Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / BlackRobe

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DwindlingParty: PlayedWith. [[spoiler: Only Chomina's closest kin travel with him back to retrieve the priest and all of them, excepting Annuka, die. In the end, [=LaForgue=] asks Daniel to stay with her and leave him alone, to fulfill the prophetic dream Chomina had where the priest travels alone]].

to:

* DwindlingParty: PlayedWith. [[spoiler: Only Chomina's closest kin travel with him back to retrieve the priest and all of them, excepting Annuka, die. In the end, film, [=LaForgue=] eventually asks Daniel to stay with her and leave him alone, to fulfill the prophetic dream Chomina had where the priest travels alone]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Daniel actively embraces GoingNative and has no moral qualms of any kind, along with continuously calling out [[=LaForgue=]] on his missionary antics. In the film, he's head over heels in love with Annuka and that's all he cares about.

to:

** Daniel actively embraces GoingNative and has no moral qualms of any kind, along with continuously calling out [[=LaForgue=]] [=LaForgue=] on his missionary antics. In the film, he's head over heels in love with Annuka and that's all he cares about.



* AdaptedOut: The two fur traders, first present in Quebec and [[spoiler: later saving the remnants of [[=LaForgue=]] expedition]], are respectively replaced by two smug asshole merchants in the opening and not present at all in the final part.

to:

* AdaptedOut: The two fur traders, first present in Quebec and [[spoiler: later saving the remnants of [[=LaForgue=]] [=LaForgue=] expedition]], are respectively replaced by two smug asshole merchants in the opening and not present at all in the final part.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the film, he does something very similar, only to ''forcefully baptise Chomina's wife'', to complete bewilderment of everyone around him.

to:

** In the film, he does something very similar, only to ''forcefully baptise Chomina's dying wife'', to complete bewilderment of everyone around him.

Added: 2351

Changed: 428

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationPersonalityChange:
** Father [=LaForgue=] is quite self-righteous and judgmental in the book, which earns him no favours. In film, he's instead viciously cynical and [[BrutalHonesty very blunt]], which also earns him no favours.
** Daniel actively embraces GoingNative and has no moral qualms of any kind, along with continuously calling out [[=LaForgue=]] on his missionary antics. In the film, he's head over heels in love with Annuka and that's all he cares about.
** Chomina is quite a hot-head in the book and very opportunistic - on top of being a named extra. His film counterpart is far more pragmatic and the voice of calm reason among the Algonquin.
* AdaptedOut: The two fur traders, first present in Quebec and [[spoiler: later saving the remnants of [[=LaForgue=]] expedition]], are respectively replaced by two smug asshole merchants in the opening and not present at all in the final part.



* AscendedExtra:
** Chomina is significantly less prominent and important character in the book. Him being a co-lead is probably the biggest deviation in the adaptation.
** Annuka isn't even ''named'' until about half-way through the book.



* CompositeCharacter: Chomina in the film is an amalgam of positive traits (and none of their negatives) of both Chomina and Neehatin, packed into a single character.



* DeadpanSnarker: [=LaForgue=] snarks at his fellow Frenchmen all the time, quite viciously at that. Alternatively, he has a ''truly'' morbid sense of humour.

to:

* DeadpanSnarker: The film version of [=LaForgue=] snarks at his fellow Frenchmen all the time, quite viciously at that. Alternatively, he has a ''truly'' morbid sense of humour.



* DiesWideOpen: [[spoiler: Father Duval was murdered by one of the Hurons, most likely with a hatchet to his face. He never had a chance to close his eyes. Meanwhile, when one morning [=LaForgue=] finds father Gerome dead in his bed, the old man's eyes are still open, suggesting he ''wasn't'' asleep when he passed away]].

to:

* DiesWideOpen: DemotedToExtra: Neehatin is one of the two Algonquin chiefs within the expedition - and the more prominent to Chomina. He isn't even named within the film and majority of his traits is transplanted to Chomina, too.
* DiesDifferentlyInAdaptation:
[[spoiler: Father Gerome is killed by one of the Hurons soon after father Paul reaches the mission. In the film, he dies in his sleep]].
* DiesWideOpen: In the film, [[spoiler: father
Duval was murdered by one of the Hurons, most likely with a hatchet to his face. He never had a chance to close his eyes. Meanwhile, when one morning [=LaForgue=] finds father Gerome dead in his bed, the old man's eyes are still open, suggesting he ''wasn't'' asleep when he passed away]].



* NightmareSequence: Chomina has a recurring nightmare, in which he's in some unknown island, weak and dying, with a raven picking his eye. All while in the distance, a black robe walks alone. It is implied in dialogues he's been having this nightmare for ''years''.

to:

* NightmareSequence: In the film, Chomina has a recurring nightmare, in which he's in some unknown island, weak and dying, with a raven picking his eye. All while in the distance, a black robe walks alone. It is implied in dialogues he's been having this nightmare for ''years''.



* SkewedPriorities:
** In the book, when to Iroquois party is capturing Daniel, [=LaForgue=], who was so far well-hidden and in no direct danger, emerges from his hideout and walks ''straight into the thick of fight''. That despite he knows he will be captured and killed, probably by torture. Why? Because he wants to give Daniel a chance to have a confession before ''he'' will be killed.
** In the film, he does something very similar, only to ''forcefully baptise Chomina's wife'', to complete bewilderment of everyone around him.



* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: We never learn what happened to [[spoiler: the rest of the party. The fate of Daniel and Annuka also remains unresolved]].

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: We never learn what happened to [[spoiler: the rest of the party. The And in the film, the ultimate fate of Daniel and Annuka also remains unresolved]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Only Sane Man requires from a character to be the only well-adjusted individual in the entire group of disfunctional characters. Which isn't the case, as they are all perfectly sane.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
If you're just planning a low-intense edit war, at least fix the formatting.


* OnlySaneMane: the Mohawk chief, who is the only one of his tribe to understand there would be more profit in ransoming the prisoners for goods than in torturing them to death and that there has to be a way to make muskets shoot more than once.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OnlySaneMane: the Mohawk chief, who is the only one of his tribe to understand there would be more profit in ransoming the prisoners for goods than in torturing them to death and that there has to be a way to make muskets shoot more than once.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OnlySaneMan: The Mohawk chief, who is the only one to think they could exchange the prisoners for goods instead of torturing them to death and that there has to be a way for muskets to shoot a second time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Then again, the lying Jesuit firly believes the Hurons' accepting baptism means they will be saved even though they didn't understand what they were doing by acceptig it. This puts him in WellIntentionedExtremist territory

to:

** Then again, the lying Jesuit firly firmly believes the Hurons' accepting baptism means they will be saved saved, even though they didn't understand what they were are doing by acceptig it. This puts him in WellIntentionedExtremist territoryterritory.



* OnlySaneMan: the Mohawk chief, who is the only one to think they could exchange the prisoners for goods instead of torturing them to death and that there has to be a way for muskets to shoot a second time.

to:

* OnlySaneMan: the The Mohawk chief, who is the only one to think they could exchange the prisoners for goods instead of torturing them to death and that there has to be a way for muskets to shoot a second time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OnlySaneMan: the Mohawk chief, who is the only one to think they could exchange the prisoners for goods instead of torturing them to death and that there has to be a way for muskets to shoot a second time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Then again, the lying Jesuit firly believes the Hurons' accepting baptism means they will be saved even though they didn't understand what they were doing by acceptig it. This puts him in WellIntentionedExtremist territory

Added: 602

Changed: 201

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MightyWhitey: Averted, with [=LaForgue=] realizing in the film's final scene that, if he wants to convert the Huron to Christianity, he needs to treat them like equals and not the superstitious children they're often treated as.

to:

* MightyWhitey: Averted, with Averted ''hard''.
** The settlers are in general helplessly dependant on the natives, their help and guidance. Especially so once the expedition departs from Quebec and both Father
[=LaForgue=] realizing in the film's final scene that, and Daniel have a hard time to even keep up with their guides, never impressing them with anything and always remaining outsiders that have to be taken care for.
** The whole character arc of [=LaForgue=] is his ongoing realisation that
if he wants to convert the Huron to Christianity, he needs to treat them like equals and not the superstitious children they're often treated as.as and adjust to them, not the other way around.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Wrong trope. Only Sane Man requires a group of disfunctional weirdos to apply, which isn't the case


* OnlySaneMan: the Iroquois chief is the only one to grasp that prisoners could be traded for muskets instead of being tortured to death… and that there must be a ay to reload muskets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OnlySaneMan: the Iroquois chief is the only one to grasp that prisoners could be traded for muskets instead of being tortured to death… and that there must be a ay to reload muskets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CultColony: Invoked, discussed and ultimately subverted. The French settlers mockingly refer to the amount of clergy and missionaries they get, instead of women, merchants and craftsmen to provide any future for their colony, all while other countries provide exactly that to their settlers. [[spoiler: The missions themselves are utter failure in their current operation, while the eventual success it still rendered into a pointless exercise in futility by outside factors]].

to:

* CultColony: Invoked, discussed discussed, played with and ultimately subverted.subverted, as inspecting this trope is one of the main points of the story. The French settlers mockingly refer to the amount of clergy and missionaries they get, instead of women, merchants and craftsmen to provide any future for their colony, all while other countries provide exactly that to their settlers. [[spoiler: The missions themselves are utter failure in their current operation, while the eventual success it still rendered into a pointless exercise in futility by outside factors]]. However, the religious devotion is still one of the main driving forces for the colonisation, while the Jesuits go into effort that makes even other colonist already in Quebec look like lacking conviction into their endevours.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CultColony: Invoked, discussed and ultimately subverted. The French settlers mockingly refer to the amount of clergy and missionaries they get, instead of women, merchants and craftsmen to provide any future for their colony, all while other countries provide exactly that to their settlers. [[spoiler: The missions themselves are utter failure in their current operation, while the eventual success it still rendered into a pointless exercise in futility by outside factors]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Sup, Anglo?


* AnachronismStew: Joan of Arc wasn't made a saint until 1920, and very few people cared or knew much about her in the 17th century anyhow.

to:

* AnachronismStew: Joan of Arc wasn't made a saint until 1920, and very few people cared or knew much about her in the 17th century anyhow.1920.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnachronismStew: Joan of Arc wasn't made a saint until 1920, and very few people cared or knew much about her in the 17th century anyhow.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Despite being ESL, I find people "fixing" proper spelling with American one to be deeply amusing


* BigLittleMan: Father [=LaForgue=] is harangued by the shaman Mestigoit, who is filmed close to the camera -- it's only when he comes face-to-face with [=LaForgue=] (who is sitting down) that we realize how short he is.

to:

* BigLittleMan: Father [=LaForgue=] is harangued by the shaman Mestigoit, who is filmed close to the camera -- it's only when he comes face-to-face with [=LaForgue=] (who is sitting down) that we realize realise how short he is.



* ForeseeingMyDeath: [[spoiler: Chomina has a vision of where he's going to die, but he doesn't realize this until he's there and actually dying. He then expresses regret that he never realized the meaning of his recurring dream, as he could have been a fearless warrior if he had known]].

to:

* ForeseeingMyDeath: [[spoiler: Chomina has a vision of where he's going to die, but he doesn't realize realise this until he's there and actually dying. He then expresses regret that he never realized realised the meaning of his recurring dream, as he could have been a fearless warrior if he had known]].



* HonorBeforeReason: Chomina decides to [[spoiler: go back and help the black robe]]. He ''openly admits'' this is stupid, but it's still his honor at stake and it's better to die than break an oath.

to:

* HonorBeforeReason: Chomina decides to [[spoiler: go back and help the black robe]]. He ''openly admits'' this is stupid, but it's still his honor honour at stake and it's better to die than break an oath.



* ItHasBeenAnHonor: [[spoiler: Eventually Chomina admits [=LaForgue=] might not be completely stupid, while the priest honors his will to die unbaptized]].

to:

* ItHasBeenAnHonor: [[spoiler: Eventually Chomina admits [=LaForgue=] might not be completely stupid, while the priest honors honours his will to die unbaptized]].



* LifeWillKillYou: It is noted several times by different characters surviving a winter is an achievement all by itself, even is such "civilized" place like Quebec.

to:

* LifeWillKillYou: It is noted several times by different characters surviving a winter is an achievement all by itself, even is such "civilized" "civilised" place like Quebec.



* MyGreatestFailure: [[spoiler: When realizing he was always dreaming about his own death, Chomina laments to Annuka he could have been a better, braver and wiser chief if he knew in advance what the dream meant. If he'd known the moment of his death, he'd have approached many situations in the past differently]].

to:

* MyGreatestFailure: [[spoiler: When realizing realising he was always dreaming about his own death, Chomina laments to Annuka he could have been a better, braver and wiser chief if he knew in advance what the dream meant. If he'd known the moment of his death, he'd have approached many situations in the past differently]].



* {{Precognition}}: [[spoiler: The recurring nightmare turns out to be this. Chomina instantly recognizes the place from his dream as the one where he will die. He only asks to be left there, since he's already mortally wounded]].

to:

* {{Precognition}}: [[spoiler: The recurring nightmare turns out to be this. Chomina instantly recognizes recognises the place from his dream as the one where he will die. He only asks to be left there, since he's already mortally wounded]].



* SelfFulfillingProphecy: [[spoiler: The three Huron elders talk about how their enemies will learn about their weakness if they embrace Christianity and this will lead to the doom of their entire confederacy. Still, they on their own decide to take baptism... and right after that the final card informs us how the Hurons were mostly wiped out by the Iroquois fifteen years later]].

to:

* SelfFulfillingProphecy: [[spoiler: The three Huron elders talk about how their enemies will learn about their weakness if they embrace Christianity and this will lead to the doom of their entire confederacy. Still, they on their own decide to take baptism... and right after that the final card informs us how the Hurons were mostly deliberately wiped out by the Iroquois fifteen years later]].

Changed: 110

Removed: 286

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That's not an example.


* CultureClash: All the freaking time. Sometimes downward scary, like when like [=LaForgue=] tries to explain what writing is and gets taken for a demon when Daniel reads his note without any oral passage of information.
* CunningLinguist: Subverted. It is noted even by [=LaForgue=] himself his Algonquin is awful and each time a new group or a tribe meets him, they instantly pick up how strange his speech patterns are. He still does his best to speak to them in their own language rather than French, though.

to:

* CultureClash: All the freaking time. Sometimes downward downright scary, like when like [=LaForgue=] tries to explain what writing is and gets taken for a demon when Daniel reads his note without any oral passage of information.
* CunningLinguist: Subverted. It is noted even by [=LaForgue=] himself that his Algonquin is awful and each time a new group or a tribe meets him, they instantly pick up how strange his speech patterns are. He still does his best to speak to them in their own language rather than French, French though.



* DeconstructorFleet: A very thorough deconstruction of all missionary fiction along with [[NobleSavage romantic take on natives]] and [[BoldExplorer exploration of unknown lands]].
* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Forceful baptism of a dying person is strongly frowned upon in modern Catholic Church - the consent is outright demanded.

to:

* DeconstructorFleet: A very thorough deconstruction of all missionary fiction along with [[NobleSavage romantic take takes on natives]] and [[BoldExplorer exploration of unknown lands]].
* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Forceful baptism of a dying person is strongly frowned upon in the modern Catholic Church - the consent is outright demanded.



* {{Fingore}}: All over the place, since Mohawks routinely cut fingers of their captives.

to:

* {{Fingore}}: All over the place, since Mohawks routinely cut fingers of off their captives.



** [[spoiler: When captured by Mohawks, [=LaForgue=] gets his left index finger cut in half with an oyster shell. The Mohawk chief is quite impressed, since the Jesuit didn't made a sound]]. And it's all shown in detail.

to:

** [[spoiler: When captured by Mohawks, [=LaForgue=] gets his left index finger cut in half with an oyster shell. The Mohawk chief is quite impressed, since the Jesuit didn't made make a sound]]. And it's all shown in detail.



* FluffyCloudHeaven: The main reason why the Jesuits have such hard time converting natives is because this is how they describe Heaven and Paradise to them. The natives find the concept ''immensely'' unappealing.
* ForeseeingMyDeath: [[spoiler: Chomina has a vision of where he's going to die, but he doesn't realise this until he's there and actually dying. He then expresses regret that he never realised the meaning of his recurring dream, as he could have been a fearless warrior if he had known]].

to:

* FluffyCloudHeaven: The main reason why the Jesuits have such a hard time converting natives is because this is how they describe Heaven and Paradise to them. The natives find the concept ''immensely'' unappealing.
* ForeseeingMyDeath: [[spoiler: Chomina has a vision of where he's going to die, but he doesn't realise realize this until he's there and actually dying. He then expresses regret that he never realised realized the meaning of his recurring dream, as he could have been a fearless warrior if he had known]].



* HeelRealization: [[spoiler: Eventually [=LaForgue=] realises that not only he is sure to die a horrible death (something he already partially accepted before even departing into the wilderness), but that he is a flawed person of prideful nature. He proceeds to TurnTheOtherCheek from then on]].

to:

* HeelRealization: [[spoiler: Eventually [=LaForgue=] realises realizes that not only is he is sure to die a horrible death (something he already partially accepted before even departing into the wilderness), but that he is a flawed person of prideful nature. He proceeds to TurnTheOtherCheek from then on]].



* HonorBeforeReason: Chomina decides to [[spoiler: go back and help the black robe]]. He ''openly admits'' this is stupid, but it's still his honour at stake and it's better to die than break an oath.

to:

* HonorBeforeReason: Chomina decides to [[spoiler: go back and help the black robe]]. He ''openly admits'' this is stupid, but it's still his honour honor at stake and it's better to die than break an oath.



* GoingNative: Daniel seems to be going down this road but after the horrific encounter with the Iroquois Chomina asks him:

to:

* GoingNative: Daniel seems to be going down this road road, but after the horrific encounter with the Iroquois Chomina asks him:



* ItHasBeenAnHonor: [[spoiler: Eventually Chomina admits [=LaForgue=] might not be completely stupid, while the priest honours his will to die unbaptized]].

to:

* ItHasBeenAnHonor: [[spoiler: Eventually Chomina admits [=LaForgue=] might not be completely stupid, while the priest honours honors his will to die unbaptized]].



* LifeWillKillYou: It is noted several times by different characters surviving a winter is an achievement all by itself, even is such "civilised" place like Quebec.

to:

* LifeWillKillYou: It is noted several times by different characters surviving a winter is an achievement all by itself, even is such "civilised" "civilized" place like Quebec.



* MyGreatestFailure: [[spoiler: When realising he was always dreaming about his own death, Chomina laments to Annuka he could have been a better, braver and wiser chief if he knew in advance what the dream meant. If he'd known the moment of his death, he'd have approached many situations in the past differently]].
* NiceJobBreakingItHero: [[spoiler: All that [=LaForgue=] achieves in the end - ''[[AmbiguousEnding if]]'' [[AmbiguousEnding he achieves anything]] - will lead to the undoing of Hurons and their complete wipe-out by Iroquois]].

to:

* MyGreatestFailure: [[spoiler: When realising realizing he was always dreaming about his own death, Chomina laments to Annuka he could have been a better, braver and wiser chief if he knew in advance what the dream meant. If he'd known the moment of his death, he'd have approached many situations in the past differently]].
* NiceJobBreakingItHero: [[spoiler: All that [=LaForgue=] achieves in the end - ''[[AmbiguousEnding if]]'' [[AmbiguousEnding he achieves anything]] - will lead to the undoing of Hurons and their complete wipe-out destruction by the Iroquois]].



* {{Precognition}}: [[spoiler: The recurring nightmare turns out to be this. Chomina instantly recognises the place from his dream as the one where he will die. He only asks to be left there, since he's already mortally wounded]].

to:

* {{Precognition}}: [[spoiler: The recurring nightmare turns out to be this. Chomina instantly recognises recognizes the place from his dream as the one where he will die. He only asks to be left there, since he's already mortally wounded]].



* ReversePsychology: [[spoiler: After escaping from the Mohawks, [=LaForgue=] suggests they still go up-river to the Huron mission, as the Mohawks will rather assume they tried to go downstream to join fellow Algonquins. Chomina agrees, finally admitting the jesuit is not as stupid as he looks]].

to:

* ReversePsychology: [[spoiler: After escaping from the Mohawks, [=LaForgue=] suggests they still go up-river to the Huron mission, as the Mohawks will rather assume they tried to go downstream to join fellow Algonquins. Chomina agrees, finally admitting the jesuit Jesuit is not as stupid as he looks]].



* RiverOfInsanity: [[spoiler: Both Chomina and [=LaForgue=] get more and more anxious as they travel up-river, while members of their expedition get less and less loyal. In the same time, the missionary is slowly, if surely {{going native}}, at least as far as his moral compass goes. And this is portayed as a ''[[DeliberateValuesDissonance good thing]]'']].
* ScarpiaUltimatum: [[spoiler: Annuka willingly has sex with a guard in Mohawk camp, but right when he climaxes, she bashes his head in and proceeds to free the rest of the expedition]]. The entire sequence is ''very'' explicit, even compared with other shots and scenes containing sex.

to:

* RiverOfInsanity: [[spoiler: Both Chomina and [=LaForgue=] get more and more anxious as they travel up-river, while members of their expedition get less and less loyal. In the same time, the missionary is slowly, if surely {{going native}}, at least as far as his moral compass goes. And this is portayed portrayed as a ''[[DeliberateValuesDissonance good thing]]'']].
* ScarpiaUltimatum: [[spoiler: Annuka willingly has sex with a guard in Mohawk camp, but right when he climaxes, she bashes his head in and proceeds to free the rest of the expedition]]. The entire sequence is ''very'' explicit, even compared with other shots and scenes containing sex.
thing]]'']].



* SelfFulfillingProphecy: [[spoiler: The three Huron elders talk about how their enemies will learn about their weakness if they embrace Christianity and this will lead to the doom of their entire confederacy. Still, they on their own decide to take baptism... and right after that final card informs how Hurons were deliberately wiped out by Iroquis fifteen years later]].
* ShaggyDogStory: [[spoiler: [=LaForgue=] reaches the remote mission and starts to work there. Some of the Hurons accept Christianity... which lead to tribal fractionalism, which weakens the already barely holding confederacy and eventually leads to the brutal conquest and massacres by Iroquis just fifteen years later. Oh, and the Jesuits missions in the area were disbanded or abandoned soon after that. The final card really doesn't beat the bush about any of it]].

to:

* SelfFulfillingProphecy: [[spoiler: The three Huron elders talk about how their enemies will learn about their weakness if they embrace Christianity and this will lead to the doom of their entire confederacy. Still, they on their own decide to take baptism... and right after that the final card informs us how the Hurons were deliberately mostly wiped out by Iroquis the Iroquois fifteen years later]].
* ShaggyDogStory: [[spoiler: [=LaForgue=] reaches the remote mission and starts to work there. Some of the Hurons accept Christianity... which lead leads to tribal fractionalism, which weakens the already barely holding confederacy and eventually leads to the brutal conquest and massacres by Iroquis the Iroquois just fifteen years later. Oh, and the Jesuits missions in the area were disbanded or abandoned soon after that. The final card really doesn't beat the bush about any of it]].



* SpiritualAntithesis: To the NobleSavage romanticism of ''Film/DancesWithWolves''
* StockSoundEffects: [[spoiler: When [=LaForgue=] and Daniel are forced into running the gauntlet by Iroquois, stock sounds of being hit are used. It fits the scene just as much as you expect]].

to:

* SpiritualAntithesis: To the NobleSavage romanticism of ''Film/DancesWithWolves''
''Film/DancesWithWolves''.
* StockSoundEffects: [[spoiler: When [=LaForgue=] and Daniel are forced into running the gauntlet by the Iroquois, stock sounds of being hit are used. It fits the scene just as much as you expect]].



* WouldHurtAChild: [[spoiler: The Mohawk chief slash the throat of Chomina's son. Right in front of Chomina, who is strip naked and forced to continue singing as the boy bleeds to death]].

to:

* WouldHurtAChild: [[spoiler: The Mohawk chief slash slashes the throat of Chomina's son. Right in front of Chomina, who is strip stripped naked and forced to continue singing as the boy bleeds to death]].

Added: 163

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlingOfWar: As part of the NotSoDifferent message, right in the opening both de Champlain and Chomina prepare themselves for negotiations by slowly putting on more and more elaborate elements of their formal attire. All while being otherwise being very pragmatic men wearing even more pragmatic clothes.

to:

* BlingOfWar: As part of the NotSoDifferent message, right in the opening both de Champlain and Chomina prepare themselves for negotiations by slowly putting on more and more elaborate elements of their formal attire. All while being otherwise being very pragmatic men wearing even more pragmatic clothes.



* DiesWideOpen: [[spoiler: Father Duval was murdered by one of the Hurons, most likely with a hatchet to his face. He never had a chance to close his eyes. Meanwhile, when one morning La Forgue finds father Gerome dead in his bed, the old man's eyes are still open, suggesting he ''wasn't'' asleep when he passed away]].

to:

* DiesWideOpen: [[spoiler: Father Duval was murdered by one of the Hurons, most likely with a hatchet to his face. He never had a chance to close his eyes. Meanwhile, when one morning La Forgue [=LaForgue=] finds father Gerome dead in his bed, the old man's eyes are still open, suggesting he ''wasn't'' asleep when he passed away]].


Added DiffLines:

* MaybeMagicMaybeMundane: Chomina's dream can be interpreted both ways. [[spoiler: And his final vision of She-Manitou could be either real or just a DyingDream]].

Added: 12432

Changed: 2992

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AintTooProudToBeg: Inverted. Chomina explicitly ''forbids'' both [=LaForgue=] and Daniel to beg [[spoiler: when they are to be tortured by the Mohawks, as per local custom this will only make the ordeal far, far worse]].
* AllThereInTheManual: [=LaForgue=]'s first name is Paul. It's mentioned ''nowhere'' in the film.



* BraidsBeadsAndBuckskins: The clothing of the natives and colonists is quite accurate.

to:

* {{Bishonen}}: Daniel is young, pretty and quite effeminate.
* BlackCloak: The eponymous "black robe" refers to the Jesuit habits. It's also what the natives call them.
* BlatantLies: Daniel claims he wants to accompany [=LaForgue=] in his mission "for the greater glory of God", but he's only there for Annuka. The Jesuits still take him along, full aware that he's lying, because they need every little help they can get.
* BlingOfWar: As part of the NotSoDifferent message, right in the opening both de Champlain and Chomina prepare themselves for negotiations by slowly putting on more and more elaborate elements of their formal attire. All while being otherwise being very pragmatic men wearing even more pragmatic clothes.
* BloodFromTheMouth: [[spoiler: After being shot with an arrow (and still having the arrow-head stuck in his side), Chomina slowly succumbs to his countless wounds and starts coughing blood, more and more as the journey goes on]].
* BodyHorror: The priest [=LaForgue=] met back in France to help him prepare for the New World was maimed and disfigured by the natives purposefully... and yet he still wants to to go back and try to proselytize some more.
-->'''Maimed Priest''' We must convert them. What more glorious task than that?
* BraidsBeadsAndBuckskins: The clothing Since it takes place among the Algonquins, Mohawks and Hurons, it's pretty accurate. Notably, some of the natives French settlers are also shown wearing bits and colonists is quite accurate.pieces of native gear, even de Champlain, who dons a ceremonial cape before negotiating with Chomina.
* BrutalHonesty: Both [=LaForgue=] and Chomina are ''very'' open with what they think and what are their chances of succeeding with just about anything are. In case of [=LaForgue=] it's implied he got it from his mother.



* CultureClash
* DiesWideOpen: Lots of people.
* DreamingOfThingsToCome: As usual, quite prophetic. Chomina wishes he had acted upon them much sooner.

to:

* CultureClash
CoitusUninterruptus: An Algonquin couple has sex in the middle of a tent, with everyone else present and asleep. [=LaForgue=] wakes up for a moment, but he stays put and after a brief moment of staring, also goes back to sleep.
* CrisisOfFaith: The entire escapade is one huge test of faith for [=LaForgue=].
-->'''[=LaForgue=]''': I'm afraid of this country. The Devil rules here. Controls the hearts and minds of these poor people.
* CultureClash: All the freaking time. Sometimes downward scary, like when like [=LaForgue=] tries to explain what writing is and gets taken for a demon when Daniel reads his note without any oral passage of information.
* CunningLinguist: Subverted. It is noted even by [=LaForgue=] himself his Algonquin is awful and each time a new group or a tribe meets him, they instantly pick up how strange his speech patterns are. He still does his best to speak to them in their own language rather than French, though.
* DeadpanSnarker: [=LaForgue=] snarks at his fellow Frenchmen all the time, quite viciously at that. Alternatively, he has a ''truly'' morbid sense of humour.
* DeconstructorFleet: A very thorough deconstruction of all missionary fiction along with [[NobleSavage romantic take on natives]] and [[BoldExplorer exploration of unknown lands]].
* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Forceful baptism of a dying person is strongly frowned upon in modern Catholic Church - the consent is outright demanded.
* DiesWideOpen: Lots [[spoiler: Father Duval was murdered by one of people.
the Hurons, most likely with a hatchet to his face. He never had a chance to close his eyes. Meanwhile, when one morning La Forgue finds father Gerome dead in his bed, the old man's eyes are still open, suggesting he ''wasn't'' asleep when he passed away]].
* DistractedByTheSexy: [[spoiler:Annuka crawls up to the guard in the Mohawk village and proceeds to have sex with him... then bashes his head open with a wooden log right when he's too busy climaxing to react]].
* DownerEnding: [[spoiler: [[ForegoneConclusion Considering the historical events]], the story couldn't really end well. Even if [=LaForgue=] eventually manages to reach the mission and ''probably'' convert the local Hurons, the final card flat-out admits he will at best play the role of UnwittingInstigatorOfDoom for them]].
* DreamingOfThingsToCome: [[spoiler: As usual, quite prophetic. Chomina wishes he had acted upon them much sooner.sooner]].
* DueToTheDead: [[spoiler: [=LaForgue=] buries father Duval, who was deliberately left untreated in the chapel by the Hurons]].
* DwindlingParty: PlayedWith. [[spoiler: Only Chomina's closest kin travel with him back to retrieve the priest and all of them, excepting Annuka, die. In the end, [=LaForgue=] asks Daniel to stay with her and leave him alone, to fulfill the prophetic dream Chomina had where the priest travels alone]].
* EndOfAnAge:
** Chomina acknowledges the dependence on gifts from the French is the beginning of the end of his people, fully knowing the exchange is unequal and there is no real way to stop or appease the white people.
** [[spoiler: The elders in the mission reflect the real concern Hurons had when facing Jesuit missionaries - accepting new faith in the all-or-nothing form presented by "black robes" will be equal to stop being Huron and will destroy their culture and ties within the confederation, leading to pointless fractionalism. [[TruthInTelevision This is exactly what happened to Hurons eventually]]]].



* {{Foreshadowing}}: Through the above-mentioned dreams.
* {{Fingore}}: All over the place.

to:

* EvilJesuit: A few of the Jesuits are shown as pretty unscrupulous — notably, one lies [[spoiler: to the Huron and tells them that baptism will cure their fever]] — and the film is certainly critical of the Jesuits' missions as a whole. In the same time though [=LaForgue=] is a genuinely good guy, who honestly believes he is helping people. His Algonquin guides, however, are pretty wary of him, since he wears the eponymous [[BlackCloak black robe]], sleeps separately from everyone else, and refuses to have sex with the women.
* {{Fingore}}: All over the place, since Mohawks routinely cut fingers of their captives.
** The carpenters in the opening discuss a missionary who ended up with just two fingers left, one to each hand.
** The priest preparing [=LaForgue=] back in France lacks several fingers, too, along with [[BodyHorror other mutilations]].
** [[spoiler: When captured by Mohawks, [=LaForgue=] gets his left index finger cut in half with an oyster shell. The Mohawk chief is quite impressed, since the Jesuit didn't made a sound]]. And it's all shown in detail.
* {{Flashback}}: Since the story opens already in Quebec settlement, this is how [=LaForgue=]'s time in France and preparation for the missionary job are shown. The more dire his situation becomes, the more personal the flashbacks get.
* FluffyCloudHeaven: The main reason why the Jesuits have such hard time converting natives is because this is how they describe Heaven and Paradise to them. The natives find the concept ''immensely'' unappealing.
* ForeseeingMyDeath: [[spoiler: Chomina has a vision of where he's going to die, but he doesn't realise this until he's there and actually dying. He then expresses regret that he never realised the meaning of his recurring dream, as he could have been a fearless warrior if he had known]].
* {{Foreshadowing}}: Through the [[spoiler: above-mentioned dreams.
dreams]].
* {{Fingore}}: All over HeelRealization: [[spoiler: Eventually [=LaForgue=] realises that not only he is sure to die a horrible death (something he already partially accepted before even departing into the place.wilderness), but that he is a flawed person of prideful nature. He proceeds to TurnTheOtherCheek from then on]].
* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Samuel de Champlain, as an old, tired man. The plot starts during his final year as a governor of the New France.
* HonorBeforeReason: Chomina decides to [[spoiler: go back and help the black robe]]. He ''openly admits'' this is stupid, but it's still his honour at stake and it's better to die than break an oath.
* HumanSacrifice: [[spoiler: The Mohawks are planning to burn Annuka at stake as a sacrifice to their god]].



** Of course, at the end, he does go off with Annuka. And that's where the Metis come from.

to:

** [[spoiler: Of course, at the end, he does go off with Annuka. And that's where the Metis come from.from]].
** [[spoiler: [=LaForgue=] has this as his HeelRealization - he eventually accepts it's him who has to adjust to locals, not them to his faith]].



* IndianMaiden: Kind of. Annuka is TheChiefsDaughter who falls in love with a white man. However, she very much averts the DamselInDistress stereotype and is much more hot-headed and impatient than her father.

to:

* IJustWantToBeSpecial: After arriving to the New World, Daniel is thoroughly bored with the settlement, because, rather than adventuring and stuff, he's doing the same carpentry job he was doing back in France. So he openly yearns to leave Quebec.
* IndianMaiden: Kind of. Annuka is TheChiefsDaughter who falls in love with a white man. However, she very much averts actively defies the DamselInDistress stereotype and is much more hot-headed and impatient than her father.father.
* ItHasBeenAnHonor: [[spoiler: Eventually Chomina admits [=LaForgue=] might not be completely stupid, while the priest honours his will to die unbaptized]].



* LifeWillKillYou: It is noted several times by different characters surviving a winter is an achievement all by itself, even is such "civilised" place like Quebec.
* TheMissionary: ZigZagged. The Jesuits obviously want to convert the natives, but due to the severe CultureClash the Algonquins assume "black robes" must be demons, as they act weirdly, have even stranger customs and never have sex. [=LaForgue=] himself is a doubtful and somewhat self-righteous man, yet in the same time he really wants nothing but the salvation of those people within the frame of his own religion.
* MasculineGirlFeminineBoy: While Daniel is no slouch on his own, he is still a sensitive {{Bishonen}} and has hard time in the wilderness, while Annuka is tough, ''extremely'' pragmatic and the dominant in their relationship.



* TheMissionary
* NobleSavage: Subverted.
* NotSoDifferent: On a cultural level. Moore compares the superstition of the natives with the Catholic beliefs of the missionaries. In the film Daniel suggests this point to [=LaForgue=]. Visual juxtaposition to this effect is all over the place.

to:

* TheMissionary
MyGreatestFailure: [[spoiler: When realising he was always dreaming about his own death, Chomina laments to Annuka he could have been a better, braver and wiser chief if he knew in advance what the dream meant. If he'd known the moment of his death, he'd have approached many situations in the past differently]].
* NiceJobBreakingItHero: [[spoiler: All that [=LaForgue=] achieves in the end - ''[[AmbiguousEnding if]]'' [[AmbiguousEnding he achieves anything]] - will lead to the undoing of Hurons and their complete wipe-out by Iroquois]].
* NightmareSequence: Chomina has a recurring nightmare, in which he's in some unknown island, weak and dying, with a raven picking his eye. All while in the distance, a black robe walks alone. It is implied in dialogues he's been having this nightmare for ''years''.
* NobleSavage: Subverted.
Subverted, if not outright defied. All the different aspects of native life, customs and warfare are shown in their unglamorous, mundane and brutal form.
* NotSoDifferent: On a cultural level. Moore compares the superstition of the natives with the Catholic beliefs of the missionaries. In the film Daniel suggests this point to [=LaForgue=]. Visual juxtaposition to this effect is all over the place.place, one right in the opening scene.
* {{Precognition}}: [[spoiler: The recurring nightmare turns out to be this. Chomina instantly recognises the place from his dream as the one where he will die. He only asks to be left there, since he's already mortally wounded]].



* SceneryPorn: Wow, Canada.

to:

* ReversePsychology: [[spoiler: After escaping from the Mohawks, [=LaForgue=] suggests they still go up-river to the Huron mission, as the Mohawks will rather assume they tried to go downstream to join fellow Algonquins. Chomina agrees, finally admitting the jesuit is not as stupid as he looks]].
* RiddleForTheAges: What did [=LaForgue=] confess?
* RiverOfInsanity: [[spoiler: Both Chomina and [=LaForgue=] get more and more anxious as they travel up-river, while members of their expedition get less and less loyal. In the same time, the missionary is slowly, if surely {{going native}}, at least as far as his moral compass goes. And this is portayed as a ''[[DeliberateValuesDissonance good thing]]'']].
* ScarpiaUltimatum: [[spoiler: Annuka willingly has sex with a guard in Mohawk camp, but right when he climaxes, she bashes his head in and proceeds to free the rest of the expedition]]. The entire sequence is ''very'' explicit, even compared with other shots and scenes containing sex.
* SceneryPorn: Wow, Canada.The many, many shots of somber, yet enthralling landscapes of Canada.
* SelfFulfillingProphecy: [[spoiler: The three Huron elders talk about how their enemies will learn about their weakness if they embrace Christianity and this will lead to the doom of their entire confederacy. Still, they on their own decide to take baptism... and right after that final card informs how Hurons were deliberately wiped out by Iroquis fifteen years later]].
* ShaggyDogStory: [[spoiler: [=LaForgue=] reaches the remote mission and starts to work there. Some of the Hurons accept Christianity... which lead to tribal fractionalism, which weakens the already barely holding confederacy and eventually leads to the brutal conquest and massacres by Iroquis just fifteen years later. Oh, and the Jesuits missions in the area were disbanded or abandoned soon after that. The final card really doesn't beat the bush about any of it]].



* ShowSomeLeg: Annuka actually ''has sex'' with [[spoiler: the Mohawk guard to distract him and then clobbering him in the face with a piece of a log]].
* ShownTheirWork: It's a faithful adaptation of a very well-researched book, going another extra mile during filming to keep things as close to recreation of the period and culture of different native tribes as feasible.
* SignatureStyle: The CultureClash and being torn between two worlds, fitting neither, is the main theme of Bruce Beresford's other works. It is worth noting Beresford wanted to make an adaptation (and direct it) of the novel the moment it was published.



* TranslationConvention: Played straight for French, which is mostly rendered in English (mostly by native French-speakers, too, interestingly enough). Averted for the indigenous languages.

to:

* StockSoundEffects: [[spoiler: When [=LaForgue=] and Daniel are forced into running the gauntlet by Iroquois, stock sounds of being hit are used. It fits the scene just as much as you expect]].
* ATasteOfTheLash: After witnessing Daniel and Annuka having sex and lusting over it, [=LaForgue=] takes off his robe and starts self-flagellating with a branch of a pine tree, praying for forgiveness for his carnal desires.
* TranslationConvention: Played straight for French, which Since there is mostly rendered in subtitled (for the most part) Algonquin and Mohawk spoken extensively by various characters, English (mostly by native French-speakers, too, interestingly enough). Averted spoken instead of French really stands out.
* {{Tsundere}}: Annuka goes in a loop consisting of indifference, malice and passion toward Daniel.
* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: We never learn what happened to [[spoiler: the rest of the party. The fate of Daniel and Annuka also remains unresolved]].
* WillNotTellALie: While his brutal honesty rubs people the wrong way most of the time, [=LaForgue=] never, ever tells a lie. Even when it would greatly simplify his life. Most importantly, he [[spoiler: informs the Hurons baptism won't cure them, but they might still ask Jesus
for help on their own]].
* WouldHurtAChild: [[spoiler: The Mohawk chief slash
the indigenous languages.throat of Chomina's son. Right in front of Chomina, who is strip naked and forced to continue singing as the boy bleeds to death]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved to Trivia


* FakeNationality: Many of the native characters, major, secondary and extras, were played by non-native actors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpiritualAntithesis: To the NobleSavage romanticism of ''DancesWithWolves''

to:

* SpiritualAntithesis: To the NobleSavage romanticism of ''DancesWithWolves''''Film/DancesWithWolves''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Jesuit missionary Father [=LaForgue=] is anxious to evangelize the indigenous peoples of 17th century interior Canada. He sets out from Quebec with the guidance of Chomina, an experienced Algonquin traveler, Chomina's family, several other natives and the non-Jesuit carpenter, Daniel. [=LaForgue=] struggles with his deeply-held religious convictions as he encounters a vast, alien landscape; meets various hostile natives and confronts cultural attitudes he fails to understand.

to:

Jesuit missionary Father [=LaForgue=] is anxious to evangelize the indigenous peoples of 17th century interior Canada. He sets out from Quebec with the guidance of Chomina, an experienced Algonquin traveler, Chomina's family, several other natives and the non-Jesuit carpenter, Daniel. [=LaForgue=] struggles with his deeply-held religious convictions as he encounters a vast, alien landscape; landscape, meets various hostile natives and confronts cultural attitudes he fails to understand.



* BigLittleMan: Father [=LaForgue=] is harangued by the shaman Mestigoit, who is filmed close to the camera -- it's only when he comes face-to-face with [=LaForgue=] (who is sitting down) that we realise how short he is.

to:

* BigLittleMan: Father [=LaForgue=] is harangued by the shaman Mestigoit, who is filmed close to the camera -- it's only when he comes face-to-face with [=LaForgue=] (who is sitting down) that we realise realize how short he is.



* DiesWideOpen: Lots of people

to:

* DiesWideOpen: Lots of peoplepeople.



* {{Fingore}}: All over the place

to:

* {{Fingore}}: All over the placeplace.



----

to:

----

Added: 169

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoingNative: Subverted. Daniel seems to be going down this road but after the horrific encounter with the Iroquois Chomina asks him:

to:

* GoingNative: Subverted. Daniel seems to be going down this road but after the horrific encounter with the Iroquois Chomina asks him:


Added DiffLines:

** Of course, at the end, he does go off with Annuka. And that's where the Metis come from.


Added DiffLines:

* SpiritualAntithesis: To the NobleSavage romanticism of ''DancesWithWolves''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InjunCountry: Averted
* MightyWhitey: It's a lot more subtle than you might expect for a film like this but it's the core of the message.

to:

* InjunCountry: Averted
Played more realistically, without the usual cliches.
* MightyWhitey: It's a lot more subtle than you might expect for a film Averted, with [=LaForgue=] realizing in the film's final scene that, if he wants to convert the Huron to Christianity, he needs to treat them like this but it's equals and not the core of the message.superstitious children they're often treated as.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!Provides Examples Of:

to:

!!Provides Examples Of:
!!This film provides examples of:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:300:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/blackrobe_8120.jpg]]

Jesuit missionary Father [=LaForgue=] is anxious to evangelize the indigenous peoples of 17th century interior Canada. He sets out from Quebec with the guidance of Chomina, an experienced Algonquin traveler, Chomina's family, several other natives and the non-Jesuit carpenter, Daniel. [=LaForgue=] struggles with his deeply-held religious convictions as he encounters a vast, alien landscape; meets various hostile natives and confronts cultural attitudes he fails to understand.

''Black Robe'' is a 1985 novel by Brian Moore. Moore also wrote the screenplay for the 1991 film of the same name.

This article mainly deals with the film.

----
!!Provides Examples Of:

* AlwaysChaoticEvil: Subverted. Daniel thinks this of the Iroquois. Chomina points out that that's just how life is there.
* AnnoyingArrows: Averted in cringe-inducing detail.
* BigLittleMan: Father [=LaForgue=] is harangued by the shaman Mestigoit, who is filmed close to the camera -- it's only when he comes face-to-face with [=LaForgue=] (who is sitting down) that we realise how short he is.
* BraidsBeadsAndBuckskins: The clothing of the natives and colonists is quite accurate.
* ClothingDamage: [=LaForgue=] and Daniel's clothes gradually get dirtied and torn. [=LaForgue=] tears up part of his robe to make a bandage for Chomina and Daniel is wearing buckskins almost exclusively by the end.
* CultureClash
* DiesWideOpen: Lots of people
* DreamingOfThingsToCome: As usual, quite prophetic. Chomina wishes he had acted upon them much sooner.
* EveryoneCallsHimBarkeep: The natives call the missionaries black robes due to their clothing. Once he leaves the colonial settlement [=LaForgue=] is almost exclusively referred to as "Black Robe". Daniel even calls him that once.
* {{Foreshadowing}}: Through the above-mentioned dreams.
* FakeNationality: Many of the native characters, major, secondary and extras, were played by non-native actors.
* {{Fingore}}: All over the place
* GoingNative: Subverted. Daniel seems to be going down this road but after the horrific encounter with the Iroquois Chomina asks him:
--> You want to be like us? What do you think now?
* IGaveMyWord: Several of Chomina's companions want to abandon or kill [=LaForgue=] and Daniel, but Chomina promised Champlain they'd be protected.
* IndianMaiden: Kind of. Annuka is TheChiefsDaughter who falls in love with a white man. However, she very much averts the DamselInDistress stereotype and is much more hot-headed and impatient than her father.
* InjunCountry: Averted
* MightyWhitey: It's a lot more subtle than you might expect for a film like this but it's the core of the message.
* TheMissionary
* NobleSavage: Subverted.
* NotSoDifferent: On a cultural level. Moore compares the superstition of the natives with the Catholic beliefs of the missionaries. In the film Daniel suggests this point to [=LaForgue=]. Visual juxtaposition to this effect is all over the place.
* TheQuest: Reaching the Huron mission.
* SceneryPorn: Wow, Canada.
* ShootTheShaggyDog
* TranslationConvention: Played straight for French, which is mostly rendered in English (mostly by native French-speakers, too, interestingly enough). Averted for the indigenous languages.
----

Top