Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / GoyoAngBatangHeneral

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Demythification}}: Compared to how his life is generally taught in schools (to the extent it is) and how previous Filipino movies have portrayed him, the film goes for a WartsAndAll approach and avoids putting him on a pedestal. This goes all the way to the moment of his death. Previous films showed the more romantic image of him being [[DefiantToTheEnd shot on horseback, saber upraised, charging at the foe]] (and the 1990s version even had him as pretty much the last man standing), which ultimately comes from an American newspaperman's account. This film follows eyewitness accounts from his own soldiers (including a Spaniard, [[ShownTheirWork identifiable]] in the film because he's called by name and only speaks Spanish) who said he was sniped rather suddenly and unceremoniously while standing on the ground, and this leads to a panicked retreat by his men.

to:

* {{Demythification}}: Compared to how his life is generally taught in schools (to the extent it is) and how previous Filipino movies have portrayed him, the film goes for a WartsAndAll approach and avoids putting him on a pedestal. This goes all the way to the moment of his death. Previous films showed the more romantic image of him being [[DefiantToTheEnd shot on horseback, saber upraised, charging at the foe]] (and the 1990s version even had him as pretty much the last man standing), which ultimately comes from an American newspaperman's account. This film follows eyewitness accounts from his own soldiers (including a Spaniard, [[ShownTheirWork identifiable]] in the film because he's called by name and only speaks Spanish) who said he was sniped rather suddenly and unceremoniously while standing on the ground, and this leads to a panicked retreat by his men. Some contemporary Filipino historians thus say the first version of his death was myth-making in action, and the second version should be given precedence, judging his own soldiers as closer, more reliable sources than the American journalist who could have spiced up his story to sell better. But historically the first version is the one most taught in schools and known in Filipino pop culture, and most illustrations, statues etc. of him are on horseback, naturally recalling this version of his death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Since Goyo is a ladies' man reputed to have a paramour in every town, some gossiping women say that his woo-and-run ways have led to the slang "nagoyo" (duped or fooled). In reality the Filipino verb "goyo" (to dupe/fool) and its derivatives "nagoyo", "manggogoyo" (deceiver), etc. is of unclear origin.

Added: 1019

Changed: 61

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeroicBSOD: Goyo suffers from some shell shock that seems to have started from when he got a grazing head wound from a previous battle, though he's also haunted by Bernal's accusations. It leads him to accosting a senile old man and nearly drowning in a stream.

to:

* HeroicBSOD: Goyo suffers from some shell shock that seems to have started from when he got a grazing head wound from a previous battle, battle years ago in the revolution against Spain, though he's also haunted by Bernal's accusations. It leads him to accosting a senile old man and nearly drowning in a stream.



* InformedAbility: While Del Pilar can handle himself and his men in a fight, his reputation as an outstanding heroic soldier and commander is largely spoken of but not really backed up by onscreen events, due to his deeds which made his reputation, eventually leading to his high rank and getting Aguinaldo's favor, all happening before the movie's timeframe when the Filipinos were rebelling against Spanish rule, and due to the Filipinos constantly getting their asses kicked by the Americans at present. In a flashback to one of his earlier battles against the Spanish forces, the Filipino rebels are already beaten and in panicked retreat. The movie [[TropesAreTools uses the contrast]] between his reputation and what's only shown onscreen by having Goyo be haunted by self-doubt until he gets a handle on himself by the end and resolves to embrace his role as "the hero"... then he's unexpectedly and immediately killed without truly living up to it further, [[DyingMomentOfAwesome at least in cinematic terms.]]



* NegatedMomentOfAwesome: Goyo's death. Immediately prior, he quietly stares off into the distance during a relative lull in the battle, self-reflects and resolves to do his duty and live up to his reputation, one of his men hands him a rifle, he does a DramaticGunCock while striding away with HeroicResolve and saying what would otherwise have been a PreAsskickingOneLiner--then [[KilledMidSentence BANG.]]

to:

* NegatedMomentOfAwesome: Goyo's death. Immediately prior, he quietly stares off into the distance during a relative lull in the battle, self-reflects and resolves to do his duty and live up to his reputation, one of his men hands him a rifle, he does a DramaticGunCock while striding away with HeroicResolve and saying what would otherwise have been a PreAsskickingOneLiner--then [[KilledMidSentence BANG.]]

Added: 809

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PrecisionFStrike: There is less swearing compared to the previous movie, mostly due to the lead figure not being a pottymouth, but there are still some zingers.
** Goyo lets out one "Putang-ina!" ("Whore-mother", but used more like "Fuck") when he notices another general is giving his troops formation orders during a parade, and he rides up and yells at him that only he can do that ("Where Gen. Del Pilar commands, you do not command!")
** ''[[OutOfCharacterMoment Aguinaldo]]'', usually quiet and reserved, angrily says "''‘Tang-ina, isang linggo na tayong ngumangata ng tubo!''" ("Fuck, we've been gnawing on sugarcane for a week!") after his wife had fallen sick and his men bring her that to eat, but since they're on the retreat deep in the mountains, they have little else in the way of food on hand.



* ShownTheirWork: The American soldiers at Tirad Pass are depicted as doing the [[UsefulNotes/AmericanCivilWar Rebel Yell.]] The unit in question, the 33rd Infantry Regiment of the United States Volunteers, was known as the "Texas Regiment" and so they were likely the sons, grandsons, etc. of former Condeferates.

to:

* ShownTheirWork: The American soldiers at Tirad Pass are depicted as doing the [[UsefulNotes/AmericanCivilWar Rebel Yell.]] The unit in question, the 33rd Infantry Regiment of the United States Volunteers, was known as the "Texas Regiment" and so they were likely the sons, grandsons, etc. of former Condeferates.Confederates.

Added: 408

Changed: 333

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KilledMidSentence: Goyo's last words in the movie, cut short by a gunshot, are ''"Tapusin na natin-- [ito]"'' ("Let's finish-- [this]" or "Let's get this over-- [with]"). Comes off as a NegatedMomentOfAwesome for him since immediately prior, he quietly stares off into the distance during a relative lull in the battle, self-reflects and resolves to do his duty and live up to his reputation, one of his men hands him a rifle, he does a DramaticGunCock while striding away with HeroicResolve, then BANG.

to:

* KilledMidSentence: Goyo's last words in the movie, cut short by a gunshot, are ''"Tapusin na natin-- [ito]"'' ("Let's finish-- [this]" or "Let's get this over-- [with]"). Comes off as a NegatedMomentOfAwesome for him since immediately prior, he quietly stares off into the distance during a relative lull in the battle, self-reflects and resolves to do his duty and live up to his reputation, one of his men hands him a rifle, he does a DramaticGunCock while striding away with HeroicResolve, then BANG.


Added DiffLines:

* NegatedMomentOfAwesome: Goyo's death. Immediately prior, he quietly stares off into the distance during a relative lull in the battle, self-reflects and resolves to do his duty and live up to his reputation, one of his men hands him a rifle, he does a DramaticGunCock while striding away with HeroicResolve and saying what would otherwise have been a PreAsskickingOneLiner--then [[KilledMidSentence BANG.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KilledMidSentence: Goyo's last words in the movie, cut short by a gunshot, are ''"Tapusin na natin-- [ito]"'' ("Let's finish-- [this]" or "Let's get this over-- [with]).

to:

* KilledMidSentence: Goyo's last words in the movie, cut short by a gunshot, are ''"Tapusin na natin-- [ito]"'' ("Let's finish-- [this]" or "Let's get this over-- [with]).[with]"). Comes off as a NegatedMomentOfAwesome for him since immediately prior, he quietly stares off into the distance during a relative lull in the battle, self-reflects and resolves to do his duty and live up to his reputation, one of his men hands him a rifle, he does a DramaticGunCock while striding away with HeroicResolve, then BANG.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KilledMidSentence: Goyo's last words in the movie, cut short by a gunshot, are ''"Tapusin na natin-- [ito]"'' ("Let's finish-- [this]" or "Let's get this over-- [with]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There are basically two conflicting versions of Del Pilar's death, and other movies have used the more romantic one from a journalist attached to the American soldiers at Tirad Pass, while this uses the less romantic, more banal one from his own soldiers who gave similar accounts to each other.

to:

** There are basically two conflicting versions of Del Pilar's death, and other movies have used the more romantic one from a journalist attached to the American soldiers at Tirad Pass, while this uses the less romantic, more banal even anticlimactic one from his own soldiers who gave similar accounts to each other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There are basically two conflicting versions of Del Pilar's death, and other movies have used the more romantic one from a journalist attached to the American soldiers at Tirad Pass, while this uses the less romantic, more banal one from his own soldiers who gave similar accounts.

to:

** There are basically two conflicting versions of Del Pilar's death, and other movies have used the more romantic one from a journalist attached to the American soldiers at Tirad Pass, while this uses the less romantic, more banal one from his own soldiers who gave similar accounts. accounts to each other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Continuing from the previous film, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was directly involved in bringing about Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''personally'' killed him, as clear "smoking gun" evidence about this has yet to be unearthed. What is certain is only that Luna was summoned to Aguinaldo's headquarters through telegraph, but the President was missing when he arrived and he was thus alone with Felipe Buencamino and Aguinaldo's presidential bodyguards (and this is all depicted in ''Heneral Luna''. At the very least, Aguinaldo can be taken to task for not punishing Luna's immediate killers. But the films take the definite stance that he was complicit, and the repercussions continue in this film, where another of his generals, Jose Alejandrino, is depicted as relentlessly prodding him about the issue - until he finally admits [[IDidWhatIHadToDo that it was for the Republic's sake, or so he thought.]] Alejandrino then relays this to Mabini in a letter, but after Mabini is captured by the Americans, the letter is left behind and lost to history.

to:

** Continuing from the previous film, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was directly involved in bringing about Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''personally'' killed him, as clear "smoking gun" evidence about this has yet to be unearthed. What is certain is only that Luna was summoned to Aguinaldo's headquarters through telegraph, but the President was missing when he arrived and he was thus alone with Felipe Buencamino and Aguinaldo's presidential bodyguards (and this is all depicted in ''Heneral Luna''.Luna''). At the very least, Aguinaldo can be taken to task for not punishing Luna's immediate killers. But the films take the definite stance that he was complicit, and the repercussions continue in this film, where another of his generals, Jose Alejandrino, is depicted as relentlessly prodding him about the issue - until he finally admits [[IDidWhatIHadToDo that it was for the Republic's sake, or so he thought.]] Alejandrino then relays this to Mabini in a letter, but after Mabini is captured by the Americans, the letter is left behind and lost to history.

Added: 315

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There are basically two conflicting versions of Del Pilar's death, and other movies have used the more romantic one from an journalist attached to the American soldiers at Tirad Pass, while this uses the less romantic, more banal one from his own soldiers who gave similar accounts.

to:

** There are basically two conflicting versions of Del Pilar's death, and other movies have used the more romantic one from an a journalist attached to the American soldiers at Tirad Pass, while this uses the less romantic, more banal one from his own soldiers who gave similar accounts.


Added DiffLines:

* ShownTheirWork: The American soldiers at Tirad Pass are depicted as doing the [[UsefulNotes/AmericanCivilWar Rebel Yell.]] The unit in question, the 33rd Infantry Regiment of the United States Volunteers, was known as the "Texas Regiment" and so they were likely the sons, grandsons, etc. of former Condeferates.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There are basically two conflicting versions of Del Pilar's death, and other movies have used the more romantic one from an journalist attached to the American soldiers at Tirad Pass, while this uses the less romantic, more banal one from his own soldiers who gave similar accounts.
** Continuing from the previous film, it is not actually clear (and may well never be) that Aguinaldo directly wanted or was directly involved in bringing about Luna's death, beyond command responsibility for the men who ''personally'' killed him, as clear "smoking gun" evidence about this has yet to be unearthed. What is certain is only that Luna was summoned to Aguinaldo's headquarters through telegraph, but the President was missing when he arrived and he was thus alone with Felipe Buencamino and Aguinaldo's presidential bodyguards (and this is all depicted in ''Heneral Luna''. At the very least, Aguinaldo can be taken to task for not punishing Luna's immediate killers. But the films take the definite stance that he was complicit, and the repercussions continue in this film, where another of his generals, Jose Alejandrino, is depicted as relentlessly prodding him about the issue - until he finally admits [[IDidWhatIHadToDo that it was for the Republic's sake, or so he thought.]] Alejandrino then relays this to Mabini in a letter, but after Mabini is captured by the Americans, the letter is left behind and lost to history.

Added: 408

Changed: 131

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnimalMotifs: Goyo is regularly referred as the Dog and the Eagle. The former is used to mock him for his UndyingLoyalty to Aguinaldo, while the latter is used to boost his morale.

to:

* AnimalMotifs: Goyo is regularly referred to as the Dog a dog and the Eagle.an eagle. The former is used to mock him for his UndyingLoyalty to Aguinaldo, while the latter is used to boost his morale.



* ArcWords: "Tandaan mo kung sino ka."[[note]]Translation: Remember who you are.[[/note]]

to:

* ArcWords: "Tandaan mo kung sino ka."[[note]]Translation: Remember who you are.[[/note]]"



** There are conflicting accounts and evidence about whom of two sisters Del Pilar courted, Dolores or Remedios Nable José. The movie goes with Remedios while a 1990s biopic titled ''Tirad Pass'' went with Dolores.

to:

** There are conflicting accounts and evidence about whom of two sisters Del Pilar courted, Dolores or Remedios Nable José. The movie goes with Remedios while a 1990s biopic titled ''Tirad Pass'' Pass: [[SpoilerTitle The Last Stand of Gen. Gregorio del Pilar]]'' went with Dolores.



* CasualDangerDialogue: The Americans make a few good quips while they're pinned at Tirad Pass, with Private Simmons telling his major that he could really use some company up the road and Lieutenant [=McClelland =] agreeing with the trooper next to him that he would indeed love some beer.

to:

* CasualDangerDialogue: The Americans make a few good quips while they're pinned at Tirad Pass, with Private Simmons telling his major that he could really use some company up the road and Lieutenant [=McClelland =] agreeing with the trooper next to him that he would indeed love some Pabst beer.


Added DiffLines:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: The lowlander Filipino soldiers look down on the highlander tribesmen whom they employ as porters, [[KickTheDog calling them monkeys]] ("unggoy") to their faces. This [[TheDogBitesBack bites them in the ass]] when a tribesman guides the Americans to higher ground at Tirad Pass in order to foil the Filipino defenses, rather like [[Film/ThreeHundred the Battle of Thermopylae.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There are conflicting accounts and evidence about whom of two sisters Del Pilar courted, Dolores or Remedios Nable José. The movie goes with the Remedios while a 1990s biopic titled ''Tirad Pass'' went with Dolores.

to:

** There are conflicting accounts and evidence about whom of two sisters Del Pilar courted, Dolores or Remedios Nable José. The movie goes with the Remedios while a 1990s biopic titled ''Tirad Pass'' went with Dolores.

Added: 218

Changed: 85

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArcWords: "Tandaan mo kung sino ka."
* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Lampshaded in the opening text, pointing out how the film is a mix of historical facts and fiction.

to:

* ArcWords: "Tandaan mo kung sino ka."
"[[note]]Translation: Remember who you are.[[/note]]
* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Lampshaded As with ''Heneral Luna'', this is lampshaded in the opening text, pointing out how the film is a mix of historical facts and fiction.fiction.
** There are conflicting accounts and evidence about whom of two sisters Del Pilar courted, Dolores or Remedios Nable José. The movie goes with the Remedios while a 1990s biopic titled ''Tirad Pass'' went with Dolores.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The trailer can be viewed [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QgQrbe5Xduk here]].

to:

The trailer can be viewed [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QgQrbe5Xduk here]].
here]]. Additionally, the short film ''[[https://web.archive.org/web/20180822225439/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DCBRjEuSQNw Angelito]]'', released for free on [=YouTube=], bridges ''Luna'' and ''Goyo''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removed from other article for misuse


* AmbiguouslyBrown: As with its predecessor, many of the characters are some form of mestizo, given how Filipinos generally tend to be mixed to various degrees.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* BasedOnATrueStory

to:

%%* BasedOnATrueStory* BasedOnATrueStory: The film is based on the final months of General Gregorio Del Pilar's life, up to and including his death at the Battle of Tirad Pass.

Added: 424

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BasedOnATrueStory

to:

* %%* BasedOnATrueStory


Added DiffLines:

* DownerEnding: [[spoiler:Del Pilar dies at the Battle of Tirad Pass as in history, and while Aguinaldo manages to escape, he eventually gets captured by American forces and is forced to give up the Philippines to the United States. Apolinario Mabini also gets captured by the Americans and is soon exiled to Guam.]]
* DroppedABridgeOnHim: Both Del Pilar and Lieutenant García are killed by snipers when they least expect it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Goyo: Ang Batang Heneral'', released September 5, 2018, is a historical biopic film starring Paulo Avelino as the titular Gregorio "Goyo" del Pilar, the youngest General during the Philippine–American War, who died in the Battle of Tirad Pass. It is written, directed, edited, and scored by Jerrold Tarog, and is the sequel to ''Film/HeneralLuna''.

to:

''Goyo: Ang Batang Heneral'', Heneral'' (Goyo: The Boy General), released September 5, 2018, is a historical biopic film starring Paulo Avelino as the titular Gregorio "Goyo" del Pilar, the youngest General during the Philippine–American War, who died in the Battle of Tirad Pass. It is written, directed, edited, and scored by Jerrold Tarog, and is the sequel to ''Film/HeneralLuna''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Famous Last Words is being dewicked


* FamousLastWords: "Tapusin na natin 'to--"[[BoomHeadshot BANG.]] ("Let's finish this--") What makes it ultimately tragic is that in any other context it would be a PreAsskickingOneLiner, and Del Pilar has just resolved to live up to his legend, casting aside any self-doubt.

Added: 201

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FacialHorror: Goyo was fatally shot on the left side of his jaw

to:

* FacialHorror: Goyo was fatally shot on the left side of his jawjaw.
* FamedInStory: Goyo is a celebrity for his earlier exploits in the Philippine Revolution, as well for his youth and ladykiller ways, and at one point he watches a play about himself held in his honor.

Added: 275

Changed: 10

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Demythification}}: Compared to how his life is generally taught in schools (to the extent it is) and how previous Filipino movies have portrayed him, the film goes for a WartsAndAll approach and avoids putting him on a pedestal. This goes all the way to the moment of his death. Previous films showed the more romantic image of him being [[DefiantToTheEnd shot on horseback, saber upraised, charging at the foe]] (and the 1990s version even had him as pretty much the last man standing), which ultimately comes from an American newspaperman's account. This film follows eyewitness accounts from his own soldiers (including a Spaniard, [[ShownTheirWork identifiable]] in the film because he's called by name and only speaks Spanish) who said he was sniped rather suddenly and unceremoniously while on the ground, and this leads to a panicked retreat by his men.

to:

* {{Demythification}}: Compared to how his life is generally taught in schools (to the extent it is) and how previous Filipino movies have portrayed him, the film goes for a WartsAndAll approach and avoids putting him on a pedestal. This goes all the way to the moment of his death. Previous films showed the more romantic image of him being [[DefiantToTheEnd shot on horseback, saber upraised, charging at the foe]] (and the 1990s version even had him as pretty much the last man standing), which ultimately comes from an American newspaperman's account. This film follows eyewitness accounts from his own soldiers (including a Spaniard, [[ShownTheirWork identifiable]] in the film because he's called by name and only speaks Spanish) who said he was sniped rather suddenly and unceremoniously while standing on the ground, and this leads to a panicked retreat by his men.



* FacialHorror: Goyo was fatally shot on the left side of his jaw.

to:

* FacialHorror: Goyo was fatally shot on the left side of his jaw.jaw
* FamousLastWords: "Tapusin na natin 'to--"[[BoomHeadshot BANG.]] ("Let's finish this--") What makes it ultimately tragic is that in any other context it would be a PreAsskickingOneLiner, and Del Pilar has just resolved to live up to his legend, casting aside any self-doubt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Demythification}}: Compared to how his life is generally taught in schools (to the extent it is) and how previous Filipino movies have portrayed him, the film goes for a WartsAndAll approach and avoids putting him on a pedestal. This goes all the way to the moment of his death. Previous films showed the more romantic image of him being [[DefiantToTheEnd shot on horseback, saber upraised, charging at the foe]] (and the 1990s version even had him as pretty much the last man standing), which ultimately comes from an American newspaperman's account. This film follows eyewitness accounts from his own soldiers (including a Spaniard, [[ShownTheirWork identifiable]] in the film because he's called by name and only speaks Spanish) who said he was sniped rather suddenly and unceremoniously while on the ground, and this leads to a panicked retreat by his men.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoryDiscretionShot: Whe the film never shies on the aforementioned {{Gorn}}, Manuel Bernal's execution is only audible with the scene showing Goyo hearing it just outside the torture chamber.

to:

* GoryDiscretionShot: Whe When the film never shies on the aforementioned {{Gorn}}, Manuel Bernal's execution is only audible with the scene showing Goyo hearing it just outside the torture chamber.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CurbStompBattle: Following Luna's death, the Filipinos are so badly outmatched that they lose ''every single battle'' against the Americans after. Not even able to wound or kill a single American in some of them.

to:

* CurbStompBattle: Following Not that they've performed particularly well prior but following Luna's death, the Filipinos are so badly outmatched that they lose ''every single battle'' against the Americans after. Not even able to wound or kill a single American in some of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Top