Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / WatchMen

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
we follow those police through the whole comic


* PragmaticAdaptation: The original comic passed through generations of filmmakers, including the likes of Creator/TerryGilliam, trying to make it into a comprehensible movie. It became famous for being impossible to adapt to the screen. Among the reasons listed is the constantly switching narrative (the first chapter is mostly the perspective of the police investigating Comedian's death, never seen again), the page layout being too intricately crafted to replicate in a film (the chapter "Fearful Symmetry" mirrors itself in color and layout) and the [[AnachronicOrder non-linear order]] (Dr. Manhattan alone sees time as omni-present, leading to his chapter being about him experiencing all major events of his life at once). The film's solution was to replicate the story as closely as possible, using the comic itself as a storyboard (much like Snyder's adaptation of ''Film/ThreeHundred''), and streamline the narrative to keep the focus on the principle characters. The antagonist's plot is simplified to reduce the number of new concepts needing to be explained to the audience: [[spoiler: instead of Veidt sending a genetically engineered squid upon a major city to scare the world into fearing an alien invasion, he detonates Dr. Manhattan inspired bombs (of comparable strength to a nuke) around the world to make them fear Dr. Manhattan personally, achieving the same effect of distracting the world from nuclear war and being more open to world peace]]. This has caused some debate as to its value compared to the original comic, while it may have lost that visceral reaction to such a devastating event, many said it possibly improves upon the original by being simpler and better {{foreshadowed}}.

to:

* PragmaticAdaptation: The original comic passed through generations of filmmakers, including the likes of Creator/TerryGilliam, trying to make it into a comprehensible movie. It became famous for being impossible to adapt to the screen. Among the reasons listed is the constantly switching narrative (the first chapter is mostly the perspective of the police investigating Comedian's death, never seen again), death), the page layout being too intricately crafted to replicate in a film (the chapter "Fearful Symmetry" mirrors itself in color and layout) and the [[AnachronicOrder non-linear order]] (Dr. Manhattan alone sees time as omni-present, leading to his chapter being about him experiencing all major events of his life at once). The film's solution was to replicate the story as closely as possible, using the comic itself as a storyboard (much like Snyder's adaptation of ''Film/ThreeHundred''), and streamline the narrative to keep the focus on the principle characters. The antagonist's plot is simplified to reduce the number of new concepts needing to be explained to the audience: [[spoiler: instead of Veidt sending a genetically engineered squid upon a major city to scare the world into fearing an alien invasion, he detonates Dr. Manhattan inspired bombs (of comparable strength to a nuke) around the world to make them fear Dr. Manhattan personally, achieving the same effect of distracting the world from nuclear war and being more open to world peace]]. This has caused some debate as to its value compared to the original comic, while it may have lost that visceral reaction to such a devastating event, many said it possibly improves upon the original by being simpler and better {{foreshadowed}}.

Added: 294

Changed: 19

Removed: 206

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
crosswicking and correcting ABC order


''Watchmen'' is the 2009 film adaptation of Creator/AlanMoore and Dave Gibbons' ''Comicbook/{{Watchmen}}'', directed by Creator/ZackSnyder.

to:

''Watchmen'' is the 2009 film adaptation {{Film Adaptation|LiveAction}} of Creator/AlanMoore and Dave Gibbons' ''Comicbook/{{Watchmen}}'', directed by Creator/ZackSnyder.



** MrFanservice: If anything there is A LOT of male nudity in this movie, A LOT!
* FriendlyAddressPrivileges: Rorschach, to the psychiatrist after his arrest.
-->You keep calling me Walter. I don't like you.


Added DiffLines:

* FilmAdaptationLiveAction: A film based on the graphic novel ''{{ComicBook/Watchmen}}''.


Added DiffLines:

* FriendlyAddressPrivileges: Rorschach, to the psychiatrist after his arrest.
-->You keep calling me Walter. I don't like you.


Added DiffLines:

* MrFanservice: If anything there is A LOT of male nudity in this movie, A LOT!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The plot is almost exactly the same as the comic, save for a completely different explanation of the ending, with dialogue and scenes lifted almost shot-for-shot at times. That makes it probably the most ''accurate'' adaptation of an Creator/AlanMoore comic (with the possible exception of the ''WesternAnimation/JusticeLeague'' episode "ComicBook/ForTheManWhoHasEverything") and one of the most comics-accurate adaptations ever made overall.

to:

The plot is almost exactly story follows the same as the comic, save for a completely different explanation of the ending, comic really closely, with dialogue and scenes lifted almost shot-for-shot at times.times. There are only a handful of alterations, much of it removing excess backstory and subplots to streamline the story, with the primary change being key elements of the villains plan at the end. That makes it probably the most ''accurate'' adaptation of an Creator/AlanMoore comic (with the possible exception of the ''WesternAnimation/JusticeLeague'' episode "ComicBook/ForTheManWhoHasEverything") and one of the most comics-accurate adaptations ever made overall.



* PragmaticAdaptation: The original comic passed through generations of filmmakers, including the likes of Creator/TerryGilliam, trying to make it into a comprehensible movie. It became famous for being impossible to adapt to the screen. Among the reasons listed is the constantly switching narrative (the first chapter is mostly the perspective of the police investigating Comedian's death, never seen again), the page layout being too intricately crafted to replicate in a film (the chapter "Fearful Symmetry" mirrors itself in color and layout) and the [[AnachronicOrder non-linear order]] (Dr. Manhattan alone sees time as omni-present, leading to his chapter being about him experiencing all major events of his life at once). The film's solution was to replicate the story as closely as possible, using the comic itself as a storyboard (much like Snyder's adaptation of ''Film/ThreeHundred''), and streamline the narrative to keep the focus on the principle characters. The antagonist's plot is streamlined to reduce the number of new concepts needing to be explained to the audience: [[spoiler: instead of Veidt sending a genetically engineered squid upon a major city to scare the world into fearing an alien invasion, he detonates Dr. Manhattan inspired bombs (of comparable strength to a nuke) around the world to make them fear Dr. Manhattan personally, achieving the same effect of distracting the world from nuclear war and being more open to world peace]]. This has caused some debate as to its value compared to the original comic, with many saying it possibly even improves upon the original by being simpler while offering similar depth and complexity to the original.

to:

* PragmaticAdaptation: The original comic passed through generations of filmmakers, including the likes of Creator/TerryGilliam, trying to make it into a comprehensible movie. It became famous for being impossible to adapt to the screen. Among the reasons listed is the constantly switching narrative (the first chapter is mostly the perspective of the police investigating Comedian's death, never seen again), the page layout being too intricately crafted to replicate in a film (the chapter "Fearful Symmetry" mirrors itself in color and layout) and the [[AnachronicOrder non-linear order]] (Dr. Manhattan alone sees time as omni-present, leading to his chapter being about him experiencing all major events of his life at once). The film's solution was to replicate the story as closely as possible, using the comic itself as a storyboard (much like Snyder's adaptation of ''Film/ThreeHundred''), and streamline the narrative to keep the focus on the principle characters. The antagonist's plot is streamlined simplified to reduce the number of new concepts needing to be explained to the audience: [[spoiler: instead of Veidt sending a genetically engineered squid upon a major city to scare the world into fearing an alien invasion, he detonates Dr. Manhattan inspired bombs (of comparable strength to a nuke) around the world to make them fear Dr. Manhattan personally, achieving the same effect of distracting the world from nuclear war and being more open to world peace]]. This has caused some debate as to its value compared to the original comic, with while it may have lost that visceral reaction to such a devastating event, many saying said it possibly even improves upon the original by being simpler while offering similar depth and complexity to the original.better {{foreshadowed}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PrettyLittleHeadshots:
** The assassination of [[spoiler:Moloch]] was clean enough that Rorschach could talk to him at length before realizing his audience was dead.
** Lee Iacocca shot during the [[spoiler:faked]] assassination attempt on Ozymandias.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Unforgettable" over the Comedian's death scene.
** Leonard Cohen's "Hallelujah" during one of the sex scenes.
** The Comedian firing his shotgun at rioters, set to "I'm Your Boogie Man" by KC and the Sunshine Band.

to:

** The opening scene of The Comedian's brutal murder with the romantic song "Unforgettable" over playing in the Comedian's death scene.
background. This was deliberate, as one theme of the story is the eroticism of violence and how, for The Comedian especially, masked heroes only felt alive when they're beating the hell out of somebody.
** The use of Leonard Cohen's "Hallelujah" during one Dan and Laurie's sex scene. The song was already meant to be ironic and melancholy. The use of the sex scenes.
word "Hallelujah" in contrast to the general mood of the song only emphasizes its mood, making it even ''more'' melancholy.
** KC & The Comedian firing his shotgun at rioters, set to Sunshine Band's "I'm Your Boogie Man" by KC and playing over the Sunshine Band.Comedian's [[SociopathicHero riot dispersal]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
How To Create A Works Page: "Things not to include: quality judgements (don't say how much it sucked/how awesome it was), critical reception (that's just a specific variant of quality judgements), recommendations (don't tell us whether or not we should check it out)"


The plot is almost exactly the same as the comic, save for a completely different explanation of the ending, with dialogue and scenes lifted almost shot-for-shot at times. That makes it probably the most ''accurate'' adaptation of an Creator/AlanMoore comic (with the possible exception of the ''WesternAnimation/JusticeLeague'' episode "ComicBook/ForTheManWhoHasEverything") and one of the most comics-accurate adaptations ever made overall. This in itself has been a point of debate among fans and critics: some like the fidelity; others would have preferred a more PragmaticAdaptation; others still don't think it's faithful enough. A textbook example of the phrase; "You Can't Please Everyone".

to:

The plot is almost exactly the same as the comic, save for a completely different explanation of the ending, with dialogue and scenes lifted almost shot-for-shot at times. That makes it probably the most ''accurate'' adaptation of an Creator/AlanMoore comic (with the possible exception of the ''WesternAnimation/JusticeLeague'' episode "ComicBook/ForTheManWhoHasEverything") and one of the most comics-accurate adaptations ever made overall. This in itself has been a point of debate among fans and critics: some like the fidelity; others would have preferred a more PragmaticAdaptation; others still don't think it's faithful enough. A textbook example of the phrase; "You Can't Please Everyone".\n
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SceneryPorn[=/=]SceneryGorn[=/=]SugarWiki/VisualEffectsOfAwesome: As per Zack Snyder's standard.

to:

* SceneryPorn[=/=]SceneryGorn[=/=]SugarWiki/VisualEffectsOfAwesome: SceneryPorn: As per Zack Snyder's standard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: The fight scenes in the comic were shown only in a few panels and very bluntly, which the film elaborates into extended fights, notably the opening which shows Eddie Blake battling the prowler who kills him, Nite Owl I fighting back the rioters which he didn't have time to do. [[spoiler:The film also provides Rorschach a more cathartic finish with Nite Owl getting to witness Rorschach's death scene and punching Adrian Veidt for his utopia.]]

to:

* AdaptationExpansion: The fight scenes in the comic were shown only in a few panels and very bluntly, which the film elaborates into extended fights, notably the opening which shows Eddie Blake battling the prowler who kills him, and Nite Owl I fighting back the rioters which he didn't have time to do. [[spoiler:The film also provides Rorschach a more cathartic finish with Nite Owl getting to witness Rorschach's death scene and punching Adrian Veidt for his utopia.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InPrisonWithTheRogues: Rorschach gets locked up in a prison full of criminals that he put behind bars. It does not go well... for the criminals.

to:

* InPrisonWithTheRogues: Rorschach gets locked set up and walks straight into a crime scene with cops tipped off ready to arrest him. He gets put in a prison full of criminals who know and resent him. But they soon learn that he put behind bars. It does if any of them try to screw with him, they'll be lucky to walk away with severe scarring. As Rorschach makes it clear: "I'm not go well... for the criminals.locked in here with you, you're locked in here with me!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InPrisonWithTheRogues: Rorschach gets locked up in a prison full of criminals that he put behind bars. It does not go well... for the criminals.

Added: 250

Changed: 155

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateHistory: All of the U.S. flags in the film have 51 stars, because in the film's alternate history, Vietnam became the 51st state after America won the Vietnam War.

to:

* AlternateHistory: AlternateHistory:
** When TheVJDayKiss happened, the lesbian Silhouette kissed the nurse instead of the sailor.
**
All of the U.S. flags in the film have 51 stars, because in the film's alternate history, Vietnam became the 51st state after America won the Vietnam War.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StealthPun: When Nite Owl and Silk Spectre rescue Rorschach from the prison riot, he states he has to go to the "little men's room", then enters the bathroom in which [[DepravedDwarf Big Figure]] tried to hide.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The plot is almost exactly the same as the comic, save for a completely different explanation of the ending, with dialogue and scenes lifted almost shot-for-shot at times. That makes it probably the most ''accurate'' adaptation of an Creator/AlanMoore comic (with the possible exception of the ''WesternAnimation/JusticeLeague'' episode "ComicBook/ForTheManWhoHasEverything") and one of the most comics-accurate adaptations ever made. This in itself has been a point of debate among fans and critics: some like the fidelity; others would have preferred a more PragmaticAdaptation; others still don't think it's faithful enough. A textbook example of the phrase; "You Can't Please Everyone".

to:

The plot is almost exactly the same as the comic, save for a completely different explanation of the ending, with dialogue and scenes lifted almost shot-for-shot at times. That makes it probably the most ''accurate'' adaptation of an Creator/AlanMoore comic (with the possible exception of the ''WesternAnimation/JusticeLeague'' episode "ComicBook/ForTheManWhoHasEverything") and one of the most comics-accurate adaptations ever made.made overall. This in itself has been a point of debate among fans and critics: some like the fidelity; others would have preferred a more PragmaticAdaptation; others still don't think it's faithful enough. A textbook example of the phrase; "You Can't Please Everyone".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The plot is almost exactly the same as the comic, save for a completely different explanation of the ending, with dialogue and scenes lifted almost shot-for-shot at times. That makes it probably the most ''correct'' adaptation of an Creator/AlanMoore comic (with the possible exception of the ''WesternAnimation/JusticeLeague'' episode "ComicBook/ForTheManWhoHasEverything"). This in itself has been a point of debate among fans and critics: some like the fidelity; others would have preferred a more PragmaticAdaptation; others still don't think it's faithful enough. A textbook example of the phrase; "You Can't Please Everyone".

to:

The plot is almost exactly the same as the comic, save for a completely different explanation of the ending, with dialogue and scenes lifted almost shot-for-shot at times. That makes it probably the most ''correct'' ''accurate'' adaptation of an Creator/AlanMoore comic (with the possible exception of the ''WesternAnimation/JusticeLeague'' episode "ComicBook/ForTheManWhoHasEverything")."ComicBook/ForTheManWhoHasEverything") and one of the most comics-accurate adaptations ever made. This in itself has been a point of debate among fans and critics: some like the fidelity; others would have preferred a more PragmaticAdaptation; others still don't think it's faithful enough. A textbook example of the phrase; "You Can't Please Everyone".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Veidt's disk has a folder titled "Boys". Veidt's TV wall is full of easter eggs, including "[[Film/ThreeHundred 300 Spartans]]", a ''porn movie'', Apple's famous '1984' commercial, a [[WesternAnimation/LooneyTunes Marvin the Martian]] cartoon (possibly a reference to Dr. Manhattan's fate), ''Film/MadMax2TheRoadWarrior''and a ''Series/MacGyver1985'' episode (the man climbing the parachute, [=MacGyver=] possibly referring to Ozy himself).

to:

** Veidt's disk has a folder titled "Boys". Veidt's TV wall is full of easter eggs, including "[[Film/ThreeHundred 300 Spartans]]", a ''porn movie'', Apple's famous '1984' commercial, a [[WesternAnimation/LooneyTunes Marvin the Martian]] cartoon (possibly a reference to Dr. Manhattan's fate), ''Film/MadMax2TheRoadWarrior''and ''Film/MadMax2TheRoadWarrior'' and a ''Series/MacGyver1985'' episode (the man climbing the parachute, [=MacGyver=] possibly referring to Ozy himself).

Added: 44

Changed: 70

Removed: 44

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CoolMask: Rorschach's moving inkblot mask.



* CoolMask: Rorschach's moving inkblot mask.



** Dr. Milton Glass and the assistant Wally Weaver were merged into one character, "Professor Wally Weaver". His death is also shown on-screen, and directly references the panel where Jon Osterman's father died.
** Ozymandias is combined with Captain Metropolis, who's AdaptedOut. In this version, ''he's'' the one who proposes the creation of the Watchmen ([[AdaptationNameChange "The Crimebusters" in the comic book]]), and ''he's'' the one who presents an ambitious plan for {{saving the world}} to the other heroes--only to get mocked by the Comedian.

to:

** Dr. Milton Glass and the his assistant Wally Weaver were merged into one character, "Professor Wally Weaver". His Weaver's death is also shown on-screen, and directly references the panel where Jon Osterman's father died.
** Ozymandias is combined with Captain Metropolis, who's AdaptedOut.[[DemotedToExtra whose role is significantly diminished]]. In this version, ''he's'' the one who proposes the creation of the Watchmen ([[AdaptationNameChange "The Crimebusters" in the comic book]]), and ''he's'' the one who presents an ambitious plan for {{saving the world}} to the other heroes--only to get mocked by the Comedian.

Added: 554

Changed: 209

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompositeCharacter: Dr. Milton Glass and the assistant Wally Weaver were merged into one character, "Professor Wally Weaver". His death is also shown on-screen, and directly references the panel where Jon Osterman's father died.

to:

* CompositeCharacter: CompositeCharacter:
**
Dr. Milton Glass and the assistant Wally Weaver were merged into one character, "Professor Wally Weaver". His death is also shown on-screen, and directly references the panel where Jon Osterman's father died.died.
** Ozymandias is combined with Captain Metropolis, who's AdaptedOut. In this version, ''he's'' the one who proposes the creation of the Watchmen ([[AdaptationNameChange "The Crimebusters" in the comic book]]), and ''he's'' the one who presents an ambitious plan for {{saving the world}} to the other heroes--only to get mocked by the Comedian.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This page is for movie-only tropes -- most will be on the main ''Comicbook/{{Watchmen}}'' page. Similarly, tropes specific to the movie's versions of the characters go [[Characters/Watchmen2009 here]].

to:

This page is for movie-only tropes -- most will be on the main ''Comicbook/{{Watchmen}}'' page. Similarly, movie-specific character tropes specific to the movie's versions of the characters go [[Characters/Watchmen2009 here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This page is for movie-only tropes -- most will be on the main ''Comicbook/{{Watchmen}}'' page.

to:

This page is for movie-only tropes -- most will be on the main ''Comicbook/{{Watchmen}}'' page.
page. Similarly, tropes specific to the movie's versions of the characters go [[Characters/Watchmen2009 here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TrailersAlwaysSpoil: Several of the trailers show scenes that tip off the reveal for anyone with even a passing familiarity with the characters. The fans of the ''comic'' also have no compunction about dropping major plot points. Said fans include ''[[PvP a major webcomic]]''. This is because a lot of the comic's power came from the fact that the plot points were stupidly obvious. Like, if you missed the fact that [[spoiler:Ozymandias]] was going to be the main villain you just weren't paying attention. And it worked anyway.

to:

* TrailersAlwaysSpoil: Several of the trailers show scenes that tip off the reveal for anyone with even a passing familiarity with the characters. The fans of the ''comic'' also have no compunction about dropping major plot points. Said fans include ''[[PvP ''[[Webcomic/PvP a major webcomic]]''. This is because a lot of the comic's power came from the fact that the plot points were stupidly obvious. Like, if you missed the fact that [[spoiler:Ozymandias]] was going to be the main villain you just weren't paying attention. And it worked anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WilhelmScream: There is one in the prison riot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Creator/CarlaGugino as the elderly Sally Jupiter is ''far'' prettier and healthy looking than how the character was drawn, as she originally looked frail and IWasOnceALooker is a major part of her personality.

to:

** Creator/CarlaGugino as the elderly Sally Jupiter is ''far'' prettier and healthy looking than how the character was drawn, as she originally looked frail and IWasOnceALooker IWasQuiteALooker is a major part of her personality.

Added: 469

Changed: 161

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Creator/CarlaGugino as Sally Jupiter is ''far'' prettier than how the character was drawn, but Sally is also supposed to have been a bombshell when she was younger.

to:

** Creator/CarlaGugino as the elderly Sally Jupiter is ''far'' prettier and healthy looking than how the character was drawn, but Sally is also supposed to have been a bombshell when as she was younger.originally looked frail and IWasOnceALooker is a major part of her personality.


Added DiffLines:

** In a broad sense the main cast are played by actors in their 30's while they are supposed to be in their mid 40's in the present day. It was a necessary deal since so much of the story features flashbacks to decades in the past, rather than trying to subtly portray the age differences of 25-45 they maintained a standard appearance throughout the film. This contrasts the older heroes, who are seen in various stages between their 20's and their 70's using make-up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----

to:

--------
->''"Who watches the Watchmen?"''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CreatorCameo: Zack Snyder had a cameo as one of the American soldiers behind the Comedian in the Vietnam War scene.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HomophobicHateCrime: In the opening montage, it's shown how Silhouette and her girlfriend were murdered as a result of being lesbians, with "Lesbian Whores" written on the wall over their bodies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PragmaticAdaptation: The original comic passed through generations of filmmakers, including the likes of Creator/TerryGilliam, trying to make it into a comprehensible movie. It became famous for being impossible to adapt to the screen. Among the reasons listed is the constantly switching narrative (the first chapter is mostly the perspective of the police investigating Comedian's death, never seen again), the page layout being too intricately crafted to replicate in a film (the chapter "Fearful Symmetry" mirrors itself in color and layout) and the [[AnachronicOrder non-linear order]] (Dr. Manhattan alone sees time as omni-present, leading to his chapter being about him experiencing all major events of his life at once). The film's solution was to replicate the story as closely as possible, using the comic itself as a storyboard (much like Snyder's adaptation of ''Film/ThreeHundred''), and streamline the narrative to keep the focus on the principle characters. The antagonist's plot is streamlined to reduce then number of new concepts needing to be explained to the audience: [[spoiler: instead of Veidt sending a genetically engineered squid upon a major city to scare the world into fearing an alien invasion, he detonates Dr. Manhattan inspired bombs (of comparable strength to a nuke) around the world to make them fear Dr. Manhattan personally, achieving the same effect of distracting the world from nuclear war and being more open to world peace]]. This has caused some debate as to its value compared to the original comic, with many saying it possibly even improves upon the original by being simpler while offering similar depth and complexity to the original.

to:

* PragmaticAdaptation: The original comic passed through generations of filmmakers, including the likes of Creator/TerryGilliam, trying to make it into a comprehensible movie. It became famous for being impossible to adapt to the screen. Among the reasons listed is the constantly switching narrative (the first chapter is mostly the perspective of the police investigating Comedian's death, never seen again), the page layout being too intricately crafted to replicate in a film (the chapter "Fearful Symmetry" mirrors itself in color and layout) and the [[AnachronicOrder non-linear order]] (Dr. Manhattan alone sees time as omni-present, leading to his chapter being about him experiencing all major events of his life at once). The film's solution was to replicate the story as closely as possible, using the comic itself as a storyboard (much like Snyder's adaptation of ''Film/ThreeHundred''), and streamline the narrative to keep the focus on the principle characters. The antagonist's plot is streamlined to reduce then the number of new concepts needing to be explained to the audience: [[spoiler: instead of Veidt sending a genetically engineered squid upon a major city to scare the world into fearing an alien invasion, he detonates Dr. Manhattan inspired bombs (of comparable strength to a nuke) around the world to make them fear Dr. Manhattan personally, achieving the same effect of distracting the world from nuclear war and being more open to world peace]]. This has caused some debate as to its value compared to the original comic, with many saying it possibly even improves upon the original by being simpler while offering similar depth and complexity to the original.

Changed: 710

Removed: 881

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Revised Ending is when the ending of the movie is changed from what the ending of the movie was going to be. The trope for "the ending of the movie is different from the comic" is Adaptational Alternate Ending. (Which I'm not adding because I don't think the *ending* is really different, just how the movie gets there.)


* PragmaticAdaptation: The original comic passed through generations of filmmakers, including the likes of Creator/TerryGilliam, trying to make it into a comprehensible movie. It became famous for being impossible to adapt to the screen. Among the reasons listed is the constantly switching narrative (the first chapter is mostly the perspective of the police investigating Comedian's death, never seen again), the page layout being too intricately crafted to replicate in a film (the chapter "Fearful Symmetry" mirrors itself in color and layout) and the [[AnachronicOrder non-linear order]] (Dr. Manhattan alone sees time as omni-present, leading to his chapter being about him experiencing all major events of his life at once). The film's solution was to replicate the story as closely as possible, using the comic itself as a storyboard (much like Snyder's adaptation of ''Film/ThreeHundred''), and streamline the narrative to keep the focus on the principle characters.
** The RevisedEnding is the biggest direct change, [[spoiler: instead of Veidt sending a genetically engineered squid upon a major city to scare the world into fearing an alien invasion, he detonates Dr. Manhattan inspired bombs (of comparable strength to a nuke) around the world to make them fear Dr. Manhattan personally, achieving the same effect of distracting the world from nuclear war and being more open to world peace]]. This has caused some debate as to its value compared to the original comic, with many saying it possibly even improves upon the original by being simpler while offering similar depth and complexity to the original.

to:

* PragmaticAdaptation: The original comic passed through generations of filmmakers, including the likes of Creator/TerryGilliam, trying to make it into a comprehensible movie. It became famous for being impossible to adapt to the screen. Among the reasons listed is the constantly switching narrative (the first chapter is mostly the perspective of the police investigating Comedian's death, never seen again), the page layout being too intricately crafted to replicate in a film (the chapter "Fearful Symmetry" mirrors itself in color and layout) and the [[AnachronicOrder non-linear order]] (Dr. Manhattan alone sees time as omni-present, leading to his chapter being about him experiencing all major events of his life at once). The film's solution was to replicate the story as closely as possible, using the comic itself as a storyboard (much like Snyder's adaptation of ''Film/ThreeHundred''), and streamline the narrative to keep the focus on the principle characters. \n** The RevisedEnding antagonist's plot is streamlined to reduce then number of new concepts needing to be explained to the biggest direct change, audience: [[spoiler: instead of Veidt sending a genetically engineered squid upon a major city to scare the world into fearing an alien invasion, he detonates Dr. Manhattan inspired bombs (of comparable strength to a nuke) around the world to make them fear Dr. Manhattan personally, achieving the same effect of distracting the world from nuclear war and being more open to world peace]]. This has caused some debate as to its value compared to the original comic, with many saying it possibly even improves upon the original by being simpler while offering similar depth and complexity to the original.



* RevisedEnding: [[spoiler: Long story short, no Giant Squid in this version. Instead, Dr. Manhattan is framed for the destruction of New York, Moscow, and several other major cities around the world. Everything else remains the same.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** When Dr. Manhattan kills someone he disintegrates them with what appears to be a quick flash of light. The movie makes it into a more obvious explosion of gore (possibly to differentiate from simply teleporting people away). [[spoiler: This is especially obvious in Rorschach's death, which lingers on the Rorschach-esque image in the snow]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Veidt's disk has a folder titled "Boys". Veidt's TV wall is full of easter eggs, including "[[Film/ThreeHundred 300 Spartans]]", a ''porn movie'', Apple's famous '1984' commercial, a [[WesternAnimation/LooneyTunes Marvin the Martian]] cartoon (possibly a reference to Dr. Manhattan's fate), Film/MadMax2 and a Series/MacGyver episode (the man climbing the parachute, [=MacGyver=] possibly referring to Ozy himself).

to:

** Veidt's disk has a folder titled "Boys". Veidt's TV wall is full of easter eggs, including "[[Film/ThreeHundred 300 Spartans]]", a ''porn movie'', Apple's famous '1984' commercial, a [[WesternAnimation/LooneyTunes Marvin the Martian]] cartoon (possibly a reference to Dr. Manhattan's fate), Film/MadMax2 and ''Film/MadMax2TheRoadWarrior''and a Series/MacGyver ''Series/MacGyver1985'' episode (the man climbing the parachute, [=MacGyver=] possibly referring to Ozy himself).

Top