Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ComicBook / BoxersAndSaints

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseLinguistics: When the Muslim soldiers of the Kansu Braves pray, the speech bubbles show them reciting the first chapter of the Qur'an in Arabic script... with the letters arranged backwards and sans cursive.

Changed: 4

Removed: 238

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
misuse. this trope is for reuniting in the afterlife


->"''Support the Ch'ing! Destroy the Foreigner!''"

to:

->"''Support ->''"Support the Ch'ing! Destroy the Foreigner!''"
Foreigner!"''



* TogetherInDeath: A non-romantic example. [[spoiler: Dr. Won throws himself in front of Father Bey to save his life. Tearfully, Father Bey realizes he was wrong to reject the Doctor, and begs God for forgiveness as the Boxers close in.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Boxers and Saints are two historical fiction companion novels written by Creator/GeneLuenYang, released together on September 10, 2013. The story is an epic and mystical take on the Boxer Rebellion of China, which occurred around the year of 1898.

Boxers stars a young boy named Little Bao, who respects his country's culture and wishes to drive the foreign devils from China. It follows him throughout his journey from being a simple boy, to becoming a leader of the Boxer Rebellion.

Saints takes on another perspective, starring Four-Girl, who is a girl from the same village, that joins the foreign devils and becomes a Chinese Christian. She takes on the name of Vibiana later in the story.

to:

Boxers ''Boxers'' and Saints ''Saints'' are two historical fiction HistoricalFiction companion graphic novels written by Creator/GeneLuenYang, released together on September 10, 2013. The story is an epic and mystical take on 2013, taking place in late 1890s China during the Boxer Rebellion of China, which occurred around the year of 1898.

Boxers
Rebellion.

''Boxers''
stars a young boy named Little Bao, who respects his country's culture and wishes to drive the foreign devils "foreign devils" from China. It follows him throughout his journey from being a simple boy, to becoming a leader of the Boxer Rebellion.

Saints ''Saints'' takes on another perspective, starring Four-Girl, who is a girl from the same village, that joins the foreign devils and becomes a Chinese Christian. She takes converts to Christianity, taking on the name of Vibiana later in the story.
Vibiana.

Changed: 1

Removed: 105

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilAllAlong: Not that Yu was morally upright to begin with, but [[spoiler: The Saints part of the storyline later revealed that he is actually a bandit leader who converted to Catholicism as a way to escape the law but continued to wear the cross even after he was expelled by Father Bey)]].

to:

* EvilAllAlong: Not that Yu was morally upright to begin with, but [[spoiler: The Saints part of the storyline later revealed that he is actually a bandit leader who converted to Catholicism as a way to escape the law but continued to wear the cross even after he was expelled by Father Bey)]].Bey]].



* [[spoiler: Moral Event Horizon: When Little Bao killed the girl from the train, it all went downhill.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding another example to "Historical Domain Character"

Added DiffLines:

** Dr. Won either is or is heavily inspired by St. Mark Ji Tianxiang, a real saint with a near identical life story.

Changed: 34

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Boxers and Saints are two historical fiction companion novels written by [[ComicBook/AmericanBornChinese Gene Luen Yang,]] released together on September 10, 2013. The story is an epic and mystical take on the Boxer Rebellion of China, which occurred around the year of 1898.

to:

Boxers and Saints are two historical fiction companion novels written by [[ComicBook/AmericanBornChinese Gene Luen Yang,]] Creator/GeneLuenYang, released together on September 10, 2013. The story is an epic and mystical take on the Boxer Rebellion of China, which occurred around the year of 1898.

Added: 718

Changed: 244

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DownerEnding: In ''Boxers'', since [[ForegoneConclusion it's the story of the Boxer rebellion from the Boxers' point of view]]. [[spoiler: The last image you see is Little Bao lying on the ground, bleeding out, as he sees the gods of the opera drift away.]]

to:

* DownerEnding: DownerEnding:
**
In ''Boxers'', since [[ForegoneConclusion it's the story of the Boxer rebellion from the Boxers' point of view]]. [[spoiler: The last image you see is Little Bao lying on the ground, bleeding out, as he sees the gods of the opera drift away.]]
** In ''Saints'', [[spoiler: Vibiana was slain along with local Christians as she refuses to denounce her faith with her last witness to Joan's spirit was her being burned at the stake.]]
** In the finale of both chapters, [[spoiler: Little Bao was NotQuiteDead as he managed to crawl out of corpse pile and escaped another death by chanting half-remembered scripture that Vibiana gave to her. But his entire group was wiped out, except for him and his remaining brother.
]]

Added: 336

Changed: 11

Removed: 94

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FrenchJerk: Father Bey, the judgemental and intolerant ([[JerkWithAHeartOfGold at first]]) priest, came from France based on his statement on Joan of Arc as "heroine of his home country," and Catholicism being France's dominant culture.

to:

* FrenchJerk: Father Bey, the judgemental and intolerant ([[JerkWithAHeartOfGold at first]]) priest, came from France based on his statement on Joan of Arc as "heroine of his home country," and Catholicism being France's dominant culture.religion.



* ReassignedToAntarctica: Father Bey's righteous nature caused a scuffle between him and a [[SinisterMinister not-as-pious Bishop]], in addition to his disdain for decadence in France, which caused him to be assigned as a missionary to China.
* RedIsHeroic: Red Lantern Chu, and the colors the Red Lanterns chose to symbolize themselves.



* RedIsHeroic: Red Lantern Chu, and the colors the Red Lanterns chose to symbolize themselves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FrenchJerk: Father Bey, the judgemental and intolerant ([[JerkWithAHeartOfGold at first]]) priest, came from France based on his statement on Joan of Arc as "heroine of his home country," and Catholicism being France's dominant culture.

Added: 667

Changed: 90

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilAllAlong: Not that Yu was morally upright to begin with, but [[spoiler: The Saints part of the storyline later revealed that he is actually a bandit leader who converted to Catholicism as a way to escape the law but continued to wear the cross even after he was expelled by Father Bey)]].



* JerkAss: how Father Bey comes across in "Boxers." In "Saints" he's more of a JerkWithAHeartOfGold.

to:

* JerkAss: JerkAss:
**
how Father Bey comes across in "Boxers." In "Saints" he's more of a JerkWithAHeartOfGold.


Added DiffLines:

*** Even worse in Saints, where [[spoiler: he is actually the leader of the bandits who was using his new religion as a way to escape the law before being excommunicated by Father Bey once his intent was exposed. He even mutilated Kong's face after he refused to rejoin his gang]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TragicHero: [[spoiler: Little Bao. He survived to the end of the story, but only because he canted the Christian prayer to prevent being shot by foreign soldiers rather than face death.]]

to:

* TragicHero: [[spoiler: Little Bao. He Initially, he was an idealist who wish to deal a blow to corrupt Chinese society being hegemonized by foreign powers. Later, he would turn into KnightTemplar from visions of The First Emperor who forced him to kill innocents and even burned down a library that claimed the life of his LoveInterest. While he survived to the end of the story, but only because he canted Little Bao chanted the Christian prayer to prevent being shot by foreign soldiers rather than face death.death. Thus making his entire effort as AllForNothing.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DefiantToTheEnd: [[spoiler: Vibiana refused to renounce her faith, even refusing to say her original name, Four Girl.]]


Added DiffLines:

* FunctionalAddict: [[spoiler: Dr. Won has been able to perform his duties as a doctor even as an opium addict. He even stated that his opium usage was to control his stomach pain rather than vices.]]


Added DiffLines:

* TragicHero: [[spoiler: Little Bao. He survived to the end of the story, but only because he canted the Christian prayer to prevent being shot by foreign soldiers rather than face death.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->"''Support the Ching! Destroy the Foreigner!''"

to:

->"''Support the Ching! Ch'ing! Destroy the Foreigner!''"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheHerosJourney: Bao's story quite brutally subverts it. We begin with FarmBoy Bao in his little village in rural China, before he hears the CallToAdventure when he sees whites and Christian converts persecuting the Chinese. {{Mentor}}s Red Latern Chu and Master Big Belly guide him on his quest to become a Kung-fu master before he finally sets out to lead the rebellion against the whites... [[spoiler: where he becomes an AxeCrazy KnightTemplar who wantonly kills the innocent when they stand in his way, who loses massively when the Boxers finally encounter Western armies in their fullest.]]

to:

* TheHerosJourney: Bao's story quite brutally subverts it. We begin with FarmBoy Bao in his little village in rural China, before he hears the CallToAdventure when he sees whites and Christian converts persecuting the Chinese. {{Mentor}}s Red Latern Chu and Master Big Belly guide him on his quest to become a Kung-fu master before he finally sets out to lead the rebellion against the whites... [[spoiler: where he becomes an AxeCrazy KnightTemplar who wantonly kills the innocent when they stand in his way, who and loses massively when the Boxers finally encounter Western armies in their fullest.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheHerosJourney: Bao's story quite brutally subverts it. We begin with FarmBoy Bao in his little village in rural China, before he hears the CallToAdventure when he sees whites and Christian converts persecuting the Chinese. {{Mentor}}s Red Latern Chu and Master Big Belly guide him on his quest to become a Kung-fu master before he finally sets out to lead the rebellion against the whites... [[spoiler: where he become an AxCrazy KnightTemplar who wantonly kills the innocent when they stand in his way, who loses massively when the Boxers finally encounter Western armies in their fullest.]]

to:

* TheHerosJourney: Bao's story quite brutally subverts it. We begin with FarmBoy Bao in his little village in rural China, before he hears the CallToAdventure when he sees whites and Christian converts persecuting the Chinese. {{Mentor}}s Red Latern Chu and Master Big Belly guide him on his quest to become a Kung-fu master before he finally sets out to lead the rebellion against the whites... [[spoiler: where he become becomes an AxCrazy AxeCrazy KnightTemplar who wantonly kills the innocent when they stand in his way, who loses massively when the Boxers finally encounter Western armies in their fullest.]]

Added: 596

Removed: 633

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheHerosJourney: Bao's story quite brutally subverts it. We begin with FarmBoy Bao in his little village in rural China, before he hears the CallToAdventure when he sees whites and Christian converts persecuting the Chinese. {{Mentor}}s Red Latern Chu and Master Big Belly guide him on his quest to become a Kung-fu master before he finally sets out to lead the rebellion against the whites... [[spoiler: only to become an AxCrazy KnightTemplar who wantonly kills the innocent when they stand in his way, who loses massively in the Siege of Peking. He only survives the ensuing RapePillageAndBurn by pretending to be a Christian.]]


Added DiffLines:

* TheHerosJourney: Bao's story quite brutally subverts it. We begin with FarmBoy Bao in his little village in rural China, before he hears the CallToAdventure when he sees whites and Christian converts persecuting the Chinese. {{Mentor}}s Red Latern Chu and Master Big Belly guide him on his quest to become a Kung-fu master before he finally sets out to lead the rebellion against the whites... [[spoiler: where he become an AxCrazy KnightTemplar who wantonly kills the innocent when they stand in his way, who loses massively when the Boxers finally encounter Western armies in their fullest.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheHerosJourney: Bao's story quite brutally subverts it. We begin with FarmBoy Bao in his little village in rural China, before he hears the CallToAdventure when he sees whites and Christian converts persecuting the Chinese. {{Mentor}}s Red Latern Chu and Master Big Belly guide him on his quest to become a Kung-fu master before he finally sets out to lead the rebellion against the whites... [[spoiler: only to become an AxCrazy KnightTemplar who wantonly kills the innocent when they stand in his way, who loses massively in the Siege of Peking. He only survives the ensuing RapePillageAndBurn by pretending to be a Christian.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:[[{{Music/Sabaton}} "Two ways to rule the world, so similar at times..."]]]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:[[{{Music/Sabaton}} "Two ways to rule view the world, so similar at times..."]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:For China!]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:For China!]]
[[caption-width-right:350:[[{{Music/Sabaton}} "Two ways to rule the world, so similar at times..."]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalDomainCharacter: A given considering the story, though in particular the German diplomat mentioned below is [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clemens_von_Ketteler Clemens von Ketteler]].

to:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: A given considering the story, though in particular the German diplomat mentioned below is [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clemens_von_Ketteler Clemens von Ketteler]]. [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zaiyi Prince Tuan]] is a also major supporting character, while Empress Dowager Cixi is mentioned in the background.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FourIsDeath: Part of the reason behind Vibiana's family issues -- she was originally blamed for the family's troubles due to being born fourth, and was not even given a name, being "Four Girl".

to:

* FourIsDeath: Part of the reason behind Vibiana's family issues -- she was originally blamed for the family's troubles due to being born fourth, and was not even given a name, being "Four Girl".called "Four-Girl".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FourIsDeath: Part of the reason behind Vibiana's family issues.

to:

* FourIsDeath: Part of the reason behind Vibiana's family issues.issues -- she was originally blamed for the family's troubles due to being born fourth, and was not even given a name, being "Four Girl".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoodShepard: Father Bey is a realistic example. He genuinely means well, unlike many of the other Westerners, and he is both brave and peaceful in the defense of his faithful, but he is also capable of being harsh, judgemental, and ignorant.

to:

* GoodShepard: GoodShepherd: Father Bey is a realistic example. He genuinely means well, unlike many of the other Westerners, and he is both brave and peaceful in the defense of his faithful, but he is also capable of being harsh, judgemental, and ignorant.

Added: 172

Changed: 2578

Removed: 644

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AntiHero: The heroes of both books.
** [[spoiler: AntiVillain: Little Bao becomes one, eventually.]]
* ArcSymbol: Eyes.
* AtrociousAlias: Four-Girl.
* AwesomeMcCoolname: The Society of Righteous and Harmonious Fists, Vibiana (only because she chose it herself), and Red Lantern all have arguably really cool names.
* {{BFS}}: What the Big Sword Society is named after.

to:

* AntiHero: The heroes of both books.
** [[spoiler: AntiVillain: Little Bao becomes one, eventually.]]
* ArcSymbol: Eyes.
Eyes, representing both compassion, as with Guan Yin and Vibiana's vision of the Christ, and rage, as with the fiery eyes that many Boxers share.
* AtrociousAlias: Four-Girl.
Four-Girl, which both dehumanizes her and [[FourIsDeath blames her for all her family's troubles]].
* AwesomeMcCoolname: The Society of Righteous and Harmonious Fists, Vibiana (only because she chose it herself), and Red Lantern all have arguably really cool names.
* {{BFS}}: What the Big Sword Society is named after.BrokenPedestal: Both Vibiana and Father Bey deeply respect Dr. Won, a Chinese Christian and man of seemingly unimpeachable character. [[spoiler: Then it turns out he's an opium addict...]]



* DeliberatelyMonochrome: Saints.
** [[spoiler: FlashbackEffect.]]

to:

* DeliberatelyMonochrome: Saints.
** [[spoiler:
''Saints'', in contrast to ''Boxers'', is very monochrome. [[spoiler: It's actually a FlashbackEffect.]]



* [[spoiler: DownerEnding: In Boxers, the last image you see is Little Bao lying on the ground, bleeding out.]]
* FatBastard: Master Big Belly. [[spoiler: Or at least, that's how Bao sees it.]]
** [[spoiler: FormerlyFat: He loses all the fat after using his mystic vision.]]

to:

* [[spoiler: DownerEnding: In Boxers, ''Boxers'', since [[ForegoneConclusion it's the story of the Boxer rebellion from the Boxers' point of view]]. [[spoiler: The last image you see is Little Bao lying on the ground, bleeding out.out, as he sees the gods of the opera drift away.]]
* FatBastard: Master Big Belly. [[spoiler: Or at least, that's how Bao sees it.]]
** [[spoiler:
Belly, Bao's harsh teacher who somehow keeps fat despite the famine consuming the land.
*
FormerlyFat: He Big Belly loses all the his fat after [[spoiler: using his the mystic vision.vision in his stomach to teach Bao how to commune with the gods of the opera.]]



* GoodSamaritan: Mei.
** Vibiana also has a vision of Jesus who tells the TropeNamer story, which encourages her to [[spoiler: teach Little Bao the prayer that saves his life]]

to:

* GoodSamaritan: Mei.
**
Mei, after being inspired by the tales of Guan Yin. Vibiana also has a vision of Jesus who tells the TropeNamer story, which encourages her to [[spoiler: teach Little Bao the prayer that saves his life]]life]].
* GoodShepard: Father Bey is a realistic example. He genuinely means well, unlike many of the other Westerners, and he is both brave and peaceful in the defense of his faithful, but he is also capable of being harsh, judgemental, and ignorant.



** Yu, the guy who tries to take more dumplings than he's paid for [[spoiler: and who brings Father Bey into the village]] is a more clear-cut example, as is the German diplomat who beats Bing Wong-Bing.

to:

** Yu, the guy bandit who tries to take more dumplings than he's paid for [[spoiler: and who brings Father Bey into the village]] is a more clear-cut example, as is the German diplomat who beats Bing Wong-Bing.



* LoveInterest: Mei in Boxers, and Kong in Saints.

to:

* LoveInterest: Mei in Boxers, ''Boxers'', and Kong in Saints.''Saints''.
* MagicRealism: The most earthy sort of poverty and the most ruthless sort of politics coincide with strange, mystical places, the gods of the opera, and visions of saints.



* SignificantGreenEyedRedhead: The girl on the train.
** [[spoiler: EvilRedhead: From the Boxers' perspective, although she was just getting revenge when she shot Bao's brother.]]

to:

* SignificantGreenEyedRedhead: The girl on the train.
**
train. [[spoiler: EvilRedhead: From the Boxers' perspective, although she was just getting revenge when she shot Bao's brother.]]She comes back after Bao let her go and avenges her brother by murdering Bao's. This convinces Bao that sparing his enemies is "weakness."]]



** [[spoiler: SuperpoweredEvilSide: What these forms could be likened to from the right perspective. Especially Little Bao when possessed by Ch'in Shih Huang.]]
* SympatheticMurderer: [[spoiler: Little Bao and the rest of the Society of Righteous and Harmonious Fists.]]



* [[spoiler: TheHeroDies: And she just happens to be killed by the other hero.]]

to:

* TogetherInDeath: A non-romantic example. [[spoiler: TheHeroDies: And she just happens Dr. Won throws himself in front of Father Bey to be killed by save his life. Tearfully, Father Bey realizes he was wrong to reject the other hero.Doctor, and begs God for forgiveness as the Boxers close in.]]



* [[spoiler: VillainProtagonist: Later, Little Bao.]]

to:

* [[spoiler: VillainProtagonist: Later, [[spoiler: Little Bao.]]Bao]] goes from an honorable outlaw defending the lives, property, and dignity of the people against bandits to a terrorist slaughtering Christians and Westerners for diverging from mainstream Chinese culture.



* YouAreNumberSix: Four-Girl.
* [[spoiler: {{Your Terrorists Are Our Freedom Fighters}}]]

to:

* YouAreNumberSix: Four-Girl.
Four-Girl, a cruel name given by a family that never wanted her.
* [[spoiler: {{Your Terrorists Are Our Freedom Fighters}}]]YourTerroristsAreOurFreedomFighters: The Society of Righteous and Harmonious Fists starts with the best of intentions and the most honorable of motives. It ends in blood and fire, having brought nothing but ruin and trouble to the Chinese people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Lady In Red is when a woman\'s red clothing is used to indicate her sexuality. Zero Context Examples and misuse is being cut.


* LadyInRed: [[spoiler: Mei when transformed into Mu Gui-ying.]]

Added: 218

Changed: 99

Removed: 218

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WellIntentionedExtremist: [[spoiler: Little Bao, eventually. The author even likens him to a terrorist near the end.]]

to:

* WellIntentionedExtremist: The First Emperor, who is loyal to China [[TheUnfettered above any moral or ethical restraints]]. [[spoiler: Little Bao, eventually. The author even likens him to a terrorist near the end.]]
* WhatTheHellHero: Mei does not take it well when she learns that [[spoiler:Little Bao intends to burn down the library, which she previously described to him as a place filled with irreplaceable books and knowledge.
]]



* WhatTheHellHero: Mei does not take it well when she learns that [[spoiler:Little Bao intends to burn down the library, which she previously described to him as a place filled with irreplaceable books and knowledge.]]

Added: 521

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He earlier has one when he realizes that the foreign devils hidden in a church are all women and children, who he previously refused to kill. [[spoiler:He ends up forcing himself to go through with burning the church and killing them, believing that otherwise any of them may come back for revenge.]]



* YinYangClash: Yin is believed to be basically poisonous.

to:

* YinYangClash: Yin is believed to be basically poisonous. poisonous.
* WhatTheHellHero: Mei does not take it well when she learns that [[spoiler:Little Bao intends to burn down the library, which she previously described to him as a place filled with irreplaceable books and knowledge.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Boxers and Saints are two historical fiction companion novels written by Gene Luen Yang, released together on September 10, 2013.
The story is an epic and mystical take on the Boxer Rebellion of China, which occurred around the year of 1898.

to:

Boxers and Saints are two historical fiction companion novels written by [[ComicBook/AmericanBornChinese Gene Luen Yang, Yang,]] released together on September 10, 2013.
2013. The story is an epic and mystical take on the Boxer Rebellion of China, which occurred around the year of 1898.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: A given considering the story, though in particular the German diplomat mentioned below is [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clemens_von_Ketteler Clemens von Ketteler]].

Top