Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ComicBook / TheSculptor

Go To

OR

Removed: 1069

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Names The Same is now a disambiguation


* [[invoked]]NamesTheSame:
** The first chapter is called "The Other David Smith". David gets confused with the ''other'' [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Smith_%28sculptor%29 David Smith]], RealLife Abstract Expressionist sculptor, and becomes quite irate with a waitress who mistakes him for the real-life David Smith, who ''also'' shares his name with her cousin.
** During David's darkest hour, he looks up his name in a phone book and sees ''dozens'' of David Smiths, making himself feel even more insignificant.
** After the protagonist becomes wanted by the law, the detective assigned to the case is... Detective David Smith. He admits that he was put on this case as a joke by his coworkers.
*** [[spoiler: This becomes poignant at the very end, as CNN accidentally report that the detective has fallen to his death. The last line of the book is Detective Smith's wife saying "David! Oh, thank god...[[MeaningfulEcho you're alive]]." This mirrors what Meg said after feeling David's heartbeat earlier in the book after they both almost fall to their deaths.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FetishesAreWeird: After [[ABirthdayNotABreak his depressing birthday]], David seemingly encounters a mysterious crowd and an angel who tells him everything will be alright. Unfortunately, at a party that night he discovers the miracle was actually a viral stunt, and his awe of the experience is shattered as the FX supervisor takes him aside and asks him anxiously if David thought the angel's actor wearing [[ZettaiRyouiki thigh-high socks]] was too fetishy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlotArmor: Averted; David can die before his 200 day deadline arrives; having a death clock doesn't make him immortal until time's up. [[spoiler:He dies on day 195 after being shot by an NYPD cop]]. No one else is safe either, [[spoiler:not even Meg.]]

to:

* PlotArmor: Averted; David can die before his 200 day deadline arrives; having a death clock doesn't make him immortal until time's up. [[spoiler:He dies on day 195 after being shot by an NYPD a cop]]. No one else is safe either, [[spoiler:not even Meg.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ExperimentedInCollege: A lame joke from David accidentally reveals that Meg's roommate Sam had a lesbian experience with her. Sam is still bitter that it was only a one night stand, Meg apologizing that she was just very drunk that night.

to:

* ExperimentedInCollege: A lame joke from David accidentally reveals that Meg's roommate Sam had a lesbian gay experience with her. Sam is still bitter that it was only a one night stand, Meg apologizing that she was just very drunk that night.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixing typo


* InformedJudaism: Both David are Meg are secular Jews. It doesn't affect their lives much, except that they celebrate Passover and Hanukkah.

to:

* InformedJudaism: Both David are and Meg are secular Jews. It doesn't affect their lives much, except that they celebrate Passover and Hanukkah.

Added: 162

Changed: 85

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOut: A banner outside the art museum reads [[Music/TheyMightBeGiants "Meet James Ensor"]].

to:

* ShoutOut: ShoutOut:
**
A banner outside the art museum reads [[Music/TheyMightBeGiants "Meet James Ensor"]].Ensor"]].
** A real estate company is named [[Literature/FightClub Durden & Tyler]].

Added: 159

Removed: 159

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AffablyEvil: Death, who is both friendly and comforting to David even though he's a (mostly) unfeeling force, and probably the closest to the story's BigBad.



* AffablyEvil: Death, who is both friendly and comforting to David even though he's a (mostly) unfeeling force, and probably the closest to the story's BigBad.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[BeatPanel]]\\

to:

[[BeatPanel]]\\''(BeatPanel)''\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[{{beat panel}}]]\\

to:

[[{{beat panel}}]]\\[[BeatPanel]]\\

Added: 170

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[{{beat panel}}]]\\

to:

[{{beat [[{{beat panel}}]]\\


Added DiffLines:

* NoMedicationForMe: Meg refuses to take her medication, because she "wants to feel everything." Her friends chastise her for this, but they can't force her to take them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShoutOut: A banner outside the art museum reads [[Music/TheyMightBeGiants "Meet James Ensor"]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReallyGetsAround: Meg's roommates chuckle at one point that she's slept with all of them at some point. David quips that Sam (a girl) is probably not among that group, only to find Meg tapped her too. However, while Meg's guy friends are more amused by her history, Sam is resentful about it.

to:

* ReallyGetsAround: Meg's roommates chuckle at one point that she's slept with all of them at some point. David quips that Sam (a girl) woman) is probably not among that group, only to find Meg tapped her too. However, while Meg's guy friends are more amused by her history, Sam is resentful about it.

Added: 274

Removed: 274

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
alphabetizing


* AFormYouAreComfortableWith: Death appears as David's great-uncle Harry, as he took over his life when he died in a war and lived a mortal life through him. When he shows David non-existence, however, this falters and his [[GlamourFailure real, skeletal hand can be seen.]]


Added DiffLines:

* AFormYouAreComfortableWith: Death appears as David's great-uncle Harry, as he took over his life when he died in a war and lived a mortal life through him. When he shows David non-existence, however, this falters and his [[GlamourFailure real, skeletal hand can be seen.]]

Added: 954

Removed: 954

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheBadGuyWins: [[spoiler:If you think Death qualifies as a "[[BlueAndOrangeMorality bad guy]]".]]



* EverybodysDeadDave: David lost his entire family before the beginning of the story.



* EverybodysDeadDave: David lost his entire family before the beginning of the story.



* TheLastDJ: David refuses to filter himself or his art to make it more appealing to critics and investors. However, this results in constant poverty and a lack of recognition.



* MagicallyBindingContract: David can bend any material with his bare hands and sculpt whatever he can imagine, but on two conditions; firstly, he has no more than 200 days left to live; and secondly, [[spoiler:every time he tells someone about the deal, he loses a further three days of his life.]]



* MagicallyBindingContract: David can bend any material with his bare hands and sculpt whatever he can imagine, but on two conditions; firstly, he has no more than 200 days left to live; and secondly, [[spoiler:every time he tells someone about the deal, he loses a further three days of his life.]]



* ReallyGetsAround: Meg's roommates chuckle at one point that she's slept with all of them at some point. David quips that Sam (a girl) is probably not among that group, only to find Meg tapped her too. However, while Meg's guy friends are more amused by her history, Sam is resentful about it.



* ReallyGetsAround: Meg's roommates chuckle at one point that she's slept with all of them at some point. David quips that Sam (a girl) is probably not among that group, only to find Meg tapped her too. However, while Meg's guy friends are more amused by her history, Sam is resentful about it.



* TheBadGuyWins: [[spoiler:If you think Death qualifies as a "[[BlueAndOrangeMorality bad guy]]".]]
* TheLastDJ: David refuses to filter himself or his art to make it more appealing to critics and investors. However, this results in constant poverty and a lack of recognition.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

----


Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

* ProphecyArmor: Averted. David Smith is given artistic superpowers by Death in exchange for living for only 200 more days. However, he is fully capable of being killed before his deadline, so as Death warns him: "No crimefighting!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheLastDJ: David refuses to filter himself or his art to make it more appealing to critics and investors. However, this results in constant poverty and a lack of recognition.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheNothingAfterDeath: What keeps David motivated through most of the story. [[spoiler:It doesn't work.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnAesop: When you die, you're gone forever, but that doesn't mean life is meaningless. No matter how mediocre or average your life is, that doesn't matter as long as you live it.

to:

* AmbiguousEnding / BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler:Bittersweet bordering on DownerEnding, anyway. Meg dies in a meaningless truck accident while out running errands. Death disappears for another millennium. David is shot by the NYPD and [[ForegoneConclusion falls to his death from a skyscraper]]. However, David finally creates the sculpture he always wanted to create and is finally recognised. The detective who shares David's name, who we only meet in the last few pages of the book, calls his wife to tell her he's alive, showing that life goes on.]]
* AnAesop: When you die, [[CessationOfExistence you're gone forever, forever]], but that doesn't mean life is meaningless. No matter how mediocre or average your life is, that doesn't matter as long as you live it.


Added DiffLines:

* ForegoneConclusion: David will be dead by the end of the book.


Added DiffLines:

*** [[spoiler: This becomes poignant at the very end, as CNN accidentally report that the detective has fallen to his death. The last line of the book is Detective Smith's wife saying "David! Oh, thank god...[[MeaningfulEcho you're alive]]." This mirrors what Meg said after feeling David's heartbeat earlier in the book after they both almost fall to their deaths.]]


Added DiffLines:

* RiddleForTheAges / SilentWhisper: We never find out what the secret David shares with Meg is [[spoiler:because they both promise that when they die, the secret dies with them. Guess what, they're both dead]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnAesop: When you die, you're gone forever, but that doesn't mean life is meaningless. No matter how mediocre or average your life is, that doesn't matter as long as you live it.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Irony}}: A [[{{Tragedy}} tragic]] example - [[spoiler:David wastes his life due to the fact he misinterprets something he is told earlier in the story. His only mark on the world is the enormous sculpture of Meg he creates at the end.]]


Added DiffLines:

* TheBadGuyWins: [[spoiler:If you think Death qualifies as a "[[BlueAndOrangeMorality bad guy]]".]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CessationOfExistence: Death shows David this, represented as two pages of blank white paper. David is horrified by the vision, but all he saw was nothing, as his mortal mind can't comprehend itself the absence of itself.

to:

* CessationOfExistence: Death shows David this, represented as two pages of blank white paper. David is horrified by the vision, but all he saw was nothing, as his mortal mind can't comprehend itself the absence of itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* YourDaysAreNumbered: 200 of them, to be exact.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A streetcrosser David and Death spot early on day dies when a scaffolding falls on him.

to:

** A streetcrosser David and Death spot early on one day dies later that night when a scaffolding falls on him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlotArmor: Averted; David can die before his 200 day deadline is up; having a death clock doesn't make him immortal until time's up. [[spoiler:He dies on day 195 after being shot by an NYPD cop]]. No one else is safe either, [[spoiler:not even Meg.]]

to:

* PlotArmor: Averted; David can die before his 200 day deadline is up; arrives; having a death clock doesn't make him immortal until time's up. [[spoiler:He dies on day 195 after being shot by an NYPD cop]]. No one else is safe either, [[spoiler:not even Meg.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Much of Meg's traits that resemble MPDG quirks [[https://twitter.com/ivyratafia/status/567548867109867521 are actually are based on traits of McCloud's own wife Ivy]]. He also responded to the criticism in several interviews, mirroring Nathan Rabin's response that the problem isn't quirky female characters, it's female characters who are nothing but quirks.

to:

** Much of Meg's traits that resemble MPDG quirks [[https://twitter.com/ivyratafia/status/567548867109867521 are actually are based on traits of McCloud's own wife Ivy]]. He also responded to the criticism in several interviews, mirroring Nathan Rabin's Creator/NathanRabin's response that the problem isn't quirky female characters, it's female characters who are nothing but quirks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MagicallyBindingContract: David can bend any material with his bare hands and sculpt whatever he can imagine, but on two conditions; firstly, he has no more than 200 days left to live; and secondly, [[spoiler:every time he tells someone about the deal, he loses a further three days off the deal.]]

to:

* MagicallyBindingContract: David can bend any material with his bare hands and sculpt whatever he can imagine, but on two conditions; firstly, he has no more than 200 days left to live; and secondly, [[spoiler:every time he tells someone about the deal, he loses a further three days off the deal.of his life.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


But just as things are at their darkest, David (inadvertently at first) makes a deal with Death itself: to have the ability to sculpt anything he can imagine with his bare hands. Of course, such a deal comes with a price: namely, David will die in exactly 200 days.

to:

But just as things are at their darkest, David (inadvertently at first) makes a deal with Death itself: to have the ability to sculpt anything he can imagine with his bare hands. Of course, such a deal comes with a price: namely, David will die in exactly 200 days.

Added: 3134

Changed: 409

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChekhovsGun:
** David's very first test of his powers [[spoiler:when he leaves his handprints on a bridge]] is used [[spoiler:by the police to gain his fingerprints.]]
** Ollie's wine glasses [[spoiler:are used by Finn to identify David to the police.]]
** After Penelope Hammer fawns over David and offers him a spot in their gallery, Finn snarks that she must be ''interested'' in him while Ollie denies it's sexual. David doesn't think much of this until he meets her again, and she greets him in a very low-cut dress ([[MayDecemberRomance and she appears to be at least 20 years his senior]].)
** Meg asks David to promise to not let her push him away. [[spoiler:He remembers just in time that this must have been her way of warning him about her depressive episodes.]]



* DyingDream: InUniverse, Death indulges that when he has to kill a person, he learns everything there is to know about the soon-to-be-deceased. This operates both ways, giving the dying person a [[MyLifeFlashedBeforeMyEyes full, final look through their life]]

to:

* DrivenToSuicide:
** After his sculpture showing gets bad reviews, David throws himself at a train. Fortunately, Meg is there to save him.
** Death reveals that [[spoiler:Uncle Harry committed suicide after his wife Sadie died, though it was filed as a car accident. However, with the cosmic knowledge of Death instilled in him, he's come to realize that he should have kept living anyway.]]
* DroppedABridgeOnHim / SurprisinglySuddenDeath:
** A streetcrosser David and Death spot early on day dies when a scaffolding falls on him.
** Right after their declaration of love and middle of their BigDamnKiss, Meg and David almost fall several stories off their roof. Meg finds the experience [[BlackComedy darkly hilarious]] but David is in complete shock at how close to death he just came.
** [[spoiler:Three days before David's deadline, Meg is hit by a truck in what was just another bike ride for her.]]
* DyingDream: InUniverse, Death indulges that when he has to kill a person, he learns everything there is to know about the soon-to-be-deceased. This operates both ways, giving the dying person a [[MyLifeFlashedBeforeMyEyes full, final look through their life]]life]].



* ExperimentedInCollege: A lame joke from David accidentally reveals that Meg's roommate Sam had a lesbian experience with her. Sam is still bitter that it was only a one night stand, Meg apologizing that she was just very drunk that night.



* {{Gayngst}}: [[spoiler:Ollie, who admits he doesn't care Finn is using him to further his career because he finds the alternative is DyingAlone.]]

to:

* {{Gayngst}}: [[spoiler:Ollie, who It's implied Ollie was practically an adopted son to David's family because his own family wouldn't accept him after he came out. [[spoiler:Afterward Ollie basically admits he doesn't care Finn is using him to further his career because he finds the alternative is DyingAlone.]]


Added DiffLines:

* PlotArmor: Averted; David can die before his 200 day deadline is up; having a death clock doesn't make him immortal until time's up. [[spoiler:He dies on day 195 after being shot by an NYPD cop]]. No one else is safe either, [[spoiler:not even Meg.]]
* ReallyGetsAround: Meg's roommates chuckle at one point that she's slept with all of them at some point. David quips that Sam (a girl) is probably not among that group, only to find Meg tapped her too. However, while Meg's guy friends are more amused by her history, Sam is resentful about it.
* ShaggyDogStory: Of a sort. [[spoiler:It turns out that had David stuck around his exhibit after the first visit and tried to get in contact with Ms. Hammer, his sculptures would have been picked up and he would have had a big exhibit. Instead he tried to kill himself that day thinking all the visitors hated him. He doesn't find out the truth until the second-to-last day of his life, by when winning success no longer matters.]]

Added: 545

Changed: 268

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChekhovsSkill: Whenever someone is about to die, Death receives detailed information about the person's life. That way, they can see their life flash before their eyes before they die.
* ChessWithDeath: {{Subverted}} - Death's "vessel", David's late uncle Harry, liked chess, but Death isn't a fan. He's still pretty good at it, though, and beats David in every game, [[spoiler:except for their last.]]

to:

* ChekhovsSkill: Whenever someone is about to die, Death receives detailed information about the person's life. That way, they can see their life flash before their eyes before they die.
die. This comes up again when:
** Death tells the backstory of a random passerby who David later witnesses die that evening.
** Death [[spoiler:meets Meg and uses their shared memories to create a fake story about them having met once, to cover that she's going to die later today.]]
** At the end when [[spoiler:David re-experiences his whole life in the last second before his death.]]
* ChessWithDeath: {{Subverted}} - Death's "vessel", David's late uncle Harry, liked chess, but Death isn't a fan. He's still pretty good at it, though, and beats David in every game, [[spoiler:except for their last.last, but it's implied he deliberately threw the game to distract David.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Death''': [[BeatPanel (beat)]] What would you give for your art, David?\\
'''David''': (beat) I'd give my life.

to:

'''Death''': [[BeatPanel (beat)]] What would you give for your art, David?\\
'''David''': (beat) '''David''': ...I'd give my life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InformedJudaism: Both David are Meg are secular Jews. It doesn't effect their lives much, except that they celebrate Passover and Hanukkah.

to:

* InformedJudaism: Both David are Meg are secular Jews. It doesn't effect affect their lives much, except that they celebrate Passover and Hanukkah.

Top