Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / ASongOfIceAndFire

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

** Manderly also very specifically and deliberately waited until Freys stopped being his guests before killing them. There is an old custom that guests are given gifts by the host when they are leaving, accepting such gifts means that their guest rights end. More specifically, once they are out of sight of the host and then return later for whatever reason they have to ask for them again. Manderly gave Freys nice swift horses as a gift then intentionally moved very slowly with his entourage so they would lose their patience and leave his sight while going to Bolton's wedding. That means that by custom, he didn't slay his guests but did have his revenge.

Added: 583

Changed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Cinderella story happens in Westeros (a young girl gets mocked and abused, gets married to a prince/ into power) it gets twisted beyond recognition and doesn't have a happy ending. It happens to at least five characters.
** Daenerys. Physically and verbally abused by her brother Vyserys, gets sold to and marries Khal Drogo, a barbarian warlord. Forced to have sex with him as 14 year old, she starts to love him once Stockholm syndrome sets in. He kills her abusive brother, only to get wounded in battle himself. She loses her child she had with him and is forced to kill him herself because the wound gets worse.

to:

* When Cinderella story happens in Westeros (a young girl gets mocked and abused, gets married to a prince/ prince / into power) it gets twisted beyond recognition and doesn't have a happy ending. It happens to at least five six characters.
** Daenerys. Physically and verbally abused by her brother Vyserys, Viserys, gets sold to and marries Khal Drogo, a barbarian warlord. Forced to have sex with him as 14 year old, she starts to love him once Stockholm syndrome sets in. He kills her abusive brother, only to get wounded in battle himself. She loses her child she had with him and is forced to kill him herself because the wound gets worse.



** Ellaria Sand. A bastard daughter of Dornish lord, she gets courted by Dornish prince Oberyn Martell and becomes his mistress. It is a happy and loving relationship but they never get married. She has four daughters with him. Then her lover gets killed in front of her eyes by Gregor Clegane in a duel he fought in to avenge the murder of his sister.

to:

** Ellaria Sand. A bastard daughter of Dornish lord, she gets courted by Dornish prince Oberyn Martell and becomes his mistress. It is a happy and loving relationship but they never get married. She has four daughters with him. Then her lover gets killed in front of her eyes by Gregor Clegane in a duel he fought in to avenge the murder of his sister.sister.
** Falia Flowers. A bastard daughter of a Shield Islands lord who was raised as a servant and forced to wait on her father, stepmother, and trueborn half-sisters. When Euron Greyjoy's Ironborn conquer the Shield Islands, Falia sides with him and becomes his mistress, taking the opportunity to gleefully humiliate her stepmother and sisters by reducing them to serving wenches and having them strip naked in front of the entire hall. Euron continues to shower her with silks and jewels, but it doesn't last long before he grows tired of her and has her sacrificed to the Drowned God.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Given how many Westerosi lords are willing to support usurpers like the Blackfyres and Renly Baratheon, the entire succession system is doomed in the long run. All it takes is one successful usurper and the precedence for MightMakesRight succession would be set. Westeros will see endless wars as anyone with an army can take whatever they want without proper claim.

to:

* Given how many Westerosi lords are willing to support usurpers like the Blackfyres and Renly Baratheon, the entire succession system is doomed in the long run. All it takes is one successful usurper and the precedence for MightMakesRight succession would be set. Westeros will see endless wars as anyone with an army can take whatever they want without proper claim.
claim. It should be noted that this reality came dangerously close to pass too, as without Melisandre's magic, Stannis would have absolutely no mean to stop Renly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Given how many Westerosi lords are willing to support usurpers like the Blackfyres and Renly Baratheon, the entire succession system is doomed in the long run. All it takes is one successful usurper and the precedence would be set for MightMakesRight to be law. Westeros will see endless wars as it will become acceptable for anyone with an army to take whatever they want.

to:

* Given how many Westerosi lords are willing to support usurpers like the Blackfyres and Renly Baratheon, the entire succession system is doomed in the long run. All it takes is one successful usurper and the precedence would be set for MightMakesRight to succession would be law. set. Westeros will see endless wars as it will become acceptable for anyone with an army to can take whatever they want.
want without proper claim.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Given how many Westerosi lords are willing to support usurpers like the Blackfyres and Renly Baratheon, the entire succession system is doomed in the long run. All it takes is one successful usurper and the precedence would be set for MightMakesRight to be law. Westeros will see endless wars as it will become acceptable for anyone with an army to take whatever they want.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternatively, as Tyrion himself points out, there exists a possibility that all current Plumms are descended from an extramarital affair between Alaena Targaryen and Aegon IV, which would give Ben two recent Targaryen ancestors instead of just one like Quentyn. His slightly purer Valyrian blood might have made all the difference.

to:

** Alternatively, as Tyrion himself points out, there exists a possibility that all current the Plumms are actually descended from an extramarital affair between Alaena Targaryen and Aegon IV, two Targaryens instead of just one, which would give Ben two recent Targaryen ancestors instead of just one like Quentyn. His slightly purer stronger Valyrian blood than Quentyn. This slight increase in purity might have made all the difference.difference when it comes to taming dragon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alternatively, as Tyrion himself points out, there exists a possibility that all current Plumms are descended from an extramarital affair between Alaena Targaryen and Aegon IV, which would give Ben two recent Targaryen ancestors instead of just one like Quentyn. His slightly purer Valyrian blood might have made all the difference.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

** The way he worded that choice brings further horror. He heard that an Oldtown whore had his child, so he came to see if it is true and to take her with him if it was. Oberyn had an argument with the girl's mother if Obara even was even his daughter until Oberyn finally said "Let the girl choose if she wants to stay or go.". So he put down a short Dornish spear he carried everywhere with him for defense then slapped Obara's mother once. Obara's mother started to cry. Then Oberyn told Obara: "Choose your weapon with which you are going to go through life, tears or spear.". Obara, who has seen how men treat women like her mother in a brothel knew even at her young age that tears don't help and that spear is better. So she chose spear. Oberyn then said "I knew she was my daughter" and took Obara with him. Obara's mother drank herself to death afterwards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
General clarification on works content


** Fat Walda Frey. Mocked her whole life by her thinner sisters and stepsisters, Walda is nevertheless a girl with sharp wit and sharper tongue. The lord she marries who might be called King in the North? SoftspokenSadist Roose Bolton who is over twice her age. He likes her, as much as any sociopath can like anyone, but he is well aware that he can't protect her and their future children from his son Ramsay forever. And he is still a sadist and psycho, who would flay a man as easy as other men kick dogs.

to:

** Fat Walda Frey. Mocked her whole life by her thinner sisters and stepsisters, cousins, Walda is nevertheless a girl with sharp wit and sharper tongue. The lord she marries who might be called King in the North? SoftspokenSadist Roose Bolton who is over twice her age. He likes her, as much as any sociopath can like anyone, but he is well aware that he can't protect her and their future children from his son Ramsay forever. And he is still a sadist and psycho, who would flay a man as easy as other men kick dogs.



** Ellaria Sand. A bastard daughter of Dornish lord, she gets courted by Dornish prince Oberyn Martell and becomes his mistress. It is a happy and loving relationship but they never get married. She has five daughters with him. Then her lover gets killed in front of her eyes by Gregor Clegane in a duel he fought in to avenge the murder of his sister.

to:

** Ellaria Sand. A bastard daughter of Dornish lord, she gets courted by Dornish prince Oberyn Martell and becomes his mistress. It is a happy and loving relationship but they never get married. She has five four daughters with him. Then her lover gets killed in front of her eyes by Gregor Clegane in a duel he fought in to avenge the murder of his sister.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


** Fat Walda Frey. Mocked her whole life by her thinner sisters and stepsisters, Walda is nevertheless a girl with sharp wit and sharper tongue. The lord she marries who might be called King in the North? SoftspokenSadist Roose Bolton who is over twice her age. He likes her, as much as any sociopath can like anyone, but he is well aware that he can't protect her and their future children from his son Ramsay forever. And he is still a sadist and psycho, who would flay a msn as easy as other men kick dogs.

to:

** Fat Walda Frey. Mocked her whole life by her thinner sisters and stepsisters, Walda is nevertheless a girl with sharp wit and sharper tongue. The lord she marries who might be called King in the North? SoftspokenSadist Roose Bolton who is over twice her age. He likes her, as much as any sociopath can like anyone, but he is well aware that he can't protect her and their future children from his son Ramsay forever. And he is still a sadist and psycho, who would flay a msn man as easy as other men kick dogs.



** Pretty Pia. A pretty teenage peasant girl who lives her whole life in cursed castle Harrenhall. Once the war starts, she gets verbally, physically and sexually abused and raped multiple times. All of her friends get killed and her nose and teeth get broken by her rapist Gregor Clegane. Gets saved by queen's brother who she sees as gallant knight, but doesn't get to marry him. She is instead gently courted by said brother's squire on his urging. The squire is a kind person but the best ending a peasant girl like Pia can hope for is that he will become a knight and lord, marry some highborn lady and keep Pia as his mistress.

to:

** Pretty Pia. A pretty teenage peasant girl who lives her whole life in cursed castle Harrenhall. Once the war starts, she gets verbally, physically and sexually abused and raped multiple times. All of her friends get killed and her nose and teeth get broken by her rapist Gregor Clegane. Gets saved by queen's brother who she sees as gallant knight, but doesn't get to marry him. She is instead gently courted by said brother's squire on his urging. The squire is a kind person but the best ending a peasant girl like Pia can hope for is that he will become a knight and lord, marry some highborn lady and keep Pia as his mistress.mistress because living in a cursed castle left her barren.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixing indentation


* Ellaria Sand. A bastard daughter of Dornish lord, she gets courted by Dornish prince Oberyn Martell and becomes his mistress. It is a happy and loving relationship but they never get married. She has five daughters with him. Then her lover gets killed in front of her eyes by Gregor Clegane in a duel he fought in to avenge the murder of his sister.

to:

* ** Ellaria Sand. A bastard daughter of Dornish lord, she gets courted by Dornish prince Oberyn Martell and becomes his mistress. It is a happy and loving relationship but they never get married. She has five daughters with him. Then her lover gets killed in front of her eyes by Gregor Clegane in a duel he fought in to avenge the murder of his sister.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* *Fat Walda Frey. Mocked her whole life by her thinner sisters and stepsisters, Walda is nevertheless a girl with sharp wit and sharper tongue. The lord she marries who might be called King in the North? SoftspokenSadist Roose Bolton who is over twice her age.

to:

* *Fat **Fat Walda Frey. Mocked her whole life by her thinner sisters and stepsisters, Walda is nevertheless a girl with sharp wit and sharper tongue. The lord she marries who might be called King in the North? SoftspokenSadist Roose Bolton who is over twice her age. He likes her, as much as any sociopath can like anyone, but he is well aware that he can't protect her and their future children from his son Ramsay forever. And he is still a sadist and psycho, who would flay a msn as easy as other men kick dogs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cinderella


** Jeyne Poole. The best friend and lady-in-waiting of a classic princess archetype Sansa Stark, her life sucks. Her father gets killed during a coup when she is 13, Jeyne gets sent to a Littlefinger's brothel where she gets whipped, raped and sexually abused multiple times. She gets let out so she can marry a 'prince'. That prince? CompleteMonster Ramsey Snow, son of above-mentioned Roose Bolton.

to:

** Jeyne Poole. The best friend and lady-in-waiting of a classic princess archetype Sansa Stark, her life sucks. Her father gets killed during a coup when she is 13, Jeyne gets sent to a Littlefinger's brothel where she gets whipped, raped and sexually abused multiple times. She gets let out so she can marry a 'prince'. That prince? CompleteMonster Ramsey Snow, son of above-mentioned Roose Bolton.Bolton.
** Pretty Pia. A pretty teenage peasant girl who lives her whole life in cursed castle Harrenhall. Once the war starts, she gets verbally, physically and sexually abused and raped multiple times. All of her friends get killed and her nose and teeth get broken by her rapist Gregor Clegane. Gets saved by queen's brother who she sees as gallant knight, but doesn't get to marry him. She is instead gently courted by said brother's squire on his urging. The squire is a kind person but the best ending a peasant girl like Pia can hope for is that he will become a knight and lord, marry some highborn lady and keep Pia as his mistress.
* Ellaria Sand. A bastard daughter of Dornish lord, she gets courted by Dornish prince Oberyn Martell and becomes his mistress. It is a happy and loving relationship but they never get married. She has five daughters with him. Then her lover gets killed in front of her eyes by Gregor Clegane in a duel he fought in to avenge the murder of his sister.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** If he found out from a more sympathetic or romanticized account, it still leaves him with the knowledge that his whole life was a lie, Ned Stark is still not his father, his brothers and sisters are still not his siblings, everyone he just discovered are his family are all already dead (his grandparents dead, his ''real'' half-siblings Rhaenys and Aegon gruesomely murdered before he could ever meet them, and he already sent Maester Aemon away with the old man dying before Jon could find out the truth)[[note]]Daenerys and possibly Aegon are still kicking, but they're not exactly rushing to the Wall to shake his hand first and neither might react too well to him being Lyanna's kid/a Stark after everything[[/note]], and his parents ''caused a war'' by running off together and breaking marriage vows to their respective partners [[BecauseDestinySaysSo specifically]] to conceive baby [[HonorBeforeReason Jon]], in the process causing many deaths and getting themselves killed. Yeah, as an EmoTeen who spent his whole life growing up with '''''massive''''' insecurity issues, surely none of ''that'' would ruin his life!

to:

** If he found out from a more sympathetic or romanticized account, it still leaves him with the knowledge that his whole life was a lie, Ned Stark is still not his father, his brothers and sisters are still not his siblings, everyone he just discovered are his family are all already dead (his grandparents dead, his ''real'' half-siblings Rhaenys and Aegon gruesomely murdered before he could ever meet them, and he already sent Maester Aemon away with the old man dying before Jon could find out the truth)[[note]]Daenerys and possibly Aegon are still kicking, but they're not exactly rushing to the Wall to shake his hand first and neither might react too well to him being Lyanna's kid/a Stark after everything[[/note]], and his parents ''caused a war'' by running off together and breaking marriage vows to their respective partners [[BecauseDestinySaysSo specifically]] to conceive baby [[HonorBeforeReason Jon]], in the process causing many deaths and getting themselves killed. Yeah, as an EmoTeen who spent his whole life growing up with '''''massive''''' insecurity issues, surely none of ''that'' would ruin his life!life!
* When Cinderella story happens in Westeros (a young girl gets mocked and abused, gets married to a prince/ into power) it gets twisted beyond recognition and doesn't have a happy ending. It happens to at least five characters.
** Daenerys. Physically and verbally abused by her brother Vyserys, gets sold to and marries Khal Drogo, a barbarian warlord. Forced to have sex with him as 14 year old, she starts to love him once Stockholm syndrome sets in. He kills her abusive brother, only to get wounded in battle himself. She loses her child she had with him and is forced to kill him herself because the wound gets worse.
* *Fat Walda Frey. Mocked her whole life by her thinner sisters and stepsisters, Walda is nevertheless a girl with sharp wit and sharper tongue. The lord she marries who might be called King in the North? SoftspokenSadist Roose Bolton who is over twice her age.
** Jeyne Poole. The best friend and lady-in-waiting of a classic princess archetype Sansa Stark, her life sucks. Her father gets killed during a coup when she is 13, Jeyne gets sent to a Littlefinger's brothel where she gets whipped, raped and sexually abused multiple times. She gets let out so she can marry a 'prince'. That prince? CompleteMonster Ramsey Snow, son of above-mentioned Roose Bolton.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Crone represents wisdom and guidance. Selyse does not think for herself and relies upon the decisions of Melisandre, whose own ability to correctly foresee the future is questionable (and Maester Aemon believes she is making a big mistake declaring Stannis to be TheChosenOne). She also seems incapable of understanding certain facts, such as the fact that the wildlings don't base their leadership on the descendants of royalty, or that leaving all the wildlings at Hardhome to die would leave them vulnerable to becoming Others.

to:

** The Crone represents wisdom and guidance. Selyse does not think for herself and relies upon the decisions of Melisandre, whose own ability to correctly foresee the future is questionable (and Maester Aemon believes she is making leading a big mistake lot of people down the wrong path declaring Stannis to be TheChosenOne). She also seems incapable of understanding certain facts, such as the fact that the wildlings don't base their leadership on the descendants of royalty, or that leaving all the wildlings at Hardhome to die would leave them vulnerable to becoming Others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Mother represents nurturing, compassion and mercy. Cersei has been killing people or ordering their executions ever since she was a young girl at Casterly Rock. As for nurturing, she is not very involved with raising her own children.
** The Crone represents wisdom and guidance. Selyse does not think for herself and relies upon the decisions of Melisandre, whose own ability to correctly foresee the future is questionable. She also seems incapable of understanding certain facts, such as the fact that the wildlings don't base their leadership on the descendants of royalty, or that leaving all the wildlings at Hardhome to die would leave them vulnerable to becoming Others.

to:

** The Mother represents nurturing, compassion and mercy. Cersei has been killing people or and ordering their executions ever since she was a young girl at Casterly Rock. As for nurturing, she is not very involved with raising her own children.
children and harshly punishes Tommen whenever he stands up to her.
** The Crone represents wisdom and guidance. Selyse does not think for herself and relies upon the decisions of Melisandre, whose own ability to correctly foresee the future is questionable.questionable (and Maester Aemon believes she is making a big mistake declaring Stannis to be TheChosenOne). She also seems incapable of understanding certain facts, such as the fact that the wildlings don't base their leadership on the descendants of royalty, or that leaving all the wildlings at Hardhome to die would leave them vulnerable to becoming Others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Another, less literal interpretation is that Daenerys, the frightened, passive child, "died" in the fire, and from the ashes arose Daenerys, the fearless queen and Mother of Dragons. Illyrio makes the observation that "The frightened child who sheltered in my manse died on the Dothraki sea, and was reborn in blood and fire."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Crone represents wisdom and guidance. Selyse does not think for herself and relies upon the decisions of Melisandre, whose own ability to correctly foresee the future is questionable. She also seems incapable of grasping certain facts, such as the fact that the wildlings don't base their leadership on the descendants of royalty, or that leaving all the wildlings at Hardhome to die would leave them vulnerable to becoming Others.

to:

** The Crone represents wisdom and guidance. Selyse does not think for herself and relies upon the decisions of Melisandre, whose own ability to correctly foresee the future is questionable. She also seems incapable of grasping understanding certain facts, such as the fact that the wildlings don't base their leadership on the descendants of royalty, or that leaving all the wildlings at Hardhome to die would leave them vulnerable to becoming Others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Crone represents wisdom and guidance. Selyse does not think for herself and relies upon the decisions of Melisandre, whose own ability to correctly foresee the future is questionable.

to:

** The Crone represents wisdom and guidance. Selyse does not think for herself and relies upon the decisions of Melisandre, whose own ability to correctly foresee the future is questionable. She also seems incapable of grasping certain facts, such as the fact that the wildlings don't base their leadership on the descendants of royalty, or that leaving all the wildlings at Hardhome to die would leave them vulnerable to becoming Others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* On the surface, the three Baratheon wives seem to match the three female faces of the deity worshipped by the Faith of the Seven, with Margaery representing the Maiden, Cersei representing the Mother, and Selyse representing the Crone. However, they are actually more like ironic subversions of the traits that the goddesses represent.
** The Maiden represents purity and innocence. Margaery has been married twice and widowed both times, and while her family insists she is still a maiden, multiple characters have cause to question if that is true.
** The Mother represents nurturing, compassion and mercy. Cersei has been killing people or ordering their executions ever since she was a young girl at Casterly Rock. As for nurturing, she is not very involved with raising her own children.
** The Crone represents wisdom and guidance. Selyse does not think for herself and relies upon the decisions of Melisandre, whose own ability to correctly foresee the future is questionable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "The valonqar shall wrap his hands about your throat and choke the life from you." This one is not necessarily inevitable regardless of circumstances, but allowing for a bit of stretch, Cersei's tendency to treat nearly everyone around her terribly leads to her making a lot of enemies, even her own family members. Her IrrationalHatred of Tyrion, believing he is her valonqar, has led to him becoming her worst enemy. As of ''A Dance of Dragons'', it seems her AllTakeAndNoGive treatment of Jaime has turned him against her and made him another candidate for the valonqar, as seen when he reads her letter pleading for help when she's imprisoned by the High Sparrow and throws it in the fire. Extra brilliance because it turns valiryan language doesn't have genders, so valonqar means younger sibling and it really doesn't have to be Cersei's sibling. That leaves possibilities open for Arya, Sansa, The Hound and any other character who has older brother or sister.

to:

** "The valonqar shall wrap his hands about your throat and choke the life from you." This one is not necessarily inevitable regardless of circumstances, but allowing for a bit of stretch, Cersei's tendency to treat nearly everyone around her terribly leads to her making a lot of enemies, even her own family members. Her IrrationalHatred of Tyrion, believing he is her valonqar, has led to him becoming her worst enemy. As of ''A Dance of Dragons'', it seems her AllTakeAndNoGive treatment of Jaime has turned him against her and made him another candidate for the valonqar, as seen when he reads her letter pleading for help when she's imprisoned by the High Sparrow and throws it in the fire. Extra brilliance because it turns valiryan out that the valyrian language doesn't have genders, so valonqar means younger sibling and it really doesn't have to be Cersei's sibling. sibling either. That leaves possibilities open for Arya, Sansa, The Hound and any other character who has older brother or sister.sister to be the valonqar to Cersei.

Top