Reviews Comments: Great Show, bad Lead
Great Show, bad Lead
I really enjoyed the show, especially the technical aspects of it. The set and music and blocking were all phenomenal. I saw the June 25h matinee at the Kimmel Center in Philly. Emma Hunton was brilliant as Natalie, really pulling me into the character and making me believe her story. The other actors were also great, Gabe walked a fine line between an emotionally torn person and a vengeful villain. Alice Ripley as Diana however, is to be missed. Her acting was good, but her voice! Every time she had a song I would cringe in the anticipation of hearing her. She was constantly flat on almost everything and she had this sort of ululating/wobbling/warbling thing during her long notes where it could give you a headache. Unfortunately, she is the main character with the most stage and song time. Usually this is where I would say "Do not let this discourage you form it though" however, it is difficult for me to say that. Go see it as it is a great musical (more like opera with about only 2 dozen lines of dialogue, the rest sung) that showcases a difficult subject. Emma Hunton was sublime and I would love to go see her in future works of hers. Go prepared to hear a horrible singer however, and maybe if you set your expectations for Alice Ripley low enough, you won't be upset with the show.
Next To Normal is indeed a rock musical, and a fantastic one at that. I think it goes without saying that some of the performers will tend to have grittier, unconventional voices than those in, say, The Sound of Music. I rather like Ripley's performance on the whole, but there are many days she can seem to sing "wobblier" than most. I mean, she sounds mostly great on the recording and she didn't win that Tony for nothing. Heh, anywho, great review; thanks for the info on the new Natalie. I absolutely love Jennifer Damiano, she's such a great Natalie and difficult to beat as Aaron Tveit as Gabe was.
comment #8297 spottytherotter 26th Jun 11
One thing I must point out is that Alice Ripley fell severly ill during the tour.
comment #9862 CarolC 12th Sep 11
In order to post comments, you need to