Reviews Comments: Not his best, but a fun read regardless
Not his best, but a fun read regardless
Let's not mince words: this is a very enjoyable book. Despite the seemingly dull premise (Wizards playing football? Are you mad?), the plot is entertaining and surprisingly deep, though the book starts out a little slowly and it takes thirty or forty pages to really get going. It's less about the football itself and more about the people whose lives are affected by the game. Most of the focus is on new characters (my favourite of these being Nutt), but many Discworld regulars make an appearance as well. Pterry's writing is also just as sharp as ever, utilizing his trademark sense of playfulness and love of wordplay. As always, any scenes involving the Unseen University staff will steal the show, particularly when the wizards argue. This installment notably has a few more running gags than the average Discworld story, but whether this is a good or bad thing really depends on your personal tolerance for that sort of thing (the first review on this site clearly doesn't think much of them). I found them funny, at any rate. The best part about this volume, however, is the sheer amount of references to earlier Discworld stories within in. Pratchett normally isn't overly bothered with continuity, so all the little references become immensely satisfying for longtime Discworld fans, such as myself. But the book is not perfect. I can't remember there being any truly laugh-out-loud moments in it, which is a shame. Granted, Pratchett's humour is usually more thought-provoking or small-chuckle-worthy than laugh-out-loud funny, but still, there's usually at least one such joke in all of his books, in my opinion, so the lack of one in this volume is certainly a drawback. Another thing is that the normally reserved and stoic Lord Vetinari is seen laughing a few times in this book. This is at odds with his previous characterization, which wouldn't bother me as much if he weren't my favourite character in all of fiction. That said, though, that is the only actual derailment that I have noticed with any of the characters in here, and it's a fairly minor one at that. So, all in all, this is a good book, but certainly not Terry Pratchett's best. It shouldn't disappoint fans, unless they are expecting it to outdo the earlier volumes. Definitely worth reading.
One minor nitpick, I'm not sure "dull" is a good choice of words when criticizing the premise. "Ludicrous" or "ridiculous" might be a bit better.
comment #2747 18.104.22.168 4th Jun 10
That's pretty much how I feel about the book. A great, entertaining read, but sorta slow, and not as funny as his other books. I do wanna say though, that most of Vetinari's characterization changes are due to the fact that for one of his major appearances in the book, he's dead drunk; he's just so badass that the only things that make it obvious are him talking more than usual, laughing (and Vetinari's allowed to laugh, in any case, he never struck me as that solemn that we'd never see him laugh), and finishing the crossword puzzle 50 seconds slower than usual.
comment #5155 gneissisnice 17th Nov 10
I liked the introduction of Orcs as a much maligned race. Nearly the entire thing was thought provoking and entertaining for me. The only thing I didn't like was the FIFA.
comment #5162 ShaiGar 18th Nov 10
In order to post comments, you need to