Reviews Comments: Flesh and Stone
Flesh and Stone
Y'know, I think what makes the Weeping Angels stand out as much as they do is the fact that they aren't typical science fiction monsters. They're horror movie villains. Nowhere is this more apparent than in this two-parter. The second episode of this story sees the Doctor, Amy, River and the clerics being menaced by the aforementioned angels, which by this point stand as strong candidates for "scariest Doctor Who monster of all time". However, as was hinted in the trailer, there are worse things than angels afoot, as the nature of the crack in Amy's wall is finally revealed. It's an ambitious concept, but I think Steven Moffat pulls it off with aplomb. This is the episode which properly introduces us to the overarching plot which will presumably be the basis of the finale. It also pushes the characters to their emotional limits, with Matt Smith putting on a stunning performance as a Doctor in a terrible and desperate situation. The pacing is good, the dialogue is fantastic, and there's a good balance of sad, happy, funny and scary moments. My one, minor (and admittedly rather nerdy) complaint is the damage that this story looks set to inflict upon the series' continuity. I'm a little unsure what the implications are with regards to the spin-off series. As with "Victory of the Daleks", this episode feels in some respects a pointed rejection of the Russell T Davies era and a sweeping away of the old to make room for the new; whether or not this is a good thing will probably depend on how you felt about RTD's take on the show.
Steven Moffat is an artist, and his canvas is our nightmares.
comment #2453 188.8.131.52 6th May 10
I'll probably should wait until this episode comes out in Australia but... ~puts on her big girl pants~ What do you mean about the spin off series. Ar e you talking about Torchwood and The Sarah Jane Adventures or are you saying that Moffat is making this series of Doctor who seem like a spin off of the RTD era?
comment #2474 wellinever 9th May 10
I mean Sarah-Jane and Torchwood; can't really elaborate without spoiling the plot for this episode. It's definitely not a spin off of the RTD era. It feels more like Moffat is deliberately trying to distance the show from that era.
comment #2483 BobbyG 11th May 10
In order to post comments, you need to