Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheDayTheEarthStoodStill2008

Go To

OR

Changed: 194

Removed: 2116

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cleaning up some unneeded snark and misused tropes.


* BrokenAesop: We're destroying the other species on our planet, and aliens think that's bad. Fine. So why does Helen's love for Jacob change Klaatu's mind? A mother's love for a child of her own species, while charming, doesn't really show anything except a desire to perpetuate her species. It'd be more valid if she showed love for an animal, perhaps something [[WhatMeasureIsANonCute completely dissimilar to humans]]. Instead, ThePowerOfLove conquers all. Perhaps it's the fact that Jacob is her husband's biological son and not hers?



* DullSurprise: Reeves plays an alien whose affect is chilly and inhuman, and is wonderfully natural in the part.

to:

* DullSurprise: Reeves plays an alien whose affect is chilly and inhuman, and is wonderfully natural in Klaatu isn't the part.most emotive alien.



* FauxFluency: Keanu Reeves' Klaatu speaks to an elderly man (who is really an alien disguised in human form) in Mandarin Chinese. It's a valiant effort, but still pretty bad.



* FunWithAcronyms: The US government decides Klaatu's robot buddy is '''G'''enetically '''O'''rganized '''R'''obotic '''T'''echnology--apparently, just having Klaatu ''say'' "Gort" at some point wasn't remakey enough.

to:

* FunWithAcronyms: The US government decides Klaatu's robot buddy is '''G'''enetically '''O'''rganized '''R'''obotic '''T'''echnology--apparently, just having Klaatu ''say'' "Gort" at some point wasn't remakey enough.'''T'''echnology.



* GratuitousForeignLanguage: Mandarin Chinese. Keanu Reeves tries really hard, but still doesn't get it quite right.



* TooDumbToLive:
** The military, law enforcement, and the government in general, though all of government in all of fiction is guilty of this trope, and it's not an unexpected reaction to aliens being suddenly real. Klaatu comes to Earth and reaches out his hand to the protagonists. Clearly, putting a bullet in him is the appropriate response. Only later do they realize he was able to shut down their defense network on a whim, and so they decide imprisoning and (implicitly) ''torturing'' him is a good idea. Klaatu's decision, after consulting a spy on Earth, is naturally that HumansAreBastards and have to go, thus the swarm of nanobots begins devouring every man-made object in its path. The military bombs it, only to see it grow larger. The Secretary of Defense at least grows a brain at this point, but the president orders even more bombing as if the opinion of his military adviser isn't worth considering.
** Klatuu's people deserve extra stupidity points as well. Consider that their entire motivation for destroying humanity is to preserve the non-human portions of Earth's biosphere. They then set their nanotech-based weapon on "Dissolve Everything", ''including rocks and trees!'' In the immortal words of Creator/RobertAsprin, "Very inferior as superior beings go."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HumanAliens: Justified, as Klaatu's human form was grown to interact with humans and survive in their environment.

to:

* HumanAliens: Justified, as Averted. Klaatu's human form was is just [[AFormYouAreComfortableWith a suit]], grown to interact with humans and survive in their environment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





* AliensAreBastards: The aliens are committing genocide against a sentient race to protect a planet which is in no appreciable danger. Even if we wipe ''ourselves'' out, life will go on, and [=CO2=] and methane scrubbing bacteria and plants will come in and clean up after us. At best, they're concerned about the other, non-sentient species of life on Earth going extinct from humanity's actions... but we’ll either kill ourselves off or wise up before too long - again, life will go on, whether we’re here or not. But even so, their plan is to just kill all humans flat out instead of just giving them more eco-friendly technology.

to:

* AliensAreBastards: The aliens are committing genocide against a sentient race to protect a planet which is in no appreciable danger. Even if we wipe ''ourselves'' out, life will go on, and [=CO2=] and methane scrubbing bacteria and plants will come in and clean up after us. At best, they're concerned about the other, non-sentient species of life on Earth going extinct from humanity's actions... but we’ll we'll either kill ourselves off or wise up before too long - again, life will go on, whether we’re we're here or not. But even so, their plan is to just kill all humans flat out instead of just giving them more eco-friendly technology.



* ArtisticLicense: For the EMP at the end. Realistically speaking, an EMP would not be able to disable all electrical systems on earth. Many military systems are already heavily shielded to withstand an emp and many more also use analog technology.

to:

* ArtisticLicense: For the EMP at the end. Realistically speaking, an EMP would not be able to disable all electrical systems on earth. Earth. Many military systems are already heavily shielded to withstand an emp EMP and many more also use analog technology.



* BrokenAesop: We're destroying the other species on our planet, and aliens think that's bad. Fine. So why does Helen's love for Jacob change Klaatu's mind? A mother's love for a child of her own species, while charming, doesn't really show anything except a desire to perpetuate her species. It'd be more valid if she showed love for an animal, perhaps something [[WhatMeasureIsANonCute completely dissimilar to humans.]] Instead, ThePowerOfLove conquers all. Perhaps it's the fact that Jacob is her husband's biological son and not hers?

to:

* BrokenAesop: We're destroying the other species on our planet, and aliens think that's bad. Fine. So why does Helen's love for Jacob change Klaatu's mind? A mother's love for a child of her own species, while charming, doesn't really show anything except a desire to perpetuate her species. It'd be more valid if she showed love for an animal, perhaps something [[WhatMeasureIsANonCute completely dissimilar to humans.]] humans]]. Instead, ThePowerOfLove conquers all. Perhaps it's the fact that Jacob is her husband's biological son and not hers?



* CyberCyclops: Gort has a single glowing red eye behind the visor — there's a good moment when one of the characters realises the eye is following him as he walks across the room.

to:

* CyberCyclops: Gort has a single glowing red eye behind the visor — there's a good moment when one of the characters realises realizes the eye is following him as he walks across the room.



* HealingPotion: Klaatu applies a salve that instantly heals his bullet wound; an added CallBack detail from the 1951 film.

to:

* HealingPotion: Klaatu applies a salve from his suit that instantly heals his bullet wound; an added CallBack detail from the 1951 film.



* StarfishAliens: Klaatu noted that he was assuming AFormYouAreComfortableWith to interact with the humans. Upon being asked by the heroine what his true form was, he refused, stating, "[[YouCannotGraspTheTrueForm It would only frighten you]]".

to:

* StarfishAliens: Klaatu noted that he was assuming AFormYouAreComfortableWith to interact with the humans. Upon being asked by the heroine Helen what his true form was, he refused, stating, "[[YouCannotGraspTheTrueForm It would only frighten you]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TechnologyErasureEvent: Klaatu permanently disables all ability to generate electricity on Earth to prevent damage to its ecosystem.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoEndorHolocaust: The movie ends with Klaatu causing his ship to emit a massive EMP wave that shuts down all the GORT nanites. It also shuts down every piece of technology on the planet, even things that should not be [[ArtisticLicense Affected by EMP]], such as analog watches. This means millions dead in hospitals, planes falling out of the sky, no way to get food or water to starving masses, etc. And billions of dead silicon-based nanites covering the landscape. Good luck making use of that land. Yes, Klaatu mentions our way of life will have to change. He just didn't mention most of us would die, while he happily flies off home, mission complete. Bear in mind that in the original movie, Klaatu selectively applies his pulse such that said hospitals, planes, etc. are unaffected, in order to cause as little harm as possible. It is possible that was his intention. Reduce the human population, take away our ability to mess up our planet. Perhaps, as he may have reasoned, this might give us the chance to start over, be more green, especially with less mouths to feed. He did tell Helen that saving Humanity "Would have a price".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TechnologyErasureEvent: Klaatu permanently disables all ability to generate electricity on Earth to prevent damage to its ecosystem.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BackFromTheDead: Klaatu kills a cop threatening him then uses some of the goo from his suit and the charge from the cop car's battery to heal and revive him. Jacob tries to get him to do the same with his dead father later, but that is beyond Klaatu's power.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Attackbackfire: Every attack on the nanite swarm only increases its size and spread.

to:

* Attackbackfire: AttackBackfire: Every attack on the nanite swarm only increases its size and spread.



* BrownNote: Both Klaatu and GORT demonstrate the ability to create debilitating sound.

to:

* BrownNote: Both Klaatu and GORT demonstrate the ability to create debilitating sound.sound in earpieces, disabling or knocking out their foes.

Added: 222

Changed: 615

Removed: 144

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Attackbackfire: Every attack on the nanite swarm only increases its size and spread.



* BrownNote: Both Klaatu and GORT demonstrate the ability to create debilitating sound.



* GreyGoo: How GORT was going to wipe out humanity.

to:

* GreyGoo: How GORT was going to wipe out humanity.humanity, dissolving into a cloud of nanites that devour everything in their path.



* HumanAliens: Justified, as Klaatu was tailor-made to interact with humans.

to:

* HumanAliens: Justified, as Klaatu Klaatu's human form was tailor-made grown to interact with humans.humans and survive in their environment.



* ScaryDogmaticAliens: The aliens are depicted as ecoterrorists, who want to wipe out human civilization and infrastructure to preserve the biosphere. Klaatu ended up with a [[RestoredMyFaithInHumanity change of heart]], but before that his mission was not to warn anyone, but to skip straight to the EXTERMINATE-part.
** He did try to speak with Earth's leaders, but as in the original the U.S. government decides they'd rather play it private and with hardball.

to:

* ScaryDogmaticAliens: The aliens are depicted as ecoterrorists, who want to wipe out human civilization and infrastructure to preserve the biosphere. Klaatu ended up with a [[RestoredMyFaithInHumanity change of heart]], but before that his mission was not to warn anyone, but to skip straight to the EXTERMINATE-part.
**
EXTERMINATE-part. He did try to speak with Earth's leaders, but as in the original the U.S. government decides they'd rather play it private and with hardball.



* TheSwarm: The metal insects that comprise Gort.



* TheSwarm: The metal insects that comprise Gort.

to:

* TheSwarm: The metal insects that comprise Gort.{{Technopath}}: Klaatu can remotely operate virtually any technology, such as tapping into the security cameras in the base to plan his escape or knocking out two attack helicopters with a gesture.



* YouWontFeelAThing: Speaking about [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt the end of the human race]], Klaatu says "the pain will only be momentary."

to:

* YouWontFeelAThing: Speaking to a cop he's about [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt the end of the human race]], to (temporarily) kill, Klaatu says "the pain will only be momentary."
momentary" before ramming him with a car and killing him almost instantly.

Added: 198

Changed: 305

Removed: 310

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KillItWithFire: The containment chamber being used to study GORT has a flash protocol that superheats the room to kill anything inside that might breach containment. It utterly fails to harm GORT.



* NoEndorHolocaust: The movie ends with Klaatu causing his ship to emit a massive EMP wave that shuts down all the GORT nanites. It also shuts down every piece of technology on the planet, even things that should not be [[ArtisticLicense Affected by EMP]], such as analog watches. This means millions dead in hospitals, planes falling out of the sky, no way to get food or water to starving masses, etc. And billions of dead silicon-based nanites covering the landscape. Good luck making use of that land. Yes, Klaatu mentions our way of life will have to change. He just didn't mention most of us would die, while he happily flies off home, mission complete. Bear in mind that in the original movie, Klaatu selectively applies his pulse such that said hospitals, planes, etc. are unaffected, in order to cause as little harm as possible.
** It is possible that was his intention. Reduce the human population, take away our ability to mess up our planet. Perhaps, as he may have reasoned, this might give us the chance to start over, be more green, especially with less mouths to feed.
*** He did tell Helen that saving Humanity "Would have a price".

to:

* NoEndorHolocaust: The movie ends with Klaatu causing his ship to emit a massive EMP wave that shuts down all the GORT nanites. It also shuts down every piece of technology on the planet, even things that should not be [[ArtisticLicense Affected by EMP]], such as analog watches. This means millions dead in hospitals, planes falling out of the sky, no way to get food or water to starving masses, etc. And billions of dead silicon-based nanites covering the landscape. Good luck making use of that land. Yes, Klaatu mentions our way of life will have to change. He just didn't mention most of us would die, while he happily flies off home, mission complete. Bear in mind that in the original movie, Klaatu selectively applies his pulse such that said hospitals, planes, etc. are unaffected, in order to cause as little harm as possible.
**
possible. It is possible that was his intention. Reduce the human population, take away our ability to mess up our planet. Perhaps, as he may have reasoned, this might give us the chance to start over, be more green, especially with less mouths to feed. \n*** He did tell Helen that saving Humanity "Would have a price".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AliensAreBastards: The aliens are committing genocide against a sentient race to protect a planet which is in no appreciable danger. Even if we wipe ourselves out life will go on, and [=CO2=] and methane scrubbing bacteria and plants will come in and clean up after us. At best, they're concerned about the other, non-sentient species of life on Earth going extinct from humanity's actions... but we’ll either kill ourselves off or wise up before too long - again, life will go on, whether we’re here or not. But even so, their plan is to just kill all humans flat out instead of just giving them more eco-friendly technology.

to:

* AliensAreBastards: The aliens are committing genocide against a sentient race to protect a planet which is in no appreciable danger. Even if we wipe ourselves out ''ourselves'' out, life will go on, and [=CO2=] and methane scrubbing bacteria and plants will come in and clean up after us. At best, they're concerned about the other, non-sentient species of life on Earth going extinct from humanity's actions... but we’ll either kill ourselves off or wise up before too long - again, life will go on, whether we’re here or not. But even so, their plan is to just kill all humans flat out instead of just giving them more eco-friendly technology.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
add1

Added DiffLines:

* EurekaMoment:
** When the Secretary of Defense (Creator/KathyBates) figures out that the alien spheres are collecting animals from all over the world:
--->'''Secretary Of Defense:''' It's [[Literature/BookOfGenesis an Ark]]; they're saving as many species as they can.\\
'''Agent:''' But if that's an Ark, then what comes next is...\\
'''Secretary Of Defense:''' ''[[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt The Flood]].''
** Helen gets one as well, when she finally pieces together Klaatu's true intentions: "You came to save the Earth. ''[[HumansAreTheRealMonsters From us]]''."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FantasticallyChallengingPatient: When Klaatu is shot by a panicked soldier, a group of doctors perform surgery, and remove the bullet, then Klaatu himself uses a salve to quickly heal the wound.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UncannyValley: Used deliberately with Klaatu. He has little or no texture on his face, and Keanu pulls off the role of an alien learning human behavior and getting it just close enough (but not perfect) to be unsettling brilliantly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoEndorHolocaust: The movie ends with Klaatu causing his ship to emit a massive EMP wave that shuts down all the GORT nanites. It also shuts down every piece of technology on the planet, even things that should not be affected by EMP, such as analog watches. This means millions dead in hospitals, planes falling out of the sky, no way to get food or water to starving masses, etc. And billions of dead silicon-based nanites covering the landscape. Good luck making use of that land. Yes, Klaatu mentions our way of life will have to change. He just didn't mention most of us would die, while he happily flies off home, mission complete. Bear in mind that in the original movie, Klaatu selectively applies his pulse such that said hospitals, planes, etc. are unaffected, in order to cause as little harm as possible.

to:

* NoEndorHolocaust: The movie ends with Klaatu causing his ship to emit a massive EMP wave that shuts down all the GORT nanites. It also shuts down every piece of technology on the planet, even things that should not be affected [[ArtisticLicense Affected by EMP, EMP]], such as analog watches. This means millions dead in hospitals, planes falling out of the sky, no way to get food or water to starving masses, etc. And billions of dead silicon-based nanites covering the landscape. Good luck making use of that land. Yes, Klaatu mentions our way of life will have to change. He just didn't mention most of us would die, while he happily flies off home, mission complete. Bear in mind that in the original movie, Klaatu selectively applies his pulse such that said hospitals, planes, etc. are unaffected, in order to cause as little harm as possible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Artistic LicenseEmp: realistically speaking, an EMP would not be able to disable all electrical systems on earth. Many military systems are already heavily shielded to withstand an emp and many more also use analog technology.

to:

* Artistic LicenseEmp: realistically ArtisticLicense: For the EMP at the end. Realistically speaking, an EMP would not be able to disable all electrical systems on earth. Many military systems are already heavily shielded to withstand an emp and many more also use analog technology.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added an artistic license.

Added DiffLines:

*Artistic LicenseEmp: realistically speaking, an EMP would not be able to disable all electrical systems on earth. Many military systems are already heavily shielded to withstand an emp and many more also use analog technology.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is the same kind of problem that led to Needs Wiki Magic Love being PRLC'd and moved to Pages Needing Wiki Magic; you're not supposed to pothole these in descriptions.


Administrivia/NeedsABetterDescription.

Top