Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Blog / TheComicsCurmudgeon

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added Guest Host example

Added DiffLines:

* GuestHost: "Uncle Lumpy", a long-time commenter who has filled in for Josh periodically since 2007. He typically mixes in a few comics that Josh rarely or never covers (e.g. ''ComicStrip/NineChickweedLane''), according to his own tastes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixed error: he's not Walt's dad, he is Walt and he's Jeremy's dad


* BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor: Josh once complained about how most comic strip parents were coded as Baby Boomers even when they were clearly too young for that (generally due to the ongoing march of ComicBookTime). Then a certain ''ComicStrip/{{Zits}}'' strip [[https://joshreads.com/2019/10/crankshaft-got-radicalized-in-a-gardening-subreddit-probably/#zits came across his desk]], depicting Walt's dad as a literal dinosaur because he used to rent movies from the video store as a teenager--which would make him a Gen-X'er or even an older Millenial. Since Josh is himself a Gen-X'er with fond memories of the video-rental age, this made him feel very old indeed.

to:

* BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor: Josh once complained about how most comic strip parents were coded as Baby Boomers even when they were clearly too young for that (generally due to the ongoing march of ComicBookTime). Then a certain ''ComicStrip/{{Zits}}'' strip [[https://joshreads.com/2019/10/crankshaft-got-radicalized-in-a-gardening-subreddit-probably/#zits came across his desk]], depicting Walt's Jeremy's dad as a literal dinosaur because he used to rent movies from the video store as a teenager--which would make him a Gen-X'er or even an older Millenial. Since Josh is himself a Gen-X'er with fond memories of the video-rental age, this made him feel very old indeed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* MagicalNegro: Josh's assessment of Otha "Clambake" Yancey, a colorful character from a 2007 ''ComicStrip/GilThorp'' story arc:
-->[[https://joshreads.com/2007/04/metapost-youre-pulling-your-head-son/ Clambake]] pretty much exudes that vibe, associated with nice old black men in too many movies and books to count, of "Here's a nice old black man who's going to help you white people solve your problems with his folk wisdom/instinctive understanding of human nature/magical powers, but isn't going to do anything to make you uncomfortable, like have sex with white women or vote or speak in that damn 'izzle' language."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* BrickJoke: [[http://joshreads.com/?p=107 October 21st, 2004]]: Josh posts an email from "Doc Martian" consisting of "ANDY CAPP!" 10 times in the subject line and 44 in the body. [[http://joshreads.com/?p=27042 April 22nd, 2016]]: In a post titled "This one's for you, Doc Martian, wherever you are", Josh decides "why ''not'' Andy Capp?" and does his first commentary on the comic.

to:

* BrickJoke: [[http://joshreads.com/?p=107 October 21st, 2004]]: Josh posts an email from "Doc Martian" consisting of "ANDY CAPP!" "[[ComicStrip/AndyCapp ANDY CAPP!]]" 10 times in the subject line and 44 in the body. [[http://joshreads.com/?p=27042 April 22nd, 2016]]: In a post titled "This one's for you, Doc Martian, wherever you are", Josh decides "why ''not'' Andy Capp?" and does his first commentary on the comic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor: Josh once complained about how most comic strip parents were coded as Baby Boomers even when they were clearly too young for that (generally due to the ongoing march of ComicBookTime). Then a certain ''ComicStrip/{{Zits}}'' strip [[https://joshreads.com/2019/10/crankshaft-got-radicalized-in-a-gardening-subreddit-probably/#zits came across his desk]], depicting Walt's dad as a literal dinosaur because he used to rent movies from the video store as a teenager--which would make him a Gen-X'er or even an older Millenial. Since Josh is himself a Gen-X'er with fond memories of the video-rental age, this made him feel very old indeed.
-->Noooooo ... not like this. ''Not like this.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removed Flame Bait wicks


* SnootySports: Golf-related comic strips are a frequent source of SnarkBait from the comics.

to:

* SnootySports: Golf-related comic strips are a frequent source of SnarkBait from the comics.snark material.



* ThinkOfTheChildren: What he says of a ''ComicStrip/HiAndLois'' [[http://joshreads.com/?p=229 strip depicting a heart-shaped candy box as black even in color]], [[UnfortunateImplications implying that the title characters are in an S&M relationship]].

to:

* ThinkOfTheChildren: What he says of a ''ComicStrip/HiAndLois'' [[http://joshreads.com/?p=229 strip depicting a heart-shaped candy box as black even in color]], [[UnfortunateImplications implying that the title characters are in an S&M relationship]].relationship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

** The ''Daddy Daze'' daddy can't actually understand his infant's pre-verbal babbling; instead, he's going slowly insane due to loneliness and projecting his deranged thoughts onto his child.

Added: 393

Removed: 244

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misplaced, moving to a more appropriate trope


** Leroy and Loretta from the ComicStrip/TheLockhorns are actually elder Millennials. This is more poking fun about ComicBookTime and commending the comic for actually making references to modern phenomena without coming across as cringeworthy.


Added DiffLines:

** Leroy and Loretta from the ''ComicStrip/TheLockhorns'' are actually Millennials. This is a joke that's mostly poking fun of how the average reader of his blog is [[ParanoiaFuel aging closer]] to the titular characters due to ComicBookTime, not helped by it being one of the few comics Josh covers that can make references to modern phenomena ''without'' being cringeworthy and out of touch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added an example

Added DiffLines:

** Leroy and Loretta from the ComicStrip/TheLockhorns are actually elder Millennials. This is more poking fun about ComicBookTime and commending the comic for actually making references to modern phenomena without coming across as cringeworthy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheNoseless: What Josh realises to his horror in regards to [[ComicStrip/{{Garfield}} Jon Arbuckle]], when he and [[ComicStrip/{{Blondie}} Dagwood Bumstead]] [[http://joshreads.com/?p=395 appeared together in the same panel]].

to:

* TheNoseless: What Josh realises to his horror in regards to [[ComicStrip/{{Garfield}} Jon Arbuckle]], when he and [[ComicStrip/{{Blondie}} [[ComicStrip/Blondie1930 Dagwood Bumstead]] [[http://joshreads.com/?p=395 appeared together in the same panel]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing index wick


** The ''ComicStrip/{{Pluggers}}'' and ''ComicStrip/SnuffySmith'' comics generally get reviewed with a mildly sneery checklist of pretty much every stereotype off the AcceptableTargets[[invoked]] checklist regarding rural people.

to:

** The ''ComicStrip/{{Pluggers}}'' and ''ComicStrip/SnuffySmith'' comics generally get reviewed with a mildly sneery checklist of pretty much every stereotype off the AcceptableTargets[[invoked]] checklist regarding rural people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ComicStrip/MarkTrail is [[UsefulNotes/{{asexuality}} asexual]] and secretly hates Rusty.

to:

** ComicStrip/MarkTrail is [[UsefulNotes/{{asexuality}} asexual]] UsefulNotes/{{asexual}} and secretly hates Rusty.

Changed: 96

Removed: 54

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope is IUEO


* FetishRetardant: In-universe, Josh has noted that he's never turned on by highly sexualized female characters such as June Morgan or Blondie, yet is [[PerverseSexualLust head-over-heels in love with]] Margo [=McGee=]. Part of it is his well documented love of strong, take-charge women.

to:

* FetishRetardant: In-universe, Josh has noted that he's never turned on by highly sexualized female characters such as June Morgan or Blondie, yet is [[PerverseSexualLust head-over-heels in love with]] with Margo [=McGee=]. Part of it is his well documented love of strong, take-charge women.



* PerverseSexualLust: Josh has it for Margo [=McGee=].



** In ''ComicStrip/Apartment3G'', Luann is [[DumbBlonde vapid]], Tommie has the personality of cardboard, and Margo Magee is a memetic psychopath who would just as soon snap someone's neck as acknowledge they exist. Of course, no part of that diminishes Josh's PerverseSexualLust for her.

to:

** In ''ComicStrip/Apartment3G'', Luann is [[DumbBlonde vapid]], Tommie has the personality of cardboard, and Margo Magee is a memetic psychopath who would just as soon snap someone's neck as acknowledge they exist. Of course, no part of that diminishes Josh's PerverseSexualLust for her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AuthorVocabularyCalendar: Frequently uses the word "ratiocination" (definition: "logical and methodical reasoning" or "the process of exact thinking") to describe the mystery/puzzle-solving abilities of [[ComicStrip/SlylockFox Slylock Fox]].

to:

* AuthorVocabularyCalendar: Frequently uses the word "ratiocination" (definition: "logical and methodical reasoning" or "the process of exact thinking") to describe the mystery/puzzle-solving abilities of [[ComicStrip/SlylockFox Slylock Fox]].ComicStrip/SlylockFox.



** ''ComicStrip/SlylockFox'' He jokes about the world being a dystopian society where animals evolved and overthrew the human race. Josh managed to pinpoint [[http://joshreads.com/?p=18625 where it all started]]

to:

** ''ComicStrip/SlylockFox'' ''ComicStrip/SlylockFox''- He jokes about the world being a dystopian society where animals evolved and overthrew the human race. Josh managed to pinpoint [[http://joshreads.com/?p=18625 where it all started]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ADateWithRosiePalms: Josh attempts to make one of these jokes about [[https://joshreads.com/2016/12/lotta-bird-metaphors-flying-around-hnn-hq/ December 22nd, 2016 Mary Worth]]:
-->'''Wilbur:''' My '''work''' for the day is '''done.''' Now... (thinks about Iris) on to matters of the '''heart!'''
-->'''Josh:''' Ahh, yes, Wilbur’s finished his writing for the day and now it’s time for him to engage his imagination and indulge in some solo erot[my keyboard, computer, and cable modem simultaneously melt down in a desperate attempt to prevent me from finishing that sentence]
-->'''Josh:''' [I sign in with my phone]Those fingerless gloves he had on in yesterday’s strip should make the whole thing eas[the entire cell network for southern California goes up in flames in an act of species preservation]


** In ''ComicStrip/ApartmentThreeG'', Luann is [[DumbBlonde vapid]], Tommie has the personality of cardboard, and Margo Magee is a memetic psychopath who would just as soon snap someone's neck as acknowledge they exist. Of course, no part of that diminishes Josh's PerverseSexualLust for her.

to:

** In ''ComicStrip/ApartmentThreeG'', ''ComicStrip/Apartment3G'', Luann is [[DumbBlonde vapid]], Tommie has the personality of cardboard, and Margo Magee is a memetic psychopath who would just as soon snap someone's neck as acknowledge they exist. Of course, no part of that diminishes Josh's PerverseSexualLust for her.


--> '''Josh:''' In part one of Soap Opera Strips I Haven’t Been Discussing Because They Have Been Boring To Me, ''ComicStrip/ApartmentThreeG''’s interminable Lu Ann vs. Ghost Albert Pinkham Ryder storyline has been boring to me. [...] In part two of Soap Opera Strips I Haven’t Been Discussing Because They Have Been Boring To Me, ''ComicStrip/ThePhantom''’s interminable Old Man Mozz Is A Hostage To Bank Robbers storyline has been boring to me.

to:

--> '''Josh:''' In part one of Soap Opera Strips I Haven’t Been Discussing Because They Have Been Boring To Me, ''ComicStrip/ApartmentThreeG''’s ''ComicStrip/Apartment3G''’s interminable Lu Ann vs. Ghost Albert Pinkham Ryder storyline has been boring to me. [...] In part two of Soap Opera Strips I Haven’t Been Discussing Because They Have Been Boring To Me, ''ComicStrip/ThePhantom''’s interminable Old Man Mozz Is A Hostage To Bank Robbers storyline has been boring to me.

Top