Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheDevilsBrigade

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trivia


* FakeNationality: Cliff Robertson (a Californian) plays the senior Canadian as an Irishman (in actuality, the senior Canadian was Major John [=McQueen=] of the Calgary Highlanders). Richard Dawson (an Englishman who emigrated to the United States) plays Canadian Corporal [=MacDonald=] with a Scottish accent. Corporal Peacock is played by an actual Englishman, Jack Watson, and though audiences might be confused by his kilt, that is a reflection of his unit (the Calgary Highlanders) and not his nationality. The other Canadians (Jeremy Slate, Harry Carey) are played by Americans and speak with a neutral English accent. Jean-Paul Vignon, who plays the only Francophone Canadian, was actually born in Ethiopia to a French father and Italian mother. In short, there are no Canadian actors in the film.
** The use of English, Scottish, Irish accents among Canadians qualifies as a trope. This liberal mixing of accents is probably more indicative of the view Americans had of their cousins to the north, than of the actual proportion of soldiers raised in the UK serving in the Canadian Army in 1943. While in 1914, the proportion of UK-born soldiers in Canadian combat units was about 50%, that number declined during the First World War in favour of Canadian-born soldiers, and by 1939 the majority of soldiers in the Canadian Army would have used a flatter "Canadian" or possibly mid-Atlantic accent. Historical accuracy would have involved the actors portraying Canadians to sound no different than someone from Michigan or Montana (where the first third of the film takes place), and there would have been little to distinguish them from the American characters.
** American General Mark Clark was portrayed by English actor Michael Rennie while German General Knapp was played by American actor James Craig.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MountainWarfare: The film's climactic battle sees the brigade scale the cliffs of Monte La Difenza, in order to attack the German positions near the summit from above and behind.

to:

* MountainWarfare: The film's climactic battle sees the brigade scale the cliffs of Monte La Difenza, Difensa, in order to attack the German positions near the summit from above and behind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MountainWarfare: The film's climactic battle sees the brigade scale the cliffs of Monte La Difenza and attack the German positions near the summit from above and behind.

to:

* MountainWarfare: The film's climactic battle sees the brigade scale the cliffs of Monte La Difenza and Difenza, in order to attack the German positions near the summit from above and behind.



* WinterWarfare: The unit is seen engaging in ski training in preparation for their (ultimately canceled) commando raid Norway. Additionally, in real life the 1st Special Service Force was initially deployed to the Aleutian Islands as part of the landings on Kiska.

to:

* WinterWarfare: The unit is seen engaging in ski training in preparation for their (ultimately canceled) commando raid in Norway. Additionally, in real life the 1st Special Service Force was initially deployed to the Aleutian Islands as part of the landings on Kiska.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MountainWarfare: The film's climactic battle sees the brigade scale the cliffs of Monte La Difenza and attack the German positions near the summit from above and behind.



** Rocky and Peacock (once they become friends) also end up becoming this.

to:

** Rocky and Peacock (once they become friends) also end up becoming this.this.
* WinterWarfare: The unit is seen engaging in ski training in preparation for their (ultimately canceled) commando raid Norway. Additionally, in real life the 1st Special Service Force was initially deployed to the Aleutian Islands as part of the landings on Kiska.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DisproportionateRestitution: After the BarBrawl that turns the unit into FireForgedFriends, Frederick gives a token punishment to the men: He sequesters their pay until all damages to the bar are paid for (a significant sum for one man, but a minor fine per head when divided across the brigade), and confines them to base for eight hours (starting in the middle of the night, meaning that he's telling them to go to bed and stay there until breakfast).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> Bronc: What's wrong with him?
--> [=MacDonald=]: Haven't you ever seen a man say goodbye?
* ActuallyPrettyFunny: During the ruck march, the Canadians are ordered to cease making derogatory insults about the Americans. A Canadian soldiers asks if ordinary insults are acceptable. Frederick has to turn away from the men to laugh.

to:

--> Bronc: '''Bronc''': What's wrong with him?
--> [=MacDonald=]: '''[=MacDonald=]''': Haven't you ever seen a man say goodbye?
* ActuallyPrettyFunny: During the ruck march, the Canadians are ordered to cease making derogatory insults about the Americans. A Canadian soldiers soldier asks if ordinary insults are acceptable. Frederick has to turn away from the men to laugh.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed misuse of the trope


* BaldHeadOfToughness: Greco is a a bald headed man whose acrobatic skills help out a lot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ObligatoryWarCrimeScene:
** The German commander on La Difensa shows a white flag as a ruse, and uses the brief cease fire to kill one of the officers sent to accept his surrender.
** Incorrectly reported as a war crime: Sgt. O'Neill dresses as a German soldier. The Hague Convention actually permits enemy uniforms to be worn as a legitimate ruse d'guerre. The rules state, however, that soldiers are not allowed to fight in them. Similar to a false flag ruse used by naval vessels, once contact with the enemy is made, one has to fight in the insignia of their own side.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Replacing bald of awesome with appropriate replacement trope.

Added DiffLines:

* BaldHeadOfToughness: Greco is a a bald headed man whose acrobatic skills help out a lot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 1968 UsefulNotes/WorldWarII film directed by Andrew V. [=McLaglen=], starring Creator/WilliamHolden, Cliff Robertson and Vince Edwards.

to:

A 1968 UsefulNotes/WorldWarII film directed by Andrew V. [=McLaglen=], starring Creator/WilliamHolden, Cliff Robertson Creator/CliffRobertson and Vince Edwards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Bald Of Awesome is being renamed and redefined per TRS decision


* BaldOfAwesome: Greco is a a bald headed man whose acrobatic skills help out a lot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnyoneCanDie: In the assault on Monte La Difensa, multiple leading members of the brigade are killed [[spoiler: including Greco, Bronx, O'Neill, Peacock, and Crown]].
* AppropriatedAppellation: Maj. Crown claims that one of the German officers he interrogated referred to them as "The Devil's Brigade", calls it a compliment and then cheerfully toasts Frederick as the devil.



* BittersweetEnding: The assault on Monte La Difensa was a success in terms of the military goal, but the 1st suffered heavy casualties and losses.



** Maj. Crown spends much of the 1st's training clearly disapproving of the international rivalry between the men and reining in the Canadians. However, towards the end of a 30-mile hike with all the men wearing rucksacks filled with rocks, he encourages the Canadians to ''start running'' the home stretch to the base for seemingly no other reason than to further annoy the struggling Americans.



* ThoseTwoGuys: Greco and Bronxc befriend each other. early on and do a lot together during training.

to:

* ThoseTwoGuys: Greco and Bronxc befriend each other. early on and do a lot together during training.training.
** Rocky and Peacock (once they become friends) also end up becoming this.

Added: 1048

Changed: 730

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BaldOfAwesome: Greco is a a bald headed man whose acrobatic skills help out a lot.



* GreatEscape: Greco tries to escape with his acrobatic skills while being brought in.
* HotBlooded: More than half of the bursts at temper towards Americans come from Private Macdonald. It isn’t that he isn’t somewhat justified but it’s notable that everyone but him can remain stoic.



* SergeantRock: Canadian Sgt. O'Neill subverts this. His first appearance is as a bespectacled, trash-talking wimp. He quickly hands Pvt. Rockman his own rear, commenting on the human body's weaknesses with every blow and deflection.
* SuspiciouslySmallArmy: during the Force's graduation parade scene, it is obvious there are only a couple of companies of extras. The real life Force commander had chosen the title "Brigade" to mask its true size from the enemy. In actual fact the First Special Service Force was made up of three regiments of about 600 men in each, or about 1800 men in total. The most ever depicted on screen at once are 200 or so.

to:

* SergeantRock: SergeantRock:
**
Canadian Sgt. O'Neill subverts this. His first appearance is as a bespectacled, trash-talking wimp. He quickly hands Pvt. Rockman his own rear, commenting on the human body's weaknesses with every blow and deflection.
** Sergeant Peacock, also of the Canadians is a husky guy capable of whipping men into attention with a few words, but he's also friendly enough most of the time.
* SuspiciouslySmallArmy: during the Force's graduation parade scene, it is obvious there are only a couple of companies of extras. The real life Force commander had chosen the title "Brigade" to mask its true size from the enemy. In actual fact the First Special Service Force was made up of three regiments of about 600 men in each, or about 1800 men in total. The most ever depicted on screen at once are 200 or so.so.
* ThoseTwoGuys: Greco and Bronxc befriend each other. early on and do a lot together during training.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:320:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/the_devils_brigade_1968.jpg]]

to:

[[quoteright:320:https://static.[[quoteright:330:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/the_devils_brigade_1968.jpg]]



The year is 1942. Lt. Col. Robert T. Frederick (Holden) is called to answer to Lord Mountbatten for his rejection of a planned American-British commando raid into occupied Norway. Seeing his willingness to call out the plan's flaws as a sign of worth, the British decide that Frederick is precisely the man they need to lead the new 1st Special Service Force. A joint American-Canadian unit, Frederick is tasked with combining the rough and rowdy Americans with the prim and proper Canadians.

to:

The year is 1942. Lt. Col. Robert T. Frederick (Holden) is called to answer to Lord Mountbatten for his rejection of a planned American-British commando raid into occupied Norway. Seeing his willingness to call out the plan's flaws as a sign of worth, the British decide that Frederick is precisely the man they need to lead the new 1st Special Service Force. A joint American-Canadian unit, the First Special Service Force. Frederick is tasked with combining the rough and rowdy Americans with the prim and proper Canadians.

Added: 163

Changed: 1103

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/the_devils_brigade.jpg]]

The year is 1942. Lt. Col. Robert T. Frederick is called to answer to Lord Mountbatten for his rejection of a planned American-British commando raid into occupied Norway. Seeing his willingness to call out the plan's flaws as a sign of worth, the British decide that Frederick is precisely the man they need to lead the new 1st Special Service Force. A joint American-Canadian unit, Frederick is tasked with combining the rough and rowdy Americans with the prim and proper Canadians.

Released a year after the more-well-known film ''Film/TheDirtyDozen'', ''The Devil's Brigade'' is loosely based on the real exploits of the 1st Special Service Force.

to:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.[[quoteright:320:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/the_devils_brigade.org/pmwiki/pub/images/the_devils_brigade_1968.jpg]]

A 1968 UsefulNotes/WorldWarII film directed by Andrew V. [=McLaglen=], starring Creator/WilliamHolden, Cliff Robertson and Vince Edwards.

The year is 1942. Lt. Col. Robert T. Frederick (Holden) is called to answer to Lord Mountbatten for his rejection of a planned American-British commando raid into occupied Norway. Seeing his willingness to call out the plan's flaws as a sign of worth, the British decide that Frederick is precisely the man they need to lead the new 1st Special Service Force. A joint American-Canadian unit, Frederick is tasked with combining the rough and rowdy Americans with the prim and proper Canadians.

Released a year after the more-well-known film better-known ''Film/TheDirtyDozen'', ''The Devil's Brigade'' is loosely based on the real exploits of the 1st Special Service Force.
Force.

-----

Top