Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / JulieAndJulia

Go To

OR

Added: 886

Changed: 439

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Louisette is less a villain than a minor hinderance, but the film paints her in a very bad light, implying that she did far less work on the cookbook than the other two. This was entirely invented for the film. Louisette Bertholle was going through a nasty divorce in the middle of writing and her ability to contribute suffered because of it, but there's no indication that Julia or Simone held this against her or confronted her over it.

to:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: HistoricalVillainUpgrade:
**
Louisette is less a villain than a minor hinderance, but the film paints her in a very bad light, implying that she did far less work on the cookbook than the other two. This was entirely invented for the film. Louisette Bertholle was going through a nasty divorce in the middle of writing and her ability to contribute suffered because of it, but there's no indication that Julia or Simone held this against her or confronted her over it.it.
** Madame Brassart is the most overtly villainous character in the film, and the shared animosity between her and Julia was absolutely true to life and as depicted in ''My Life in France''; however Tim and Nina Zagat, who knew both women personally, came to Brassart's defense and pointed out that the friction between the two women (who could, after all, scarcely be more different from one another) was simply due to a clash of personalities.

Added: 523

Changed: 690

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
ZCEs, improper indentations, new example, minor edits


The other story is about Julia Child herself (played by the great Creator/MerylStreep) and how she came to (help) write that cookbook and become a great cook. We meet her in the beginning of the film in the late 1940s, when she moves to Paris. She is the life of the party, so exuberant that most people love her despite her impropriety, which is good because she is married to a diplomat. Since the wives of diplomats are rarely required to do anything, Julia knows she needs to do something to keep from going crazy. After unsuccessful (as in unenjoyable) attempts at hatmaking and learning to play bridge, she decides to take a cooking class at Le Cordon Bleu. On determining that she already knows what the cooking course is attempting to teach her, she asks the woman running the place (one of the few people who dislike her, and the feeling becomes mutual) if there is anything more advanced. There is--the course for professional chefs. So Julia takes that one and loves it...

to:

The other story is about Julia Child herself (played by the great Creator/MerylStreep) and how she came to (help) write that cookbook and become a great cook. We meet her in the beginning of the film in the late 1940s, when she moves to Paris. She is the life of the party, so exuberant that most people love her despite her impropriety, which is good because she is married to a diplomat. Since the wives of diplomats are rarely required to do anything, Julia knows she needs to do something to keep from going crazy. After unsuccessful (as in unenjoyable) attempts at hatmaking hat making and learning to play bridge, she decides to take a cooking class at Le Cordon Bleu. On determining that she already knows what the cooking course is attempting to teach her, she asks the woman running the place (one of the few people who dislike her, and the feeling becomes mutual) if there is anything more advanced. There is--the course for professional chefs. So Julia takes that one and loves it...



* LovingAShadow: In the platonic sense.

to:

* %%* LovingAShadow: In the platonic sense.



* RedScare: This ends up causing problems for Paul and Julia.

to:

* %%* RedScare: This ends up causing problems for Paul and Julia.



* TinyGuyHugeGirl: Julia is 6'2"; Paul is around 5'8". Also, [[spoiler:Julia's sister Dorothy and her future husband.]]

to:

* TinyGuyHugeGirl: Julia is 6'2"; Paul is around 5'8". Also, [[spoiler:Julia's sister Dorothy and is much taller than her future husband.]]



* UglyGuyHotWife: When Julia's sister comes to visit, Julia intends on setting her up with a tall, dark and handsome colleague of her husband. Instead, the sister is seen getting flirty with a short, smarmy-looking friend of theirs who makes her laugh. [[spoiler:They eventually marry and have a family]].

to:

* UglyGuyHotWife: UnreliableVoiceover: Julia narrates a letter as she's writing it to a friend, mentioning that Paul comes home for lunch every day and then takes a nap before going back to work. What's being shown, however, is him getting re-dressed while she reclines against the headboard with a ModestyBedsheet.
* UglyGuyHotWife:
**
When Julia's sister comes to visit, Julia intends on setting her up with a tall, dark and handsome colleague of her husband. Instead, the sister is seen getting flirty with a short, smarmy-looking friend of theirs who makes her laugh. [[spoiler:They eventually marry and have a family]].



* VitriolicBestBuds: Julia and Simca, who ultimately parted ways over ''Mastering'' volume 3 (which was eventually published as ''Simca's Cuisine'', without Julia's collaboration). They did remain friends but never collaborated again.

to:

* VitriolicBestBuds: VitriolicBestBuds:
**
Julia and Simca, who ultimately parted ways over ''Mastering'' volume 3 (which was eventually published as ''Simca's Cuisine'', without Julia's collaboration). They did remain friends but never collaborated again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Eric is nothing but kind and supportive of Julie, giving encouragement and actively helping her-- and then it gets not so much subverted as shown to be the top layer of his HiddenDepths when Julie's efforts to complete the challenge make her obsessed with her blog, and Eric refuses to be an ExtremeDoormat as it consumes their relationship. He draws the line after a fight asking that she not talk about the fight in her blog and storms out. Julie sincerely calling him "a saint" becomes a sore spot, as he feels it invalidates his concerns and negative feelings. Part of their reconciliation involves her substituting "saint" when he helps her for "horrible, and difficult to live with".

to:

** Eric is nothing but kind and supportive of Julie, giving encouragement and actively helping her-- and then it gets not so much subverted as shown to be the top layer of his HiddenDepths when Julie's efforts to complete the challenge make her obsessed with her blog, and Eric refuses to be an ExtremeDoormat as it consumes their relationship. He draws the line after a fight asking that she not talk about the fight in her blog and storms out. Julie sincerely calling him "a saint" becomes a sore spot, as he feels it invalidates his concerns and negative feelings. Part of their reconciliation involves her substituting calling him "saint" when he helps her for "horrible, and difficult to live with".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Eric is nothing but kind and supportive of Julie, giving encouragement and actively helping her-- and then it gets not so much subverted as shown to be the top layer of his HiddenDepths when Julie's efforts to complete the challenge make her obsessed with her blog, and Eric refuses to be an ExtremeDoormat as it consumes their relationship. He draws the line after a fight asking that she not talk about the fight in her blog and storms out. Julie sincerely calling him "a saint" becomes a sore spot, as he feels it invalidates his concerns and negative feelings. Part of their reconciliation involves her substituting "saint" when he helps her for "horrible, and difficult to live with".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HappilyMarried: Julia and Paul, very much so despite never being able to have children. Julie and Eric... yes and no (see FunnyAneurysmMoment under the YMMV tag).

to:

* HappilyMarried: Julia and Paul, very much so despite never being able to have children. Julie and Eric... yes and no (see FunnyAneurysmMoment under the YMMV tag).no.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Blog}}

to:

* {{Blog}}{{Blog}}: Blogging was a relatively new phenomenon at the time the modern half of the film is set, as can be seen in the details. For example, while it's common practice now to put a donation link on one's personal site, Julie is hesitant to monetize her blog, thinking it will make her look like she's just doing this for the money.



* ASimplePlan

to:

* ASimplePlanASimplePlan: All Julie wants to do is cook her way through Julia Child's book in order to prove to herself she can finish a project. It ends up taking over her life and threatening both her marriage and her husband's hyperacidic stomach.

Added: 467

Removed: 463

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalVillainy: Louisette is less a villain than a minor hinderance, but the film paints her in a very bad light, implying that she did far less work on the cookbook than the other two. This was entirely invented for the film. Louisette Bertholle was going through a nasty divorce in the middle of writing and her ability to contribute suffered because of it, but there's no indication that Julia or Simone held this against her or confronted her over it.


Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Louisette is less a villain than a minor hinderance, but the film paints her in a very bad light, implying that she did far less work on the cookbook than the other two. This was entirely invented for the film. Louisette Bertholle was going through a nasty divorce in the middle of writing and her ability to contribute suffered because of it, but there's no indication that Julia or Simone held this against her or confronted her over it.

Added: 1057

Changed: 177

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalVillainy: Louisette is less a villain than a minor hinderance, but the film paints her in a very bad light, implying that she did far less work on the cookbook than the other two. This was entirely invented for the film. Louisette Bertholle was going through a nasty divorce in the middle of writing and her ability to contribute suffered because of it, but there's no indication that Julia or Simone held this against her or confronted her over it.



* {{Foreshadowing}}: Paul and Julia are walking through a park where they pass a couple pushing a baby carriage - Julia watches them sadly and Paul pats her hand tenderly. See HappilyMarried below.

to:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: {{Foreshadowing}}:
** During the Valentine's dinner, one of the guests ask if Julia and Paul were spies during the war. Both of them deny this. When the Childs' records were unsealed in 2008, it came to light that Julia really was a top-secret researcher. The filmmakers elected to go with only facts that were established in 2002, when the modern half of the film was set, but added the conversation to hint at the later revelation.
**
Paul and Julia are walking through a park where they pass a couple pushing a baby carriage - Julia watches them sadly and Paul pats her hand tenderly. See HappilyMarried below.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LawOfInverseFertility: When her sister Dorothy writes to tell Julia of her pregnancy, Julia tries her best to be happy for her, but ends up crying on her husband's shoulder. Julia desperately wanted children, but didn't marry until she was 34 and found herself unable to conceive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


One story is about Julie Powell (played by Creator/AmyAdams). Julie is a government worker and unsuccessful writer who has just moved from Brooklyn to a depressing part of Queens for a larger apartment (relatively speaking) and to be closer to her husband's place of work. Her work is depressing -- the year is 2002, and she is dealing with a lot of calls related to the 9/11 attacks. When she learns that one of her friends, who she considers vapid, is writing a blog, she decides to write one herself. She and her husband discuss what it should be about, because it is supposed to be a distraction from her depressing life. They finally decide it should be about cooking. She has a copy of Creator/JuliaChild's cookbook ''Mastering the Art of French Cooking'' and so she decides to cook every recipe in it in one year (please note that there are [[{{Doorstopper}} over five hundred recipes]] included in it). This, even though she has a husband, a job, and a cat, and is only home in the late evening, quickly becomes an obsession.

to:

One story is about Julie Powell (played by Creator/AmyAdams). Julie is a government worker and unsuccessful writer who has just moved from Brooklyn to a depressing part of Queens for a larger apartment (relatively speaking) and to be closer to her husband's place of work. Her work is depressing -- the year is 2002, and she is dealing with a lot of calls related to the 9/11 attacks. When she Julie learns that one of her friends, who she considers vapid, is writing a blog, she decides to write one herself. She and her husband discuss what it should be about, because it is supposed to be a distraction from her depressing life. They finally decide it should be about cooking. She has a copy of Creator/JuliaChild's cookbook ''Mastering the Art of French Cooking'' and so she decides to cook every recipe in it in one year (please note that there are [[{{Doorstopper}} over five hundred recipes]] included in it). This, even though she has a husband, a job, and a cat, and is only home in the late evening, quickly becomes an obsession.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


One story is about Julie Powell (played by Creator/AmyAdams). Julie is a government worker and unsuccessful writer who has just moved from Brooklyn to a depressing part of Queens for a larger apartment (relatively speaking) and to be closer to her husband's place of work. Her work is depressing -- the year is 2002, and she is dealing with a lot of calls related to 9/11. When she learns that one of her friends, one she considers vapid, is writing a blog, she wants to write one herself. She and her husband discuss what it should be about, because it is supposed to be a distraction from her depressing life. They finally decide it should be about cooking. She has a copy of Creator/JuliaChild's cookbook ''Mastering the Art of French Cooking'' and so she decides to cook every recipe in it in one year (please note that there are [[{{Doorstopper}} over five hundred recipes]] included in it). This, even though she has a husband, a job, and a cat, and is only home in the late evening, quickly becomes an obsession.

to:

One story is about Julie Powell (played by Creator/AmyAdams). Julie is a government worker and unsuccessful writer who has just moved from Brooklyn to a depressing part of Queens for a larger apartment (relatively speaking) and to be closer to her husband's place of work. Her work is depressing -- the year is 2002, and she is dealing with a lot of calls related to 9/11. the 9/11 attacks. When she learns that one of her friends, one who she considers vapid, is writing a blog, she wants decides to write one herself. She and her husband discuss what it should be about, because it is supposed to be a distraction from her depressing life. They finally decide it should be about cooking. She has a copy of Creator/JuliaChild's cookbook ''Mastering the Art of French Cooking'' and so she decides to cook every recipe in it in one year (please note that there are [[{{Doorstopper}} over five hundred recipes]] included in it). This, even though she has a husband, a job, and a cat, and is only home in the late evening, quickly becomes an obsession.

Top