Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / FantasticBeastsTheSecretsOfDumbledore

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ButNotTooGay: The film finally confirms the past relationship between Dumbledore and Grindelwald onscreen after it was only hinted at in the previous movies. Unlike the heterosexual relationships in the series, there is never any physical interaction between them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ThickerThanWater: The defining trait of the brothers Dumbledore, despite everything they went through they stick together regardless, [[spoiler: and ultimately saving Credence from Grindelwald in the climax together.]]

to:

* ThickerThanWater: The defining trait of the brothers Dumbledore, despite everything they went through they stick together regardless, [[spoiler: and [[spoiler:and ultimately saving Credence from Grindelwald in the climax together.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Albus Dumbledore''': If you don't mind me saying, you should stop doubting yourself. You have something most men go their entire lives without. Do you know what that is? A heart that is full. Only a truly brave man could open himself up so honestly and completely as you do.

to:

-->'''Albus Dumbledore''': If One other thing, if you don't mind me saying, you saying. You should stop doubting yourself. You have something most men go their entire lives without. Do you know what that is? A heart that is full. Only a truly brave man man... could open himself up so honestly and completely as you do.
Willbyr MOD

Added: 256

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

%%


Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

* MenacingHandShot: Just before Credence confronts and then attacks Dumbledore in the street, the view behind him shifts to show him tightly gripping his wand in his right hand, a sign of his anger and pain toward Dumbledore for seemingly abandoning him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->'''Dumbledore:''' He's [[spoiler:your son]], Aberforth.

to:

--->'''Dumbledore:''' -->'''Dumbledore:''' He's [[spoiler:your son]], Aberforth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhamLine: Newt overhears Dumbledore talking to his brother, Aberforth, about Credence. This line is dropped, finally confirming who Credence really is.
--->'''Dumbledore:''' He's [[spoiler:your son]], Aberforth.

Added: 227

Removed: 220

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyDo: [[spoiler:The final scene of the movie is Jacob and Queenie getting married at the former's bakery, with Newt as best man, [[TheCameo Tina]] as maid of honor, and Theseus, Lally, and Bunty also in attendance.]]


Added DiffLines:

* WeddingFinale: [[spoiler:The final scene of the movie is Jacob and Queenie getting married at the former's bakery, with Newt as best man, [[TheCameo Tina]] as maid of honor, and Theseus, Lally, and Bunty also in attendance.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheyDo: [[spoiler:The final scene of the movie is Jacob and Queenie getting married at the former's bakery, with Newt as best man, [[TheCameo Tina]] as maid of honor, and Theseus, Lally, and Bunty also in attendance.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DarkHorseVictory: Subverted. [[spoiler:The first person that the real Qilin, who can sense the pure of heart, bows to at the election is Albus Dumbledore, who isn't even a candidate. However, since he doesn't trust himself in any kind of position of power, he tells her that he's honored but convinces her that there's another person present who's equally worthy. The Qilin subsequently bows to Vincencia Santos, who ''is'' one of the three candidates running, and she's subsequently elected Supreme Mugwump.]]

to:

* DarkHorseVictory: Subverted. [[spoiler:The first person that the real Qilin, who can sense the pure of heart, bows to at the election is Albus Dumbledore, who isn't even a candidate. However, since he doesn't trust himself in any kind of position of power, he tells her that he's honored but convinces her that there's another person present who's equally worthy. The Qilin subsequently bows to Vincencia Vicencia Santos, who ''is'' one of the three candidates running, and she's subsequently elected Supreme Mugwump.]]

Added: 512

Changed: 30

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DarkHorseVictory: Subverted. [[spoiler:The first person that the real Qilin, who can sense the pure of heart, bows to at the election is Albus Dumbledore, who isn't even a candidate. However, since he doesn't trust himself in any kind of position of power, he tells her that he's honored but convinces her that there's another person present who's equally worthy. The Qilin subsequently bows to Vincencia Santos, who ''is'' one of the three candidates running, and she's subsequently elected Supreme Mugwump.]]



* FaceDeathWithDignity: While he doesn't actually die, once Grindelwald "wins" the election and has Jacob brought before him to MakeAnExampleOfHim, it's very clear from the expressions on his, Queenie's, and Newt's faces that they're terrified he's about to be murdered on the spot by the dark wizard. Though Jacob is trembling, he tries to keep a StiffUpperLip and starts to raise his arms in a "BringIt" gesture while turning to face Grindelwald before being hit by a Cruciatus Curse instead.

to:

* FaceDeathWithDignity: While he doesn't actually die, once Grindelwald "wins" the election and has Jacob brought before him to MakeAnExampleOfHim, [[MakeAnExampleOfThem make an example of him]], it's very clear from the expressions on his, Queenie's, and Newt's faces that they're terrified he's about to be murdered on the spot by the dark wizard. Though Jacob is trembling, he tries to keep a StiffUpperLip and starts to raise his arms in a "BringIt" gesture while turning to face Grindelwald before being hit by a Cruciatus Curse instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ColdBloodedTorture: Grindelwald inflicts this on Jacob with the Cruciatus Curse to declare war on Muggles after winning the election. While poor Queenie and Newt, who've both been captured, are ForcedToWatch. Luckily, [[NiceGirl Santos]] quietly lifts the spell.


Added DiffLines:

* FaceDeathWithDignity: While he doesn't actually die, once Grindelwald "wins" the election and has Jacob brought before him to MakeAnExampleOfHim, it's very clear from the expressions on his, Queenie's, and Newt's faces that they're terrified he's about to be murdered on the spot by the dark wizard. Though Jacob is trembling, he tries to keep a StiffUpperLip and starts to raise his arms in a "BringIt" gesture while turning to face Grindelwald before being hit by a Cruciatus Curse instead.


Added DiffLines:

** After using the reanimated Qilin to win the election, Grindelwald decides to torture Jacob, the sole Muggle present whom he previously framed for trying to kill him, in front of the amassed crowd (which includes Jacob's lover Queenie and best friend Newt) for no real reason other than EvilIsPetty.


Added DiffLines:

* LittleNo: Newt, when captured and ForcedToWatch Grindelwald torture Jacob. The second one is less little.


Added DiffLines:

* MakeAnExampleOfThem: Grindelwald, who previously framed Jacob for trying to kill him, uses this pretense to torture him in front of the entire crowd at the election once the former has apparently won. It ultimately backfires on Grindelwald, though, since it turns Queenie against him for good, shows the world his true colors, and in the wake of his subsequent actions, turns all but his most die-hard supporters against him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* YouAreBetterThanYouThinkYouAre: Dumbledore to Jacob shortly before the climax of the movie:
-->'''Albus Dumbledore''': If you don't mind me saying, you should stop doubting yourself. You have something most men go their entire lives without. Do you know what that is? A heart that is full. Only a truly brave man could open himself up so honestly and completely as you do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Add note


* CameBackWrong: Grindelwald actually seems capable of returning the qilin to a life, or something imitating it. The ritual itself is dark and disturbing and the qilin seems weak, confused, and ill in the time after it. Whether it is undead or truly alive is never made clear, but it certainly did not return to our world as it once was.

to:

* CameBackWrong: Grindelwald actually seems capable of returning the qilin to a life, or something imitating it. The ritual itself is dark and disturbing and the qilin seems weak, confused, and ill in the time after it. Whether it is undead or truly alive is never made clear, but it certainly did not return to our world as it once was.[[note]]It is canon that Grindelwald had an interest in the undead, since Dumbledore asserted that he wanted the Resurrection Stone in order to gain an army of [[OurZombiesAreDifferent Inferi]].[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Minor edit


* SequelHook: While Grindelwald's plan to take control of the ICW [[spoiler:is foiled and Dumbledore's obligation to the blood oath to him is forfeited--meaning the two can now fight each other, Grindelwald still escapes and intends to find another means to force the Wizarding World to bow to his whim--which will continue for years until Dumbledore finally beats him, rids him of the Elder Wand and Grindelwald is sent to Azkaban for what will be the rest of his life]].

to:

* SequelHook: While Grindelwald's plan to take control of the ICW [[spoiler:is foiled and Dumbledore's obligation to the blood oath to him is forfeited--meaning the two can now fight each other, Grindelwald still escapes and intends to find another means to force the Wizarding World to bow to his whim--which will continue for years until Dumbledore finally beats him, rids him of the Elder Wand and Grindelwald is sent to Azkaban Nurmengard for what will be the rest of his life]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Minor edit.


* SequelHook: While Grindelwald's plan to take control of the ICW [[spoiler:is foiled and Dumbledore's obligation to the blood oath to him is forfeited--meaning the two can now fight each other, Grindelwald still escapes and intends to find another means to force the Wizarding World to bow to his whim--which will continue for years until Dumbledore finally beats him; rids him of the Elder Wand and Grindelwald is sent to Azkaban for what will be the rest of his life]].

to:

* SequelHook: While Grindelwald's plan to take control of the ICW [[spoiler:is foiled and Dumbledore's obligation to the blood oath to him is forfeited--meaning the two can now fight each other, Grindelwald still escapes and intends to find another means to force the Wizarding World to bow to his whim--which will continue for years until Dumbledore finally beats him; him, rids him of the Elder Wand and Grindelwald is sent to Azkaban for what will be the rest of his life]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SequelHook: While Grindelwald's plan to take control of the ICW [[spoiler:is foiled and Dumbledore's obligation to the blood oath to him is forfeited--meaning the two can now fight each other, Grindelwald still escapes and intends to find another means to force the Wizarding World to bow to his whim--which will continue for years until Dumbledore finally beats him; rids him of the Elder Wand and Grindelwald is sent to Azkaban for what will be the rest of his life]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
While this trope arguably does apply, the example was inaccurate as it's Grindelwald who says 'you're all alone,' not Dumbledore.


* ShipSinking: Dumbledore firmly and decisively abandons Grindelwald with a firm, "You're all alone."

to:

* ShipSinking: The breaking of the blood troth is both a symbolic and literal breaking up of Dumbledore firmly and decisively abandons Grindelwald with Grindelwald's relationship. Regardless of how they may still feel about each other, things have reached a firm, "You're all alone."tipping point and they can't go back.

Added: 2844

Changed: 1165

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CentralTheme: Love. While one could argue that this is the main theme of the Wizarding World at large, this installment really hammers it home. Love between romantic partners, siblings, friends, and parents and children all play a significant role in the film. Dumbledore and Grindelwald both are still madly in love with each other and over the course of the movie get driven apart for the final time over their political disagreements and Grindelwald's cruelty. Dumbledore's relationship with his siblings and regrets over not being there for them in the way he should have ([[spoiler:he tells Newt that if he'd been a better brother Aberforth might have confided in him about Credence]]) is a clear source of anguish but he does really try to patch things up with Aberforth and they do stick together in the end. Newt goes through hell to get Theseus out of the German prison and the two have clearly grown closer since the second film. Yusuf's motivated by his regret over not having been able to get to know Leta, his only family member. Ultimately [[spoiler:Aberforth's love for Credence]] is the thing that sets him on the right path, although it's too late to save him.

to:

* CentralTheme: CentralTheme:
**
Love. While one could argue that this is the main theme of the Wizarding World at large, this installment really hammers it home. Love between romantic partners, siblings, friends, and parents and children all play a significant role in the film. Dumbledore and Grindelwald both are still madly in love with each other and over the course of the movie get driven apart for the final time over their political disagreements and Grindelwald's cruelty. Dumbledore's relationship with his siblings and regrets over not being there for them in the way he should have ([[spoiler:he tells Newt that if he'd been a better brother Aberforth might have confided in him about Credence]]) lingering doubts that Credence survived]]) is a clear source of anguish but he does really try to patch things up with Aberforth and they do stick together in the end. Newt goes through hell to get Theseus out of the German prison and the two have clearly grown closer since the second film. Yusuf's motivated by his regret over not having been able to get to know Leta, his only family member. Ultimately [[spoiler:Aberforth's love for Credence]] is the thing that sets him on the right path, although it's too late to save him.
** Loneliness: The movie's central conflict, as noted by David Heyman, is between two men who are constantly surrounded by people but at the same time deeply lonely. Two men who could only find companionship in one another but were driven apart long ago by tragedy and still carry the scars. Their loneliness also presents itself differently. Albus's loneliness presents itself as shutting himself off and keeping it inside, such as not really letting anyone other than Aberforth and later on Newt in and keeping everyone else at a distance. Grindelwald's loneliness presents itself as lashing out. He thought the meeting at the restaurant was supposed to be friendly, he was absolutely ecstatic to see him after thirty years, judging by the way he flirts and beams (which is the only time he's ever truly smiled in the series). He takes the offer to break the troth personally, gets offended, and storms out. He also does things such as get out of the car to try to feel something outside the banquet. By the end, he's screaming and almost crying when he realizes he's really been dumped for good. While his "statement", "Who will love you now, Dumbledore? You're all alone!" can be interpreted in any number of ways, two popular takes are that he's saying, "We're both stuck like this because of you" and/or that it's meant to be taunting. Whatever way you view it, it's certainly done from a place of lashing out after getting dumped. Credence also mentions having been lonely his whole life. Newt via his CharacterDevelopment has gotten to a place where he's more open to people but this time it's Theseus's turn to be lonely due to Leta's death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JustToyingWithThem: Credence's fight with Dumbledore takes place entirely in an illusion Dumbledore traps him in as the opening move, and Dumbledore makes it clear even that was humoring Credence so he could blow off steam.

Added: 101

Changed: 40

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnguishedDeclarationOfLove: Grindelwald almost screams, “Who will love you now?” at Dumbledore as [[spoiler:the blood troth breaks]].

to:

* AnguishedDeclarationOfLove: Grindelwald almost screams, “Who will love you now?” now, Dumbledore?” at Dumbledore Albus as [[spoiler:the blood troth breaks]].



* HumiliationConga: It's Grindelwald's turn to lose after managing to so effectively manipulate the events of the first two movies to his favor. He loses hard, too. [[spoiler:He manages to lose the election, have two powerful Acolytes defect, get exposed for his true colors, lose his former lover forever, and be forced into hiding in one fell swoop. Albus pretty masterfully manages to use ConfusionFu to negate his seeing with the only hiccup being Theseus getting arrested. Grindelwald gets Vogel to pardon him of his crimes, get him on the ballot, and help him use the zombified Qilin to bow to him. Meanwhile, Bunty manages to slip by his group of supporters in Bhutan with the suitcase with the second Qilin because he mistakenly thought the more powerful Scamander brothers or Eulalie would have been given it. Queenie, whom he worked so hard to recruit, also defects before the election takes place. After a short respite of him winning the initial vote for Supreme Mugwump of the International Confederation of Wizards, Newt and Credence expose his fraudulent Qilin and Bunty walks up with the suitcase as the zombified one disanimates in Vogel's arms. A new vote is called. The Qilin first bows to Albus who turns her down and then to Santos, whom the crowd elects the new ICW Supreme Mugwump. At that point, Grindelwald completely loses it. He tries to kill Credence in front of everyone and the blood pact gets destroyed in the crossing of spells. As he and Albus fight to a draw in the mirror dimension, he desperately reaches for him as they part and Albus turns his back on him which signifies the breaking of their bond, both literally and metaphorically. With real pain in his voice, all he can do is lash out at him with, "Who will love you now, Dumbledore. You're all alone!" As everyone starts pointing their wands at him, all he can do (while being a visible wreck of emotions) is jump off the cliff and Apparate away.]] A far cry from the cocky, flirtatious, and smug demeanor seen at the beginning of the movie in the restaurant scene.

to:

* HumiliationConga: It's Grindelwald's turn to lose after managing to so effectively manipulate the events of the first two movies to his favor. He loses hard, too. [[spoiler:He manages to lose the election, have two powerful Acolytes defect, get exposed for his true colors, lose his former lover forever, and be forced into hiding in one fell swoop. Albus pretty masterfully manages to use ConfusionFu to negate his seeing with the only hiccup being Theseus getting arrested. Grindelwald gets Vogel to pardon him of his crimes, get him on the ballot, and help him use the zombified Qilin to bow to him. Meanwhile, Bunty manages to slip by his group of supporters in Bhutan with the suitcase with the second Qilin because he mistakenly thought the more powerful Scamander brothers or Eulalie would have been given it. Queenie, whom he worked so hard to recruit, also defects before the election takes place. After a short respite of him winning the initial vote for Supreme Mugwump of the International Confederation of Wizards, Newt and Credence expose his fraudulent Qilin and Bunty walks up with the suitcase as the zombified one disanimates in Vogel's arms. A new vote is called. The Qilin first bows to Albus who turns her down and then to Santos, whom the crowd elects the new ICW Supreme Mugwump. At that point, Grindelwald completely loses it. He tries to kill Credence in front of everyone and the blood pact gets destroyed in the crossing of spells. As he and Albus fight to a draw in the mirror dimension, he desperately reaches for him as they part and Albus turns his back on him which signifies the breaking of their bond, both literally and metaphorically. With real pain in his voice, all he can do is lash out at him with, "Who will love you now, Dumbledore. You're all alone!" Dumbledore?" As everyone starts pointing their wands at him, all he can do (while being a visible wreck of emotions) is jump off the cliff and Apparate away.]] A far cry from the cocky, flirtatious, and smug demeanor seen at the beginning of the movie in the restaurant scene.


Added DiffLines:

* ShipSinking: Dumbledore firmly and decisively abandons Grindelwald with a firm, "You're all alone."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WardensAreEvil: The warden in the Erkstag prison definitely fits the bill, as he seems to enjoy seeing people enter the prison and never come back out.

Added: 271

Changed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AssholeVictim: Though not shown on screen, the Erkstag warden's OhCrap face in his final scene means he's about to get skewered by the manticore, and seeing how much he enjoyed that happening to the prisoners he was supposed to be watching, it feels like a KarmicDeath.



* HellholePrison: The prison in Berlin is horrific, with inmates tied up and hanging upside down, with the possibility of being [[FedToTheBeast eaten]] by the temperamental manticore at the bottom of the prison.

to:

* HellholePrison: The Erkstag, the magical prison in Berlin Berlin, is horrific, with inmates tied up and hanging upside down, with the possibility of being [[FedToTheBeast eaten]] by the temperamental manticore at the bottom of the prison.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NeverTrustATrailer: The trailer shows Jacob getting a wand, implying he'll start doing magic, but in the movie it's just a fake wand to help blend in with wizards. It's unclear whether it has been enchanted to perform a single spell, or the whole thing was faked directly by Lalie, but Jacob has no control over that feature either way.

to:

* NeverTrustATrailer: The trailer shows Jacob getting a wand, implying he'll start doing magic, but in the movie it's just a fake wand to help blend in with wizards. It's unclear whether it has been enchanted to perform a single spell, or the whole thing was faked directly by Lalie, Lalie (given that it has no magical core, it's most likely the latter case), but Jacob has no control over that feature either way.



* PapaWolf: [[spoiler: Aberforth in the climax, along with Albus to save Credence.]]

to:

* PapaWolf: [[spoiler: Aberforth [[spoiler:Aberforth in the climax, along with Albus to save Credence.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VillainExitStageLeft: At the end of the film, [[spoiler:Grindelwald jumps off a cliff and flies away.]]

to:

* VillainExitStageLeft: At the end of the film, [[spoiler:Grindelwald jumps off a cliff and flies disapparates away.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RagtagBunchOfMisfits: Theseus notes that the team entrusted to take down the most dangerous wizard in four centuries include himself and Yusuf, a Magizoologist (Newt), his assistant (Bunty), a school teacher (Eulalie), and a Muggle (Jacob).

to:

* RagtagBunchOfMisfits: Theseus notes that the team entrusted to take down the most dangerous wizard in four centuries include himself and Yusuf, himself, a wizard descended from a very old French family (Yusuf), a Magizoologist (Newt), his indispensable assistant (Bunty), a school teacher schoolteacher (Eulalie), and a Muggle baker (Jacob).

Top