Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* BeneathTheMask: A flamboyant Italian showman to the public; but when he drops the facade he's a down-to-earth Irishman who wants to blackmail his old boss.
Changed line(s) 384 (click to see context) from:
* {{Jerkass}}: He abuses his child assistant and attempts to blackmail Sweeney.
to:
* {{Jerkass}}: He abuses his child child/mentally-handicap assistant and attempts to blackmail Sweeney.Sweeney.
* ALighterShadeOfBlack: It speaks to how dark the play is. He cons people into buying a bullshit product, abuses his assistant, tries to blackmail his old boss, and [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking fakes a ridiculous Italian accent]]. All horrible things, but compared to corrupt ephebophillic rapist Judge Turpin and crazed SerielKiller Sweeney Todd, he doesn't come off quite as awful.
* ALighterShadeOfBlack: It speaks to how dark the play is. He cons people into buying a bullshit product, abuses his assistant, tries to blackmail his old boss, and [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking fakes a ridiculous Italian accent]]. All horrible things, but compared to corrupt ephebophillic rapist Judge Turpin and crazed SerielKiller Sweeney Todd, he doesn't come off quite as awful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* ProfessionalButtKisser: To Judge Turpin. "Ladies in Their Sensitivities" contains ''many'' instances of him calling Turpin "My lord."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 152 (click to see context) from:
* MotorMouth: In Mrs. Lovett’s introductory song ''The Worst Pies In London'', she goes from talking about how little customers she’s getting, bemoaning the taste of her pies, explaining that the price of meat has increased, and gossiping about how her competitor Mrs. Mooney May be using cats in her pies in a matter of seconds.
to:
* MotorMouth: In Mrs. Lovett’s introductory song ''The Worst Pies In London'', she goes from talking about how little customers she’s getting, bemoaning the taste of her pies, explaining that the price of meat has increased, and gossiping about how her competitor Mrs. Mooney May may be using cats in her pies in a matter of seconds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* AdaptationalNameChange: His literary counterpart was named Mark Ingestrie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
merged to Chatty Hairdresser
Deleted line(s) 27 (click to see context) :
* TheBarber: He was a straight version when he was still Benjamin Barker, friendly and respected among his customers. His exile and returning to find his wife has died changes his attitude, but not his skill with the razors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 394 (click to see context) from:
!!!'''Played by:''' Ken Jennings (Original Broadway Cast), Creator/NeilPatrickHarris (2001 Concert), Ed Sanders (2007 film), Gaten Matarazzo (2023 Broadway revival)
to:
!!!'''Played by:''' Ken Jennings (Original Broadway Cast), Creator/NeilPatrickHarris (2001 Concert), Ed Sanders (2007 film), Gaten Matarazzo Creator/GatenMatarazzo (2023 Broadway revival)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 191 (click to see context) from:
* SplitPersonality: Is portrayed as having Dissociative Identity Disorder in the 2023 revival, an idea developed by her actress, Ruthie Ann Miles
to:
* SplitPersonality: Is portrayed as having Dissociative Identity Disorder in the 2023 revival, revival. This was an idea developed by her actress, Ruthie Ann MilesMiles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding tropes from the 2023 revival.
Added DiffLines:
* SplitPersonality: Is portrayed as having Dissociative Identity Disorder in the 2023 revival, an idea developed by her actress, Ruthie Ann Miles
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* BewareTheSillyOnes: On the surface, Mrs. Lovett seems like a harmlessly eccentric matron, swatting flies in her pie shop and making witty jokes. Beneath the surface lies the soul of an alarmingly expedient woman who’ll do anything to succeed, including use dead corpses to combat the shortage of meat in her pies.
* BrightIsNotGood: Matching Mrs. Lovett’s deceptively cheery and maternal facade is her colorful wardrobe with flashy accessories.
* MotorMouth: In Mrs. Lovett’s introductory song ''The Worst Pies In London'', she goes from talking about how little customers she’s getting, bemoaning the taste of her pies, explaining that the price of meat has increased, and gossiping about how her competitor Mrs. Mooney May be using cats in her pies in a matter of seconds.
Changed line(s) 152 (click to see context) from:
* PerkyFemaleMinion: In the stage musical. She is much more obviously batshit in the movie.
to:
* PerkyFemaleMinion: In the stage musical. She musical, Mrs. Lovett is an enthusiastic and cheerful supporter and accomplice of Todd’s murders. This trope doesn’t apply in the film, where she’s portrayed in a much more obviously batshit in the movie.deadpan light.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 290 (click to see context) from:
* Expy: To Judge Claude Frollo of The Hunchback of Notre Dame. Both men are aging and morally bankrupt judges who become father figures at late points in life. They didn't plan on it, but it's their own damn fault. They both do a completely abysmal job of it by keeping their "child" locked up. And most disturbingly of all, they both lust after a woman young enough to be their granddaughter.
to:
* Expy: {{Expy}}: To Judge Claude Frollo of The ''The Hunchback of Notre Dame.Dame''. Both men are aging and morally bankrupt judges who become father figures at late points in life. They didn't plan on it, but it's their own damn fault. They both do a completely abysmal job of it by keeping their "child" locked up. And most disturbingly of all, they both lust after a woman young enough to be their granddaughter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* Expy: To Judge Claude Frollo of The Hunchback of Notre Dame. Both men are aging and morally bankrupt judges who become father figures at late points in life. They didn't plan on it, but it's their own damn fault. They both do a completely abysmal job of it by keeping their "child" locked up. And most disturbingly of all, they both lust after a woman young enough to be their granddaughter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added Villain Has a Point to Mrs. Lovett
Added DiffLines:
* VillainHasAPoint: Throughout the play and the film, she advises Todd to stop obsessing over the past and move on with his life. Granted, what she really wants is for Todd to move on and start a new life with ''her'', and she's [[spoiler: lying about Lucy being dead]], but she's also not wrong in suggesting that Todd would be better off if he wasn't fixated on revenge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
!!!'''Dubbed by:''' Creator/BrunoChoel (European French, 2007 film)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* KickTheDog: Her singularly nasty treatment of the Beggar Woman whenever the two of them are on scene together is an early indicator that she is much darker than she initially appears to be. Especially when you learn that [[spoiler:she knows just who the Beggar Woman actually is]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* IronicEcho: A very odd version. When Anthony raises his pistol he shouts, ''"Stop, Mr. Fogg, or I'll fire!"'' Mr. Fogg's immediate response (and final words) are, ''"Fire, and I will stop!"''
* ParentalSubstitute: Considers himself one, calling his inmates "my children." They certainly don't agree, and are quick to either murder him and/or gleefully escape the asylum after his death.
* ShearMenace: In the stage play, he advances on Anthony with his scissors before Johanna shoots him.
* ParentalSubstitute: Considers himself one, calling his inmates "my children." They certainly don't agree, and are quick to either murder him and/or gleefully escape the asylum after his death.
* ShearMenace: In the stage play, he advances on Anthony with his scissors before Johanna shoots him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 406 (click to see context) from:
[[folder:Jonas Fogg]]
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[folder:Jonas Fogg]]
!!!'''Played by:''' Robert Ousley (Original Broadway Cast), Philip Philmar (2007 film), Simeon Truby (West End, 2012), Stephen Tewksbury (2023 Broadway revival)
[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/957983_128475667041642res_368_300.jpg]]
The corrupt head of the local insane asylum who is in league with Judge Turpin.
----
* BabyTalk: How he speaks to his wards, offering them "sweeties" when they behave.
* BedlamHouse: The sort of establishment he runs.
* DiesDifferentlyInAdaptation: In the original play, Fogg was shot by Johanna. In the 2007 movie, he gets killed by a mob of his inmates after Anthony leaves him in the cell.
* HoistByHisOwnPetard: However he dies, it's always at the hands of at least one of the inmates he mistreated.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
In the play, he doesn't unjustly sentence a kid to death. (He does sentence a repeat criminal to death, but it's not made clear whether this is deserved)
Changed line(s) 288 (click to see context) from:
* FreudianExcuse: "Johanna (Mea Culpa)", his ObsessionSong, reveals that Judge Turpin genuinely believes that SexIsEvil to an extremely unhealthy degree. He regularly flagellates himself as punishment for impure thoughts, and it's suggested that his marrying Johanna is the only way he can think of to "purify" himself. Sondheim himself wrote that without the song, Turpin come across as much more of a one-note villain who is simply evil for evil's sake, as opposed to someone who, though still an utterly loathsome rapist and murderer, has at least a shred of reasoning behind his actions.
to:
* FreudianExcuse: "Johanna (Mea Culpa)", his ObsessionSong, reveals that Judge Turpin genuinely believes that SexIsEvil to an extremely unhealthy degree. He regularly flagellates himself as punishment for impure thoughts, and it's suggested that his marrying Johanna is the only way he can think of to "purify" himself. Sondheim himself wrote that without the song, Turpin come across as much more of a one-note villain who is simply evil for evil's sake, as opposed to someone who, though still an utterly loathsome rapist and murderer, rapist, has at least a shred of reasoning behind his actions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 287 (click to see context) from:
* FauxAffablyEvil: Gives off the air of refunded Judge, but in a truth a sexually depraved bastard who sentences children to death for crimes they might not have even committed.
to:
* FauxAffablyEvil: Gives He give off the air of refunded Judge, a refined gentleman, but in a truth reality he's a sexually depraved bastard who sentences children to death for crimes they might not have even committed.
Changed line(s) 310 (click to see context) from:
* TheSociopath: Turpin is a cold, unfeeling man who only cares about satisfying his lust and dispensing his own self righteous view of justice.
to:
* TheSociopath: Turpin is a cold, unfeeling man who only cares about satisfying his lust and dispensing his own self righteous self-righteous view of justice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It's about a week since the 2023 Broadway revival of this musical came out. I just did research and found the rest of the cast.
Changed line(s) 106 (click to see context) from:
!!!'''Played by:''' Creator/AngelaLansbury (Original Broadway Cast), Creator/PattiLuPone (2001 Concert, 2005 Broadway revival), Creator/HelenaBonhamCarter (2007 film), Creator/ImeldaStaunton (West End, 2012), Creator/AnnaleighAshford (Broadway revival 2023)
to:
!!!'''Played by:''' Creator/AngelaLansbury (Original Broadway Cast), Creator/PattiLuPone (2001 Concert, 2005 Broadway revival), Creator/HelenaBonhamCarter (2007 film), Creator/ImeldaStaunton (West End, 2012), Creator/AnnaleighAshford (Broadway revival 2023)(2023 Broadway revival)
Changed line(s) 167 (click to see context) from:
!!!'''Played by:''' Merle Louise (Original Broadway Cast), Victoria Clark (2001 Concert), Laura Michelle Kelly (2007 film)
to:
!!!'''Played by:''' Merle Louise (Original Broadway Cast), Victoria Clark (2001 Concert), Laura Michelle Kelly (2007 film)film), Ruthie Ann Miles (2023 Broadway revival)
Changed line(s) 192 (click to see context) from:
!!!'''Played by:''' Creator/VictorGarber (Original Broadway Cast), Davis Gaines (2001 Concert), Creator/JamieCampbellBower (2007 film)
to:
!!!'''Played by:''' Creator/VictorGarber (Original Broadway Cast), Davis Gaines (2001 Concert), Creator/JamieCampbellBower (2007 film)film), Jordan Fisher (2023 Broadway revival)
Changed line(s) 244 (click to see context) from:
!!!'''Played by:''' Sarah Rice (Original Broadway Cast), Lisa Vroham (2001 Concert), Jayne Wisener (2007 film)
to:
!!!'''Played by:''' Sarah Rice (Original Broadway Cast), Lisa Vroham (2001 Concert), Jayne Wisener (2007 film)film), Maria Bilbao (2023 Broadway revival)
Changed line(s) 273 (click to see context) from:
!!!'''Played by:''' Creator/EdmundLyndeck (Original Broadway Cast), Timothy Nolen (2001 Concert), Creator/AlanRickman (2007 film)
to:
!!!'''Played by:''' Creator/EdmundLyndeck (Original Broadway Cast), Timothy Nolen (2001 Concert), Creator/AlanRickman (2007 film)film), Jaime Jackson (2023 Broadway revival)
Changed line(s) 320 (click to see context) from:
!!!'''Played by:''' Jack Eric Williams (Original Broadway Cast), John Aler (2001 Concert), Creator/TimothySpall (2007 film)
to:
!!!'''Played by:''' Jack Eric Williams (Original Broadway Cast), John Aler (2001 Concert), Creator/TimothySpall (2007 film)film), John Rapson (2023 Broadway revival)
Changed line(s) 348 (click to see context) from:
!!!'''Played by:''' Joaquin Romaguera (Original Broadway Cast), Stanford Olsen (2001 Concert), Creator/SachaBaronCohen (2007 film)
to:
!!!'''Played by:''' Joaquin Romaguera (Original Broadway Cast), Stanford Olsen (2001 Concert), Creator/SachaBaronCohen (2007 film)film), Nicholas Christopher (2023 Broadway revival)
Changed line(s) 386 (click to see context) from:
!!!'''Played by:''' Ken Jennings (Original Broadway Cast), Creator/NeilPatrickHarris (2001 Concert), Ed Sanders (2007 film)
to:
!!!'''Played by:''' Ken Jennings (Original Broadway Cast), Creator/NeilPatrickHarris (2001 Concert), Ed Sanders (2007 film)film), Gaten Matarazzo (2023 Broadway revival)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Indentation issues.
Changed line(s) 15 (click to see context) from:
* AdaptationalHeroism: In "The String of Pearls", the penny dreadful the play is based on, Sweeney Todd is an unrepentant murderer motivated by {{greed}} and bloodlust with no sympathetic or redeeming qualities. In this musical, he's a tragic character. He used to be a normal family man, until a corrupt judge deported him to Australia for a crime he didn't commit to get at his wife. When he comes back, he initially only wants to take revenge on said judge and his beadle, but unfortunate circumstances and his own increasing insanity drive him to commit worse and worse crimes. To top it all off, he's absolutely horrified when [[spoiler:he realizes that he unwittingly killed his wife]].
to:
* AdaptationalHeroism: AdaptationalHeroism:
** In "The String of Pearls", the penny dreadful the play is based on, Sweeney Todd is an unrepentant murderer motivated by {{greed}} and bloodlust with no sympathetic or redeeming qualities. In this musical, he's a tragic character. He used to be a normal family man, until a corrupt judge deported him to Australia for a crime he didn't commit to get at his wife. When he comes back, he initially only wants to take revenge on said judge and his beadle, but unfortunate circumstances and his own increasing insanity drive him to commit worse and worse crimes. To top it all off, he's absolutely horrified when [[spoiler:he realizes that he unwittingly killed his wife]].
** In "The String of Pearls", the penny dreadful the play is based on, Sweeney Todd is an unrepentant murderer motivated by {{greed}} and bloodlust with no sympathetic or redeeming qualities. In this musical, he's a tragic character. He used to be a normal family man, until a corrupt judge deported him to Australia for a crime he didn't commit to get at his wife. When he comes back, he initially only wants to take revenge on said judge and his beadle, but unfortunate circumstances and his own increasing insanity drive him to commit worse and worse crimes. To top it all off, he's absolutely horrified when [[spoiler:he realizes that he unwittingly killed his wife]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
** In the Christopher Bond play that directly inspired the musical, Sweeney hears Tobias walking into the carnage and he repents for mistreating the boy, decides to free him, and even says aloud that he wouldn't care if Tobias reported his misdeeds to the world. While the musical removes those lines, it can be interpreted that he decided not to target Toby.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 13 (click to see context) from:
* AdaptationalAttractiveness: Depending on the staging, he ranges from worn-out and burly (but with a ''great'' head of hair) in the original production, to young-middle-aged and intense but fairly handsome still (arguably both Michael Cerveris in the 2005 revival and Johnny Depp in the film).
to:
* AdaptationalAttractiveness: Depending on the staging, he ranges from worn-out and burly (but with a ''great'' head of hair) in the original production, to young-middle-aged and intense but fairly handsome still (arguably both applies to Michael Cerveris in the 2005 revival and revival, Johnny Depp in the film).film, and Josh Groban in the 2023 revival).
Changed line(s) 41 (click to see context) from:
** The stage version implies that this happened too, with the original stage version giving him thick, wavy (if unflatteringly parted) hair that suggests [[IWasQuiteALooker he was once a handsome young man]], or conversely Michael Cerveris's Sweeney still being relatively young and handsome, but hollow-eyed, dour, and [[BaldOfEvil completely bald]].
to:
** The stage version implies that this happened too, with the original stage version giving him thick, wavy (if unflatteringly parted) hair that suggests [[IWasQuiteALooker he was once a handsome young man]], or conversely Michael Cerveris's Sweeney still being relatively young and handsome, but hollow-eyed, dour, and [[BaldOfEvil completely bald]]. Josh Groban in the 2023 revival looks like... well, Josh Groban, but made up to look hollow, gaunt, and exhausted.
** [[spoiler:JoshGroban in the 2023 revival actually ''laughs with exhausted relief'' when Toby pulls him up by the hair to slit his throat.]]
Changed line(s) 52 (click to see context) from:
* KarmicDeath: [[spoiler: Dies the same way he kills his victims, by having his throat slashed with a razor.]]
to:
* KarmicDeath: [[spoiler: Dies the same way he kills his victims, by having his throat slashed with a razor.razor- though he arguably still dodged some of that karma by at least wanting it by that point.]]
Changed line(s) 69 (click to see context) from:
* NiceGuy: Used to be a loving father and husband until Turpin had him arrested and shipped off to Australia.
to:
* NiceGuy: Used to be a loving father and husband until Turpin had him arrested and shipped off to Australia. In some productions (such as the 2023 revival), there are still flashes of this here and there, which only makes the depravity he's sunken to worse.
Changed line(s) 107 (click to see context) from:
* AdaptationalAttractiveness: Zigzagged; she is described in the libretto as a "vigorous, slatternly woman in her forties", and the "slatternly" (which just means unkempt and/or ReallyGetsAround) part is fairly open to interpretation, ranging from Creator/AngelaLansbury's matronly dustmop to Dorothy Loudon, her first replacement, playing her as simply pretty, and onto to Creator/PattiLuPone's 2005 Lovett being TheVamp in torn stockings and Creator/HelenaBonhamCarter's UnkemptBeauty interpretation. However, in ''Literature/TheStringOfPearls'', the original penny dreadful that began the Sweeney Todd legend in the first place, she is explicitly young and beautiful, which makes all of the portrayals that lean her toward plainness mild AdaptationalUgliness.
to:
* AdaptationalAttractiveness: Zigzagged; she is described in the libretto as a "vigorous, slatternly woman in her forties", and the "slatternly" (which just means unkempt and/or ReallyGetsAround) part is fairly open to interpretation, ranging from Creator/AngelaLansbury's matronly dustmop to Dorothy Loudon, her first replacement, playing her as simply pretty, and onto to Creator/PattiLuPone's 2005 Lovett being TheVamp in torn stockings and stockings, Creator/HelenaBonhamCarter's UnkemptBeauty interpretation, and Creator/AnnaleighAshford's petite, demure-looking blonde striver interpretation. However, in ''Literature/TheStringOfPearls'', the original penny dreadful that began the Sweeney Todd legend in the first place, she is explicitly young and beautiful, which makes all of the portrayals that lean her toward plainness mild AdaptationalUgliness.
** In the 2023 revival, she ''adores'' Toby from the start. [[spoiler:She still realizes the boy has to be disposed of after he realizes Sweeney must have killed Pirelli, but she cries and stammers over her words when she feels pushed to this point.]]
Changed line(s) 118 (click to see context) from:
* CuteAndPsycho: Well, how cute she is depends on the actress, but as played by Helena Bonham Carter, she's ''stunning''. And murderously insane (or, alternatively, sane but ''absolutely'' lacking in any moral compass whatsoever).
to:
* CuteAndPsycho: Well, how cute she is depends on the actress, but as played by Helena Bonham Carter, in many versions, she's ''stunning''. And murderously insane (or, alternatively, sane but ''absolutely'' lacking in any moral compass whatsoever).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Coitus Ensues got renamed because of misuse. I also removed that pothole because it seems misused to me.
Changed line(s) 255 (click to see context) from:
* TheIngenue: Subverted -- living more as Judge Turpin's prisoner (and the [[LustObject target of his perverse lust]]) than his daughter has left Johanna brittle, anxious, and more than a little cynical, and when Anthony rescues her from the asylum, in the musical [[spoiler:she's the one who actually shoots and kills Fogg]]. She also tosses Anthony the key to her house from her window, and in some productions [[CoitusEnsues sleeps with him]] ''before she even knows his name''!
to:
* TheIngenue: Subverted -- living more as Judge Turpin's prisoner (and the [[LustObject target of his perverse lust]]) than his daughter has left Johanna brittle, anxious, and more than a little cynical, and when Anthony rescues her from the asylum, in the musical [[spoiler:she's the one who actually shoots and kills Fogg]]. She also tosses Anthony the key to her house from her window, and in some productions [[CoitusEnsues sleeps with him]] him ''before she even knows his name''!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* WouldHitAGirl: Slashes the throat and the beggar woman and throws Mrs. Lovett into an open flame at the end of the film.
Changed line(s) 202 (click to see context) from:
* MeaningfulName: He's the most optimistic character in the entire work.
to:
* MeaningfulName: He's the most optimistic character in the entire work.work and his surname is "Hope".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 194 (click to see context) from:
* {{Determinator}}: Anthony ''will not give up'', ever. Yes, he's enamored with Johanna, but when describing her the first words out of his mouth are "There's a girl who needs my help!" (and given she gave him the key to her house, she definitely ''wants'' him to, too). And he takes that duty ''very'' seriously throughout the story, refusing to be deterred by beatings, threats, or her being shipped off to an insane asylum.
to:
* {{Determinator}}: {{Determinator}}:
** Anthony ''will not give up'', ever. Yes, he's enamored with Johanna, but when describing her the first words out of his mouth are "There's a girl who needs my help!" (and given she gave him the key to her house, she definitely ''wants'' him to, too).And he He takes that duty ''very'' seriously throughout the story, refusing to be deterred by beatings, threats, or her being shipped off to an insane asylum.
** Anthony ''will not give up'', ever. Yes, he's enamored with Johanna, but when describing her the first words out of his mouth are "There's a girl who needs my help!" (and given she gave him the key to her house, she definitely ''wants'' him to, too).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Deleted line(s) 80 (click to see context) :
* ReassignedToAntarctica: The judge sent Benjamin off to Botany Bay on a false charge so that he could get at his wife Lucy.
Added DiffLines:
* SentencedToDownUnder: The judge sent Benjamin off to Botany Bay on a false charge so that he could get at his wife Lucy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 194,196 (click to see context) from:
* {{Determinator}}:
** A less cynical reading of Anthony makes him out to be this, especially in the movie adaptation. Yes, he's enamored with Johanna, but when describing her the first words out of his mouth are "There's a girl who needs my help!" And he takes that duty ''very'' seriously throughout the story, refusing to be deterred by beatings, threats, or her being shipped off to an insane asylum once she makes it clear that she ''wants him'' to help her.
** The [[StalkerWithACrush otherwise kind of creepy]] lyrics of 'Johanna' are rendered decidedly sweeter and more genuine with context and this interpretation. Yes, under normal circumstances it would not be particularly romantic to swear you're going to track a young girl down and kidnap her away, and that in the meantime you'll imagine what it would be like to be holding her. When the girl in question is currently huddled in a filthy corner, terrified and alone, however... it can be read less as an unhealthy obsession and more as [[YouAreNotAlone an oath to a frightened young woman]] that he's not going to give up on [[RescueRomance saving her]] just because their path to freedom has gotten harder. Plus, she gives him her key in the movie, making clear that she wants him to help her.
** A less cynical reading of Anthony makes him out to be this, especially in the movie adaptation. Yes, he's enamored with Johanna, but when describing her the first words out of his mouth are "There's a girl who needs my help!" And he takes that duty ''very'' seriously throughout the story, refusing to be deterred by beatings, threats, or her being shipped off to an insane asylum once she makes it clear that she ''wants him'' to help her.
** The [[StalkerWithACrush otherwise kind of creepy]] lyrics of 'Johanna' are rendered decidedly sweeter and more genuine with context and this interpretation. Yes, under normal circumstances it would not be particularly romantic to swear you're going to track a young girl down and kidnap her away, and that in the meantime you'll imagine what it would be like to be holding her. When the girl in question is currently huddled in a filthy corner, terrified and alone, however... it can be read less as an unhealthy obsession and more as [[YouAreNotAlone an oath to a frightened young woman]] that he's not going to give up on [[RescueRomance saving her]] just because their path to freedom has gotten harder. Plus, she gives him her key in the movie, making clear that she wants him to help her.
to:
* {{Determinator}}:
** A less cynical reading of{{Determinator}}: Anthony makes him out to be this, especially in the movie adaptation. ''will not give up'', ever. Yes, he's enamored with Johanna, but when describing her the first words out of his mouth are "There's a girl who needs my help!" (and given she gave him the key to her house, she definitely ''wants'' him to, too). And he takes that duty ''very'' seriously throughout the story, refusing to be deterred by beatings, threats, or her being shipped off to an insane asylum once she makes it clear that she ''wants him'' to help her.
asylum.
** The [[StalkerWithACrushotherwise kind of potentially creepy]] lyrics of 'Johanna' are rendered decidedly sweeter and more genuine with context and this interpretation.context. Yes, under normal circumstances it would not be particularly romantic to swear you're going to track a young girl down and kidnap her away, and that in the meantime you'll imagine what it would be like to be holding her. When the girl in question is currently huddled in a filthy corner, terrified and alone, however... it can be read less as an unhealthy obsession and more as [[YouAreNotAlone an oath to a frightened young woman]] that he's not going to give up on [[RescueRomance saving her]] just because their path to freedom has gotten harder. Plus, she gives him her key in the movie, making clear that she wants him to help her.
** A less cynical reading of
** The [[StalkerWithACrush
Changed line(s) 203 (click to see context) from:
* NiceGuy: Depending on the adaptation he can be the nicest character in the work. Downplayed in works that acknowledge the possible stalker-ish intent with Johanna.
to:
* MirrorCharacter: He's not that far off from the kind of man Sweeney once was in his former life as Benjamin Barker, but with the crucial difference that while Sweeney is ruled by despair, Anthony- true to his name- is always hopeful and proactive. When he finally realizes that London is a cruel, corrupt place, his response is to break the law ''to do the right thing'', not to wreak revenge.
* NiceGuy:Depending on the adaptation he can be the nicest The only character in the work. Downplayed in works whole thing that acknowledge the possible stalker-ish intent with Johanna.manages to be both stable and decent.
* NiceGuy:
Changed line(s) 205,207 (click to see context) from:
* ObsessionSong: A good number of people cite "Johanna," particularly the second half, as this.
* OfficialCouple: While Benjamin/Lucy and Sweeney/Mrs. Lovett fans are fiercely divided over who is the first OfficialCouple, Anthony/Johanna is very much the second.
* PrettyBoy: Bamford even says he has a "pretty little head" while beating him up and threatening him for Turpin.
* OfficialCouple: While Benjamin/Lucy and Sweeney/Mrs. Lovett fans are fiercely divided over who is the first OfficialCouple, Anthony/Johanna is very much the second.
* PrettyBoy: Bamford even says he has a "pretty little head" while beating him up and threatening him for Turpin.
to:
* PrettyBoy: Bamford even says he has a "pretty little head" while beating him up and threatening him for
Changed line(s) 209,211 (click to see context) from:
* StalkerWithACrush:
** The more cynical readings of Anthony's character make him out to be this for Johanna. The lyrics of the second half of "Johanna" definitely don't help things, nor his rather creepy bloody face as he sings it in the movie. Judge Turpin, on the other hand, is ten times worse.
** Completely averted in the musical. In "Kiss Me", they plan their escape together, and it’s clear they both have a serious case of LoveAtFirstSight. Johanna can’t wait to elope and marry Anthony right away.
** The more cynical readings of Anthony's character make him out to be this for Johanna. The lyrics of the second half of "Johanna" definitely don't help things, nor his rather creepy bloody face as he sings it in the movie. Judge Turpin, on the other hand, is ten times worse.
** Completely averted in the musical. In "Kiss Me", they plan their escape together, and it’s clear they both have a serious case of LoveAtFirstSight. Johanna can’t wait to elope and marry Anthony right away.
to:
* StalkerWithACrush:
** The more cynical readings of Anthony's character make him out to be this for Johanna. The lyrics ofStalkerWithACrush: In the second half of "Johanna" definitely don't help things, nor his rather creepy bloody face as he sings it in the movie. Judge Turpin, on the other hand, is ten times worse.
** Completely averted in the musical.2005 revival, but otherwise completely averted. In "Kiss Me", they plan their escape together, and it’s clear they both have a serious case of LoveAtFirstSight. Johanna can’t wait to elope and marry Anthony right away.
** The more cynical readings of Anthony's character make him out to be this for Johanna. The lyrics of
** Completely averted in the musical.
Changed line(s) 213,214 (click to see context) from:
'''Johanna''' : I loved you, even as I was you, even as it doesn’t matter that I still don’t know your name.
* TenorBoy: In the movie. Onstage, surprisingly, he's usually a baritone.
* TenorBoy: In the movie. Onstage, surprisingly, he's usually a baritone.
to:
'''Johanna''' : I loved you, even as I was saw you, even as it doesn’t matter that I still don’t know your name.
* TenorBoy: In the movie. Onstage, surprisingly, he'susually a baritone.baritone (albeit a lyric baritone, with a higher, warmer range than Sweeney).
* TenorBoy: In the movie. Onstage, surprisingly, he's
Changed line(s) 216,217 (click to see context) from:
* WideEyedIdealist: As Sweeney tells him near the beginning, "You are young. Life has been kind to you. You will learn." Johanna says a variant of the same thing to him near the end.
* WrongGenreSavvy: He fancies himself the hero of a RescueRomance, saving the DamselInDistress Johanna from the clutches of her evil guardian, and expects a HappilyEverAfter. He ''might'' get it, but we don't know for sure -- and even if he does, Johanna has a ''lot'' of emotional damage she's going to need help with.
* WrongGenreSavvy: He fancies himself the hero of a RescueRomance, saving the DamselInDistress Johanna from the clutches of her evil guardian, and expects a HappilyEverAfter. He ''might'' get it, but we don't know for sure -- and even if he does, Johanna has a ''lot'' of emotional damage she's going to need help with.
to:
* WideEyedIdealist: As Sweeney tells him near the beginning, "You are young. Life has been kind to you. You will learn." Johanna says a variant of the same thing to him near the end.
end. That said, while he ''does'' learn, he takes a decidedly different lesson from it than Sweeney did.
* WrongGenreSavvy: He fancies himself the hero of a RescueRomance, saving the DamselInDistress Johanna from the clutches of her evil guardian, and expects a HappilyEverAfter. He ''might'' get it, but we don't know for sure -- and even if he does, Johanna has a ''lot'' of emotional damage she's going to need help with. At least he's the kind of guy who will always be willing to do so.
* WrongGenreSavvy: He fancies himself the hero of a RescueRomance, saving the DamselInDistress Johanna from the clutches of her evil guardian, and expects a HappilyEverAfter. He ''might'' get it, but we don't know for sure -- and even if he does, Johanna has a ''lot'' of emotional damage she's going to need help with. At least he's the kind of guy who will always be willing to do so.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 9 (click to see context) from:
!!!'''Played by:''' Creator/LenCariou (Original Broadway Cast), George Hearn (2001 Concert), Creator/JohnnyDepp (2007 film), Michael Ball (West End, 2012)
to:
!!!'''Played by:''' Creator/LenCariou (Original Broadway Cast), George Hearn (2001 Concert), Creator/JohnnyDepp (2007 film), Michael Ball (West End, 2012)2012), Music/JoshGroban (2023 Broadway revival)
Changed line(s) 102 (click to see context) from:
!!!'''Played by:''' Creator/AngelaLansbury (Original Broadway Cast), Creator/PattiLuPone (2001 Concert), Creator/HelenaBonhamCarter (2007 film), Creator/ImeldaStaunton (West End, 2012)
to:
!!!'''Played by:''' Creator/AngelaLansbury (Original Broadway Cast), Creator/PattiLuPone (2001 Concert), Concert, 2005 Broadway revival), Creator/HelenaBonhamCarter (2007 film), Creator/ImeldaStaunton (West End, 2012)2012), Creator/AnnaleighAshford (Broadway revival 2023)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 149 (click to see context) from:
* SupremeChef: Once she gets her hands on some decent meat, that is. Otherwise they're just "''the worst pies in London''"
to:
* SupremeChef: Once she gets her hands on some decent meat, that is. Otherwise they're just "''the worst pies in London''"London''".