Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Characters / DuneDenisVilleneuveHouseHarkonnen

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He successfully destroys Sietch Tabr. In the book it's the Sardaukar who attack it, and kill Leto II and capture Alia, before being successfully fended off by children, the elderly and women (much to their humiliation) that Paul had left behind before they can finish the job.

Changed: 207

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
He also does in the book, and since in the book his plan via Thufir is the same one that Paul ends up using, clearly it stood a chance to work.


* AdaptationalBadass: The novel version is constantly thrown around by events, playing a perfunctory role in the Emperor's machinations, and this is best shown when he's reduced to submission by the Emperor's arrival. His film version, in contrast, is almost always much more in control of everything: kills personally Yueh in a impressive way suggesting he is not a total NonActionGuy, and when the Emperor arrives in Arrakis, even if their encounter transpires the same way, the Baron at least has the will and influence to gather the noble houses in response and turn them ''against'' Shaddam. Notably, he also claims to have a plan to plant a Harkonnen on the imperial throne, which, assuming he was not simply talking off his arse, he would clearly have a non-zero chance to achieve in this version.

to:

* AdaptationalBadass: The novel version is constantly thrown around by events, playing a perfunctory role in the Emperor's machinations, and this is best shown when he's reduced to submission by the Emperor's arrival. His film version, in contrast, is almost always much more in control of everything: kills personally Yueh in a impressive way suggesting he is not a total NonActionGuy, and when the Emperor arrives in Arrakis, even if their encounter transpires the same way, the Baron at least has the will and influence to gather the noble houses in response and turn them ''against'' Shaddam. Notably, he also claims to have a plan to plant a Harkonnen on the imperial throne, which, assuming he was not simply talking off his arse, he would clearly have a non-zero chance to achieve in this version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The book Baron, via Thufir, eventually does realize how powerful and numerous the Fremen are, and how they could be turned into an army to rival the Sardaukars, and his plot to put Feyd-Rautha in charge of Arrakis involves this. The film Baron never gets this idea, which in turns diminishes Feyd-Rautha's role as a dark mirror of Paul, and the implication in the book that the Jihad isn't entirely Paul's fault, due to the Fremen being such a potent resource that it's only a matter of time before ''someone'' weaponizes them, and someone would've done it even if Paul hadn't.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:''"RATS! HARRY RATS! KILL THEM!! KILL THEM!! KILL THEM ALL! KILL... THEM... ALL! RATS!"'']]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:''"RATS! HARRY HAIRY RATS! KILL THEM!! KILL THEM!! KILL THEM ALL! KILL... THEM... ALL! RATS!"'']]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalNiceGuy: While the Harkonnen are arguably more kill crazy than their book counterparts, the film leaves out the Baron's pedophilia, it also leaves out a lot of the more petty evil actions of the Harkonnen on Arrakis meant to frivolously waste water in full view of the natives both as a taunt and as a flex of their exceptional wealth, such as how the palace is purposefully designed to not retain its humidity from dissipating into the outside air, and the elaborate dinner rituals designed to waste water before handing the wet towels to beggars to scrabble over the water from wringing said towels.

to:

* AdaptationalNiceGuy: While the Harkonnen Harkonnens are arguably more kill crazy than their book counterparts, the film leaves out the Baron's pedophilia, it also leaves out a lot of the more petty evil actions of the Harkonnen Harkonnens on Arrakis meant to frivolously waste water in full view of the natives both as a taunt and as a flex of their exceptional wealth, such as how the palace is purposefully designed to not retain its humidity from dissipating into the outside air, and the elaborate dinner rituals designed to waste water before handing the wet towels to beggars to scrabble over the water from wringing said towels.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalNiceGuy: While the Harkonnen are arguably more kill crazy than their book counterparts, and the film leaves out the Baron's pedophilia, it also leaves out a lot of the more petty evil actions of the Harkonnen on Arrakis meant to frivolously waste water in full view of the natives both as a taunt and as a flex of their exceptional wealth, such as how the palace is purposefully designed to not retain its humidity from dissipating into the outside air, and the elaborate dinner rituals designed to waste water before handing the wet towels to beggars to scrabble over the water from wringing said towels.

to:

* AdaptationalNiceGuy: While the Harkonnen are arguably more kill crazy than their book counterparts, and the film leaves out the Baron's pedophilia, it also leaves out a lot of the more petty evil actions of the Harkonnen on Arrakis meant to frivolously waste water in full view of the natives both as a taunt and as a flex of their exceptional wealth, such as how the palace is purposefully designed to not retain its humidity from dissipating into the outside air, and the elaborate dinner rituals designed to waste water before handing the wet towels to beggars to scrabble over the water from wringing said towels.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChildishOlderSibling: His little brother Feyd is also a [[Ax-Crazy vicious nutcase]], but what Feyd ''isn't'' is a PsychopathicManchild.

to:

* ChildishOlderSibling: His little brother Feyd is also a [[Ax-Crazy [[AxCrazy vicious nutcase]], but what Feyd ''isn't'' is a PsychopathicManchild.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ChildishOlderSibling: His little brother Feyd is also a [[Ax-Crazy vicious nutcase]], but what Feyd ''isn't'' is a PsychopathicManchild.

Added: 1813

Changed: 679

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalDumbass: Downplayed. He's much less incompetent than the literary Baron, but he lacks his novel counterpart's streak of GenreSavvy. Notably The Baron accepts Rabban's statement that Paul and Jessica died from flying into a sandstorm, whereas his book counterpart flew into a rage when presented with this claim, knowing that it's premature to believe they're dead if the Harkonnens NeverFoundTheBody. Additionally, in the book Piter and the Baron develop the plan to bring the downfall of House Atreides. While the Emperor aided and supported him, it was largely The Baron's scheme. In the movie, The Baron is depicted as a junior, albeit extremely willing, partner in The Emperor's ploy.

to:

* AdaptationalDumbass: AdaptationalDumbass:
**
Downplayed. He's much less incompetent than the literary Baron, but he lacks his novel counterpart's streak of GenreSavvy. Notably The Baron accepts Rabban's statement that Paul and Jessica died from flying into a sandstorm, whereas his book counterpart flew into a rage when presented with this claim, knowing that it's premature to believe they're dead if the Harkonnens NeverFoundTheBody. Additionally, in the book Piter and the Baron develop the plan to bring the downfall of House Atreides. While the Emperor aided and supported him, it was largely The Baron's scheme. In the movie, The Baron is depicted as a junior, albeit extremely willing, partner in The Emperor's ploy.ploy.
** Because the events leading to the assault on the Atreides are compressed, a lot of the layers and complexities of the plan never make it to screen, making it seem that for all his genius, the Baron's entire plan was "Get the Emperor's dudes to help me". In the book the Baron and Pieter deliberately let it leak that they have a mole, to plant paranoia among the Atreides. They also make sure the Atreides find them smuggling Lasguns, as to plant in them doubts about using shields. [[note]]In the book, laser impacting shields detonate both of them in a blast that can compare to a nuclear blast at high levels. But it's also possible to put a lasgun on a timer or remote, so that it'll fire at a static shield with no one in the blast zone.[[/note]] Then employing what would be archaic artillery normally rendered useless by shields to supplement their assault when the Atreides have turned their shields off. He even goes so far as to, as Thufir Hawat comes to suspect, plant false intel about how much money the Harkonnens have made from Arrakis so as to muddle just how much money he has on hand to move troops to Arrakis.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnimalMotifs: His tendency to [[ScreamingWarrior snarl and bark during combat]] gives him a primal quality not unlike a rabid dog, not to mention how often he bares his [[ScaryTeeth blackened teeth]]. Gurney outright calls Feyd an "animal", a description that is even more appropriate here than in the original book.

to:

* AnimalMotifs: His tendency to [[ScreamingWarrior snarl and bark during combat]] gives him a primal quality not unlike a rabid dog, not to mention how often he bares his [[ScaryTeeth blackened teeth]]. Gurney outright calls Feyd an "animal", a description that is even more appropriate here than in the original book.book and is a juxtaposition to the "young pup" nickname given to Paul.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlwaysNight: The planet Giedi Prime is fouled with pollution, preventing sunlight from piercing the cloud cover.

to:

* AlwaysNight: The planet Their planet, Giedi Prime Prime, is fouled with pollution, preventing sunlight from piercing the cloud cover.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No more than in the movie.


* AdaptationalBadass: The novel version is constantly thrown around by events, playing a perfunctory role in the Emperor's machinations and only surviving to Leto's attempt on his life by dumb luck, and this is best shown when he's reduced to submission by the Emperor's arrival. His film version, in contrast, is almost always much more in control of everything: kills personally Yueh in a impressive way suggesting he is not a total NonActionGuy, and when the Emperor arrives in Arrakis, even if their encounter transpires the same way, the Baron at least has the will and influence to gather the noble houses in response and turn them ''against'' Shaddam. Notably, he also claims to have a plan to plant a Harkonnen on the imperial throne, which, assuming he was not simply talking off his arse, he would clearly have a non-zero chance to achieve in this version.

to:

* AdaptationalBadass: The novel version is constantly thrown around by events, playing a perfunctory role in the Emperor's machinations and only surviving to Leto's attempt on his life by dumb luck, machinations, and this is best shown when he's reduced to submission by the Emperor's arrival. His film version, in contrast, is almost always much more in control of everything: kills personally Yueh in a impressive way suggesting he is not a total NonActionGuy, and when the Emperor arrives in Arrakis, even if their encounter transpires the same way, the Baron at least has the will and influence to gather the noble houses in response and turn them ''against'' Shaddam. Notably, he also claims to have a plan to plant a Harkonnen on the imperial throne, which, assuming he was not simply talking off his arse, he would clearly have a non-zero chance to achieve in this version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Book Baron also survives because he has a shield, and also because he realized from what Yueh had said that something was up with Leto, so arguably he's more competent in the book.


* AdaptationalBadass: The novel version is constantly thrown around by events, playing a perfunctory role in the Emperor's machinations and only surviving to Leto's attempt on his life by dumb luck, and this is best shown when he's reduced to submission by the Emperor's arrival. His film version, in contrast, is almost always much more in control of everything: he survives the attempt thanks to his personal gear and quick thinking, kills personally Yueh in a impressive way suggesting he is not a total NonActionGuy, and when the Emperor arrives in Arrakis, even if their encounter transpires the same way, the Baron at least has the will and influence to gather the noble houses in response and turn them ''against'' Shaddam. Notably, he also claims to have a plan to plant a Harkonnen on the imperial throne, which, assuming he was not simply talking off his arse, he would clearly have a non-zero chance to achieve in this version.

to:

* AdaptationalBadass: The novel version is constantly thrown around by events, playing a perfunctory role in the Emperor's machinations and only surviving to Leto's attempt on his life by dumb luck, and this is best shown when he's reduced to submission by the Emperor's arrival. His film version, in contrast, is almost always much more in control of everything: he survives the attempt thanks to his personal gear and quick thinking, kills personally Yueh in a impressive way suggesting he is not a total NonActionGuy, and when the Emperor arrives in Arrakis, even if their encounter transpires the same way, the Baron at least has the will and influence to gather the noble houses in response and turn them ''against'' Shaddam. Notably, he also claims to have a plan to plant a Harkonnen on the imperial throne, which, assuming he was not simply talking off his arse, he would clearly have a non-zero chance to achieve in this version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:''"Rest? REST? KILL... THEM... ALL! KILL... THEM... ALL! RATS!"'']]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:''"Rest? REST? KILL... THEM... [[caption-width-right:350:''"RATS! HARRY RATS! KILL THEM!! KILL THEM!! KILL THEM ALL! KILL... THEM... ALL! RATS!"'']]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalNiceGuy: While the Harkonnen are arguably more kill crazy than their book counterparts, and the film leaves out the Baron's pedophilia, it also leaves out a lot of the more petty evil actions of the Harkonnen on Arrakis meant to frivolously waste water in full view of the natives both as a taunt and as a flex of their exceptional wealth, such as how the palace is purposefully designed to not retain its humidity from dissipating into the outside air, and the elaborate dinner rituals designed to waste water before handing the wet towels to beggars to scrabble over the water from wringing said towels.

Added: 757

Changed: 327

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NotSoStoic: [[spoiler:When Leto releases the poison gas in his tooth, the Baron goes visibly OhCrap and rapidly escapes to the farthest, highest corner of the ceiling he can find to remove himself from the threat. He is still clinging to that spot when his servants unseal the room the next morning, and is moaning in pain, fear or both.]]

to:

* NotSoStoic: NotSoStoic:
**
[[spoiler:When Leto releases the poison gas in his tooth, the Baron goes visibly OhCrap and rapidly escapes to the farthest, highest corner of the ceiling he can find to remove himself from the threat. He is still clinging to that spot when his servants unseal the room the next morning, and is moaning in pain, fear or both.]]
** [[spoiler:In ''Part Two'', the normally composed Baron is on the defensive when Emperor Shaddam IV is criticizing him for his failure to control Arrakis, and he subsequently doubles down in terror and pain when he's stripped of his antigravity harness. When he's at Paul's mercy, Vladimir can only gape in horror as the vengeful heir of House Atreides acknowledges their familial heritage shortly before finishing him off.
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* VillainWithGoodPublicity: He's regarded as a benevolent leader by his people. This could not be further from the truth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A great House of the Landsraad, with their capital on the heavily industrialized planet Giedi Prime. The historical enemies of House Atreides, they are infamous for their underhanded and sinister political tactics, fueled by ambition, malevolence, hatred and brutality. They are ruled by a Baron.

to:

A great major House of the Landsraad, with their capital on the heavily industrialized planet Giedi Prime. The historical enemies of House Atreides, they are infamous for their underhanded and sinister political tactics, fueled by ambition, malevolence, hatred and brutality. They are ruled by a Baron.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

A great House of the Landsraad, with their capital on the heavily industrialized planet Giedi Prime. The historical enemies of House Atreides, they are infamous for their underhanded and sinister political tactics, fueled by ambition, malevolence, hatred and brutality. They are ruled by a Baron.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheCorruption: [[spoiler:Both Paul and Jessica undergo profound personality changes after taking the Water of Life, and both of them admit to learning their relationship to him after taking the water, implying that the Water's effect of awakening them to their Harkonnen descent is what turns them ruthless and manipulative. It's even lampshaded by Paul declaring that they are Harkonnens, and to survive they will have to be Harkonnens.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DragonAscendant: [[spoiler:Feyd succeeds his uncle as head of House Harkonnen, following the Baron's death at Paul's hands in the climax of ''Part Two''. His ascendancy doesn't short-lived, however, as Feyd himself is killed by Paul in a final duel to decide the Imperial throne.]]

to:

* DragonAscendant: [[spoiler:Feyd succeeds his uncle as head of House Harkonnen, following the Baron's death at Paul's hands in the climax of ''Part Two''. His ascendancy doesn't is short-lived, however, as Feyd himself is killed by Paul in a final duel to decide the Imperial throne.]]



* NoChallengeEqualsNoSatisfaction: Being a full-fledged BloodKnight, Feyd relishes a good fight when he finds one. Notably, when he cuts down the first two Atreides soldiers who'd been drugged, Feyd does so casually with an almost bored expression on his face. When he gets to Lanville and realizes he isn't drugged and can actually give him a fight, Feyd is notably ecstatic and savors every second of it, even discarding his shield to make the fight more fair and barking at the guards to back off when they try to assist him.

to:

* NoChallengeEqualsNoSatisfaction: Being a full-fledged BloodKnight, Feyd relishes a good fight when he finds one. Notably, when he cuts down the first two Atreides soldiers soldiers, who'd been drugged, drugged prior to the fight, Feyd does so casually with an almost bored expression on his face. When he gets to Lanville and realizes he isn't drugged and can actually give him a fight, Feyd is notably ecstatic and savors every second of it, even discarding his shield to make the fight more fair and barking at the guards to back off when they try to assist him.

Changed: 12

Removed: 424

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Evil Albino is no longer a trope, and Albinos Are Freaks is only about discrimination.


* AlbinosAreFreaks: The villainous Harkonnens and their soldiers have very pale skin in this adaptation. Villeneuve [[https://ew.com/movies/dune-trailer-breakdown-denis-villeneuve/ explained]] that their homeworld of Giedi Prime is so polluted that they're not used to the sun. Stilgar also mentions that Harkonnen bodies are so loaded with chemicals that the Fremen can only use the water they extract for cooling purposes.



* RedRightHand: In addition to the BaldOfEvil and EvilAlbino traits shared among all Harkonnen, Feyd and his cannibalistic harem have had their teeth painted black. This makes him particularly unsettling to look at, especially when he's [[ScaryTeeth baring them in the heat of battle]].

to:

* RedRightHand: In addition to the BaldOfEvil and EvilAlbino albinistic traits shared among all Harkonnen, Feyd and his cannibalistic harem have had their teeth painted black. This makes him particularly unsettling to look at, especially when he's [[ScaryTeeth baring them in the heat of battle]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DragonAscendant: [[spoiler:Feyd succeeds his uncle as head of House Harkonnen, following the Baron's death at Paul's hands in the climax of ''Part Two''. His ascendancy doesn't short-lived, however, as Feyd himself is killed by Paul in a final duel to decide the Imperial throne.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalNiceGuy: Feyd is still very much a psychotic despot-to-be, but the film's AdaptationalBadass treatment makes him much more of an honorable warrior than the original CombatPragmatist from the book. His attempts to assassinate the Baron are also omitted, with him reacting to his own assassination attempt with the disgust of someone who considers himself over treachery, and it's stated Feyd intends to inherit his uncle's titles legitimately.

to:

* AdaptationalNiceGuy: Feyd is still very much a psychotic despot-to-be, but the film's AdaptationalBadass treatment makes him much more of an honorable warrior than the original CombatPragmatist from the book. His attempts to assassinate the Baron are also omitted, with him reacting to his own assassination attempt with the disgust of someone who considers himself over treachery, and it's stated Feyd intends to inherit his uncle's titles legitimately. Margot outright notes that he values honor and this is a lever they can use to control him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbitionIsEvil: All Harkonnen leadership seek power to one degree or another, and will use any means possible to see their ambitions realized. Due to their brutal MightMakesRight philosophy, a Harkonnen has to be ruthless and cutthroat to climb the social hierarchy, or risk being killed themselves by someone even more ambitious than them.

to:

* AmbitionIsEvil: All Harkonnen leadership seek power to one degree or another, and will use any means possible to see their ambitions realized. Due to their brutal MightMakesRight philosophy, a Harkonnen has to be ruthless and cutthroat to climb the social hierarchy, or risk being killed themselves by someone even more an equally ambitious than them.rival.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbitionIsEvil: All Harkonnen leadership seek power to one degree or another, and will use any means possible to see their ambitions realized. Due to their brutal MightMakesRigh philosophy, a Harkonnen has to be ruthless and cutthroat to climb the social hierarchy, or risk being killed themselves by someone even more ambitious than them.

to:

* AmbitionIsEvil: All Harkonnen leadership seek power to one degree or another, and will use any means possible to see their ambitions realized. Due to their brutal MightMakesRigh MightMakesRight philosophy, a Harkonnen has to be ruthless and cutthroat to climb the social hierarchy, or risk being killed themselves by someone even more ambitious than them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbitionIsEvil: All Harkonnen leadership are ambitious to one degree or another. Due to their brutal MightMakesRigh philosophy, a Harkonnen has to be ruthless and cutthroat to climb the social hierarchy, or risk being killed themselves by someone even more ambitious than them.

to:

* AmbitionIsEvil: All Harkonnen leadership are ambitious seek power to one degree or another.another, and will use any means possible to see their ambitions realized. Due to their brutal MightMakesRigh philosophy, a Harkonnen has to be ruthless and cutthroat to climb the social hierarchy, or risk being killed themselves by someone even more ambitious than them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AmbitionIsEvil: All Harkonnen leadership are ambitious to one degree or another. Due to their brutal MightMakesRigh philosophy, a Harkonnen has to be ruthless and cutthroat to climb the social hierarchy, or risk being killed themselves by someone even more ambitious than them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DragonTheirFeet: [[spoiler:He outlives the Baron by attempting to get out of dodge as soon as Paul and the Fremen descend upon the Imperial stronghold. He doesn't get past Arrakeen before Gurney catches up to him and settles his grudge with a knife to the Beast's throat.]

to:

* DragonTheirFeet: [[spoiler:He outlives the Baron by attempting to get out of dodge as soon as Paul and the Fremen descend upon the Imperial stronghold. He doesn't get past Arrakeen before Gurney catches up to him and settles his grudge with a knife to the Beast's throat.]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalWimp: The reader never quite gets a look on Feyd's inner world in the novel, so it's reasonable to assume he's just as confident and worldly as he looks. Meanwhile, the film makes him surprisingly vulnerable in this field, showing him disappointed and angry at his uncle's attempt on his life, and later insecure and almost disturbed at Margot's advances. Her report on him to Mohiam explicitly state she is drawing on his insecurities to manipulate him.

to:

* AdaptationalWimp: Zig-zagged. The film's Feyd is clearly superior to the book's Feyd as a ''warrior'', but the reader never quite gets a look on at Feyd's inner world in the novel, so it's reasonable to assume he's just as confident and worldly as he looks. Meanwhile, the film makes depicts him surprisingly vulnerable in this field, showing him disappointed and angry at his uncle's attempt on his life, and later insecure and almost disturbed at Margot's advances. Her report on him to Mohiam explicitly state she is drawing on his insecurities to manipulate him.

Top