Indeed, they were accomplices but not the main killers. Among other things, it is also implied that Rosa was an accomplice under threat. So no, my point is not completely wrong since in no game was given to Rosa the opportunity to take revenge seriously against her father and shitty older siblings by massacring them as instead Kinzo, Eva and Rudolf did with her (who, among other things, they have much more superficial, weak and even pathetic motivations to hate Rosa and Maria to the point of killing them with no regrets for greed compared to how many Rosa herself has for wanting to kill them all).
Edited by Darkness197
Either way though I kind of propose we take out that section especially since that part kind of borders into YMMV is what I was trying to say and we don't really lose a whole lot by cutting it
"Life's like a movie, write your own ending. Keep believing, keep pretending."-Jim Henson
On the other hand, I think she is fine where she is since it implicitly points out that, although Rosa has many more reasons to become more homicidal and sadistic than other characters such as Maria, Eva and Rudolf or Black Battler, she is instead one of the characters with the most ironclad morality.
Also on YMMV there are already tropes related to this topic about the character, just because you obviously don't like it doesn't mean it's wrong.
Edited by Darkness197
However it turns out you don't like that this point emphasizes an untapped possibility of a possible episode with a hypothetical Rosa-Beatrice aka Rosatrice (as if the canon Evatrice we had in Episode 3 made sense with that pathetic little old hag shit of Eva becoming a Carrie White wannabe who practically splits personality only for a Stay In The Kitchen speech) as an antagonist. I am right?
Edited by Darkness197
"It should would be surprising why Ryukishi 07 never chose her as a killer in games where Sayo wasn't the culprit (seriously, she has many more understandable and almost justifiable reasons than all the other members of the family put together)."
I would like to politely point out this statement is actually incorrect, as Rosa and Maria were accomplices in Turn of the Golden Witch
"Life's like a movie, write your own ending. Keep believing, keep pretending."-Jim Henson Hide / Show Replies