Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Brooklyn

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrattyHalfPint: Tony's younger brother Frankie comes across this way.


Added DiffLines:

** She also asks Sheila, one of her housemates, why she's not married, and is told it's because Sheila's husband left her. [[spoiler: Eilis later considers leaving Tony to stay in Ireland, although she decides not to.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CharacterDevelopment: Eilis gets a ton of it over the course of the story, as she goes from a very insecure and shy young woman uncertain about her place in her new country to a confident adult who embraces it by the end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CastTheExpert: The singer in New York who sings "Casadh an tSúgáin" is Iarla Ó Lionáird, a famous sean-nós singer in his own right for Afro Celt Sound System, and grand-nephew of famous folk singer Elizabeth Cronin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CastTheExpert: The singer in New York who sings "Casadh an tSúgáin" is Iarla Ó Lionáird, a famous sean-nós singer in his own right for Afro Celt Sound System, and grand-nephew of famous folk singer Elizabeth Cronin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film stars Creator/SaoirseRonan, Emory Cohen, Creator/DomhnallGleeson, Creator/JimBroadbent, and Creator/JulieWalters.

to:

The film stars Creator/SaoirseRonan, Emory Cohen, Creator/EmoryCohen, Creator/DomhnallGleeson, Creator/JimBroadbent, and Creator/JulieWalters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ItalianAmericanCaricature: Downplayed. Eilis falls in love with Tony Fiorello, a second-generation Italian-American plumber with a big family. They talk with their hands and are impressed by how well she eats spaghetti, to which she explains she learned how from an Italian girl in her boarding house.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film stars Creator/SaoirseRonan, Emory Cohen, Creator/DomhnallGleeson, Jim Broadbent, and Julie Walters.

to:

The film stars Creator/SaoirseRonan, Emory Cohen, Creator/DomhnallGleeson, Jim Broadbent, Creator/JimBroadbent, and Julie Walters.Creator/JulieWalters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnAesop:
** The countryside or your home town is not always {{Arcadia}} and sometimes leaving for the unknown ''is'' actually a good thing, as is evident from the many conversations about Ireland and its challenges. Leaving home is bound to be full of heart aches and struggles, but homesickness does pass and it can lead to something great. Additionally sometimes small towns can be full of people who are just as nasty as some found in the big cities.
** The movie is all about how the glamour and opportunities of the big city will not automatically lead to a better life as Eilis discovers when she volunteers to work at a soup kitchen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Good Adultery Bad Adultery now requires two affairs, with one being 'good' and one being 'bad'.


* GoodAdulteryBadAdultery: While Eilis is home, she's courted by Jim. Even though it's only emotional cheating, she still has a HeelRealisation and it's presented as something wrong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalNameChange: Minor, but Mrs Keogh in the film was spelt Mrs Kehoe in the book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnachronismStew: Minor example. [[spoiler: Rose's headstone]] dates the film to 1951-1952, and Eilis and Tony go to see ''Film/SinginInTheRain'' - which was released in 1952. However when Eilis first moves to America, one of her co-workers references ''Film/TheQuietMan'' - which didn't come out until August 1952 (and at this point it's still 1951).

to:

* AnachronismStew: ArtisticLicenseHistory: Minor example. [[spoiler: Rose's headstone]] dates the film to 1951-1952, and Eilis and Tony go to see ''Film/SinginInTheRain'' - which was released in 1952. However when Eilis first moves to America, one of her co-workers references ''Film/TheQuietMan'' - which didn't come out until August 1952 (and at this point it's still 1951).

Added: 146

Removed: 146

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheFifties: Set in 1951-1952. WordOfGod is that they took full advantage of the fact that pop culture was just starting to take off in America.



* TheFifties: Set in 1951-1952. WordOfGod is that they took full advantage of the fact that pop culture was just starting to take off in America.

Added: 449

Removed: 449

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnImmigrantsTale: A DeconReconSwitch. [[spoiler: Eilis ultimately does find a happy and fufilling new life in America but only after tremendous homesickness and being seriously tempted to return to Ireland for good. The film does not pull any punches about the grimmer side of this trope either whether it be immigrants who never truly find a home in their new country or the family and friends left behind who essentially lose someone for good.]]


Added DiffLines:

* AnImmigrantsTale: A DeconReconSwitch. [[spoiler: Eilis ultimately does find a happy and fufilling new life in America but only after tremendous homesickness and being seriously tempted to return to Ireland for good. The film does not pull any punches about the grimmer side of this trope either whether it be immigrants who never truly find a home in their new country or the family and friends left behind who essentially lose someone for good.]]

Added: 470

Changed: 1

Removed: 309

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mrs Keogh in the film is considerably kinder, softer and more motherly than she is in the book.

to:

** Mrs Mrs. Keogh in the film is considerably kinder, softer and more motherly than she is in the book.



* HateSink: Mrs. Kelly represents everything hateful about a small-town gossiping busy body. Many older viewers noted the sad TruthInTelevision surrounding her.



* JerkassHasAPoint: Miss Kelly is a self-righteous busybody, but she's right in that it's inappropriate for Eilis to date Jim, given that she's ''married''. While this does make Eilis remember that she wanted to get away from this suffocating small town, it also spurs her HeelRealization about her behaviour.



* JerkassHasAPoint: Miss Kelly is a self-righteous busybody, but she's right in that it's inappropriate for Eilis to date Jim, given that she's ''married''. While this does make Eilis remember that she wanted to get away from this suffocating small town, it also spurs her HeelRealization about her behaviour.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trivia trope(s).


* CaliforniaDoubling: Partly filmed in Montreal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IronicEcho: After returning to Ireland, Eilis states "I'd forgotten", referring to all the things she loved about her hometown. After Miss Kelly confronts her about her marriage, Eilis declares "I'd forgotten", this time referring to everything she ''hated''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PottyFailure: Subverted. Eilis can't get into the shared bathroom because it's locked (whether out of spite or because the person using it is also very ill is unclear). She barely--but successfully--manages to find a bucket instead.

to:

* PottyFailure: Subverted. Eilis can't get into the shared bathroom because it's locked (whether out of spite or because (because the person using it is also very ill is unclear).ill). She barely--but successfully--manages to find a bucket instead.

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NostalgiaAintLikeIUsedToBe: The early 1950s are a pretty place, with lots of charming and rather innocent wholesome young folks - in both Ireland and New York - but not everything is rosy. Perhaps most notably in an age where only the rich could fly trans-Atlantic (and even then it wasn't by jet airliner in six hours) everyone else had to take the boat - and the boat was not as romantic as it seems, with cramped cabins, and the unpleasant side effects of seasickness.

to:

* NostalgiaAintLikeIUsedToBe: NostalgiaAintLikeItUsedToBe: The early 1950s are a pretty place, with lots of charming and rather innocent wholesome young folks - in both Ireland and New York - but not everything is rosy. Perhaps most notably in an age where only the rich could fly trans-Atlantic (and even then it wasn't by jet airliner in six hours) everyone else had to take the boat - and the boat was not as romantic as it seems, with cramped cabins, and the unpleasant side effects of seasickness.

Added: 473

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NostalgiaAintLikeIUsedToBe: The early 1950s are a pretty place, with lots of charming and rather innocent wholesome young folks - in both Ireland and New York - but not everything is rosy. Perhaps most notably in an age where only the rich could fly trans-Atlantic (and even then it wasn't by jet airliner in six hours) everyone else had to take the boat - and the boat was not as romantic as it seems, with cramped cabins, and the unpleasant side effects of seasickness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Incorrect use of trope. Natter


* {{Foil}}: Jim to Tony. While Jim is taller, lives in Ireland and wants to see the world, Tony is closer to Eilis' height, lives in Brooklyn and planning to go into business with his family.



** Tony has bought land that he is planning to build a house on, and is going into business. Jim's job prospects aren't really specified and he is living with his parents. Big houses require money to keep them decent after all, and inheritances can be dwindled quickly.
*** It's stated that he runs his father's shop: since this is presumably the same line of work that put his father in a position to own such a house in the first place, he's probably doing all right.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LimitedWardrobe: When packing for New York, Rose notes that every single item of clothing Eilis owns can fit in a small suitcase, including her shoes. Even after getting a job in New York and buying new clothes, Eilis is shown repeating clothes throughout the movie. Some of the more distinctive outfits (for example, the bright yellow dress and blue swimsuit) are very noticeably worn several times, which is realistic for anyone but even more so for a poor immigrant.

to:

* LimitedWardrobe: When packing for New York, Rose notes that every single item of clothing Eilis owns can fit in a small suitcase, including her shoes. Even after getting a job in New York and buying new clothes, Eilis is shown repeating clothes throughout the movie. Some of the more distinctive outfits (for example, the bright yellow dress and blue green swimsuit) are very noticeably worn several times, which is realistic for anyone but even more so for a poor immigrant.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LimitedWardrobe: When packing for New York, Rose notes that every single item of clothing Eilis owns can fit in a small suitcase, including her shoes. Even after getting a job in New York and buying new clothes, Eilis is shown repeating clothes throughout the movie. Some of the more distinctive outfits (the bright yellow dress for example) are very noticeably worn several times, which is realistic for anyone but even more so for a poor immigrant.

to:

* LimitedWardrobe: When packing for New York, Rose notes that every single item of clothing Eilis owns can fit in a small suitcase, including her shoes. Even after getting a job in New York and buying new clothes, Eilis is shown repeating clothes throughout the movie. Some of the more distinctive outfits (the (for example, the bright yellow dress for example) and blue swimsuit) are very noticeably worn several times, which is realistic for anyone but even more so for a poor immigrant.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LimitedWardrobe: When packing for New York, Rose notes that every single item of clothing Eilis owns can fit in a small suitcase, including her shoes. Even after getting a job in New York and buying new clothes, Eilis is shown repeating clothes throughout the movie. Some of the more distinctive outfits (the bright yellow dress for example) are very noticeably worn several times, which is realistic for anyone but even more so for a poor immigrant.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** It's stated that he runs his father's shop: since this is presumably the same line of work that put his father in a position to own such a house in the first place, he's probably doing all right.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
corrected multiple misspellings of Mrs Keogh's name (understandable in that the DVD subtitles misspelled it, too)


** Mrs Kehoe in the film is considerably kinder, softer and more motherly than she is in the book.

to:

** Mrs Kehoe Keogh in the film is considerably kinder, softer and more motherly than she is in the book.



* BrainyBrunette: Eilis is given the distinction of being the first girl in Mrs Kehoe's boarding house to pass any exam at all.

to:

* BrainyBrunette: Eilis is given the distinction of being the first girl in Mrs Kehoe's Keogh's boarding house to pass any exam at all.



* CoolOldLady: Mrs Kehoe, who acts as a surrogate mother to all the girls in the boarding house.

to:

* CoolOldLady: Mrs Kehoe, Keogh, who acts as a surrogate mother to all the girls in the boarding house.

Top