Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheHorseWhisperer

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseAnimalCare: As [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Horse_Whisperer_(film)#Horse_training_methods_and_controversies The Other Wiki]] explains, both the book and film's final session with Pilgrim being hobbled, roped and forced on the ground, followed by Grace riding him and the two being miraculously cured is not much rooted in reality, and would rather have been a very dangerous situation. The same article also points out that a horse going through an accident such as Pilgrim did might develop a fear for vehicles, roads and/or steep slopes, but would likely not have a complete change in personality and manner as he does. The Pilgrim in the book and film behaves more like a horse having been exposed to long-term animal abuse than simply having been in an accident.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseAnimalCare: As [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Horse_Whisperer_(film)#Horse_training_methods_and_controversies The Other Wiki]] explains, both the book and film's final session with Pilgrim being hobbled, roped and forced on the ground, followed by Grace riding him and the two being miraculously cured is not much rooted in reality, and would rather have been a very dangerous situation. The same article also points out that a horse going through an accident such as Pilgrim did might develop a fear for vehicles, roads and/or steep slopes, but would likely not have a complete change in personality and manner as he does. The Pilgrim in the book and film behaves more like a horse having been exposed to long-term animal abuse than simply having been in an accident.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BettyAndVeronica: Annie (Archie) has to chose between her husband (Betty), who is a NiceGuy, a successful lawyer and a city-dweller like her, and Tom (Veronica), a rancher who does not want to leave the country and who is generally sarcastic with her.

to:

* BettyAndVeronica: Annie (Archie) has to chose choose between her husband (Betty), who is a NiceGuy, a successful lawyer and a city-dweller like her, and Tom (Veronica), a rancher who does not want to leave the country and who is generally sarcastic with her.

Changed: 83

Removed: 132

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdultFear: Robert and Annie [=MacLean=]'s daughter loses a leg because of a horse accident. Moreover, she suffers from depression.



* AnArmAndALeg: Grace [=MacLean=] loses a leg after a horse accident.

to:

* AnArmAndALeg: Grace [=MacLean=] Robert and Annie [=MacLean=]'s daughter loses a leg after because of a horse accident.accident. Which leads to her suffering from depression.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
How To Create A Works Page: Things not to include: value judgments (don't say how much they sucked/how awesome it was), critical reception (that's just a specific variant of value judgments), recommendations (don't tell us whether or not we should check it out).


The story explores both the recovery and the mutual attraction developed between the two adults. Which is confusing for them as Annie is still married and Tom is recovering from a divorce. The film received mostly positive reviews. While critics praised the "exquisitively crafted, morally and thematically mature picture", several felt it was overly long and dull. It was also a box office hit, earning $186,883,563 worldwide. It earned $75,383,563 in the United States, the 27th most successful film of its year.

to:

The story explores both the recovery and the mutual attraction developed between the two adults. Which is confusing for them as Annie is still married and Tom is recovering from a divorce. The film received mostly positive reviews. While critics praised the "exquisitively crafted, morally and thematically mature picture", several felt it was overly long and dull. It was also a box office hit, earning $186,883,563 worldwide. It earned $75,383,563 in the United States, the 27th most successful film of its year.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Horse Whisperer'' is the name of a 1995 novel by Nicholas Evans and of a 1998 film adaptation of it. The latter was directed by Creator/RobertRedford. The main stars were Redford himself (directing himself for the first time onscreen), Creator/KristinScottThomas and Creator/ScarlettJohansson.

The film begins on a winter morning, with teenagers Grace [=MacLean=] (Johansson) and Judith (Kate Bosworth) taking their horses for a ride. An accident involving an icy slope and a truck results in Judith and her horse being instantly killed. Grace and her horse, Pilgrim, survive but are badly injured. Grace loses part of her leg in the subsequent surgery.

to:

''The Horse Whisperer'' is the name of a 1995 novel by Nicholas Evans and of a 1998 film adaptation of it. The latter was directed by Creator/RobertRedford. The main stars were Redford himself (directing himself for the first time onscreen), Creator/KristinScottThomas Creator/KristinScottThomas, Creator/KateBosworth and Creator/ScarlettJohansson.

The film begins on a winter morning, with teenagers Grace [=MacLean=] (Johansson) and Judith (Kate Bosworth) (Bosworth) taking their horses for a ride. An accident involving an icy slope and a truck results in Judith and her horse being instantly killed. Grace and her horse, Pilgrim, survive but are badly injured. Grace loses part of her leg in the subsequent surgery.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Horse Whisperer'' is the name of a 1995 novel by Nicholas Evans and of a 1998 film adaptation of it. The latter was directed by Creator/RobertRedford. The main stars were Redford himself (directing himself for the first time onscreen), Kristin Scott Thomas and Creator/ScarlettJohansson.

to:

''The Horse Whisperer'' is the name of a 1995 novel by Nicholas Evans and of a 1998 film adaptation of it. The latter was directed by Creator/RobertRedford. The main stars were Redford himself (directing himself for the first time onscreen), Kristin Scott Thomas Creator/KristinScottThomas and Creator/ScarlettJohansson.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WakingNonSequitur: Subverted; the first thing Grace says when she wakes up in the hospital is "Judith".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationDistillation: Several things, but perhaps most notably is how Annie and Tom in the film never do more than kiss, while in the book they slept together several times.

to:

* AdaptationDistillation: Several things, but perhaps most notably is how Annie and Tom in the film never do more than kiss, while in the book they slept sleep together several times.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CryIntoChest: Grace does this twice. First, after a bitter argument with her mother (after it's revealed she tried to ride a horse again without asking anyone's permission), and Annie is leaving, Grace starts crying and asking aloud, "Who's going to want me?", at which point Annie comes back and hugs her as Grace continues to cry. The second time, it's to Tom when Grace finally tells him about the accident.


Added DiffLines:

* ThereAreNoTherapists: Zigzagged. On the one hand, it is hard to believe no one would think of getting Grace a therapist to help her deal with the fact her best friend was killed and [[ItsAllMyFault she thinks she's responsible]]; on the other hand, it could be argued the trip to Montana itself is a form of therapy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationDistillation: Several things, but perhaps most notably is how Annie and Tom in the film never do more than kiss, while in the book they slept together several times.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
style


* AnimalMetaphor: Pilgrim, the horse who [[GoMadFromTheRevelation went mad]] after the accident symbolizes Grace's difficulties to have a social life after the loss of her leg. The training of Pilgrim parallels her mental recovery.

to:

* AnimalMetaphor: Pilgrim, the horse who [[GoMadFromTheRevelation went mad]] after the accident accident, symbolizes Grace's difficulties to have a social life after the loss of her leg. The training of Pilgrim parallels her mental recovery.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* AnimalMetaphor: Pilgrim, the horse who [[GoMadFromTheRevelation went mad]] after the accident symbolizes Grace's difficulties to have a social life after the loss of her leg. The training of Pilgrim parallels her mental recovery.

Added: 105

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* BettyAndVeronica: Annie (Archie) has to chose between her husband (Betty), who is a nice guy, a successful lawyer and a city-dweller like her, and Tom (Veronica), a rancher who does not want to leave the country and who is generally sarcastic with her.

to:

* BettyAndVeronica: Annie (Archie) has to chose between her husband (Betty), who is a nice guy, NiceGuy, a successful lawyer and a city-dweller like her, and Tom (Veronica), a rancher who does not want to leave the country and who is generally sarcastic with her.


Added DiffLines:

* NiceGuy: Robert [=MacLean=] is depicted as a good husband and father. See also IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* MercyKill: {{Subverted|Trope}}. After the accident, the veterinary recommends to kill Pilgrim, who is badly injured. Annie rejects this proposal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* AdultFear: Robert and Annie [=MacLean=]'s daughter loses a leg because of a horse accident. Moreover, she suffers from depression.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
style


* DefrostingIceQueen: Annie is a cold and successful businesswoman at start. Her daughter tells her that she treats everybody (including her daughter and husband) as her employees. Tom Booker will soften her cold demeanor during the course of the film.

to:

* DefrostingIceQueen: Annie is a cold and successful businesswoman at start.in the beginning. Her daughter tells her that she treats everybody (including her daughter and husband) as her employees. Tom Booker will soften her cold demeanor during the course of the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* CoolHorse: Pilgrim. Even if he is badly injured, Joe Booker, Tom's nephew, acknowledges that it was a magnificent horse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
clearer


* BettyAndVeronica: Annie (Archie) has to chose between her husband (Betty), who is a nice guy, a successful lawyer and a city-dweller like her, and Tom (Veronica), a rancher who cannot leave the country and who is generally sarcastic with her.

to:

* BettyAndVeronica: Annie (Archie) has to chose between her husband (Betty), who is a nice guy, a successful lawyer and a city-dweller like her, and Tom (Veronica), a rancher who cannot does not want to leave the country and who is generally sarcastic with her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* BaitAndSwitchComment: When she gives comments about a project of magazine cover, Annie start saying everything is perfect, then she says it is dull, so it has to be scrapped.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* {{Arcadia}}: In Montana, the people have a simple life. Two New-Yorkers and a horse recover from their emotional pains there.


Added DiffLines:

* GoMadFromTheRevelation: Pilgrim, Grace's horse, goes mad because of the shock of the accident.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* MatingDance: There is a very sensual dance between Tom Booker and Annie. Her husband is in the same room, but he does not pay attention.

Top