Follow TV Tropes

Following

History AnachronismStew / PiratesOfTheCaribbeanAtWorldsEnd

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Beckett sets the ''Dutchman'' to give no quarter in the maelstrom battle, he orders his officer to make semaphore signals to the other ship. This is done by an officer holding two flags in different positions, the modern way. However, the British Navy in the 18th century did this by hoisting sets of special flags on the masts of the ships, not by setting an officer on deck.

to:

* When Beckett sets the ''Dutchman'' to give no quarter in the maelstrom battle, he orders his officer to make semaphore signals to the other ship. This is done by an officer holding two flags in different positions, the modern way. However, the British Navy in the 18th century did this by hoisting sets of special flags on the masts of the ships, not by setting an officer on deck. Handheld flag semaphore was invented in 1866.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Barbossa states that the incantation to release Calypso must be spoken "as if to a lover", referring to a romantic partner. Back then however "lover" meant "close friend" or "ally"; Barbossa would have been looking for the word "paramour".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Barbossa states that the incantation to release Calypso must be spoken "as if to a lover", referring to a romantic partner. Back then however "lover" meant "close friend" or "ally"; Barbossa would have been looking for the word "paramour".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Barbossa states that the incantation to release Calypso must be spoken "as if to a lover", referring to a romantic partner. Back then however "lover" meant "close friend" or "ally"; Barbossa would have been looking for the word "paramour".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Directly after the battle between the ''Black Pearl'' and the ''Flying Dutchman'' near the end of the film, Barbossa says "Belay that, or we'll be a sitting duck!" in response to Jack's command. but the phrase "sitting duck" was not introduced until the early 1900s.

to:

* Directly after the battle between the ''Black Pearl'' and the ''Flying Dutchman'' near the end of the film, Barbossa says "Belay that, or we'll be a sitting duck!" in response to Jack's command. but the The phrase "sitting duck" was not introduced until the early 1900s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Gibbs has a Toys/TeddyBear at the end. The incident with UsefulNotes/TheodoreRoosevelt and his bear took place in November 1902. The political cartoons of Clifford Berryman which were inspired by the incident started appearing that month. The toy bears inspired by the cartoon were introduced, simultaneously but independently, by Morris Michtom and Richard Steiff in 1903. Although it is possible that it was an improvised toy, resembled teddy bear.

to:

* Gibbs has a Toys/TeddyBear at the end. The incident with UsefulNotes/TheodoreRoosevelt and his bear took place in November 1902. The political cartoons of Clifford Berryman which were inspired by the incident started appearing that month. The toy bears inspired by the cartoon were introduced, simultaneously but independently, by Morris Michtom and Richard Steiff in 1903. Although it is possible that it was it's an improvised toy, resembled toy that only resembles a teddy bear.

Added: 831

Changed: 1822

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding the reference of the Pirate Republic of Nassau.


* There is no record of any pirate communes working together as "Pirate Lords", to further elect their King. The real-life pirates only once gathered as something distantly resembling the Brethren Court, although it happened only once and was formally referred to as "Brethren of the Coast". The term "popular vote" used by Gibbs was used at the modern time of real-world democracy, which could not occur among traitorous pirates.
* Similarly, the Pirate Code was never a unified book of strict laws, which was lampshaded by Barbossa in the first film as "guidelines". Each pirate ship had their own Pirate Code depending on the captain of the ship, it usually consisted only of one page, it was not a huge Doorstopper shown in the movie.

to:

* There is no record of any pirate communes working together as "Pirate Lords", to further elect their King. The real-life pirates only once gathered as something distantly resembling inspiration seems drawn from two sources: The informal coalition called "[[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brethren_of_the_Coast Brethren of the Coast]]" (the obvious name reference of the Brethren Court, although it happened only once Court) and the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Pirates Pirate Republic of Nassau]]. The former was formally referred essentially a alliance of privateers (so, nautical mercenaries working at the behest of kingdoms rather than an independent government as shown here) hired by Protestant Kingdoms to as "Brethren sack Catholic ships. The Pirate Republic is closer to the ideal of the Coast". The term "popular vote" used Brethren Court as a loose independent Republic government commanded by Gibbs was used a democratic coalition of the most influential pirates in the Caribbean at the modern time time. In either case, neither the Brethren of real-world democracy, which could not occur among traitorous pirates.the Coast nor the Pirate Republic appointed "Kings" (with the closest being reports of the Pirate Republic appointing magistrates to handle island business) and neither had its members known as "Lords" commanding entire islands all over the world (both being isolated to the Caribbean).
* The Brethren Court membership contain a couple of historical characters (or implied to be historical characters) among their rank, but pilfered from different periods: Sri Sumbajee (the Indian Lord) is based on Sambhaji Angre (a young man whose nautical career was ''just'' starting in the period the film's set, so far from being a wizened pirate Lord), Mistress Ching (the Chinese Pirate Lady) is [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ching_Shih Widow Ching]] (who operated a full century after the film is set).
* The term "popular vote" used by Gibbs was a fairly recent invention unlikely to be used by pirates.
* Similarly, the Pirate Code was never a unified book of strict laws, laws (though the Pirate Codes were usually very similar to one another owing to shared pirate culture), which was lampshaded by Barbossa in the first film as "guidelines". Each pirate ship had their own Pirate Code depending on the captain of the ship, it usually consisted only of one page, it was not a huge Doorstopper shown in the movie. The idea of it being a huge book "sealed by Morgan and Bartholomew" (implicitly, famous historical pirates Henry Morgan and Bartholomew Roberts) raises questions given that Henry Morgan died when Roberts was 8 years old (although it is possible that the meaning is more they both contributed to the code at different times).

Added: 1007

Changed: 76

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More historical inaccuracies


* Gibbs has a Toys/TeddyBear at the end. The incident with UsefulNotes/TheodoreRoosevelt and his bear took place in November 1902. The political cartoons of Clifford Berryman which were inspired by the incident started appearing that month. The toy bears inspired by the cartoon were introduced, simultaneously but independently, by Morris Michtom and Richard Steiff in 1903.

to:

* Gibbs has a Toys/TeddyBear at the end. The incident with UsefulNotes/TheodoreRoosevelt and his bear took place in November 1902. The political cartoons of Clifford Berryman which were inspired by the incident started appearing that month. The toy bears inspired by the cartoon were introduced, simultaneously but independently, by Morris Michtom and Richard Steiff in 1903. Although it is possible that it was an improvised toy, resembled teddy bear.


Added DiffLines:

* There is no record of any pirate communes working together as "Pirate Lords", to further elect their King. The real-life pirates only once gathered as something distantly resembling the Brethren Court, although it happened only once and was formally referred to as "Brethren of the Coast". The term "popular vote" used by Gibbs was used at the modern time of real-world democracy, which could not occur among traitorous pirates.
* Similarly, the Pirate Code was never a unified book of strict laws, which was lampshaded by Barbossa in the first film as "guidelines". Each pirate ship had their own Pirate Code depending on the captain of the ship, it usually consisted only of one page, it was not a huge Doorstopper shown in the movie.


Added DiffLines:

* Sao Feng's navigational charts show that Juan Ponce de León discovered the fountain in 1523, but de León died in 1521, while the expedition for the Fountain of Youth started in 1513. Possibly it was just a misprint when the number "2" replaced the correct number "1".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When Pintel refers to the Kraken as a fish, Ragetti tells him it's actually a cephalopod, a term that was first coined in the 1820's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Directly after the battle between the ''Black Pearl'' and the ''Flying Dutchman'' near the end of the film, Barbarossa says "Belay that, or we'll be a sitting duck!" in response to Jack's command. but the phrase "sitting duck" was not introduced until the early 1900s.

to:

* Directly after the battle between the ''Black Pearl'' and the ''Flying Dutchman'' near the end of the film, Barbarossa Barbossa says "Belay that, or we'll be a sitting duck!" in response to Jack's command. but the phrase "sitting duck" was not introduced until the early 1900s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UsefulNotes/{{Singapore}} didn't exist at that time, it was founded in 1819. Before, it was a tiny fishing village called Temasek, though the name "Singapura"--"city of the lions"--was first given in the fourteenth century, and its inhabitants were Malay, not Chinese. Though it was found by an EITC official, Sir Stamford Raffles is nowhere near Cutler Beckett.

to:

* UsefulNotes/{{Singapore}} didn't exist at that time, it was founded in 1819. Before, it was a tiny fishing village called Temasek, though the name "Singapura"--"city of the lions"--was first given in the fourteenth century, and its inhabitants were Malay, not Chinese. Though Singapore was an island of crime, so much so that it was found by an EITC official, Sir Stamford Raffles is nowhere near Cutler Beckett.called "Sin Galore" but most of it came from vice, not piracy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UsefulNotes/{{Singapore}} didn't exist at that time, it was founded in 1819. Before, it was a tiny fishing village called Temasek, though the name "Singapura"--"city of the lions"--was first given in the fourteenth century, and its inhabitants were Malay, not Chinese.

to:

* UsefulNotes/{{Singapore}} didn't exist at that time, it was founded in 1819. Before, it was a tiny fishing village called Temasek, though the name "Singapura"--"city of the lions"--was first given in the fourteenth century, and its inhabitants were Malay, not Chinese. Though it was found by an EITC official, Sir Stamford Raffles is nowhere near Cutler Beckett.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* All the gallows have a style of the trap door was not used until 1813.

to:

* All the gallows have a style of the New Drop trap door was not used until 1813.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* There's a Toys/TeddyBear at the end. The incident with UsefulNotes/TheodoreRoosevelt and his bear took place in November 1902. The political cartoons of Clifford Berryman which were inspired by the incident started appearing that month. The toy bears inspired by the cartoon were introduced, simultaneously but independently, by Morris Michtom and Richard Steiff in 1903.

to:

* There's Gibbs has a Toys/TeddyBear at the end. The incident with UsefulNotes/TheodoreRoosevelt and his bear took place in November 1902. The political cartoons of Clifford Berryman which were inspired by the incident started appearing that month. The toy bears inspired by the cartoon were introduced, simultaneously but independently, by Morris Michtom and Richard Steiff in 1903.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UsefulNotes/{{Singapore}} didn't exist at that time, it was founded in 1819. Before, it was a tiny fishing village called Temasek, though the name "Singapura" - "city of the lions" - was first given in the fourteenth century, and its inhabitants were Malay, not Chinese.

to:

* UsefulNotes/{{Singapore}} didn't exist at that time, it was founded in 1819. Before, it was a tiny fishing village called Temasek, though the name "Singapura" - "city "Singapura"--"city of the lions" - was lions"--was first given in the fourteenth century, and its inhabitants were Malay, not Chinese.



* When Beckett sets the Dutchman to give no quarter in the maelstrom battle, he orders his officer to make semaphore signals to the other ship. This is done by an officer holding two flags in different positions, the modern way. However, the British Navy in the 18th century did this by hoisting sets of special flags on the masts of the ships, not by setting an officer on deck.
* Directly after the battle between the Black Pearl and the Flying Dutchman near the end of the film, Barbarossa says "Belay that, or we'll be a sitting duck!" in response to Jack's command. but the phrase "sitting duck" was not introduced until the early 1900s.

to:

* When Beckett sets the Dutchman ''Dutchman'' to give no quarter in the maelstrom battle, he orders his officer to make semaphore signals to the other ship. This is done by an officer holding two flags in different positions, the modern way. However, the British Navy in the 18th century did this by hoisting sets of special flags on the masts of the ships, not by setting an officer on deck.
* Directly after the battle between the Black Pearl ''Black Pearl'' and the Flying Dutchman ''Flying Dutchman'' near the end of the film, Barbarossa says "Belay that, or we'll be a sitting duck!" in response to Jack's command. but the phrase "sitting duck" was not introduced until the early 1900s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* All the gallows have a style of the trap door was not used until the 1800s.

to:

* All the gallows have a style of the trap door was not used until the 1800s.1813.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* There's a Toys/TeddyBear at the end. The incident with TheodoreRoosevelt and his bear took place in November 1902. The political cartoons of Clifford Berryman which were inspired by the incident started appearing that month. The toy bears inspired by the cartoon were introduced, simultaneously but independently, by Morris Michtom and Richard Steiff in 1903.

to:

* There's a Toys/TeddyBear at the end. The incident with TheodoreRoosevelt UsefulNotes/TheodoreRoosevelt and his bear took place in November 1902. The political cartoons of Clifford Berryman which were inspired by the incident started appearing that month. The toy bears inspired by the cartoon were introduced, simultaneously but independently, by Morris Michtom and Richard Steiff in 1903.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UsefulNotes/{{Singapore}} didn't exist at that time, it was founded in 1819. Before, it was a tiny fishing village called Temasek, though the name "Singapura" - "city of the lions" - was first given in the fourteenth century, and its inhabitants were Malay, not Chinese.
* There's a Toys/TeddyBear at the end. The incident with TheodoreRoosevelt and his bear took place in November 1902. The political cartoons of Clifford Berryman which were inspired by the incident started appearing that month. The toy bears inspired by the cartoon were introduced, simultaneously but independently, by Morris Michtom and Richard Steiff in 1903.
* In the beginning of the tea drinking scene with William, Lord Beckett adds a sugar cube into his tea. The first sugar cubes were invented in the Czech town of Dacice during 1840s.
* The British fleet seen in the film consists of some ten three-decked ships of the line. In 1720 the Royal Navy only had six such ships in commission world-wide.
* All the British Men of War in the film are painted in the "Nelson Checker" (black and yellow bands with black gun-ports). However this pattern was not common until 1805 when used by Admiral Nelson.
* All the gallows have a style of the trap door was not used until the 1800s.
* When Beckett sets the Dutchman to give no quarter in the maelstrom battle, he orders his officer to make semaphore signals to the other ship. This is done by an officer holding two flags in different positions, the modern way. However, the British Navy in the 18th century did this by hoisting sets of special flags on the masts of the ships, not by setting an officer on deck.
* Directly after the battle between the Black Pearl and the Flying Dutchman near the end of the film, Barbarossa says "Belay that, or we'll be a sitting duck!" in response to Jack's command. but the phrase "sitting duck" was not introduced until the early 1900s.
----

Top