Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanfic / WhatIfGineWentWithGokuToEarth

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvenBadMenLoveTheirMamas: Raditz has done years of work for the Frieza force with little complaint, and even in canon gives little thought for his brother Kakarot beyond how he can use him to get ahead. But meeting Gine again causes Raditz's resolve to collapse, and ultimately he decides to go on the run and spare his family.

to:

* EvenBadMenLoveTheirMamas: Raditz has done years of work for the Frieza force with little complaint, and even in canon gives little thought for his brother Kakarot beyond how he can use him to get ahead. But meeting Gine again causes Raditz's resolve to collapse, waver, and ultimately he decides to go on the run and spare his family.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvenBadMenLoveTheirMamas: Raditz has done years of work for the Frieza force with little complaint, and even in canon gives little thought for his brother Kakarot beyond how he can use him to get ahead. But meeting Gine again causes Raditz's resolve to collapse, and ultimately he decides to go on the run and spare his family.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the original Grandpa Gohan is killed when Goku indvertingly sees the moon one night, turns into an Oozaru and unwittingly crushes him in his rampage. In this rendition, thanks to Gine being there, she's able to calm Kakarot down when it happens and Gohan is spared his inital death. He manages to make it to the Buu Saga of ''Z'' before old age eventually catches up to him and he dies of natural causes, though he passes away peacefully.

to:

** In the original Grandpa Gohan is killed when Goku indvertingly sees the moon one night, turns into an Oozaru and unwittingly crushes him in his rampage. In this rendition, thanks to Gine being there, she's able to calm Kakarot down when it happens and Gohan is spared his inital death. He manages to make it to the Buu Saga of ''Z'' before [[LifeWillKillYou old age eventually catches up to him and he dies of natural causes, though he passes away peacefully.peacefully]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


An adaptation written by [=Meganechan720=] and read aloud by Lawrence on his personal streams can be found [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12929804/1/What-if-Gine-Went-with-Goku-to-Earth here]] for the story itself and [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84E0NGPXO5c&list=PLNSgpJTAeqwmaBJO_vHT-UvKxdFafcMht here]] for Masako's reading of it. A Dragon Ball FanWebcomic, ''Webcomic/DragonBallReboot'', explores a similar premise.

to:

An adaptation written by [=Meganechan720=] and read aloud by Lawrence on his personal streams can be found [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12929804/1/What-if-Gine-Went-with-Goku-to-Earth here]] for the story itself and [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84E0NGPXO5c&list=PLNSgpJTAeqwmaBJO_vHT-UvKxdFafcMht here]] for Masako's reading of it. A Dragon Ball FanWebcomic, fan-made webcomic, ''Webcomic/DragonBallReboot'', explores a similar premise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


An adaptation written by [=Meganechan720=] and read aloud by Lawrence on his personal streams can be found [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12929804/1/What-if-Gine-Went-with-Goku-to-Earth here]] for the story itself and [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84E0NGPXO5c&list=PLNSgpJTAeqwmaBJO_vHT-UvKxdFafcMht here]] for Masako's reading of it.

to:

An adaptation written by [=Meganechan720=] and read aloud by Lawrence on his personal streams can be found [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12929804/1/What-if-Gine-Went-with-Goku-to-Earth here]] for the story itself and [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84E0NGPXO5c&list=PLNSgpJTAeqwmaBJO_vHT-UvKxdFafcMht here]] for Masako's reading of it.
it. A Dragon Ball FanWebcomic, ''Webcomic/DragonBallReboot'', explores a similar premise.

Added: 157

Changed: 184

Removed: 130

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: Masako's reading of [=Meganechan720=]'s novelization of it is much more detailed than his original What If.



* AdaptationalNameChange: Or rather, canonical lack thereof. Because Gine is with him, Kakarot never gets named Goku and remains known only by his Saiyan name.

to:

* AdaptationalNameChange: AdaptationExpansion: Masako's reading of [=Meganechan720=]'s novelization of it is much more detailed than his original What If.
* AdaptationNameChange:
Or rather, canonical lack thereof. Because Gine is with him, Kakarot never gets named Goku and remains known only by his Saiyan name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Gine's relationship with Bardock. He may have found her cute, but he didn't love her; conversely, Gine is well aware that Bardock would regard her attempt to find a peaceful life on Earth with contempt, but she kills Dodoria on his behalf, then beats Vegeta to a bloody pulp for insulting him.

to:

** Gine's relationship with Bardock. He may have found her cute, but he didn't love her; conversely, Gine is well aware that Bardock would regard her attempt to find a peaceful life on Earth with contempt, but she kills Dodoria on his behalf, then beats Vegeta to a bloody pulp for insulting him. Subverted in the retcon/prequel "Part 0", where Bardock is shown to be genuinely fond of Gine. Though he blames her for giving birth to two weak sons, in the end he cares enough for her to tell her to hide and run before his suicidal charge on Frieza's forces.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Gine is subjected to this many times, due to her reluctance and peaceful personality. Foes who face Gine initially don't view her as much as a threat, only to be quickly silenced. King Piccolo, Vegeta, Frieza's soldiers, and even Frieza ''himself'' get victimized hard by this. Even ''Kakarot'' is stunned as child when he hears of his mother's true strength.

to:

** Gine is subjected to this many times, due to her reluctance and peaceful personality. Foes who face Gine initially don't view her as much as a threat, only to be quickly silenced. King Piccolo, Vegeta, Frieza's soldiers, and even Frieza ''himself'' get victimized hard by this. Even ''Kakarot'' is stunned as a child when he hears of his mother's true strength.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''What If Gine Went With Goku to Earth?'' is a ''Franchise/DragonBall'' WhatIf fanfic by Lawrence Simpson a.k.a. Creator/MasakoX of Creator/TeamFourStar fame as part of his Dragon Ball Discussion series of [=YouTube=] videos. This particular topic started on Mar 19, 2018 in response to the invention of Gine, Goku's mother, for ''Dragon Ball Minus''.

to:

''What If Gine Went With Goku to Earth?'' is a ''Franchise/DragonBall'' WhatIf fanfic by Lawrence Simpson a.k.a. Creator/MasakoX of Creator/TeamFourStar fame as part of his Dragon Ball Discussion series of [=YouTube=] videos. This particular topic started on Mar 19, 2018 in response to the invention of Gine, Goku's mother, for ''Dragon Ball Minus''.
Minus'', and is the eighteenth entry in the series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvenEvilHasStandards: In the novelization, Gine is shocked and repulsed when Vegeta kills Nappa for losing to Goku, citing that such a betrayal is monstrous even by ''Sayian'' moral codes and deciding that Vegeta has to be mad if he'd do something like that.

to:

* EvenEvilHasStandards: In the novelization, Gine is shocked and repulsed when Vegeta kills Nappa for losing to Goku, citing that such a betrayal is monstrous even by ''Sayian'' ''Saiyan'' moral codes and deciding that Vegeta has to be mad if he'd do something like that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CombinationAttack: Cell is killed by a Family Kamehameha, albeit with Gohan, Kakarot, Gine and Raditz, rather than Gohan, Goku and Goten.

to:

* CombinationAttack: Cell is killed by a Family Kamehameha, albeit with Gohan, Kakarot, Gine and Raditz, rather than Gohan, Goku Gohan and Goten.Goku.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvenEvilHasStandards: In the novelization, Gine is shocked and repulsed when Vegeta kills Nappa for losing to Goku, citing that such a betrayal is monstrous even by ''Sayian'' moral codes and deciding that Vegeta has to be mad if he'd do something like that.
-->For all that she had spent the last year hammering home how nasty Saiyans could be, she had forgotten that even they had lines they didn't cross. This was one of them.
-->But the Prince ''was'' mad, she realized. He was grinning up at the dissipating smoke overhead like he'd just done something amusing instead of something so monstrous even a Saiyan would be horrified.

Changed: 153

Removed: 473

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* RealityEnsues:
** Grandpa Gohan was already pretty old by the start of the story, by the time of the end of the Cell saga he was in his twilight years and his body eventually grew frail and ultimately passes away, albeit peacefully in this rendition.
** Gine is much older than Kakarot and Vegeta, as a result, her age eventually catches up to her. As a result, she largely sits out the Buu Saga and the following ones, settling to just be TheMentor for her grandchildren.



* RetiredBadass: Gine decides to retire from fighting after the Namek incident. It doesn't last thanks to [[ArcVillain Cell]].

to:

* RetiredBadass: Gine decides to retire from fighting after the Namek incident.incident and her age eventually catching up to her. She largely sits out the Buu Saga and the following ones, settling to just be TheMentor for her grandchildren. It doesn't last thanks to [[ArcVillain Cell]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Gine is much older than Kakarot and Vegeta, as a result her age eventually catches up to her. As a result, she largely sits out the Buu Segas and the following ones, settling to just be TheMentor for her grandchildren.

to:

** Gine is much older than Kakarot and Vegeta, as a result result, her age eventually catches up to her. As a result, she largely sits out the Buu Segas Saga and the following ones, settling to just be TheMentor for her grandchildren.

Added: 535

Changed: 45

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Gohan achieves Super Saiyan while they're training for the arrival of the Androids.

to:

** Gohan achieves Super Saiyan while they're the Z-Fighters are training for the arrival of the Androids.



** Kakarot is ''shocked'' to learn that his own mother easily defeated King Piccolo and realizes she is a ''far'' stronger fighter than him. Seeing as his mother never really showcased her power before (to that point Gine never participated in the World Martial Arts Tournament like he did).

to:

** Kakarot is ''shocked'' to learn that his own mother easily defeated King Piccolo and realizes she is a ''far'' stronger fighter than him. Seeing as his mother never really showcased her power before (to that point Gine never fought the Red Ribbon Army or participated in the World Martial Arts Tournament like he did).


Added DiffLines:

* SilkHidingSteel: Gine's kindhearted and motherly attitude hides her tremendous strength. In the days of ''Dragon Ball'', she's actually the most powerful fighter on Earth.


Added DiffLines:

** Gine is subjected to this many times, due to her reluctance and peaceful personality. Foes who face Gine initially don't view her as much as a threat, only to be quickly silenced. King Piccolo, Vegeta, Frieza's soldiers, and even Frieza ''himself'' get victimized hard by this. Even ''Kakarot'' is stunned as child when he hears of his mother's true strength.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheResenter: Vegeta, as per usual. Like in original story, this carries over into the Buu Saga when he becomes Majin Vegeta. Instead of attacking the World Martial Arts Tournament, he instead attacks Gine at Mount Paozu.

to:

* TheResenter: Vegeta, as per usual. Like in the original story, this carries over into the Buu Saga when he becomes Majin Vegeta. Instead of attacking the World Martial Arts Tournament, Tournament to goad Goku into fighting him, he instead attacks Gine at Mount Paozu.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Gohan achieves Super Saiyan while they were training for the arrival of the Androids.

to:

** Gohan achieves Super Saiyan while they were they're training for the arrival of the Androids.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RevisitingTheRoots: Vegeta's [[TheResenter hostility towards Gine]] has an undercurrent of sexism to it, which may be off-putting to fans of Vegeta. This characterization actually corresponds with his personality during the Android Saga towards Android 18. This, combined with Vegeta's resentment towards Goku in the original being projected onto Gine instead is what leads to their terrible relationship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwesomeButImpractical: As showcased in the original story, the Second Grade Super Saiyan form grants the user incredible power, at the cost of greater energy drain and reduced speed. To Gine's own personal dismay, it also causes greater emotional turmoil and further amplifies the violent BloodKnight nature of Saiyans, the very thing she was trying to avoid. As evident by her lashing out in response to Vegeta's BreakingSpeech.

to:

* AwesomeButImpractical: As showcased in the original story, the Second Grade Super Saiyan form grants the user incredible power, at the cost of greater energy drain and reduced speed. To Gine's own personal dismay, it also causes greater emotional turmoil and further amplifies the violent BloodKnight nature of Saiyans, the very thing she was trying to avoid. As avoid, as evident by her lashing out in response to Vegeta's BreakingSpeech.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WithholdingTheBigGood: Kid Goku/Kakarot still takes the helm for most of the adventure during the ''Dragon Ball'' era, until the [[KnightOfCerebus King Piccolo Saga]] kicks off. After Kakarot loses to King Piccolo the first time and left near-dead, Gine [[MamaBear steps in]] and wallops King Piccolo, allowing Master Roshi and Grandpa Gohan to re-seal him with Mafuba.

to:

* WithholdingTheBigGood: Kid Goku/Kakarot still takes the helm for most of the adventure during the ''Dragon Ball'' era, until the [[KnightOfCerebus King Piccolo Saga]] kicks off. After Kakarot loses to King Piccolo the first time and is left near-dead, Gine [[MamaBear steps in]] and wallops King Piccolo, allowing Master Roshi and Grandpa Gohan to re-seal him with Mafuba.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadassFamily: Gine's presence completely changes the fabric of the Son family. Goku/Kakarot is far stronger as a warrior, Chi-Chi remains a martial artist and [[TookALevelInBadass even joining the frontline ranks of the Z Fighters herself]], Gohan gains Super Saiyan much earlier, and her eldest son Raditz not only ''lives'' but also gains Super Saiyan as well. Best shown instead of a Father-Son Kamehameha, it's a ''Family Kamehameha'' that finishes Cell off.

to:

* BadassFamily: Gine's presence completely changes the fabric of the Son family. Goku/Kakarot is far stronger as a warrior, Chi-Chi remains a martial artist and [[TookALevelInBadass even joining joins the frontline ranks of the Z Fighters herself]], Gohan gains Super Saiyan much earlier, and her eldest son Raditz not only ''lives'' but also gains Super Saiyan as well. Best shown instead of a Father-Son Kamehameha, it's a ''Family Kamehameha'' that finishes Cell off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the original Grandpa Gohan is killed when Goku indvertingly sees the moon one night, turns into an Oozaru and unwittingly crushes him in his rampage. In this rendition, thanks to Gine being there, she's able to calm Kakarot down when it happens and Gohan is spared his inital death. He manages to make it to the Buu Saga of ''Z'' before old age eventually catches up to him and he dies of natural causes, though passes away peacefully.

to:

** In the original Grandpa Gohan is killed when Goku indvertingly sees the moon one night, turns into an Oozaru and unwittingly crushes him in his rampage. In this rendition, thanks to Gine being there, she's able to calm Kakarot down when it happens and Gohan is spared his inital death. He manages to make it to the Buu Saga of ''Z'' before old age eventually catches up to him and he dies of natural causes, though he passes away peacefully.

Added: 667

Changed: 572

Removed: 335

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rearranged tropes listed by alphabetical order.


* TenMinuteRetirement: After the climactic showdown with Freeza on Namek, Gine finally decides once and for all to retire from fighting and leave the protector job to her sons and grandchild. Her retirement is short-lived when [[Characters/DragonBallCell Imperfect Cell]], in search of a good food source and finding Gine's power appetizing, appears and attacks her in her home. After being rescued by Raditz, Gine is inspired by Raditz and Grandpa Gohan to [[HesBack stand up and fight once more]].



* TheMentor: Gine eventually retires and chooses to be Gohan and Goten's mentor after the Cell Sega. As a result, the two of them are far stronger by the Buu Sega.



* TenMinuteRetirement: After the climactic showdown with Freeza on Namek, Gine finally decides once and for all to retire from fighting and leave the protector job to her sons and grandchild. Her retirement is short-lived when [[Characters/DragonBallCell Imperfect Cell]], in search of a good food source and finding Gine's power appetizing, appears and attacks her in her home. After being rescued by Raditz, Gine is inspired by Raditz and Grandpa Gohan to [[HesBack stand up and fight once more]].
* TheMentor: Gine eventually retires and chooses to be Gohan and Goten's mentor after the Cell Sega. As a result, the two of them are far stronger by the Buu Sega.

to:

* TenMinuteRetirement: After the climactic showdown with Freeza on Namek, Gine finally decides once and for all to retire from fighting and leave the protector job to her sons and grandchild. Her retirement is short-lived when [[Characters/DragonBallCell Imperfect Cell]], in search of a good food source and finding Gine's power appetizing, appears and attacks her in her home. After being rescued by Raditz, Gine is inspired by {{Teleportation}}: Because Raditz settled on Yardrat and Grandpa Gohan to [[HesBack stand up and fight once more]].
* TheMentor: Gine eventually retires and chooses to be Gohan and Goten's mentor after
defended it, the Cell Sega. As a result, Yardrats taught him the two of them are far stronger by Instant Transmission technique. He is the Buu Sega.one who teaches it to Kakarot.



* {{Teleportation}}: Because Raditz settled on Yardrat and defended it, the Yardrats taught him the Instant Transmission technique. He is the one who teaches it to Kakarot.



** Then it's flipped when Vegeta provokes Gine into lashing out at him by insulting Bardock, and once she does, declares that the Saiyan pride and warrior spirit she claimed to deny in lieu of peace and kindness is something she can never get away from.

to:

** Then it's flipped when Vegeta provokes Gine into lashing out at him by insulting Bardock, and once she does, declares that the Saiyan pride and warrior spirit she claimed to deny in lieu of peace and kindness is something she can never get away from.from.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

->''"I guess you could call this a… a family vacation?"''
-->--'''Creator/MasakoX'''

Added: 587

Changed: 439

Removed: 146

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** King Cold is assassinated by Kakarot and Raditz in his home.
** Dr. Gero is killed by Raditz before he can escape and release Android 17 and 18.



* DiesDifferentlyInAdaptation: In the original Grandpa Gohan is killed when Goku indvertingly sees the moon one night, turns into an Oozaru and unwittingly crushes him in his rampage. In this rendition, thanks to Gine being there, she's able to calm Kakarot down when it happens and Gohan is spared his inital death. He manages to make it to the Buu Saga of ''Z'' before old age eventually catches up to him and he dies of natural causes, though passes away peacefully.

to:

* DiesDifferentlyInAdaptation: DiesDifferentlyInAdaptation:
**
In the original Grandpa Gohan is killed when Goku indvertingly sees the moon one night, turns into an Oozaru and unwittingly crushes him in his rampage. In this rendition, thanks to Gine being there, she's able to calm Kakarot down when it happens and Gohan is spared his inital death. He manages to make it to the Buu Saga of ''Z'' before old age eventually catches up to him and he dies of natural causes, though passes away peacefully. peacefully.
** King Cold is assassinated by Kakarot and Raditz in his home.
** Dr. Gero is killed by Raditz before he can escape and release Android 17 and 18.

Top