Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History WhatAnIdiot / StarWars

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Yes, this game exist. Yes it has tropes. [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/discussion.php?id=w8mhxkfgfm6t36uzfqzr77ao&trope=VideoGameTransformersCybertronAdvaentures Yes, I used an YKKTW]]. Yes, I\'ll index it this week. Yes, feel free to copy past the YKTTW. Yes, I\'ll add tropes. No, I\'m not on everyday.
to:
Yes, this game exist. Yes it has tropes. [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/discussion.php?id=w8mhxkfgfm6t36uzfqzr77ao&trope=VideoGameTransformersCybertronAdvaentures Yes, I used an YKKTW]]. Yes, I\\\'ll index it this week. Yes, feel free to copy past the YKTTW. Yes, I\\\'ll add tropes. No, I\\\'m not on everyday. Yes, I would finish this, but not right now, since I have something in real life t do at the moment
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Yes, this game exist. Yes it has tropes. [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/discussion.php?id=w8mhxkfgfm6t36uzfqzr77aao&trope=VideoGameTransformersCybertronAdvaentures Yes, I used an YKKTW]]. Yes, I\'ll index it this week. Yes, feel free to copy past the YKTTW. Yes, I\'ll add tropes. No, I\'m not on everyday.
to:
Yes, this game exist. Yes it has tropes. [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/discussion.php?id=w8mhxkfgfm6t36uzfqzr77ao&trope=VideoGameTransformersCybertronAdvaentures Yes, I used an YKKTW]]. Yes, I\\\'ll index it this week. Yes, feel free to copy past the YKTTW. Yes, I\\\'ll add tropes. No, I\\\'m not on everyday.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Yes, this game exist. Yes it has tropes. [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/discussion.php.?id=w8mhxkfgfm6t36uzfqzr77aao&trope=VideoGameTransformersCybertronAdvaentures Yes, I used an YKKTW]]. Yes, I\'ll index it this week. Yes, feel free to copy past the YKTTW. Yes, I\'ll add tropes. No, I\'m not on everyday.
to:
Yes, this game exist. Yes it has tropes. [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/discussion.php?id=w8mhxkfgfm6t36uzfqzr77aao&trope=VideoGameTransformersCybertronAdvaentures Yes, I used an YKKTW]]. Yes, I\\\'ll index it this week. Yes, feel free to copy past the YKTTW. Yes, I\\\'ll add tropes. No, I\\\'m not on everyday.
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
Also, that game is not \
to:
Also, that game is not \\\"likely non-canon\\\", but \\\'\\\'definitely\\\'\\\' non-canon. \\\'\\\'Everything\\\'\\\' was wiped, not just post-RotJ. The statement specifically said that only the six movies and TCW remain. And how do I explain a story element of a game that never actually happened? Well, how do you explain TFU\\\'s Tatooine and Hoth bonus levels? It\\\'s non-canon, it NEVER happened. Not even before the ContinuityReboot, because it contradicted the movie, thus was always non-canon.\\\\\\\\
\\\\\\\\
It also just occured to me, that as far we know, the Rebels might\\\'ve attempted to land and help Han\\\'s group. There\\\'s no telling if they did or did not. It was just never stated on-screen, because it was irrelevant to the over-all plot.\\\\\\\\
\\\\\\\\
@Larkman: As far as we know the reason Han\\\'s ship needed the shield lowered was that they were posing as Imperials for an infiltration mission. It would\\\'ve blown their cover if they tried to slow down to the speed of a walking human (around the max speed which an energy shield won\\\'t stop) to pass through it, not to mention it\\\'s highly unlikely that a spaceship could slow down that much at all. So merely from that, we really can\\\'t draw any assumpions on what that shield was composed of, and whether it would\\\'ve stopped rebel ground forces or not. That\\\'s not even the point here.\\\\\\\\
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
Also, that game is not \
to:
Also, that game is not \\\"likely non-canon\\\", but \\\'\\\'definitely\\\'\\\' non-canon. \\\'\\\'Everything\\\'\\\' was wiped, not just post-RotJ. The statement specifically said that only the six movies and TCW remain. And how do I explain a story element of a game that never actually happened? Well, how do you explain TFU\\\'s Tatooine and Hoth bonus levels? It\\\'s non-canon, it NEVER happened. Not even before the ContinuityReboot, because it contradicted the movie, thus was always non-canon.\\\\\\\\
\\\\\\\\
It also just occured to me, that as far we know, the Rebels might\\\'ve attempted to land and help Han\\\'s group. There\\\'s no telling if they did or did not. It was just never stated on-screen, because it was irrelevant to the over-all plot.
\\\\\\\\
@Larkman: As far as we know the reason Han\\\'s ship needed the shield lowered was that they were posing as Imperials for an infiltration mission. It would\\\'ve blown their cover if they tried to slow down to the speed of a walking human (around the max speed which an energy shield won\\\'t stop) to pass through it, not to mention it\\\'s highly unlikely that a spaceship could slow down that much at all. So merely from that, we really can\\\'t draw any assumpions on what that shield was composed of, and whether it would\\\'ve stopped rebel ground forces or not. That\\\'s not even the point here.\\\\\\\\
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
Also, that game is not \
to:
Also, that game is not \\\"likely non-canon\\\", but \\\'\\\'definitely\\\'\\\' non-canon. \\\'\\\'Everything\\\'\\\' was wiped, not just post-RotJ. The statement specifically said that only the six movies and TCW remain. And how do I explain a story element of a game that never actually happened? Well, how do you explain TFU\\\'s Tatooine and Hoth bonus levels? It\\\'s non-canon, it NEVER happened. Not even before the ContinuityReboot, because it contradicted the movie, thus was always non-canon.\\\\\\\\
\\\\\\\\
@Larkman: As far as we know the reason Han\\\'s ship needed the shield lowered was that they were posing as Imperials for an infiltration mission. It would\\\'ve blown their cover if they tried to slow down to the speed of a walking human (around the max speed which an energy shield won\\\'t stop) to pass through it, not to mention it\\\'s highly unlikely that a spaceship could slow down that much at all. So merely from that, we really can\\\'t draw any assumpions on what that shield was composed of, and whether it would\\\'ve stopped rebel ground forces or not. That\\\'s not even the point here.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
@TropeLicious you\'re ignoring one crucial detail: How were they supposed to land those transports in the first place? It\'s not like they had a free pass to the moon, when there was an entire fleet of Star Destroyers and fighter-bombers standing between them. Remember, the only reason they made it out of Hoth, was because the planetary ion-canon temporarly disabled the Star Destroyers.
Also, that game is not likely non-canon, but definitely non-canon. \'\'Everything\'\' was wiped, not just post-RotJ. The statement specifically said that only the six movies and TCW remain. And how do I explain a story element of a game that never actually happened? Well, how do you explain TFU\'s Tatooine and Hoth bonus levels? It\'s non-canon, it NEVER happened. Not even before the ContinuityReboot, because it contradicted the movie, thus was always non-canon.\\\\
to:
@TropeLicious you\\\'re ignoring one crucial detail: How were they supposed to land those transports in the first place? It\\\'s not like they had a free pass to the moon, when there was an entire fleet of Star Destroyers and fighter-bombers standing between them. Remember, the only reason they made it out of Hoth, was because the planetary ion-canon temporarly disabled the Star Destroyers. They didn\\\'t have that at Endor.\\\\\\\\
Also, that game is not \\\"likely non-canon\\\", but \\\'\\\'definitely\\\'\\\' non-canon. \\\'\\\'Everything\\\'\\\' was wiped, not just post-RotJ. The statement specifically said that only the six movies and TCW remain. And how do I explain a story element of a game that never actually happened? Well, how do you explain TFU\\\'s Tatooine and Hoth bonus levels? It\\\'s non-canon, it NEVER happened. Not even before the ContinuityReboot, because it contradicted the movie, thus was always non-canon.\\\\\\\\
Changed line(s) 4 from:
n
@Larkman: As far as we know the reason Han\'s ship needed the shield lowered was that they were posing as Imperials for an infiltration mission. It would\'ve blown their cover if they tried to slow down to the speed of a walking human (around the max speed which an energy shield won\'t stop) to pass through it, not to mention it\'s highly unlikely that a spaceship could slow down that much at all.
to:
@Larkman: As far as we know the reason Han\\\'s ship needed the shield lowered was that they were posing as Imperials for an infiltration mission. It would\\\'ve blown their cover if they tried to slow down to the speed of a walking human (around the max speed which an energy shield won\\\'t stop) to pass through it, not to mention it\\\'s highly unlikely that a spaceship could slow down that much at all. So we really can\\\'t draw any assumpions on what that shield was composed of, and whether it would\\\'ve stopped rebel ground forces or not. That\\\'s not even the point here.
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
Also, that game is not likely non-canon, but definitely non-canon. \'\'Everything\'\' was wiped, not just post-RotJ. The statement specifically said that only the six movies and TCW remain. And how do I explain a story element of a game that never actually happened? Well, how do you explain TFU\'s Tatooine and Hoth bonus levels? It\'s non-canon, it NEVER happened. Not even before the ContinuityReboot, because it contradicted the movie, thus was always non-canon.
to:
Also, that game is not likely non-canon, but definitely non-canon. \\\'\\\'Everything\\\'\\\' was wiped, not just post-RotJ. The statement specifically said that only the six movies and TCW remain. And how do I explain a story element of a game that never actually happened? Well, how do you explain TFU\\\'s Tatooine and Hoth bonus levels? It\\\'s non-canon, it NEVER happened. Not even before the ContinuityReboot, because it contradicted the movie, thus was always non-canon.\\\\\\\\
\\\\\\\\
Top