History DethroningMoment / WebOriginal

25th Jul '16 10:17:26 PM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider's [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes]] was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the Powerpuff Girls reboot isn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every Scooby-Doo remake in existence!]] Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. And he makes it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater ("If you don't think these [[insert topic of the list here]] are bad, that's great! It's just my silly personal opinion. And I'm glad you can enjoy these [[topic of the list]] while I can't.") But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "the series won't just die already!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is STILL going after 40 years. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, but I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place it at #1 on a "Worst Remakes" list and bash it simply because of that one fact. Someone in the comments section called him out on this and even accused him of only including all of the remakes simply he didn't like the original (he never replied). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".

to:

* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider's [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes]] was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the Powerpuff Girls reboot isn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every Scooby-Doo remake in existence!]] Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. And he makes it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater ("If you don't think these [[insert topic of the list here]] are bad, that's great! It's just my silly personal opinion. And I'm glad you can enjoy these [[topic of the list]] while I can't.") But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "the series won't just die already!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is STILL still going after 40 years. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, but I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place it at #1 on a "Worst Remakes" list and bash it simply because of that one fact. Someone in the comments section called him out on this and even accused him of only including all of the remakes simply he didn't like the original (he never replied). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".
25th Jul '16 10:14:19 PM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider's [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes]] was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the Powerpuff Girls reboot isn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:''every Scooby-Doo remake in existence!'']] Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. And he makes it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater ("If you don't think these [[insert topic of the list here]] are bad, that's great! It's just my silly personal opinion. And I'm glad you can enjoy these [[topic of the list]] while I can't.") But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "the series won't just die already!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is STILL going after 40 years. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, but I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place it at #1 on a "Worst Remakes" list and bash it simply because of that ONE fact. Someone in the comments section called him out on this and even accused him of only including all of the remakes simply he didn't like the original (he never replied). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".

to:

* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider's [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes]] was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the Powerpuff Girls reboot isn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:''every [[spoiler:every Scooby-Doo remake in existence!'']] existence!]] Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. And he makes it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater ("If you don't think these [[insert topic of the list here]] are bad, that's great! It's just my silly personal opinion. And I'm glad you can enjoy these [[topic of the list]] while I can't.") But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "the series won't just die already!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is STILL going after 40 years. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, but I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place it at #1 on a "Worst Remakes" list and bash it simply because of that ONE one fact. Someone in the comments section called him out on this and even accused him of only including all of the remakes simply he didn't like the original (he never replied). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".
25th Jul '16 10:09:31 PM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider's [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes]] was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the Powerpuff Girls reboot isn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:''every Scooby-Doo remake in existence!'']] Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. And he makes it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater ("If you don't think these [[insert topic of the list here]] are bad, that's great! It's just my silly personal opinion. And I'm glad you can enjoy these [[topic of the list]] while I can't.") But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "the series won't just die already!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is STILL going after 40 years. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, but I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place it at #1 on a "Worst Remakes" list and bash it simply because of that ONE fact. Someone in the comments section called him out on this and even accused him of only including all of the remakes simply he didn't like the original (he never replied). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".
25th Jul '16 5:50:37 PM Ferot_Dreadnaught
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/{{Jonn}}: ''anachronauts'' arc 3, fs03. The female elf Nel was rescued by and fell in love with space-girl Una, [[IncompatibleOrientation who is straight]]. Okay, plenty of healthy relationships have grown out of a RescueRomance. She doesn't tell her. Okay, that's reasonable. Nel [[http://xkcd.com/513/ decides to devote her life to being Una's best friend]]. [[UnfortunateImplications Um, what?]] Nel never gets any significant characterization, background, or personality traits other than being in love with Una. [[SatelliteLoveInterest Hmm]]. [[spoiler:Nel is tempted by a genie to kill one of the other Anachronauts in order to have Una. She refuses, saying that she'd rather have Una naturally. [[GenreSavvy You go, girl]]. And then in fs03, Una gets her hands on the sense-recording earrings Nel has been wearing since the beginning of the arc, and is able to effectively be Nel as she talked to the Genie, including her declaration of love. She re-evaluates her interactions with Nel, and then instantly realizes she loves her. Please note that Una has been exclusively heterosexual up to this point, and realizing she likes girls in general and loves Nel in particular is portrayed as [[SuddenlySexuality basically flipping a switch]]. Oh, and the author pretty clearly [[AuthorAppeal has a fetish for lesbians]], as it popped up in his earlier ''SailorNothing'', and in an aside in arc 2. Their friendship is written as exactly that; a friendship, with no romantic or sexual tension. Compared to the other romances in the series, which are written much more organically, it seems more like a StrangledByTheRedString RomanticPlotTumor than an actual romance. Nel and Una are given some "private time" at the end of that chapter, which would be ideal for showing their conversation before the inevitable sex and underlining the fact that they actually do have feelings for each other, except we never get to see it.]] Did I mention that there had been no other significant LGBT characters in the series up to that point? Yes, that's right, the only known homosexual is there for solely for the purpose of FetishFuel. It's kinda creepy, and I couldn't read the series after that.

to:

* Tropers/{{Jonn}}: ''anachronauts'' arc 3, fs03. The female elf Nel was rescued by and fell in love with space-girl Una, [[IncompatibleOrientation who is straight]]. Okay, plenty of healthy relationships have grown out of a RescueRomance. She doesn't tell her. Okay, that's reasonable. Nel [[http://xkcd.com/513/ decides to devote her life to being Una's best friend]]. [[UnfortunateImplications Um, what?]] Nel never gets any significant characterization, background, or personality traits other than being in love with Una. [[SatelliteLoveInterest Hmm]]. [[spoiler:Nel is tempted by a genie to kill one of the other Anachronauts in order to have Una. She refuses, saying that she'd rather have Una naturally. [[GenreSavvy You go, girl]].girl. And then in fs03, Una gets her hands on the sense-recording earrings Nel has been wearing since the beginning of the arc, and is able to effectively be Nel as she talked to the Genie, including her declaration of love. She re-evaluates her interactions with Nel, and then instantly realizes she loves her. Please note that Una has been exclusively heterosexual up to this point, and realizing she likes girls in general and loves Nel in particular is portrayed as [[SuddenlySexuality basically flipping a switch]]. Oh, and the author pretty clearly [[AuthorAppeal has a fetish for lesbians]], as it popped up in his earlier ''SailorNothing'', and in an aside in arc 2. Their friendship is written as exactly that; a friendship, with no romantic or sexual tension. Compared to the other romances in the series, which are written much more organically, it seems more like a StrangledByTheRedString RomanticPlotTumor than an actual romance. Nel and Una are given some "private time" at the end of that chapter, which would be ideal for showing their conversation before the inevitable sex and underlining the fact that they actually do have feelings for each other, except we never get to see it.]] Did I mention that there had been no other significant LGBT characters in the series up to that point? Yes, that's right, the only known homosexual is there for solely for the purpose of FetishFuel. It's kinda creepy, and I couldn't read the series after that.
24th Jul '16 8:58:24 PM lolface123
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Lolface123: Webvideo/GameChap was one of the best YouTube channels I had set my eyes upon. I enjoyed their videos thoroughly, their YeOldeButcheredeEnglishe and funny antics managing to make me crack a smile through even a hard day. However, that all changed when the clickbait began rolling in. At first I thought it was nothing and that it was simply nothing more than a phase, if you could call it that. But it kept persisting, over and over and over. And then when I found out about their activities as [[ScrewTheRulesIMakeThem head moderator]] [[TheCaligula on their own forums]], up to and including banning people for no reason whatsoever and both disrespecting and downgrading them, for what seemed to me purely in the name of ego, I was [[TranquilFury livid]]. For I had a small-time hobby in literature on the side, but despite that I made people welcome, appreciated, respected, regardless of who they were. And then I [[BerserkButton see the direct inverse of what is happening.]] All in the sake of some vicious egotist who [[StupidEvil doesn't even give off the pretension that he cares about it afterwards.]] I quickly withdrew my contribution of the subscriber count in disgust. I still visit his profile occasionally, hoping that he decides to once again engage in narcissistic stupidity so that someone with more sway over YouTube clips his wings for good.

to:

* Lolface123: Webvideo/GameChap was one of the best YouTube channels I had set my eyes upon. I enjoyed their videos thoroughly, their YeOldeButcheredeEnglishe and funny antics managing to make me crack a smile through even a hard day. However, that all changed when the clickbait began rolling in. At first I thought it was nothing and that it was simply nothing more than a phase, if you could call it that. But it kept persisting, over and over and over. And then when I found out about their activities as [[ScrewTheRulesIMakeThem head moderator]] [[TheCaligula on their own forums]], up to and including banning people for no reason whatsoever and both disrespecting and downgrading them, for what seemed to me purely in the name of ego, I was [[TranquilFury livid]]. For I had a small-time hobby in literature on the side, but despite that I made people welcome, appreciated, respected, regardless of who they were. And then I [[BerserkButton see the direct inverse of what is happening.]] All in the sake of some vicious egotist who [[StupidEvil doesn't even give off the pretension that he cares about it afterwards.afterwards, even when the consequences could mean the end for his channel.]] I quickly withdrew my contribution of the subscriber count in disgust. I still visit his profile occasionally, hoping that he decides to once again engage in narcissistic malicious stupidity so that someone with more sway over YouTube clips his wings for good.
24th Jul '16 8:54:19 PM lolface123
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Lolface123: Webvideo/GameChap was one of the best YouTube channels I had set my eyes upon. I enjoyed their videos thoroughly, their YeOldeButcheredeEnglishe and funny antics managing to make me crack a smile through even a hard day. However, that all changed when the clickbait began rolling in. At first I thought it was nothing and that it was simply nothing more than a phase, if you could call it that. But it kept persisting, over and over and over. And then when I found out about their activities as [[ScrewTheRulesIMakeThem head moderator]] [[TheCaligula on their own forums]], up to and including banning people for no reason whatsoever and both disrespecting and downgrading them, for what seemed to me purely in the name of ego, I was [[TranquilFury livid]]. For I had a small-time hobby in literature on the side, but despite that I made people welcome, appreciated, respected, regardless of who they were. And then I [[BerserkButton see the direct inverse of what is happening.]] All in the sake of some vicious egotist who [[StupidEvil doesn't even give off the pretension that he cares about it afterwards.]] I quickly withdrew my contribution of the subscriber count in disgust. I still visit his profile occasionally, hoping that he decides to once again engage in narcissistic stupidity so that someone with more sway over YouTube clips his wings for good.
24th Jul '16 8:30:32 PM lolface123
Is there an issue? Send a Message
24th Jul '16 8:27:41 PM lolface123
Is there an issue? Send a Message
20th Jul '16 9:41:21 PM Loekman3
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* The moments must pertain to the creator's own works. Any moments on the author themselves or a personal experience with them is considered a [[Administrivia/NoRealLifeExamplesPlease Real Life example]] and will be cut.

to:

* The moments must pertain to the creator's own works.Creator's works only. Any moments on the author themselves or a personal experience with them is considered a [[Administrivia/NoRealLifeExamplesPlease Real Life example]] and will be cut.
20th Jul '16 11:03:42 AM Sammettik
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Blazer: One of their most recent lists, Top 10 {{Magical Girl}}s in Anime, is painful and rife with mistakes on all ends. Their main rule is "magical girl in the traditional sense", which disqualifies wizards and witches... yet somehow friggin' [[Manga/CardcaptorSakura Sakura Kinomoto herself]] is on the list as well as the characters from ''Anime/FateKaleidLinerPrismaIllya'' while people will happily declare that those like [[Manga/FairyTail Ezra Scarlet]] and the heroines of ''Manga/MagicKnightRayearth'' don't count. They include Manga/CuteyHoney despite the fact that she's an android that uses undefined {{Phlebotinum}} and [[Anime/RevolutionaryGirlUtena Utena Tenjou]] who isn't actually a Magical Girl. Then, there's the entry for [[Anime/MagicalGirlLyricalNanoha Nanoha Takamachi]], where the narrator describes the original storyline while showing scenes from [=StrikerS=] which showcase scenes with ''Subaru''!

to:

* Blazer: One of their most recent lists, Top 10 {{Magical Girl}}s in Anime, Anime is painful and rife with mistakes on all ends. Their main rule is "magical girl in the traditional sense", which disqualifies wizards and witches... yet somehow friggin' [[Manga/CardcaptorSakura Sakura Kinomoto herself]] is on the list as well as the characters from ''Anime/FateKaleidLinerPrismaIllya'' while people will happily declare that those like [[Manga/FairyTail Ezra Scarlet]] and the heroines of ''Manga/MagicKnightRayearth'' don't count. They include Manga/CuteyHoney despite the fact that she's an android that uses undefined {{Phlebotinum}} and [[Anime/RevolutionaryGirlUtena Utena Tenjou]] who isn't actually a Magical Girl. Then, there's the entry for [[Anime/MagicalGirlLyricalNanoha Nanoha Takamachi]], where the narrator describes the original storyline while showing scenes from [=StrikerS=] which showcase scenes with ''Subaru''!
This list shows the last 10 events of 1875. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=DethroningMoment.WebOriginal