Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / DoctorWho

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
This was removed from AlternateCharacterInterpretation, admittedly for being factually wrong and ignoring the occasions River self-identifies as a psychopath, but if fans genuinely think either of these things about River, even if there\'s tenuous on-screen evidence, shouldn\'t the example stay? There are \'\'so\'\' many examples of dissention on and off this wiki, especially regarding the Russell T Davies era, where I go \
to:
This was removed from AlternateCharacterInterpretation, admittedly for being factually wrong and ignoring the occasions River self-identifies as a psychopath, but if fans genuinely think either of these things about River, even if there\\\'s tenuous on-screen evidence, shouldn\\\'t the example stay? There are \\\'\\\'so\\\'\\\' many examples of dissention on and off this wiki, especially regarding the Russell T Davies era, where I go \\\"was I really watching the same episode?\\\"

Edit reason by Tropers/{{emeriin}}: Did you miss the various talks about her being a psychopath?

** River Song: devoted [[spoiler: wife]] who just wants to keep the Doctor safe at all costs with a penchant for teasing and flirting, or complete and utter [[BlackHoleSue Black Hole]] JerkSue CreatorsPet? Branching off the latter, perhaps a [[DeconstructedTrope deconstruction]] of many a MarySue fan-made self insert character?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
This was removed from AlternateCharacterInterpretation, admittedly for being factually wrong and ignoring the occasions River self-identifies as a psychopath, but if fans genuinely think either of these things about River, even if there\'s tenuous on-screen evidence, shouldn\'t the example stay? There are \'\'so\'\' many examples of dissention across this page, especially from the Russell T Davies era, where I go \
to:
This was removed from AlternateCharacterInterpretation, admittedly for being factually wrong and ignoring the occasions River self-identifies as a psychopath, but if fans genuinely think either of these things about River, even if there\\\'s tenuous on-screen evidence, shouldn\\\'t the example stay? There are \\\'\\\'so\\\'\\\' many examples of dissention on and off this wiki, especially regarding the Russell T Davies era, where I go \\\"was I watching the same episode\\\"?

Edit reason by Tropers/{{emeriin}}: Did you miss the various talks about her being a psychopath?

** River Song: devoted [[spoiler: wife]] who just wants to keep the Doctor safe at all costs with a penchant for teasing and flirting, or complete and utter [[BlackHoleSue Black Hole]] JerkSue CreatorsPet? Branching off the latter, perhaps a [[DeconstructedTrope deconstruction]] of many a MarySue fan-made self insert character?
Top