Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Funny / Gettysburg

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->(''A shell explodes just a few feet away'')

to:

-->(''A -->(''[[FunnyBackgroundEvent A shell explodes just a few feet away'')away]]'')
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Harry Heth's report to General Lee, explaining how the "militia" he thought he was dealing turned out to be dismounted cavalry who were not about to be swept away so easily.
--> "Well sir--they wouldn't ''leave!''"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* One of the 2nd Maine's complaints, as described by Private Bucklin, are that their commanders were "so stupid they couldn't pour piss out of a boot with instructions written on the heel."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Armistead and Garnett's last exchange before Pickett's charge is darkly funny.
--> '''Garnett''': How are you, Lew?
-->(''A shell explodes just a few feet away'')
--> '''Armistead''' (''unfazed''): [[CasualDangerDialogue I'm fine, Dick.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Before that, when the 20th is moving into position under artillery fire:
--> '''Chamberlain:''' Tom, move farther down the line. Another one like that and it could be a hard day for mother.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I've seen this I don't know HOW many times. Probably the closest to this that happens is an exchange between Longstreet and T.J. Goree.


* This exchange between two Confederate officers:
-->'''Dick''': "How are you, Lou?"
-->''An artillery shell explodes just a few feet away.''
-->'''Lou''': [[CasualDangerDialogue "I'm fine, Dick."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* This exchange between two Confederate officers:
-->'''Dick''': "How are you, Lou?"
-->''An artillery shell explodes just a few feet away.''
-->'''Lou''': [[CasualDangerDialogue "I'm fine, Dick."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [Soldier]: I'm moving these Rebs with an empty musket.
** {Chamberlain}: Sh. Not so loud.

to:

** [Soldier]: --> '''Soldier''': I'm moving these Rebs with an empty musket.
** {Chamberlain}: --> '''Chamberlain''': Sh. Not so loud.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* From after the 20th Maine's bayonet charge:
** [Soldier]: I'm moving these Rebs with an empty musket.
** {Chamberlain}: Sh. Not so loud.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** A bit of a GeniusBonus, it's even funnier as a TakeThat to George [=McClellan=] (Who graduated first in his class in that year, but ultimately proved to be a rather ineffective field commander), though the West Point Class of 1846 also included Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson and a dozen other officers of both sides.

to:

*** A bit of a GeniusBonus, it's even funnier as a TakeThat to George [=McClellan=] (Who graduated first second in his class in that year, but ultimately proved to be a rather ineffective field commander), though the West Point Class of 1846 also included Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson and a dozen other officers of both sides.

Added: 4

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** Jackson himself had been regarded as a dumb country bumpkin at West Point, due to his origins as an orphan in rural western Virginia, and his performance at the Academy was considered mediocre at best. He was not taken seriously until the Mexican War, when it was [[TookALevelInBadass discovered that he was utterly fearless,had an uncanny talent for field command in combat, and could instinctively read a tactical situation and respond appropriately]]. As that war faded from memory, Jackson was again regarded as simple-minded and eccentric (Spending much of the time between wars as a decidedly mediocre math teacher at VMI didn't help), [[BadassDecay even if he was highly-skilled, bilingual, and one of the most decorated war heroes in American History to that point]]. Once Jackson had another war to fight, his negative reputation disappeared again.

to:

**** Jackson himself had been regarded as a dumb country bumpkin at West Point, due to his origins as an orphan in rural western Virginia, and his performance at the Academy was considered mediocre at best. He was not taken seriously until the Mexican War, when it was [[TookALevelInBadass discovered that he was utterly fearless,had fearless, had an uncanny talent for field command in combat, and could instinctively read a tactical situation and respond appropriately]]. As that war faded from memory, Jackson was again regarded as simple-minded and eccentric (Spending much of the time between wars as a decidedly mediocre math teacher at VMI didn't help), [[BadassDecay even if he was highly-skilled, bilingual, and one of the most decorated war heroes in American History to that point]]. Once Jackson had another war to fight, his negative reputation disappeared again.



*** And then Longstreet's exasperated eye roll over the whole thing as he walks away.

to:

*** And then Longstreet's exasperated eye roll over the whole thing as he walks away.away.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** Jackson himself had been regarded as a dumb country bumpkin at West Point, due to his origins as an orphan in rural western Virginia, and his performance at the Academy was considered mediocre at best. He was not taken seriously until the Mexican War, when it was [[TookALevelInBadass discovered that he was utterly fearless,had an uncanny talent for field command in combat, and could instinctively read a tactical situation and respond appropriately]]. As that war faded from memory, Jackson was again regarded as simple-minded and eccentric, [[BadassDecay even if he was highly-skilled, bilingual, and one of the most decorated war heroes in American History to that point]]. Once Jackson had another war to fight, his negative reputation disappeared again.

to:

**** Jackson himself had been regarded as a dumb country bumpkin at West Point, due to his origins as an orphan in rural western Virginia, and his performance at the Academy was considered mediocre at best. He was not taken seriously until the Mexican War, when it was [[TookALevelInBadass discovered that he was utterly fearless,had an uncanny talent for field command in combat, and could instinctively read a tactical situation and respond appropriately]]. As that war faded from memory, Jackson was again regarded as simple-minded and eccentric, eccentric (Spending much of the time between wars as a decidedly mediocre math teacher at VMI didn't help), [[BadassDecay even if he was highly-skilled, bilingual, and one of the most decorated war heroes in American History to that point]]. Once Jackson had another war to fight, his negative reputation disappeared again.

Added: 768

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** A bit of a GeniusBonus, it's even funnier as a TakeThat to George [=McClellan=] (Who graduated first in his class in that year, but ultimately proved to be a rather ineffective field commander), though the West Point Class of 1846 also included Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson and a dozen other officers of both sides.

to:

*** A bit of a GeniusBonus, it's even funnier as a TakeThat to George [=McClellan=] (Who graduated first in his class in that year, but ultimately proved to be a rather ineffective field commander), though the West Point Class of 1846 also included Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson and a dozen other officers of both sides.
**** Jackson himself had been regarded as a dumb country bumpkin at West Point, due to his origins as an orphan in rural western Virginia, and his performance at the Academy was considered mediocre at best. He was not taken seriously until the Mexican War, when it was [[TookALevelInBadass discovered that he was utterly fearless,had an uncanny talent for field command in combat, and could instinctively read a tactical situation and respond appropriately]]. As that war faded from memory, Jackson was again regarded as simple-minded and eccentric, [[BadassDecay even if he was highly-skilled, bilingual, and one of the most decorated war heroes in American History to that point]]. Once Jackson had another war to fight, his negative reputation disappeared again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** A bit of a GeniusBonus, it's even funnier as a TakeThat to George [=McClellan=], though the West Point Class of 1846 also included Thomas Jackson and a dozen other officers of both sides.

to:

*** A bit of a GeniusBonus, it's even funnier as a TakeThat to George [=McClellan=], [=McClellan=] (Who graduated first in his class in that year, but ultimately proved to be a rather ineffective field commander), though the West Point Class of 1846 also included Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson and a dozen other officers of both sides.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The following argument against evolution: while one could suggest that Pickett or Armistead might be descended from an ape, no one would ever suggest that General Lee is descended from an ape.

to:

*** The following argument against evolution: while one could suggest that Pickett or Armistead might be descended from an ape, no one would ever suggest that General Lee is descended from an ape.ape.
*** And then Longstreet's exasperated eye roll over the whole thing as he walks away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** As Armistead and Longstreet walk away, Kemper can be heard asking how many of Pickett's relatives are apes.

to:

*** As Armistead and Longstreet walk away, Kemper can be heard asking how many of Pickett's relatives are apes.apes.
*** The following argument against evolution: while one could suggest that Pickett or Armistead might be descended from an ape, no one would ever suggest that General Lee is descended from an ape.

Added: 140

Changed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** A bit of a GeniusBonus, it's even funnier as a TakeThat George McClellan, though the West Point Class of 1846 also included Thomas Jackson and a dozen other officers of both sides.

to:

*** A bit of a GeniusBonus, it's even funnier as a TakeThat to George McClellan, [=McClellan=], though the West Point Class of 1846 also included Thomas Jackson and a dozen other officers of both sides.sides.
**Kemper telling Pickett he has a talent for "trivializing the momentous and complicating the obvious," then suggesting he run for Congress.

Added: 543

Changed: 136

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Armistead and Pickett's evolution debate. "George, all science trembles before the searing logic of your fiery intellect."

to:

Armistead *The camp scenes with Pickett and his brigade commanders have quite a few.
**Longstreet's quip about Pickett ranking dead last in his class at West Point, "Quite a feat if you consider his classmates."
***A bit of a GeniusBonus, it's even funnier as a TakeThat George McClellan, though the West Point Class of 1846 also included Thomas Jackson and a dozen other officers of both sides.
**Armistead
and Pickett's evolution debate. "George, all science trembles before the searing logic of your fiery intellect.""
***As Armistead and Longstreet walk away, Kemper can be heard asking how many of Pickett's relatives are apes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Armistead and Pickett's evolution debate. "George, all science trembles before the searing logic of your fiery intellect."

Top