Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / Ib

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The implication is that [[GeniusLoci the gallery itself]] communicates with it's victims by leaving written messages.

to:

** The implication is that [[GeniusLoci the gallery itself]] communicates with it's victims by leaving written messages. It also seems to be serving [[spoiler: Mary]] by luring innocents into the art world [[spoiler: to replace her.]] Perhaps it initially started kidnapping people to give it's master [[IJustWantToHaveFriends some company.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The implication is that [[GeniusLoci the gallery itself]] communicates with it's victims by leaving written messages.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**If asked "are you a liar?", ''every painting in the room would answer "no"''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One of the variations of the "Ib All Alone" ending (namely, the one that is encountered when [[spoiler: Garry dies]]) has Ib [[spoiler: step away from the "Fabricated World" rather than jump in]]. Some players are confused as to why she would do this, but consider this: she only steps back after [[spoiler: reading the message "There's no going back. All your time here will be lost." She probably would rather stay in the gallery forever than ''forget''.]]

to:

* One of the variations of the "Ib All Alone" ending (namely, the one that is encountered when [[spoiler: Garry dies]]) has Ib [[spoiler: step away from the "Fabricated World" rather than jump in]]. Some players are confused as to why she would do this, but consider this: she only steps back after [[spoiler: reading the message "There's no going back. All your time here will be lost." She probably would rather stay in the gallery forever than ''forget''.]]]]
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* At first there seems to be no point to ''Carrie Careless and the Galette des Rois'' other than to freak out the player some more. However, [[spoiler: it's actually there to foreshadow what Garry will need to do to escape the Doll Room, i.e. cut a key out of one of their stomachs.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's mentioned that the blue dolls are an oddity that Guertena probably didn't create like everything else in the gallery. Which means it's most likely they were made by Mary, especially since she seems to think they're so cute and they're happy to help her when she needs it. So what book did [[spoiler: Ib and Garry find in Mary's room? ''How To Make Friends''. Mary had quite literally been "making friends"!]]

to:

* It's mentioned that the blue dolls are an oddity that Guertena probably didn't create like everything else in the gallery. Which means [[spoiler: it's most likely they were made by Mary, especially since she seems to think they're so cute and they're happy to help her when she needs it. it.]] So what book did [[spoiler: Ib and Garry find in Mary's room? ''How To Make Friends''. Mary had quite literally been "making friends"!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* It's mentioned that the blue dolls are an oddity that Guertena probably didn't create like everything else in the gallery. Which means it's most likely they were made by Mary, especially since she seems to think they're so cute and they're happy to help her when she needs it. So what book did [[spoiler: Ib and Garry find in Mary's room? ''How To Make Friends''. Mary had quite literally been "making friends"!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler:If you try to look into a mirror with Mary in your party (which you probably won't, since it involves otherwise pointless backtracking), the mirror shatters.]]

to:

* [[spoiler:If you try to look into a mirror with Mary in your party (which you probably won't, since it involves otherwise pointless backtracking), the mirror shatters.shatters - probably because [[GlamourFailure false humans have no reflections]], which would have quickly revealed that Mary is actually one of the artworks.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alternately, we see these images only when playing as Ib. When the player is controlling Garry, we no longer see the hanging images of Ib or the bunnies - we see things that would cater only to Garry's fears, like the blue doll that follows him in the hallway leading to the Doll Room. It's more likely that the gallery appears different to each person who enters, and that the person witnessing it subconsciously projects their own fears and memories into the gallery, like a "blank canvas," so to speak. The reason it appears to target Ib the most is because we see the most of her perspective (due to her being the main character).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Worse, what happens when one of her parents realizes their small daughter is carrying [[spoiler: a lighter]] around? They'll probably take it away from her for safety's sake anyway, but what if they punish her just for having it, or accuse her of stealing it? It's bad enough she'll lose her keepsake, but how will it change her parents' perception of her, realizing their sad, traumatized daughter was hiding a fire-starting tool without their knowledge?

to:

** Worse, what happens when one of her parents realizes their small daughter is carrying [[spoiler: a lighter]] around? They'll probably take it away from her for safety's sake anyway, but what if they punish her just for having it, or accuse her of stealing it? It's bad enough she'll lose her keepsake, but how will it change her parents' perception of her, realizing their sad, traumatized daughter was hiding a fire-starting tool without their knowledge?knowledge?
* One of the variations of the "Ib All Alone" ending (namely, the one that is encountered when [[spoiler: Garry dies]]) has Ib [[spoiler: step away from the "Fabricated World" rather than jump in]]. Some players are confused as to why she would do this, but consider this: she only steps back after [[spoiler: reading the message "There's no going back. All your time here will be lost." She probably would rather stay in the gallery forever than ''forget''.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I've always read it as "Don't kill me"... 'cause, you know, [[spoiler: Mary is afraid of fire]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*[[ParanoiaFuel Just what the hell is in the moving box?!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*After Garry attempts using the lighter in the seperation room, the walls and floor are covered with messages. Most read "NONONO" or "DON'T"..however one in the corner appears to read "Don't kick me".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While many fans like to ship Ib/Garry, the gallery itself apparently does, too - the first area you run into after Garry joins you is the area with the Groo and the Bride.

to:

* While many fans like to ship Ib/Garry, the gallery itself apparently does, too - the first area you run into after Garry joins you is the area with the Groo Groom and the Bride.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler: Worse: he isn't just holding a paintbrush in the painting, there's green paint on his canvas. Green paint of an oddly familiar shade and something that looks like an outline of a skirt and a tiny leg. There may be a reason Mary was both his last and his most life-like painting - he breathed all of his life energy into her and left none for himself.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's likely that the book [[spoiler: tailors itself to whoever is reading it. When Ib is reading it, the story mentions the girl's parents and her being hungry and thirsty, but when Mary is reading it, this words blur together, because Mary doesn't have parents and cannot get hungry or thirsty]].

to:

** It's likely that the book [[spoiler: tailors itself to whoever is reading it. When Ib is reading it, the story mentions the girl's parents and her being hungry and thirsty, but when Mary is reading it, this these words blur together, because Mary doesn't have parents and cannot get hungry or thirsty]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's likely that the book [[spoiler: tailors itself to whoever is reading it. When Ib is reading it, the story mentions the girl's parents and her being hungry and thirsty, but when Mary is reading it, this words blur together, because Mary doesn't have parents and cannot get hungry or thirsty]].

Changed: 173

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* While many fans like to ship Ib/Garry, the gallery itself apparently does, too - the first area you run into after Garry joins you is the area with the Groo and the Bride.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the "Forgotten Portrait" ending, [[spoiler:Garry has his lighter taken by Ib to defeat Mary, and she probably still has that lighter when she returns to the Real World. Given how quickly Garry remembers Ib when he discovers her handkerchief in his pocket, one can only imagine how Ib will react when she finds that lighter.]]

to:

* In the "Forgotten Portrait" ending, [[spoiler:Garry has his lighter taken by Ib to defeat Mary, and she probably still has that lighter when she returns to the Real World. Given how quickly Garry remembers Ib when he discovers her handkerchief in his pocket, pocket in the true ending, one can only imagine how Ib will react when she finds that lighter.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Another reason why Mary singles out Ib so much may be because Ib is a foil to her. [[spoiler: She has everything that Mary doesn't - a family, a friend, a sense of belonging.]] Their personalities are also completely opposite - Mary is bubbly, energetic, talkative and a little lightheaded, and Ib is solemn, withdrawn and serious. Like they say, opposites attract.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Lady in Red, whom Guertena had based on some gold-digger in his life, looks very similar to Ib's mother, and some people speculated that they actually are the same woman. If that were true, the entire plot of the game would probably be the revenge gambit on part of Guertena's spirit/his creations - to get back at the girlfriend who had used him by robbing her of her child. Damn.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The Liars' Room. The liars punish the truth-teller for telling Ib the truth, right? After all, it ''is'' the Liars' Room, so how did the truth-telling painting end up there in the first place? Simple: ''It lied about being a liar'', and telling Ib the truth outed it to the others!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the "Forgotten Portrait" ending, [[spoiler:Garry has his lighter taken by Ib to defeat Mary, and she probably still has that lighter when she returns to the Real World. Given how quickly Garry remembers Ib when he discovers her handkerchief in his pocket, one can only imagine how Ib will react when she finds that lighter.]]

to:

* In the "Forgotten Portrait" ending, [[spoiler:Garry has his lighter taken by Ib to defeat Mary, and she probably still has that lighter when she returns to the Real World. Given how quickly Garry remembers Ib when he discovers her handkerchief in his pocket, one can only imagine how Ib will react when she finds that lighter.]]]]
** Worse, what happens when one of her parents realizes their small daughter is carrying [[spoiler: a lighter]] around? They'll probably take it away from her for safety's sake anyway, but what if they punish her just for having it, or accuse her of stealing it? It's bad enough she'll lose her keepsake, but how will it change her parents' perception of her, realizing their sad, traumatized daughter was hiding a fire-starting tool without their knowledge?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Garry also uses female pronouns in the Japanese version of the game

to:

** Garry also uses does use female pronouns in the Japanese version of the gamegame, which could be the reason the gallery was confused.

Added: 70

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[FridgeBrilliance He's a guy.]] Almost all of the artworks are either distinctly feminine, or genderless, and the masculine ones like the Hanged Man and the Fisherman are paintings; one of them is tired to Garry himself, the other eventually ends up empty when the fisherman vacates the picture. Guertena prefers women as artistic subjects, and since the gallery is his own feeling made manifest, it may have "interpreted" Garry as a female and then reacted bitterly when it realized he wasn't.

to:

** [[FridgeBrilliance He's a guy.]] Almost all of the artworks are either distinctly feminine, or genderless, and the masculine ones like the Hanged Man and the Fisherman are paintings; one of them is tired tied to Garry himself, the other eventually ends up empty when the fisherman vacates the picture. Guertena prefers women as artistic subjects, and since the gallery is his own feeling made manifest, it may have "interpreted" Garry as a female and then reacted bitterly when it realized he wasn't.wasn't.
** Garry also uses female pronouns in the Japanese version of the game
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the Forgotten Portrait ending, [[spoiler:Garry has his lighter taken by Ib to defeat Mary, and she probably still has that lighter when she returns to the Real World. Given how quickly Garry remembers Ib when he discovers her handkerchief in his pocket, one can only imagine how Ib will react when she finds that lighter.]]

to:

* In the Forgotten Portrait "Forgotten Portrait" ending, [[spoiler:Garry has his lighter taken by Ib to defeat Mary, and she probably still has that lighter when she returns to the Real World. Given how quickly Garry remembers Ib when he discovers her handkerchief in his pocket, one can only imagine how Ib will react when she finds that lighter.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Related to an above piece of FridgeBrilliance: it is outright stated that when the roses' petals are plucked, wounds appear on the body of the person who owns it. Yet after [[spoiler: Garry has his rose plucked by Mary, Ib says he looks like he's sleeping. Ib hallucinates at several points as a comfort-mechanism. Just think about what Garry ''might'' have [[{{Gorn}} looked like]]]].

to:

* Related to an above piece of FridgeBrilliance: it is outright stated that when the roses' petals are plucked, wounds appear on the body of the person who owns it. Yet after [[spoiler: Garry has his rose plucked by Mary, Ib says he looks like he's sleeping. Ib hallucinates at several points as a comfort-mechanism. Just think about what Garry ''might'' have [[{{Gorn}} looked like]]]].like]]]].
* In the Forgotten Portrait ending, [[spoiler:Garry has his lighter taken by Ib to defeat Mary, and she probably still has that lighter when she returns to the Real World. Given how quickly Garry remembers Ib when he discovers her handkerchief in his pocket, one can only imagine how Ib will react when she finds that lighter.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Related to an above piece of FridgeBrilliance: it is outright stated that when the roses' petals are plucked, wounds appear on the body of the person who owns it. Yet after [[spoiler: Garry has his rose plucked by Mary, Ib says he looks like he's sleeping. Ib hallucinates at several points in-game. Just think about what Garry ''might'' have [[{{Gorn}} looked like]]]].

to:

* Related to an above piece of FridgeBrilliance: it is outright stated that when the roses' petals are plucked, wounds appear on the body of the person who owns it. Yet after [[spoiler: Garry has his rose plucked by Mary, Ib says he looks like he's sleeping. Ib hallucinates at several points in-game.as a comfort-mechanism. Just think about what Garry ''might'' have [[{{Gorn}} looked like]]]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[FridgeBrilliance He's a guy.]] Almost all of the artworks are either distinctly feminine, or genderless, and the masculine ones like the Hanged Man and the Fisherman are paintings; one of them is tired to Garry himself, the other eventually ends up empty when the fisherman vacates the picture. Guertena prefers women as artistic subjects, and since the gallery is his own feeling made manifest, it may have "interpreted" Garry as a female and then reacted bitterly when it realized he wasn't.

to:

** [[FridgeBrilliance He's a guy.]] Almost all of the artworks are either distinctly feminine, or genderless, and the masculine ones like the Hanged Man and the Fisherman are paintings; one of them is tired to Garry himself, the other eventually ends up empty when the fisherman vacates the picture. Guertena prefers women as artistic subjects, and since the gallery is his own feeling made manifest, it may have "interpreted" Garry as a female and then reacted bitterly when it realized he wasn't.wasn't.
* Related to an above piece of FridgeBrilliance: it is outright stated that when the roses' petals are plucked, wounds appear on the body of the person who owns it. Yet after [[spoiler: Garry has his rose plucked by Mary, Ib says he looks like he's sleeping. Ib hallucinates at several points in-game. Just think about what Garry ''might'' have [[{{Gorn}} looked like]]]].

Top