This is discussion archived from a time before the current discussion method was installed.
From YKTTW Working Title: The Great McGonagall
Count Dorku: I have to ask...does the Discworld's greatest bad inventor, Bergholt Stuttley Johnson, qualify?
Lukebn: I'm going to go with yes— his successes are mostly accidental, and as close as you can get to So Bad, It's Good outside of art.
Lord Seth: Are Seltzer And Friedberg really an example? They're bad, but it seems to me it's more of them just not putting forth any effort than anything else. This trope is for people who try really hard but are really bad.
Leaper: C'mon, is David Caruso really the best real actor to put in this entry? Really?
