat]] hits the protagonist for [[DivideByZero an erroneous]] amount of damage that kills him, then spills out and injures the party, the game world, and the multiverse.

Added: 51

Changed: 54

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What if the audience doesn't want a harem? He suggests starting with a small romantic plot before [[RomanticPlotTumor expanding it into a whole harem later in the story.]] This is illustrated by him sneaking a [[Running Gag love triangle]] into a story.

to:

* What if the audience doesn't want a harem? He suggests starting with a small romantic plot before [[RomanticPlotTumor expanding it into a whole harem later in the story.]] This is illustrated by him sneaking a [[Running Gag [[RunningGag love triangle]] into a story.



* Now that he's established the characters of a [=LitRPG=] story, he needs a setting, and what better setting than the common Tolkeinesque HighFantasy? Don't worry, it's not a lazy copy-paste, because he's added catgirls! ''[[SarcasmMode "Pushing the originality there!"]]''

to:

* Now that he's established the characters of a [=LitRPG=] story, he needs a setting, and what better setting than the common Tolkeinesque HighFantasy? Don't worry, it's not a lazy copy-paste, because he's added catgirls! ''[[SarcasmMode catgirls!
-->[[SarcasmMode
"Pushing the originality there!"]]''there!"]]

Added: 662

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JP's contempt toward the harem trope (yes, it's even found its way into Western [=LitRPGs=]) is made clear, especially when he describes how the UnresolvedRomanticTension stays unresolved either from plot contrivances, or because the VanillaProtagonist has no characterization whatsoever.

to:

* JP's contempt toward the harem trope (yes, it's even found its way into Western [=LitRPGs=]) is made clear, especially when he describes how the UnresolvedRomanticTension UnresolvedSexualTension stays unresolved either from plot contrivances, or because the VanillaProtagonist has no characterization whatsoever.


Added DiffLines:

* Now that he's established the characters of a [=LitRPG=] story, he needs a setting, and what better setting than the common Tolkeinesque HighFantasy? Don't worry, it's not a lazy copy-paste, because he's added catgirls! ''[[SarcasmMode "Pushing the originality there!"]]''
* On the concept of using the game mechanics in the story, he gleefully tosses aside the brainpower needed to spin them into an interesting story and just uses it because it's cool. The result is a combat log where [[TheGoomba a normal rat]] hits the protagonist for [[DivideByZero an erroneous]] amount of damage that spills out and injures the party, the game world, and the multiverse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JP's contempt toward the harem trope (yes, it's even found its way into Western [=LitRPGs=]) is made clear, especially when he describes how the UnresolvedRomanticTension stays unresolved either from plot contrivances, or because the VanillaProtagonist has no characterization whatsoever.
* What if the audience doesn't want a harem? He suggests starting with a small romantic plot before [[RomanticPlotTumor expanding it into a whole harem later in the story.]] This is illustrated by him sneaking a [[Running Gag love triangle]] into a story.
* JP adds that a power fantasy isn't a bad thing -- the audience wants to see a strong protagonist, but what matters is the journey to obtaining and mastering their power. After all, a shortcut to power is like taking a cab to an end of a marathon -- it defeats the point, and would that even be fun? [[ItsAllAboutMe Well, it sure is fun for him!]]

Added: 12

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!World building Governments and Politics

to:

!!World building !!Worldbuilding Governments and Politics


Added DiffLines:


!![=LitRPG=]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The episode begins with JP getting hit by Truck-kun (a truck with big anime eyes) and waking up with AnimeHair.

to:

* The episode begins with JP getting hit by Truck-kun (a truck with big anime eyes) and waking up with AnimeHair.AnimeHair and eyes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* The second thing the video establishes, after the setting (take the modern world and slap on some magic), is the LoveTriangle. And of course, it doesn't even hide that it's taking a potshot at ''Literature/{{Twilight}}'', as the first two possible suitor choices are vampires and werewolves, while gleefully tossing aside the usual flaws that each mythical creature type would suffer from.

to:

* The second thing the video establishes, after the setting (take the modern world and slap on some magic), is the LoveTriangle. And of course, it doesn't even hide that it's taking a potshot at ''Literature/{{Twilight}}'', ''Literature/TheTwilightSaga'', as the first two possible suitor choices are vampires and werewolves, while gleefully tossing aside the usual flaws that each mythical creature type would suffer from.

Added: 258

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!Worldbuilding Governments and Politics

to:

!!Worldbuilding !!World building Governments and PoliticsPolitics
* This moment:
-->'''JP:''' "Now, JP," I hear you ask, "Surely you don't need to cover the U.S.' system of democracy! Are you suggesting that your majority American audience doesn't know how their own government works?"\\
''({{beat}})''\\
'''JP:''' So, anyway--
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* With writing the beginning, he notes a strange trend of [[LookBothWays killing the character in his original world via traffic accident]] to set up his reincarnation into the fantasy world, instead of the billion other ways you can establish such a story. The LongList of ideas he brainstorms is something he's done in ''two minutes'', and there's a note saying "Surely isekai writers could have done better if they actually tried?"

to:

* With writing the beginning, he notes a strange trend of [[LookBothWays [[RunningOverThePlot killing the character in his original world via traffic accident]] to set up his reincarnation into the fantasy world, instead of the billion other ways you can establish such a story. The LongList of ideas he brainstorms is something he's done in ''two minutes'', and there's a note saying "Surely isekai writers could have done better if they actually tried?"



* When pondering what to do after [[StuffedIntoTheFridge stuffing a love interest into the fridge]] to start the story, JP suggests reveling in over-the-top grimdark violence and placing it [[ActionPrologue at the beginning of the story]] [[MoodWhiplash even though the rest of the book might be a light-hearted action-adventure tale]]. Since he can't actually ''show'' the violence without getting demonetized by [=YouTube=], he puts up an "[[RelaxOVision unrelated ad saving puppy]]".

to:

* When pondering what to do after [[StuffedIntoTheFridge stuffing a love interest into the fridge]] to start the story, JP suggests reveling in [[RRatedOpening over-the-top grimdark violence and placing it [[ActionPrologue at the beginning of the story]] even though [[MoodWhiplash even though the rest of the book might be a light-hearted action-adventure tale]]. Since he can't actually ''show'' the violence without getting demonetized by [=YouTube=], he puts up an "[[RelaxOVision unrelated ad saving puppy]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


!!Worldbuilding Governments and Politics
* JP’s section on “Power and Influence of States” has a segment featuring [[StrawmanNewsMedia Generic News Network]] with the headline “United Nations suddenly highly competent and evil!”, while the newscaster delivers what’s seemingly a spoof of the [[Literature/LeftBehind Left Behind]] series, saying that a coalition of nations including “Iceland, New Zealand, Luxembourg, Kansas and The North Pole” invaded Israel, and all their leaders say “Because The Book of Revelations says so. Glory to The Beast”!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When all else fails and the author risks ''expending effort to write'', he suggests taking an existing template and adding a gimmick to it, such as the protagonist getting to fantasy land [[LightNovel/InAnotherWorldWithMySmartphone with his cellphone!]] That has [[CellPhonesAreUseless no reception]].

to:

* When all else fails and the author risks ''expending effort to write'', he suggests taking an existing template and adding a gimmick to it, such as the protagonist getting to fantasy land [[LightNovel/InAnotherWorldWithMySmartphone [[Literature/InAnotherWorldWithMySmartphone with his cellphone!]] That has [[CellPhonesAreUseless no reception]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* He says that even if the Elite Mooks are effective, they won't appear again after they manage to capture the Hero. This is over a scene of [[WesternAnimation/AvatarTheLastAirbender Aang]] being told by an Earth Kingdom soldier that he hasn't seen any [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Recap/AvatarTheLastAirbenderTheBlueSpirit archers]] in the enemy ranks.

to:

* He says that even if the Elite Mooks are effective, they won't appear again after they manage to capture the Hero. This is over a scene of [[WesternAnimation/AvatarTheLastAirbender Aang]] being told by an Earth Kingdom soldier that he hasn't seen any [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Recap/AvatarTheLastAirbenderTheBlueSpirit [[Recap/AvatarTheLastAirbenderTheBlueSpirit archers]] in the enemy ranks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This trope fits the context.


!![[RatedMForManly Alpha Heroes]]

to:

!![[RatedMForManly !![[FetishizedAbuser Alpha Heroes]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JP almost breaks the character at many points when describing the comic relief character, with a clear disdain in his voice.

to:

* JP almost breaks the character at many points when describing the comic relief character, with a clear disdain in his voice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JP almost breaks the character at many points when describing the comic relief character, with a clear disdain in his voice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


!!Dungeon Crawl
* JP recalls a tabletop story of an adventuring party reaching a fork in the road. Their first choice leads them to a troll cave. They're not interested, so they double back and take the other path... [[{{Railroading}} which leads them to a troll cave.]] They get frustrated and go back the way they came... [[ButThouMust and come across yet another troll cave.]]
* He takes a bit of liberty with the term "{{Troll}}" and frames the need to go into the troll cave because the king, ignoring the saying "thou shalt not feed the trolls", set out a bounty for the troll's head after it left some inflammatory comments on the royal missive boards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:2023]]
!!Evil Lackeys
*JP talks about adding EliteMooks to the story. Only the word "Elite" is framed by enough quotation marks to stretch to both sides of the screen.
* He says that even if the Elite Mooks are effective, they won't appear again after they manage to capture the Hero. This is over a scene of [[WesternAnimation/AvatarTheLastAirbender Aang]] being told by an Earth Kingdom soldier that he hasn't seen any [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Recap/AvatarTheLastAirbenderTheBlueSpirit archers]] in the enemy ranks.
* When talking about the Dark Lord's [[YouHaveFailedMe Zero Tolerance policy for failure]], he shows the Dark Lord {{Neck Lift}}ing a mook next to a sign reading "(0) Days since the Dark Lord shot the messenger".
* A man in a suit is joining the Evil Lackeys:
--> '''Boss:''' "You have an impressive resume, but why leave Tech Support?"
--> '''Applicant:''' "Because working Tech Support has left me with an infinite well of hatred for Humanity! So I figured changing jobs to Evil Lackey would be at worst a lateral move."
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In "Filler" he doesn't even want to spare the effort to write a love triangle, and suggests that the filler love interest be erased via a "filler black hole" which also gets used to erase other temporary elements like neighboring countries and {{MacGuffin}}s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!Fan Fiction {{Original Characters}}

to:

!!Fan Fiction {{Original Characters}}Character}}s
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[/folder]]

to:

[[/folder]]





to:

[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

!!Deconstruction
* JP explains the "best" motive for deconstructing something is [[ComplainingAboutShowsYouDontWatch petty spite of a genre you don't watch or understand]] to show off [[SmallNameBigEgo how smart you are]], as opposed to actually telling a story - you know, [[TheBully being a bully]]. This is represented by his avatar shaking Creator/JRRTolkien by the scruff of his collar and demanding his lunch money.
* The running gag of something being hit with a big red [DECONSTRUCTED] stamp whenever JP does his ShallowParody DarkerAndEdgier advice for various topic. The BrickJoke hits when he accidentally describes the premise of his show as a deconstruction of advice channels, and his avatar is knocked over by the stamp.

Added: 629

Changed: 417

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JP also illustrates how easy it is to assemble the harem cast by displaying each physical attribute in a table, with instructions to roll dice to determine which combination of physical traits make up the character. As for characterization? They don't have any other than "[[SatelliteLoveInterest is in love with the protagonist]]".

to:

* JP also illustrates demonstrates how easy it is to assemble shallow the harem cast is by displaying each presenting a table with an assortment of physical attribute in a table, with instructions to attributes. Just roll dice to determine which combination of mix-and-match the physical traits make up the character. As for characterization? appearance of each character and your harem is done! Personality? They don't have any none other than "[[SatelliteLoveInterest is "is in love with the protagonist]]".protagonist."



* The isekai protagonist themselves is described as "[[VanillaProtagonist with a character as flat as the loli's chest]]" and "whose nationality and culture is as interchangeable as the cardboard box the Blu-Ray arrives in".

to:

* The isekai protagonist themselves is described as "[[VanillaProtagonist with a character as flat as the loli's chest]]" and "whose nationality and culture is as interchangeable and deep as the cardboard box the Blu-Ray arrives in".



* When discussing how political figures react to the protagonist tearing up the setting, one example he throws out is the baron bribing the hero with a harem that he can actually sleep with and won't [[PervertRevengeMode assault him when he sees their underwear by accident.]]



** One idea involves a ScienceHero teleporting into the fantasy land, with every instance of "Science!" announced with reverb. Also the hook lampshades how cool it would be "to see Manga/DrStone science around in Fantasy Land."
** "A wardrobe leads to Jesus lion" is a blatant ''Literature/{{Narnia}}'' reference -- it's basically an isekai story anyway.



** When all else fails and all other ways to start the plot actually ''take effort to write'', he suggests that the protagonist is simply whisked off to another world! [[LightNovel/InAnotherWorldWithMySmartphone With his cellphone!]] That has [[CellPhonesAreUseless no reception]].

to:

** * When all else fails and all other ways to start the plot actually ''take author risks ''expending effort to write'', he suggests that taking an existing template and adding a gimmick to it, such as the protagonist is simply whisked off getting to another world! fantasy land [[LightNovel/InAnotherWorldWithMySmartphone With with his cellphone!]] That has [[CellPhonesAreUseless no reception]].reception]].


Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When a scene that reads like it's from a pornographic work won't do, he instead suggests IkeaErotica or [[MillsAndBoonsProse Purple Prose Porn]].

to:

* When a scene that reads like it's from a pornographic work won't do, he instead suggests IkeaErotica or [[MillsAndBoonsProse [[MillsAndBoonProse Purple Prose Porn]].

Added: 651

Changed: 29

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When a scene that reads like it's from a pornographic work won't do, he instead suggests IkeaErotica or PurpleProse.

to:

* When a scene that reads like it's from a pornographic work won't do, he instead suggests IkeaErotica or PurpleProse.[[MillsAndBoonsProse Purple Prose Porn]].
-->'''Beige:''' He then inserted tab A into slot B and repeated. He finished assembly quickly in under 2 minutes, but his partner was unsatisfied with the results and they had to return the bed back to the store.\\
'''Purple:''' They were joined in a single act of decadent expression. Like a birth of a bright shining star, or existing in the eye of a tropical storm. The tempestuous sea of desire that their souls navigated, joined in lascivious ambrosia, could only be cast about in the endless dephts of aching pleasure.\\
'''JP:''' So, what just happened? Did they make love? Are they on a sailboat or something? Did they just buy a car? Who knows!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In "Noble Houses", JP's noble house motto is the comically bad Latin phrase "Amor Triangulo".

Top