Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheDevilsBrigade

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SuspiciouslySmallArmy: during the Force's graduation parade scene, it is obvious there are only a couple of companies of extras. The real life Force commander had chosen the title "Brigade" to mask its true size from the enemy. In actual fact the First Special Service Force was made up of three regiments of about 600 men in each, or about 1800 men in total.

to:

* SuspiciouslySmallArmy: during the Force's graduation parade scene, it is obvious there are only a couple of companies of extras. The real life Force commander had chosen the title "Brigade" to mask its true size from the enemy. In actual fact the First Special Service Force was made up of three regiments of about 600 men in each, or about 1800 men in total. The most ever depicted on screen at once are 200 or so.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SergeantRock: Canadian Sgt. O'Neill subverts this. His first appearance is as a bespectacled, trash-talking wimp. He quickly hands Pvt. Rockman his own rear, commenting on the human body's weaknesses with every blow and deflection.

to:

* SergeantRock: Canadian Sgt. O'Neill subverts this. His first appearance is as a bespectacled, trash-talking wimp. He quickly hands Pvt. Rockman his own rear, commenting on the human body's weaknesses with every blow and deflection.deflection.
* SuspiciouslySmallArmy: during the Force's graduation parade scene, it is obvious there are only a couple of companies of extras. The real life Force commander had chosen the title "Brigade" to mask its true size from the enemy. In actual fact the First Special Service Force was made up of three regiments of about 600 men in each, or about 1800 men in total.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** American General Mark Clark was portrayed by English actor Michael Rennie while German General Knapp was played by American actor James Craig.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The use of English, Scottish, Irish accents among Canadians qualifies as a trope. This liberal mixing of accents is probably more indicative of the view Americans had of their cousins to the north, than of the actual proportion of soldiers raised in the UK serving in the Canadian Army in 1943. While in 1914, the proportion of UK-born soldiers in Canadian combat units was about 50%, that number declined during the First World War in favour of Canadian-born soldiers, and by 1939 the majority of soldiers in the Canadian Army would have used a flatter "Canadian" or possibly mid-Atlantic accent. Historical accuracy would have involved the actors portraying Canadians to sound no different than someone from Michigan or Montana, and there would have been little to distinguish them from the American characters.

to:

** The use of English, Scottish, Irish accents among Canadians qualifies as a trope. This liberal mixing of accents is probably more indicative of the view Americans had of their cousins to the north, than of the actual proportion of soldiers raised in the UK serving in the Canadian Army in 1943. While in 1914, the proportion of UK-born soldiers in Canadian combat units was about 50%, that number declined during the First World War in favour of Canadian-born soldiers, and by 1939 the majority of soldiers in the Canadian Army would have used a flatter "Canadian" or possibly mid-Atlantic accent. Historical accuracy would have involved the actors portraying Canadians to sound no different than someone from Michigan or Montana, Montana (where the first third of the film takes place), and there would have been little to distinguish them from the American characters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FakeNationality: Cliff Robertson (a Californian) plays the senior Canadian as an Irishman (in actuality, the senior Canadian was Major John [=McQueen=] of the Calgary Highlanders). Richard Dawson (an Englishman who emigrated to the United States) plays Canadian Corporal [=MacDonald=] with a Scottish accent. Corporal Peacock is played by an actual Englishman, Jack Watson, and though audiences might be confused by his kilt, that is a reflection of his unit (the Calgary Highlanders) and not his nationality. The other Canadians (Jeremy Slate, Harry Carey) are played by Americans and speak with a neutral English accent. Jean-Paul Vignon, who plays the only Francophone Canadian, was actually born in Ethiopia to a French father and Italian mother.

to:

* FakeNationality: Cliff Robertson (a Californian) plays the senior Canadian as an Irishman (in actuality, the senior Canadian was Major John [=McQueen=] of the Calgary Highlanders). Richard Dawson (an Englishman who emigrated to the United States) plays Canadian Corporal [=MacDonald=] with a Scottish accent. Corporal Peacock is played by an actual Englishman, Jack Watson, and though audiences might be confused by his kilt, that is a reflection of his unit (the Calgary Highlanders) and not his nationality. The other Canadians (Jeremy Slate, Harry Carey) are played by Americans and speak with a neutral English accent. Jean-Paul Vignon, who plays the only Francophone Canadian, was actually born in Ethiopia to a French father and Italian mother. In short, there are no Canadian actors in the film.

Added: 544

Changed: 205

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ObligatoryWarCrimeScene: Downplayed but present. During the initial action in Italy Sgt. O'Neill dresses as a German soldier, which under the rules of war would have gotten him shot by the enemy and court martialed by his country.

to:

* ObligatoryWarCrimeScene: Downplayed but present. During ObligatoryWarCrimeScene:
**The German commander on La Difensa shows a white flag as a ruse, and uses
the initial action in Italy brief cease fire to kill one of the officers sent to accept his surrender.
**Incorrectly reported as a war crime:
Sgt. O'Neill dresses as a German soldier, which under the soldier. The Hague Convention actually permits enemy uniforms to be worn as a legitimate ruse d'guerre. The rules of war would have gotten him shot state, however, that soldiers are not allowed to fight in them. Similar to a false flag ruse used by naval vessels, once contact with the enemy and court martialed by his country.is made, one has to fight in the insignia of their own side.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**During the bar brawl, it is revealed Corporal [=MacDonald=] doesn't know the correct manner to wear a kilt, as a set of white cotton briefs are shown when he takes a flying kick at someone. Soldiers (particularly at that time) were expected not to wear anything under the kilt. By the same token, it is later made obvious the actor doesn't actually know how to play the bagpipes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The use of English, Scottish, Irish accents among Canadians qualifies as a trope. This liberal mixing of accents is probably more indicative of the view Americans had of their cousins to the north, than of the actual proportion of soldiers raised in the UK serving in the Canadian Army in 1943. While in 1914, the proportion of UK-born soldiers in Canadian combat units was about 50%, that number declined during the First World War in favour of Canadian-born soldiers, and by 1939 the majority of soldiers in the Canadian Army would have used a flatter "Canadian" or possibly mid-Atlantic accent.

to:

** The use of English, Scottish, Irish accents among Canadians qualifies as a trope. This liberal mixing of accents is probably more indicative of the view Americans had of their cousins to the north, than of the actual proportion of soldiers raised in the UK serving in the Canadian Army in 1943. While in 1914, the proportion of UK-born soldiers in Canadian combat units was about 50%, that number declined during the First World War in favour of Canadian-born soldiers, and by 1939 the majority of soldiers in the Canadian Army would have used a flatter "Canadian" or possibly mid-Atlantic accent. Historical accuracy would have involved the actors portraying Canadians to sound no different than someone from Michigan or Montana, and there would have been little to distinguish them from the American characters.

Added: 600

Changed: 533

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FakeNationality: Cliff Robertson (a Californian) plays the senior Canadian as an Irishman (in actuality, the senior Canadian was Major John McQueen of the Calgary Highlanders). Richard Dawson (an Englishman who emigrated to the United States) plays Canadian Corporal [=MacDonald=] with a Scottish accent. Corporal Peacock is played by an actual Englishman, Jack Watson, and though audiences might be confused by his kilt, that is a reflection of his unit (the Calgary Highlanders) and not his nationality. The other Canadians (Jeremy Slate, Harry Carey) are played by Americans and speak with a neutral English accent. Jean-Paul Vignon, who plays the only Francophone Canadian, was actually born in Ethiopia to a French father and Italian mother. The liberal mixing of accents among the senior Canadians is probably more indicative of the view Americans had of their cousins to the north, than of the actual proportion of soldiers raised in the UK serving in the Canadian Army in 1943. While in 1914, the proportion of UK-born soldiers in Canadian combat units was about 50%, that number declined during the war in favour of Canadian-born soldiers, and by 1939 the majority of soldiers in the Canadian Army would have used a flatter "Canadian" or possibly mid-Atlantic accent.

to:

* FakeNationality: Cliff Robertson (a Californian) plays the senior Canadian as an Irishman (in actuality, the senior Canadian was Major John McQueen [=McQueen=] of the Calgary Highlanders). Richard Dawson (an Englishman who emigrated to the United States) plays Canadian Corporal [=MacDonald=] with a Scottish accent. Corporal Peacock is played by an actual Englishman, Jack Watson, and though audiences might be confused by his kilt, that is a reflection of his unit (the Calgary Highlanders) and not his nationality. The other Canadians (Jeremy Slate, Harry Carey) are played by Americans and speak with a neutral English accent. Jean-Paul Vignon, who plays the only Francophone Canadian, was actually born in Ethiopia to a French father and Italian mother. The
**The use of English, Scottish, Irish accents among Canadians qualifies as a trope. This
liberal mixing of accents among the senior Canadians accents is probably more indicative of the view Americans had of their cousins to the north, than of the actual proportion of soldiers raised in the UK serving in the Canadian Army in 1943. While in 1914, the proportion of UK-born soldiers in Canadian combat units was about 50%, that number declined during the war First World War in favour of Canadian-born soldiers, and by 1939 the majority of soldiers in the Canadian Army would have used a flatter "Canadian" or possibly mid-Atlantic accent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FakeNationality: Cliff Robertson (a Californian) plays the senior Canadian as an Irishman (in actuality, the senior Canadian was Major John McQueen of the Calgary Highlanders). Richard Dawson (an Englishman who emigrated to the United States) plays Canadian Corporal MacDonald with a Scottish accent. Corporal Peacock is played by an actual Englishman, Jack Watson, and though audiences might be confused by his kilt, that is a reflection of his unit (the Calgary Highlanders) and not his nationality. The other Canadians (Jeremy Slate, Harry Carey) are played by Americans and speak with a neutral English accent. Jean-Paul Vignon, who plays the only Francophone Canadian, was actually born in Ethiopia to a French father and Italian mother. The liberal mixing of accents among the senior Canadians is probably more indicative of the view Americans had of their cousins to the north, than of the actual proportion of soldiers raised in the UK serving in the Canadian Army in 1943. While in 1914, the proportion of UK-born soldiers in Canadian combat units was about 50%, that number declined during the war in favour of Canadian-born soldiers, and by 1939 the majority of soldiers in the Canadian Army would have used a flatter "Canadian" or possibly mid-Atlantic accent.

to:

* FakeNationality: Cliff Robertson (a Californian) plays the senior Canadian as an Irishman (in actuality, the senior Canadian was Major John McQueen of the Calgary Highlanders). Richard Dawson (an Englishman who emigrated to the United States) plays Canadian Corporal MacDonald [=MacDonald=] with a Scottish accent. Corporal Peacock is played by an actual Englishman, Jack Watson, and though audiences might be confused by his kilt, that is a reflection of his unit (the Calgary Highlanders) and not his nationality. The other Canadians (Jeremy Slate, Harry Carey) are played by Americans and speak with a neutral English accent. Jean-Paul Vignon, who plays the only Francophone Canadian, was actually born in Ethiopia to a French father and Italian mother. The liberal mixing of accents among the senior Canadians is probably more indicative of the view Americans had of their cousins to the north, than of the actual proportion of soldiers raised in the UK serving in the Canadian Army in 1943. While in 1914, the proportion of UK-born soldiers in Canadian combat units was about 50%, that number declined during the war in favour of Canadian-born soldiers, and by 1939 the majority of soldiers in the Canadian Army would have used a flatter "Canadian" or possibly mid-Atlantic accent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FakeNationality: Cliff Robertson (a Californian) plays the senior Canadian as an Irishman (in actuality, the senior Canadian was Major John McQueen of the Calgary Highlanders). Richard Dawson (an Englishman who emigrated to the United States) plays Canadian Corporal MacDonald with a Scottish accent. Corporal Peacock is played by an actual Englishman, Jack Watson, and though audiences might be confused by his kilt, that is a reflection of his unit (the Calgary Highlanders) and not his nationality. The other Canadians (Jeremy Slate, Harry Carey) are played by Americans and speak with a neutral English accent. Jean-Paul Vignon, who plays the only Francophone Canadian, was actually born in Ethiopia to a French father and Italian mother. The liberal mixing of accents among the senior Canadians is probably more indicative of the view Americans had of their cousins to the north, than of the actual proportion of soldiers raised in the UK serving in the Canadian Army in 1943. While in 1914, the proportion of UK-born soldiers in Canadian combat units was about 50%, that number declined during the war in favour of Canadian-born soldiers, and by 1939 the majority of soldiers in the Canadian Army would have used a flatter "Canadian" or possibly mid-Atlantic accent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigEntrance: Just as the American troops embarrass themselves with a unruly brawl, the Canadians arrive marching in perfect formation, complete with a band playing [[EverythingsLouderWithBagpipes "Scotland the Brave"]], as a proper army. With one move, the Americans learn the standard they suddenly have to live up to.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
not a trope


* UsefulNotes/CanucksWithChinooks: The professional half of the 1st SSF.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> {{MacDonald}}: Haven't you ever seen a man say goodbye?

to:

--> {{MacDonald}}: [=MacDonald=]: Haven't you ever seen a man say goodbye?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ManInAKilt: Several Canadians, and a source of cheap shots by the Americans until the bar brawl.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> MacDonald: Haven't you ever seen a man say goodbye?

to:

--> MacDonald: {{MacDonald}}: Haven't you ever seen a man say goodbye?



* CanucksWithChinooks

to:

* CanucksWithChinooksUsefulNotes/CanucksWithChinooks: The professional half of the 1st SSF.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CanucksWithChinooks


Added DiffLines:

* EverythingsLouderWithBagpipes: Used in the opening credits, and then later as the Canadians march proudly into the training camp.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ActionFilmQuietDramaScene: Just before the assault on Monte La Difensa, Fredrick makes his way through the men and makes sure they're prepared for the assault. The Americans, still relatively green, don't understand what was happening.
--> Bronc: What's wrong with him?
--> MacDonald: Haven't you ever seen a man say goodbye?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MilitaryMaverick: Fredrick doesn't care about rank advancement or how he's perceived by higher ranks, and after their first successful combat operation turns down a promotion.
--> Lt. Gen. Clark: Full-bird colonels aren't expendable colonel.
--> Lt. Col. Fredrick: How high up can a man go and still be "expendable"?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/the_devils_brigade.jpg]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChekhovsSkill: One of the Americans is a former circus acrobat, which comes in handy for getting through to places that the Nazis wouldn't expect their enemies to come from.

to:

* ChekhovsSkill: One of the Americans Pvt. Greco is a former circus acrobat, which comes in handy for getting through to places that the Nazis wouldn't expect their enemies to come from.



* JerkassHasAPoint: The general in Italy makes several solid points regarding the 1st: They're a green unit that is half made up of derelict soldiers on the American side, and led by a commander who hasn't yet seen any combat.

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: The general in Italy Maj. Gen. Hunter makes several solid points regarding the 1st: They're a green unit that is half made up of derelict soldiers on the American side, and led by a commander who hasn't yet seen any combat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ChekhovsSkill: One of the Americans is a former circus acrobat, which comes in handy for getting through to places that the Nazis wouldn't expect their enemies to come from.


Added DiffLines:

* JerkassHasAPoint: The general in Italy makes several solid points regarding the 1st: They're a green unit that is half made up of derelict soldiers on the American side, and led by a commander who hasn't yet seen any combat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MajorlyAwesome: Canadian Maj. Crown, survivor of Dunkirk with the most combat experience of the unit's officers.



* RuleOfCool: Surviving members of the unit note that while the film was just barely based on real life, they did admit it was an entertaining movie to watch.

to:

* RuleOfCool: Surviving members of the unit note that while the film was just barely based on real life, they did admit it was an entertaining movie to watch.watch.
* SergeantRock: Canadian Sgt. O'Neill subverts this. His first appearance is as a bespectacled, trash-talking wimp. He quickly hands Pvt. Rockman his own rear, commenting on the human body's weaknesses with every blow and deflection.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ActuallyPrettyFunny: During the ruck march, the Canadians are ordered to cease making derogatory insults about the Americans. A Canadian soldiers asks if ordinary insults are acceptable. Frederick has to turn away from the men to laugh.


Added DiffLines:

* NotSoAboveItAll: Frederick has several moments where it's clear he's just as much of a misfit as the rest of the Americans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Released a year after the more-well-known film Film/TheDirtyDozen, The Devil's Brigade is loosely based on the real exploits of the 1st Special Service Force.

to:

Released a year after the more-well-known film Film/TheDirtyDozen, The ''Film/TheDirtyDozen'', ''The Devil's Brigade Brigade'' is loosely based on the real exploits of the 1st Special Service Force.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CaptainOblivious: The German garrison commander who goes through his entire morning routine without even realizing that he and his men are under assault.


Added DiffLines:

* NakedPeopleAreFunny: The Brigade manages to capture a squad of Germans during their morning shower, and marches them out in their towels.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ObligatoryWarCrimeScene: Downplayed but present. During the initial action in Italy Sgt. O'Neill dresses as a German soldier, which under the rules of war would have gotten him shot by the enemy and court martialed by his country.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Released a year after the more-well-known film TheDirtyDozen, the Devil's Brigade is loosely based on the real exploits of the 1st Special Service Force.

to:

Released a year after the more-well-known film TheDirtyDozen, the Film/TheDirtyDozen, The Devil's Brigade is loosely based on the real exploits of the 1st Special Service Force.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

The year is 1942. Lt. Col. Robert T. Frederick is called to answer to Lord Mountbatten for his rejection of a planned American-British commando raid into occupied Norway. Seeing his willingness to call out the plan's flaws as a sign of worth, the British decide that Frederick is precisely the man they need to lead the new 1st Special Service Force. A joint American-Canadian unit, Frederick is tasked with combining the rough and rowdy Americans with the prim and proper Canadians.

Released a year after the more-well-known film TheDirtyDozen, the Devil's Brigade is loosely based on the real exploits of the 1st Special Service Force.

!!This film provides examples of:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: As noted by former member Bill Story, the Americans in the unit were not the ill-disciplined stockade grabs as depicted in the movie.
* ArmyOfThievesAndWhores: Well the Americans at least, ranging from accused hustlers to layabouts to accused rapists.
* ArsonMurderAndJaywalking: Compared to the rest of the unit, Pvt. Ransom's offense of committing adultery is downright innocent.
* BarBrawl: The 1st Special Service Force gets into the thick of it as one unit when a group of lumberjacks decides they don't like Canadians in their local bar.
* BreakTheHaughty: First the Canadians break the Americans by showing off their hand-to-hand combat skills after the Americans continue causing trouble. The second is when the unit proves itself to their commanders in Italy by capturing an entire German garrison, tanks and all.
* TheChainsOfCommanding: Frederick feels this heavily before ordering his men to assault Monte La Difensa.
* ElitesAreMoreGlamorous: Subverted: The Canadians match the image of a proper elite military force, but the American contribution makes it clear that being in an elite unit doesn't translate into an easy military career.
* ItsPersonal: Maj. Crown still nurses anger over the retreat from Dunkirk, and carries it with him to [[spoiler: his death.]]
* MisfitMobilizationMoment: Ties in with the bar brawl. It marks the point where the Americans and Canadians finally realize they can both fight together as one.
* RefugeInAudacity: Both the operations shown in the film. No one on the American side expected the unit to perform so well in their first mission, and later when they accurately predict that the German defenses on Monte La Difensa would be pointing away from the sheer cliffs expecting no one could make the climb.
* RuleOfCool: Surviving members of the unit note that while the film was just barely based on real life, they did admit it was an entertaining movie to watch.

Top