Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanfic / ItFeelsMoreLikeAMemory

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Removed: 1033

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* TriangRelations: The following examples are in chronological order.
** Type Four: Eliza wants Aaron, who only wants her friendship and is in a romantic relationship with Alexander.
** Type Seven: Aaron marries Eliza at Alexander and the Schuylers’ behest, but still loves Alexander, who loves him back. He doesn’t quite love her, but also doesn’t not love her. Some may feel the “doesn’t quite love” part makes this still a Type Four despite the marriage and the “doesn’t not love part.”
** [[spoiler:Type Eight: Unbeknownst to the still-married Aaron who still loves Alexander, Alexander has sex with Eliza in an attempt to ruin Aaron’s marriage out of jealousy and hope that the ruined marriage will send Aaron back to him. If you don’t count sex as enough to make a mutual connection between Alexander and Eliza, this is either a Type Seven or Type Four depending on how you judged the above bullet point, but it still evolves into a Type Eight because Alexander eventually falls for Eliza and she him, and both still love Aaron.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Direct link.


* {{Seer}}: Aaron Burr can see future events, as could some other [[HistoricalDomainCharacter Historical Domain Characters]] who came before him, most importantly Joan of Arc.

to:

* {{Seer}}: {{Seers}}: Aaron Burr can see future events, as could some other [[HistoricalDomainCharacter Historical Domain Characters]] who came before him, most importantly Joan of Arc.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MentalTimeTravel: Part of how the lifetimes work in this story. When Aaron [[ResurrectionDeathLoop dies and starts a new lifetime]], he ends up back on the day he was born, as a newborn baby, and still has a baby brain that needs time to develop before he can walk and talk. Not a perfect transferring of the mind over time. However, he also [[RippleEffectProofMemory keeps all his memories from past time loops]], including ones that happened in that loop's 1800 or so (Aaron's a 1750s kid). [[spoiler:Later experiments with Benjamin Franklin reveal that though his mind doesn't perfectly transfer over time, his memories do: he has perfect recall of every loop he completed before.]] This mitigates some of the imperfect mental transfer, greatly accelerating his re-learning of things he already knew like how to read and write.


Added DiffLines:

* ResurrectionDeathLoop: After Aaron dies, he’ll wake up again as a baby. He often thinks it's a curse or punishment from God, but whatever it is he's pretty sure that it has to do with having to suffer through a death and remember how the death felt. He thinks it's a finite experience though, [[spoiler:and WordOfGod [[https://archiveofourown.org/comments/83891392 confirms]] [[https://archiveofourown.org/comments/81890599 he's]] [[https://archiveofourown.org/comments/88274770 right]] in the chapter 28 comments]].


Added DiffLines:

* RetroactivePrecognition: Aaron's memories of previous lifetimes allow him to know how certain events will play out, provided he didn't change anything relevant to those events.


Added DiffLines:

* RippleEffectProofMemory: Aaron keeps all his memories from past time loops.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShowWithinAShow: Musicals within a fanfiction, and fanfiction within a fanfiction. In universe of the fanfiction ''it feels more like a memory'', the second timeline has the musical ''Fanfic/{{Hamilton}}'', and the third timeline has ''Fanfic/BurrAnAmericanMusical'' and many fanfics based on that musical, one called ''Fanfic/IfTheresAReason''.

to:

* ShowWithinAShow: Musicals within a fanfiction, and fanfiction within a fanfiction. In the universe of the fanfiction ''it feels more like a memory'', the second timeline has the musical ''Fanfic/{{Hamilton}}'', and the third timeline has ''Fanfic/BurrAnAmericanMusical'' and many fanfics based on ''Fanfic/BurrAnAmericanMusical''. In-Universe, people wrote fanfic of that musical, one called with the In-Universe savrenim of the third timeline writing ''Fanfic/IfTheresAReason''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DifferentWorldDifferentMovies: The second and third timeline still have an equivalent to the real-life ''Hamilton'' musical (one also titled ''Fanfic/{{Hamilton}}'' and one titled ''Fanfic/BurrAnAmericanMusical'']], respectively). However, the actual events shown are different, given what happened in those timelines differs from what happened in real life. The third timeline also has an equivalent to the real-life ''Hamilton'' fanfic written by savrenim titled ''it feels more like a memory'': a ''Burr: An American Musical'' fanfic written by savrenim titled ''Fanfic/IfTheresAReason''. Again, the fic's events are different because what happened in the third timeline, and thus what the musical's events are, are different from what happened in real life.

to:

* DifferentWorldDifferentMovies: The second and third timeline still have an equivalent to the real-life ''Hamilton'' musical (one also titled ''Fanfic/{{Hamilton}}'' and one titled ''Fanfic/BurrAnAmericanMusical'']], ''Fanfic/BurrAnAmericanMusical'', respectively). However, the actual events shown are different, given what happened in those timelines differs from what happened in real life. The third timeline also has an equivalent to the real-life ''Hamilton'' fanfic written by savrenim titled ''it feels more like a memory'': a ''Burr: An American Musical'' fanfic written by savrenim titled ''Fanfic/IfTheresAReason''. Again, the fic's events are different because what happened in the third timeline, and thus what the musical's events are, are different from what happened in real life.



* ShowWithinAShow: The InUniverse versions of the musicals the fic author wrote for Aaron's second and third lifetime.

to:

* ShowWithinAShow: The InUniverse versions Musicals within a fanfiction, and fanfiction within a fanfiction. In universe of the musicals fanfiction ''it feels more like a memory'', the fic author wrote for Aaron's second timeline has the musical ''Fanfic/{{Hamilton}}'', and the third lifetime.timeline has ''Fanfic/BurrAnAmericanMusical'' and many fanfics based on that musical, one called ''Fanfic/IfTheresAReason''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SparedByTheAdaptation: Downplayed. Aaron’s grandfather and grandmother consistently live longer than they did in reality in every single lifetime: instead of both dying when Aaron is 2, his grandmother dies when he’s 4 and his grandfather dies when he’s 8.
-->welcome to the ''it feels more like a memory'' timeline, where everything is very similar to our own history except Johnathan Edwards and his wife get a couple more years of life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A musical also titled ''Fanfic/{{Hamilton}}'' ([[https://savrenim.tumblr.com/post/154913162666/wheeee-mkay-latest-anon-so-i-am-paranoid-about link]] and ([[http://web.archive.org/web/20210112153112/https://savrenim.tumblr.com/post/154913162666/wheeee-mkay-latest-anon-so-i-am-paranoid-about mirror]]), based on events from ''it feels more like a memory'' long after everyone in the fic had died and the events became historical ones. The actual musical hasn’t been written out of universe, just a synopsis and various facts about it, which is what’s linked. Spoils up to the end of chapter 27.

to:

* A musical also titled ''Fanfic/{{Hamilton}}'' ([[https://savrenim.tumblr.com/post/154913162666/wheeee-mkay-latest-anon-so-i-am-paranoid-about link]] and ([[http://web.[[http://web.archive.org/web/20210112153112/https://savrenim.tumblr.com/post/154913162666/wheeee-mkay-latest-anon-so-i-am-paranoid-about mirror]]), based on events from ''it feels more like a memory'' long after everyone in the fic had died and the events became historical ones. The actual musical hasn’t been written out of universe, just a synopsis and various facts about it, which is what’s linked. Spoils up to the end of chapter 27.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DaddyDNATest: Way after the fic’s events became historical events In-Universe, one of these was conducted around 1985 where [[spoiler:[=DNA=] from the descendants of Aaron’s cousins got compared to [=DNA=] of descendants of the Burr kids Aaron and Eliza raised, proving the Burr kids besides Angie were biologically Alexander’s. Angie didn’t leave behind any descendants so her parentage can’t be proven In-Universe that way, though WordOfGod leaves it ambiguous if they dug up her body for another way to test her parentage through [=DNA=]. WordOfGod says she’s biologically Aaron’s]]. This creates lots of In-Universe controversy over whether the non-biological father was aware the kids weren’t biologically his.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HypotheticalCasting: The cast for the two InUniverse musicals. The same people from ''Hamilton'' are still in these two musicals, although the characters they play sometimes don’t match who they played in real life. For example, Creator/PhillipaSoo, who played Eliza in the real-life version of ''Hamilton'' plays Dolley Madison in ''Burr: An American Musical''.

Changed: 944

Removed: 428

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllMusicalsAreAdaptations: The [[SelfAdaptation author of this fic adapted the events of Aaron's second and third lifetimes into musicals]], making two fanfiction-to-musical adaptations. The InUniverse versions of these musicals are also adaptations, albeit [[ATrueStoryInMyUniverse historical-event-to-musical adaptations]].
* AllThereInTheManual: Both the works with the ''Fanfic/{{Hamilton}}'' and ''Fanfic/BurrAnAmericanMusical'' musicals include canon details that didn’t make it to the fic about how people in 21st century of the second and third timeline interpret the events of the life Aaron lived in that timeline, and the musicals’ production and reception. ''Burr: An American Musical'' also details [[spoiler:Jefferson’s impeachment trial]].

to:

* AllMusicalsAreAdaptations: The [[SelfAdaptation author of this fic adapted the events of Aaron's second and third lifetimes into musicals]], making two fanfiction-to-musical adaptations. The InUniverse versions of these musicals are also adaptations, albeit [[ATrueStoryInMyUniverse historical-event-to-musical adaptations]].
* AllThereInTheManual: Both the works with the ''Fanfic/{{Hamilton}}'' and ''Fanfic/BurrAnAmericanMusical'' musicals include canon details that didn’t make it to the fic about how people in 21st century of the second and third timeline interpret the events of the life Aaron lived in that timeline, and the musicals’ production and reception.reception, and other details about their respective timeline that didn't make it to the fic. ''Burr: An American Musical'' also details [[spoiler:Jefferson’s impeachment trial]].



* DifferentWorldDifferentMovies: The second and third timeline still have an equivalent to the real-life ''Hamilton'' musical ([[https://savrenim.tumblr.com/post/154913162666/wheeee-mkay-latest-anon-so-i-am-paranoid-about one also titled ''Hamilton'']] and [[https://archiveofourown.org/works/10308764/chapters/22794623 one titled ''Burr: An American Musical'']], respectively). Both timeline equivalents were made by the same creators, including the actors, from the ''Hamilton'' musical. However, the actual events shown are different, given what happened in those timelines differs from what happened in real life. The third timeline also has an equivalent to the real-life ''Hamilton'' fanfic written by savrenim titled ''it feels more like a memory'': a ''Burr: An American Musical'' fanfic written by savrenim titled [[https://savrenim.tumblr.com/post/158449285416 ''if there's a reason'']]. Again, the fic's events are different because what happened in the third timeline, and thus what the musical's events are, are different from what happened in real life.

to:

* DifferentWorldDifferentMovies: The second and third timeline still have an equivalent to the real-life ''Hamilton'' musical ([[https://savrenim.tumblr.com/post/154913162666/wheeee-mkay-latest-anon-so-i-am-paranoid-about one (one also titled ''Hamilton'']] ''Fanfic/{{Hamilton}}'' and [[https://archiveofourown.org/works/10308764/chapters/22794623 one titled ''Burr: An American Musical'']], respectively). Both timeline equivalents were made by the same creators, including the actors, from the ''Hamilton'' musical.''Fanfic/BurrAnAmericanMusical'']], respectively). However, the actual events shown are different, given what happened in those timelines differs from what happened in real life. The third timeline also has an equivalent to the real-life ''Hamilton'' fanfic written by savrenim titled ''it feels more like a memory'': a ''Burr: An American Musical'' fanfic written by savrenim titled [[https://savrenim.tumblr.com/post/158449285416 ''if there's a reason'']].''Fanfic/IfTheresAReason''. Again, the fic's events are different because what happened in the third timeline, and thus what the musical's events are, are different from what happened in real life.

Added: 346

Changed: 594

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllThereInTheManual: ''Burr: An American Musical'' has canon details that didn’t make it to the fic, especially about [[spoiler:Jefferson’s impeachment trial]].
* AllThereInTheScript: The only part of Aaron's grandfather's name found directly in the fic is his surname, Edwards. The author's notes after the end of chapter 36 gives his full name, Jonathan Edwards.

to:

* AllThereInTheManual: Both the works with the ''Fanfic/{{Hamilton}}'' and ''Fanfic/BurrAnAmericanMusical'' musicals include canon details that didn’t make it to the fic about how people in 21st century of the second and third timeline interpret the events of the life Aaron lived in that timeline, and the musicals’ production and reception. ''Burr: An American Musical'' has canon also details that didn’t make it to the fic, especially about [[spoiler:Jefferson’s impeachment trial]].
* AllThereInTheScript: AllThereInTheScript:
** [[https://archiveofourown.org/comments/84252469 This]] comment names [[spoiler:the slave Thomas Jefferson sent to collect Aaron in chapter 30: James Hemmings]].
**
The only part of Aaron's grandfather's name found directly in the fic is his surname, Edwards. The author's notes after the end of chapter 36 gives his full name, Jonathan Edwards.



* SuperRegistrationAct: At least in America, Seers are required to reveal themselves to their country’s government during wartime, otherwise they’re committing treason, and it’s based off of a similar law in Britain. WordOfGod also [[https://archiveofourown.org/comments/84320524 says]] most countries have a law where Seers have to declare themselves to the government.

to:

* SuperRegistrationAct: At least in America, Seers are required to reveal themselves to their country’s government during wartime, otherwise they’re committing treason, and it’s based off of a similar law in Britain.Britain[[note]]Can be found in the fic itself but also confirmed by WordOfGod [[https://archiveofourown.org/comments/84252469 here]][[/note]]. WordOfGod also [[https://archiveofourown.org/comments/84320524 says]] most countries have a law where Seers have to declare themselves to the government.

Added: 375

Changed: 323

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** InUniverse events pre-Aaron Burr proceeded just like real history, even though Seers existed throughout. Any changes are more akin to RealEventFictionalCause, where the event plays out just the same but there's an extra reason for it. Even that might not count, because she claimed to have visions of saints in real life in a time period where religion was taken very seriously, and that's also how her power manifested in this story. All the new events pre-Burr that happened differently than real life because Seers exist are 1) as a consequence of Joan of Arc, Britain set up a way to confirm someone as a Seer so they might know the next time a Seer comes around and 2) Seers are an object of study, and there are debates about who was a Seer.

to:

** InUniverse events pre-Aaron Burr proceeded just like real history, even though Seers existed throughout. Any changes are more akin to RealEventFictionalCause, where the event plays out just the same but there's an extra reason for it. Even that might not count, it, like [[https://archiveofourown.org/comments/89971694 people being even more set on conducting the Salem Witch Trials]] because she claimed to have visions of saints in real life in a time period where religion was taken very seriously, when Seers exist and that's also how her society thinks [[ReligionIsMagic their power manifested in this story.comes from God]], impersonating one is seen as more severe. All the new events pre-Burr that happened differently than real life because Seers exist are 1) as a consequence of Joan of Arc, Britain set up a way to confirm someone as a Seer so they might know the next time a Seer comes around and 2) Seers are an object of study, and there are debates about who was a Seer.


Added DiffLines:

** According to WordOfGod [[https://archiveofourown.org/comments/89971694 here]], the Salem Witch Trials still happened, there was just an extra reason for the people of the time to think of them as legitimate: Seers are real. Since they [[ReligionIsMagic saw a Seer’s power as God-given]], people impersonating Seers or doing witchcraft would be seen as an even worse thing.

Top