Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Anime / WhenMarnieWasThere

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
How To Write An Example - Don't Write Reviews


* NewParentNomenclatureProblem: Anna calls her foster mother "auntie". A CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming ensues towards the end when she suddenly addresses her with "mother".

to:

* NewParentNomenclatureProblem: Anna calls her foster mother "auntie". A CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming ensues towards Towards the end when end, she suddenly addresses her with "mother".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving to trivia section as per discussion here


* EndOfAnAge: Due to Studio Ghibli's restructuring, this is the last Ghibli film to feature Hiromasa Yonebayashi as director and Yoshiaki Nishimura as producer.

Added: 160

Changed: 247

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EndOfAnAge: Due to Studio Ghibli's restructuring, this is the last Ghibli film to feature Hiromasa Yonebayashi as director and Yoshiaki Nishimura as producer.



* GrandFinale: This was the last Ghibli film made before the studio's restructuring, the last to feature Hiromasa Yonebayashi as director and Yoshiaki Nishimura as producer before leaving to form Studio Ponoc, and the last film with animator Makiko Futaki before her passing three years after the film's release.

to:

* GrandFinale: This was the last Ghibli film made before became the studio's restructuring, the last to feature final film for Hiromasa Yonebayashi as director and Yoshiaki Nishimura as producer before leaving to form producer, as the latter left during Studio Ghibli's restructuring and formed Studio Ponoc, and the last film with animator Makiko Futaki before her passing three years after the film's release.Yonebayashi joining soon after.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GrandFinale: This was the last Ghibli film made before the studio's restructuring, the last to feature Hiromasa Yonebayashi as director and Yoshiaki Nishimura as producer, the last film with animator Makiko Futaki before her passing three years after the film's release, and the last film before Toshio Suzuki retired.

to:

* GrandFinale: This was the last Ghibli film made before the studio's restructuring, the last to feature Hiromasa Yonebayashi as director and Yoshiaki Nishimura as producer, producer before leaving to form Studio Ponoc, and the last film with animator Makiko Futaki before her passing three years after the film's release, and the last film before Toshio Suzuki retired.release.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GrandFinale: This was the last Ghibli film made before the studio's restructuring, the last to feature Hiromasa Yonebayashi as director and Yoshiaki Nishimura as producer, the last film with animator Makiko Futaki before her passing three years after the film's release, and the last film before Toshio Suzuki retired.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EndOfAnAge: This was the last Ghibli film made before the studio's restructuring, the last to feature Hiromasa Yonebayashi as director and Yoshiaki Nishimura as producer, the last film with animator Makiko Futaki before her passing three years after the film's release, and the last film before Toshio Suzuki retired.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
no critical perception on work pages


The film was nominated for the UsefulNotes/AcademyAwardForBestAnimatedFeature in 2016. It became Yonebayashi and producer Yoshiaki Nishimura's SwanSong for Ghibli before its restructuring.

to:

The film was nominated for the UsefulNotes/AcademyAwardForBestAnimatedFeature in 2016. It became Yonebayashi and producer Yoshiaki Nishimura's SwanSong for Ghibli before its restructuring.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film was nominated for the UsefulNotes/AcademyAwardForBestAnimatedFeature in 2016. It became the fifth Studio Ghibli film to achieve such an honor. However, this film and ''Anime/TheTaleOfThePrincessKaguya'' became a temporary CreatorKiller for Studio Ghibli until ''WesternAnimation/TheRedTurtle'' in 2016 and it was Yonebayashi and producer Yoshiaki Nishimura's SwanSong for Ghibli.

to:

The film was nominated for the UsefulNotes/AcademyAwardForBestAnimatedFeature in 2016. It became the fifth Studio Ghibli film to achieve such an honor. However, this film and ''Anime/TheTaleOfThePrincessKaguya'' became a temporary CreatorKiller for Studio Ghibli until ''WesternAnimation/TheRedTurtle'' in 2016 and it was Yonebayashi and producer Yoshiaki Nishimura's SwanSong for Ghibli.
Ghibli before its restructuring.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EndOfAnAge: This was the last Ghibli film made before the studio's restructuring, the last with Hiromasa Yonebayashi as director and Yoshiaki Nishimura as producer, and the last film produced before Toshio Suzuki's retirement.

to:

* EndOfAnAge: This was the last Ghibli film made before the studio's restructuring, the last with to feature Hiromasa Yonebayashi as director and Yoshiaki Nishimura as producer, the last film with animator Makiko Futaki before her passing three years after the film's release, and the last film produced before Toshio Suzuki's retirement.Suzuki retired.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EndOfAnAge: This was the last Ghibli film made before the studio's restructuring, the last one to feature Hiromasa Yonebayashi as director, and the last with Yoshiaki Nishimura as producer.

to:

* EndOfAnAge: This was the last Ghibli film made before the studio's restructuring, the last one to feature with Hiromasa Yonebayashi as director, director and the last with Yoshiaki Nishimura as producer.producer, and the last film produced before Toshio Suzuki's retirement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EndOfAnAge: This was the last Ghibli film made before the studio's restructuring, the last one to feature Hiromasa Yonebayashi as director, and the last with Yoshiaki Nishimura as producer.

Added: 94

Changed: 95

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseBiology: Unless Anna's father was also Caucasian, it's almost impossible for Anna to have blue eyes.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseBiology: ArtisticLicenseBiology:
**
Unless Anna's father was also Caucasian, it's almost impossible for Anna to have blue eyes.



* {{Mukokuseki}}: Subverted [[spoiler:Anna's blue eyes attract notice and are an important clue to her heritage]].

to:

* {{Mukokuseki}}: Subverted Subverted. [[spoiler:Anna's blue eyes attract notice and are an important clue to her heritage]].



* TheReveal: ''Three'' over the course of the film, all regarding Marnie's true identity.

to:

* TheReveal: ''Three'' over the course of the film, all regarding Marnie's true identity.identity:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Marnie's features are even more unlikely. Her father is a blond, blue-eyed "foreigner" of some kind but her mother appears to be a standard Japanese beauty (black hair and dark eyes.) Needless to say, the odds that their child would be a blond, blue-eyed girl are remote to the point of being practically impossible.

to:

** Marnie's features are even more unlikely. Her father is a blond, blue-eyed "foreigner" of some kind but her mother appears to be a standard Japanese beauty (black hair and dark eyes.) Needless to say, the odds that their child would be a blond, blue-eyed girl are remote to the point of being practically impossible.are...remote.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Marnie's features are even more unlikely. Her father is a blond, blue-eyed "foreigner" of some kind but her mother appears to be a standard Japanese beauty (black hair and dark eyes.) Needless to say, the odds that their child would be a blond, blue-eyed girl are remote to the point of being practically impossible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RedHerring: Brief, early flashbacks Anna has of herself as a little girl show her clutching a doll that resembles Marnie, which causes observant viewers to assume that Marnie is entirely an imaginary friend, which Anna herself comes to believe for a moment. [[spoiler: Marnie is revealed to have actually been much, much more: Anna's grandmother as a young girl.]]

Added: 187

Removed: 187

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GildedCage: Marnie lives in a luxurious mansion with wealthy parents, but her governess is abusive and the maids bully her. [[spoiler:Hisako]] explicitly says that Marnie was neglected.


Added DiffLines:

* GildedCage: Marnie lives in a luxurious mansion with wealthy parents, but her governess is abusive and the maids bully her. [[spoiler:Hisako]] explicitly says that Marnie was neglected.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BaitAndSwitchLesbians: The beginning of the movie is virtually ''dripping'' with romantic tension between the two main characters, which led many viewers to believe that this would lead to a payoff by the end. [[spoiler: Marnie is Anna's grandmother. As girl she had feelings for Kazuhiko, a boy whom she later marries. Marnie was effectively viewing Anna as a stand-in for Kazuhiko all along.]]

to:

* BaitAndSwitchLesbians: The beginning of the movie is virtually ''dripping'' with romantic tension between the two main characters, which led many viewers to believe that this would lead to a payoff by the end. [[spoiler: Marnie is Anna's grandmother. As a girl she had feelings for Kazuhiko, a boy whom she later marries.married. Marnie was effectively viewing Anna as a stand-in for Kazuhiko all along.]]

Added: 96

Removed: 96

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnguishedDeclarationOfLove: "[[TearJerker I love you, Marnie! And I won't ever forget you!]]"



* AnguishedDeclarationOfLove: "[[TearJerker I love you, Marnie! And I won't ever forget you!]]"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicense-Biology: Unless Anna's father was also Caucasian, it's almost impossible for Anna to have blue eyes.

to:

* ArtisticLicense-Biology: ArtisticLicenseBiology: Unless Anna's father was also Caucasian, it's almost impossible for Anna to have blue eyes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicense-Biology: Unless Anna's father was also Caucasian, the chances of her having blue eyes is almost impossible.

to:

* ArtisticLicense-Biology: Unless Anna's father was also Caucasian, the chances of her having blue eyes is it's almost impossible.impossible for Anna to have blue eyes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I think this was meant to say Anna, as Marnie's father is certainly caucasian - we see him during the party scenes at the mansion, and his hair is lighter than Marnie's.


* ArtisticLicense-Biology: Unless Marnie's father was also Caucasian, the chances of her having blue eyes is almost impossible

to:

* ArtisticLicense-Biology: Unless Marnie's Anna's father was also Caucasian, the chances of her having blue eyes is almost impossibleimpossible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Your child being abused by the people who are supposed to care for her while you are away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicense-Biology: Unless Marnie's father was also Caucasian, the chances of her having blue eyes is almost impossible

Changed: 180

Removed: 117

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





!!This film provides examples of:

to:

!!This film !!''When Marnie Was There'' provides examples of:



* AmbiguousDisorder: Anna is frequently noted to act oddly for a child or focus on strange things. As the book begins, she book acts detached from other people, enjoys spending time alone, has little time for the family she lives with, and sends postcards to her guardian that are only a few sentences long. She views the world as being a circle with people on the "inside" and on the "outside", believing herself to be on the outside and separate from everyone else. At one point, she goes into a fury over an insult which everyone, even the narrator, considers to be silly. She also doesn't seem to have many friends, but the people she does meet and bond with (Marnie [[spoiler:and, later, the family that moves into her house]]) she's able to form very close ties to. Some of her behavior can be attributed to her [[spoiler:fearing that her foster mother is only keeping her for the money]], but her reaction to that still comes across as unusual for an upset child.

to:

* AmbiguousDisorder: Anna is frequently noted to act oddly for a child or focus on strange things. As the book begins, she book acts detached from other people, enjoys spending time alone, has little time for the family she lives with, and sends postcards to her guardian that are only a few sentences long. She views the world as being a circle with people on the "inside" and on the "outside", believing herself to be on the outside and separate from everyone else. At one point, she goes into a fury over an insult which everyone, even the narrator, considers to be silly. She also doesn't seem to have many friends, but the people she does meet and bond with (Marnie [[spoiler:and, later, the family that moves into her house]]) she's able to form very close ties to. Some of her behavior can be attributed to her [[spoiler:fearing that her foster mother is only keeping her for the money]], but her reaction to that still comes across as unusual for an upset child.



* FriendlessBackground: Being an overly introvert and quirky girl, Anna has no no friends at home.

to:

* FriendlessBackground: Being an overly introvert and quirky girl, Anna has no no friends at home.



* GhostlyGoals: [[spoiler: Marnie wants to spend time with Anna, who is truly her granddaughter, and help her grow beyond her abandonment issues.]]

to:

* GhostlyGoals: [[spoiler: Marnie [[spoiler:Marnie wants to spend time with Anna, who is truly her granddaughter, and help her grow beyond her abandonment issues.]]



-->'''Anna''': [[spoiler:Marnie is...someone I made up. An imaginary girl, only in my mind.]]

to:

-->'''Anna''': -->'''Anna:''' [[spoiler:Marnie is...is... someone I made up. An imaginary girl, only in my mind.]]



* LongLostRelative: [[spoiler: Marnie is Anna's grandmother. Kazuhiko is therefore her grandfather and Marnie's mother and father are Anna's are, therefore great-grandparents.]]
* LoveLetterLunacy: [[spoiler: Parental love version: Anna's isolation and disillusionment began when she found a hidden letter to her foster mother that rocked her whole world.]]

to:

* LongLostRelative: [[spoiler: Marnie [[spoiler:Marnie is Anna's grandmother. Kazuhiko is therefore her grandfather and Marnie's mother and father are Anna's are, therefore great-grandparents.]]
* LoveLetterLunacy: [[spoiler: Parental [[spoiler:Parental love version: Anna's isolation and disillusionment began when she found a hidden letter to her foster mother that rocked her whole world.]]



* MeaningfulEcho: [[spoiler: On the boat Sayaka's wants the diary to be her and Anna's secret which echoes the scene earlier at the same place where Marnie asked to keep her relationship with Anna a secret. The connection is that Marnie's diary brought Anna and Sayaka together as friends.]]

to:

* MeaningfulEcho: [[spoiler: On [[spoiler:On the boat Sayaka's wants the diary to be her and Anna's secret which echoes the scene earlier at the same place where Marnie asked to keep her relationship with Anna a secret. The connection is that Marnie's diary brought Anna and Sayaka together as friends.]]



* {{Mukokuseki}}: Subverted [[spoiler: Anna's blue eyes attract notice and are an important clue to her heritage]].

to:

* {{Mukokuseki}}: Subverted [[spoiler: Anna's [[spoiler:Anna's blue eyes attract notice and are an important clue to her heritage]].



-->'''Anna''': My real parents died when I was little. My grandmother, too. I know they didn't die on purpose, but... sometimes I feel like... I can't forgive them... for leaving me all alone.

to:

-->'''Anna''': -->'''Anna:''' My real parents died when I was little. My grandmother, too. I know they didn't die on purpose, but... sometimes I feel like... I can't forgive them... for leaving me all alone.



** Anna is this around everyone, hiding her feelings unless provoked because she knows that she has a good life and thus she shouldn't complain. The few times that the facade breaks is heartbreaking, like when she tells Marnie that [[spoiler:she found out her foster parents were being paid to look after her, but they use it to take care of her, and she hates that it was being kept a secret.]]

to:

** Anna is this around everyone, hiding her feelings unless provoked because she knows that she has a good life and thus she shouldn't complain. The few times that the facade façade breaks is heartbreaking, like when she tells Marnie that [[spoiler:she found out her foster parents were being paid to look after her, but they use it to take care of her, and she hates that it was being kept a secret.]]



* TroubledFetalPosition:
** Marnie when two maids tried to drag her to the silo, and later on when she's trapped in there due to her own fear.

to:

* TroubledFetalPosition:
**
TroubledFetalPosition: Marnie when two maids tried to drag her to the silo, and later on when she's trapped in there due to her own fear.



** [[spoiler: Sayaka's "Are you Marnie?"]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Sayaka's [[spoiler:Sayaka's "Are you Marnie?"]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheReveal: ''Three'' over the course of the film, all regarding Marnie's true identity.
** Anna [[spoiler:was only ''imagining'' Marnie the entire time]].
** Marnie [[spoiler:was born ''decades'' ago, and eventually married, bore children, and [[DeadAllAlong died in her old age]], which leads up to the final reveal...]]
** Marnie [[spoiler:is Anna's deceased grandmother]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film was nominated for the UsefulNotes/AcademyAwardForBestAnimatedFeature in 2016. It became the fifth Studio Ghibli film to achieve such an honor. However, this film and ''Anime/TheTaleOfThePrincessKaguya'' became a temporary CreatorKiller for Studio Ghibli until ''The Red Turtle'' in 2016 and it was Yonebayashi and producer Yoshiaki Nishimura's SwanSong for Ghibli.

to:

The film was nominated for the UsefulNotes/AcademyAwardForBestAnimatedFeature in 2016. It became the fifth Studio Ghibli film to achieve such an honor. However, this film and ''Anime/TheTaleOfThePrincessKaguya'' became a temporary CreatorKiller for Studio Ghibli until ''The Red Turtle'' ''WesternAnimation/TheRedTurtle'' in 2016 and it was Yonebayashi and producer Yoshiaki Nishimura's SwanSong for Ghibli.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MsExposition: Hisako, blantly so. Her story fills in many of the gaps by the end of the movie.

to:

* MsExposition: Hisako, blantly blatantly so. Her story fills in many of the gaps by the end of the movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film was nominated for the UsefulNotes/AcademyAwardForBestAnimatedFeature in 2016. It became the fifth Studio Ghibli film to achieve such an honor. However, this film and ''Anime/TheTaleOfPrincessKaguya'' became a temporary CreatorKiller for Studio Ghibli until ''The Red Turtle'' in 2016 and it was Yonebayashi and producer Yoshiaki Nishimura's SwanSong for Ghibli.

to:

The film was nominated for the UsefulNotes/AcademyAwardForBestAnimatedFeature in 2016. It became the fifth Studio Ghibli film to achieve such an honor. However, this film and ''Anime/TheTaleOfPrincessKaguya'' ''Anime/TheTaleOfThePrincessKaguya'' became a temporary CreatorKiller for Studio Ghibli until ''The Red Turtle'' in 2016 and it was Yonebayashi and producer Yoshiaki Nishimura's SwanSong for Ghibli.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film was nominated for the UsefulNotes/AcademyAwardForBestAnimatedFeature in 2016. It became the fifth Studio Ghibli film to achieve such an honor. However, this film and ''Anime/TheTaleOfPrincessKaguya'' became a temporary CreatorKiller for Studio Ghibli until ''The Red Turtle'' in 2016 and it was Yonebayashi and producer Yoshiaki Nishimura's swan song for Ghibli.

to:

The film was nominated for the UsefulNotes/AcademyAwardForBestAnimatedFeature in 2016. It became the fifth Studio Ghibli film to achieve such an honor. However, this film and ''Anime/TheTaleOfPrincessKaguya'' became a temporary CreatorKiller for Studio Ghibli until ''The Red Turtle'' in 2016 and it was Yonebayashi and producer Yoshiaki Nishimura's swan song SwanSong for Ghibli.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film was nominated for the UsefulNotes/AcademyAwardForBestAnimatedFeature in 2016. It became the fifth Studio Ghibli film to achieve such an honor.

to:

The film was nominated for the UsefulNotes/AcademyAwardForBestAnimatedFeature in 2016. It became the fifth Studio Ghibli film to achieve such an honor. However, this film and ''Anime/TheTaleOfPrincessKaguya'' became a temporary CreatorKiller for Studio Ghibli until ''The Red Turtle'' in 2016 and it was Yonebayashi and producer Yoshiaki Nishimura's swan song for Ghibli.

Top