Katakuri should get his own page so he can be worked on and the other commanders merged back with the Big Mom Pirates Page. Their entries are not that long.
A better title for this page as it is now is "Katakuri and some fluff."
Edited by DocJamore
now that Snack appeared in person we should move him from this page and remove all the speculation.
Hide / Show Replies
Because the Big Mom Pirates page was getting too long (you got a notifier about that when you tried to edit).
The Warlords and Supernovas have had a single page for years and haven't been split yet. How did Katakuri get so many tropes it caused a split?
Why don't we just give him his own page and just merge the rest back to the Big Mom Pirates page.
Edited by DocJamore
I have no idea. I feel like ever since Dressrosa EVERY time any character does even a TINY little thing some troper feels like they have to post something about it. And a lot of the time it's misused or irrelevant.
Like, I'm reading through Katakuri's tab right now, and someone seriously posted self contradicting things like:
- Bad Boss: While he's normally good to his men
And for some reason people rarely try to cut things like this. And now we have ridiculous stuff like Germa having their own section even though only Reiju and Judge have any real substance to them (the brothers share a ton of tropes and are practically just one entity at this point).
Sorry for the rant. But the One Piece characters from Dressrosa onward needs a serious overhaul.
Anyway. Now I feel motivated to do some cleanup. I'm going to be deleting a lot of things, so if anyone thinks I went too far, I encourage you to bring it up here (or in any respective tab).
I agree that Katakuri's folder is overloaded, and it is a problem that people shoehorn tropes to describe every single panel with him (and even when the tropes aren't shoehorned, there's a such thing as reader-friendliness - casual readers will probably not be interested in 25 different tropes describing the same tiny idiosyncrasy even though editors who are die-hard One Piece fans feel that the world isn't complete without adding everything that can be added).
But... You should really give an edit reason before deleting tropes. Otherwise, other editors can't tell if you're deleting the tropes by mistake, or because you're biased and don't like them, or because you genuinely think they don't belong. I see that one other editor is enraged by your mass-deletion, so you should only delete a couple of tropes at a time and provide a thorough edit reason so that people have an actual chance of raising objections.
Edited by Hvedekorn
So apparently they're called the "Sweet 3 Generals" in the VIZ release, not the Three Sweet Commanders. Since that's the most recent official translation, can someone change the title of the page?
Edited by DeeeFoo