[001]
77.48.59.193
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Removed because ofThreadMode and ConversationOnTheMainPage which are not allowed.
to:
Removed because ThreadMode and ConversationOnTheMainPage are not allowed.
Changed line(s) 8 from:
n
*** Most people attempting to interpret Loghain in a positive light forget that he never thinks the Darkspawn pose an actual threat. His coup and \
to:
*** Most people attempting to interpret Loghain in a positive light forget that he never thinks the Darkspawn pose an actual threat. His coup and \\\"ends justify the means\\\" attitude were based solely on the belief that Cailan having any sort of friendly relationship with Orlais would immediately cause Orlais to invade them and destroy Ferelden.
*** Most people also forget that Cailan completely deferred to Loghain on military matters. Loghain is the one that came up with the plan that failed and resulted in Cailan\\\'s death. Loghain just set it up to look like Cailan had a stupid plan that got him killed.
*** Plus, it was Arl Howe who [[spoiler: sold the elves into slavery]]. Though it is possible Loghain let him do it.
**** Also, Loghain plots the demise of King Cailan, forgetting that Ferelden is not the Empire with strong monarchic rule but rather a federation of feudal domains. Most positive interpretations of Loghain portray him as a [[WellIntentionedExtremist well-intentioned extremist]] although he seems to be more of a short-sighted egomaniac (deliberate destruction of a defending army and underestimation of an obviously powerful enemy are hardly characteristics of a good leader).
***** Or, alternatively, Loghain openly and unequivocally objected to Cailan\\\'s plan, leaving so little room for doubt that Cailan could not help but be aware of how wholehearted his dissent, and when the time came for him to play his part in the stupidity, he decided to just shuffle off rather than commit his troops to it. He volunteered his disagreement with Cailan to you, [[PlayerCharacter the player]], who he\\\'s never met before, so surely it wasn\\\'t a secret. If he was lurking in the shadows to stab when least expected, he certainly wasn\\\'t stealthy about it, and wasn\\\'t very proactive when the time came; what exactly did he \\\'\\\'do\\\'\\\' to \\\'destroy a defending army\\\'?
*** [[FantasticRacism Elves don\\\'t count]].
**** [[PennyArcade I\\\'d love to know why you have a rule for that.]]
*** And Loghain is there to ask the question: do the ends justify the means? If he \\\'\\\'did\\\'\\\' manage to save the country, selling people into slavery still saves thousands of lives, and this was his intent all along.
*** Is Loghain even \\\'\\\'sane\\\'\\\' at the time of Origins? As stated above he makes serious blunders that a master strategist would likely see coming a mile away, he\\\'s so paranoid about Orlais that he completely disregards the historically-proven fact that Grey Wardens are the only ones that can end Blights (even if he considered this Orlesian propaganda, not allowing for the possibility of it being true is just plain stupid). He\\\'s had a hard life detailed in the ExpandedUniverse filled with loss and horrors and the only two things he seems to care about are his daughter and Ferelden, and he takes actions that endanger both of them (mishandling the Blight, causing a civil war and leaving Anora in the care of Arl Howe). Loghain is getting on in years in a world roughly corresponding to the Dark Ages where psychological illness is considered to be a sign of DemonicPossession instead of a medical condition (as shown by the serial killer of elven girls in \\\'\\\'Dragon Age II\\\'\\\'). If Loghain suspected his faculties are deteriorating, he sure wouldn\\\'t admit it for fear of being imprisoned for one reason or another.
*** Alternately, Loghain is what happens when a brilliant military strategist tries to apply his skills to politics, which leads to him treating his allies like subordinates and detractors like enemies. He\\\'s a beast on the battlefield, but nowhere near as savvy as his daughter in the political arena.
*** Many suspect Bann Teagan of sleeping around with his brother\\\'s wife, Isolde, due to the very personal and intimate way they speak with each other--some even claim Connor resembles Teagan more closely than he resembles the Arl. Though given that Eamon and Teagan are brothers, it\\\'s hardly suspicious for Eamon\\\'s son to resemble Teagan. And while Teagan is initially grateful to see Isolde alive since he had been under the impression that everyone in the castle was dead, he quickly gets pissed at her for her part in the mess and stays that way. Frankly, he probably would have been just as relieved to find Owen\\\'s daughter Valena still alive, especially if she could give him news about his family. Though even on the off-chance he was having an affair with Isolde, I hardly think that qualifies him as being gray.
*** Then there\\\'s the Dwarven throne candidates. Is Bhelen a ruthless politician who will do anything to secure power and rules as a tyrant while spitting on Dwarven society, or a WellIntentionedExtremist who [[IDidWhatIhadToDo does what he has to]] to change a society that is slowly dying from its inherent flaws? Is Harrowmont an honorable lord who leads according to Dwarven culture, or a weak old man too wrapped up in tradition to realize the current system doesn\\\'t work?
**** Most likely, Bhelen is a ruthless egomaniac whose politics, while solely motivated to give him dictatorial powers, just happen to be exactly the reforms Dwarven society needs, while Harrowmont is a genuine honorable man, whose well-meant political ideals just happen to entrench his people deeper into failing tradition that are dooming ethem alle. In other words, the Dwarves got the [[IncrediblyLamePun shortstick]].
*** Is Arl Eamon the BigGood of the game or a ManipulativeBastard who desired to turn Cailan and Alistair into a PuppetKing, something that was even lampshaded by Loghain in the game itself. It\\\'s worth noting, Eamon gives up his arling \\\'\\\'only\\\'\\\' if Alistair becomes King, which no longer matters since at now he\\\'s got the King in his pocket. He also threw Alistair, his adopted son into a monastery because of a woman and \\\'\\\'never\\\'\\\' apologises for it.
*** Anora, fittingly, has as many interpretations as her father and shares his love of Ferelden. Is she really as heartless as she seems or is it more a case of IDidWhatIHadToDo considering she has a much clearer picture of the Darkspawn threat than her father? Is she really barren as some suspect or is she deliberately not providing heirs so she doesn\\\'t lose the power she has over the throne?
*** Is Cailan really as big a goof as he seems, or was he ObfuscatingStupidity? While Anora was certainly the brains, Cailan\\\'s overtures to divorce her and marry the Orlesian empress would have given Ferelden a foothold into Orlais and a direct line to inheriting the Orlesian throne through her and Cailan\\\'s heirs. It\\\'s a bit of a Wild Mass Guess, but doing something like this is \\\'\\\'exactly\\\'\\\' what Anora would convince Cailan to try. And while Cailan didn\\\'t take the Darkspawn seriously, neither did Loghain in the long run. And why would he? He had Ferelden\\\'s greatest strategist, a large army and the Grey Wardens on his side.
* With \\\'\\\'VideoGame/DragonAgeII\\\'\\\' we now have even more characters to obsess over. Is Meredith the Only Sane Woman in a town full of rebellious mages that need to be brought to heel and perfectly justified in her actions including [[spoiler: taking over the viscount\\\'s authority after Dumar\\\'s death]]? Is Anders [[spoiler: justified in starting a mage/templar war to free mages from the Chantry\\\'s control, no matter who he has to kill]]? Merrill, idealistic young woman trying to preserve her people\\\'s history or foolish girl with a martyr complex messing with magics and spirits she has no hope of controlling? Fenris, abused former slave with good reason to mistrust mages or {{Jerkass}} who lacks empathy for other oppressed minorities? The list goes on.
** Isabela. LovableRogue who enjoys her freedom in a world of uptight belief systems like the Chantry and the Qun, or selfish BrokenBird whose actions swing up and down the moral spectrum to relieve her guilt over the victims of her crimes? She may [[PetTheDog free slaves and look after Merrill in Kirkwall]], but her [[spoiler: stealing the sacred text of the Qunari caused a war that devastated Kirkwall and she may only return to stop it because Hawke was a good influence on her]], and she\\\'s perfectly willing to let a slave trader walk away free if he gives her a ship and promises to leave her alone. And her chosen career is \\\'\\\'piracy\\\'\\\' when she clearly has the skills to take more legitimate employment. Even if you like Isabela it gets a little uncomfortable when you realize that, while she does have affection for others, she likely places herself and her hedonistic tendencies first.
*** The friendship/rivalry meter banks on this. Isabela for example will be gleefully happy with her new ship if you\\\'ve got a friendly relationship with her [[spoiler: and she\\\'ll be remorseless about letting the slaver walk]], while If you\\\'ve got a rivalry relationship with her she\\\'ll [[spoiler: feel ashamed for letting him walk away in return for the ship]], knowing she could\\\'ve [[spoiler: stopped him]]. The whole point is that while a friendly relationship will make them like you [[spoiler: at the cost of them being irresponsible and selfish]], a rivalry relationship will make them dislike Hawke [[spoiler: but grudgingly admit s/he\\\'s right most of the time and they become less selfish people as a result]].
*** To be fair, [[spoiler: Isabela isn\\\'t incredibly torn up if you\\\'re her friend and kill the slaver instead of taking the ship, because - while still self-centered - she admits it was the right thing to do]]. So at least in that case, the situation can be viewed as less of \\\"being friends = pandering and supporting negative behavior\\\" as much as \\\"being friends = being supportive and non-judgmental, but also influencing said companion to be a better person.\\\"
*** In-universe, Sebastian and Anders argue over Elthina\\\'s merits as Grand Cleric. Sebastian sees her as a mother figure and one of the few sources of moderation in Kirkwall. Anders considers the system she\\\'s trying to preserve inherently unsustainable, and her refusal to openly oppose Meredith the same as condoning all the abuses the Circle Mages suffer.
*** Most people also forget that Cailan completely deferred to Loghain on military matters. Loghain is the one that came up with the plan that failed and resulted in Cailan\\\'s death. Loghain just set it up to look like Cailan had a stupid plan that got him killed.
*** Plus, it was Arl Howe who [[spoiler: sold the elves into slavery]]. Though it is possible Loghain let him do it.
**** Also, Loghain plots the demise of King Cailan, forgetting that Ferelden is not the Empire with strong monarchic rule but rather a federation of feudal domains. Most positive interpretations of Loghain portray him as a [[WellIntentionedExtremist well-intentioned extremist]] although he seems to be more of a short-sighted egomaniac (deliberate destruction of a defending army and underestimation of an obviously powerful enemy are hardly characteristics of a good leader).
***** Or, alternatively, Loghain openly and unequivocally objected to Cailan\\\'s plan, leaving so little room for doubt that Cailan could not help but be aware of how wholehearted his dissent, and when the time came for him to play his part in the stupidity, he decided to just shuffle off rather than commit his troops to it. He volunteered his disagreement with Cailan to you, [[PlayerCharacter the player]], who he\\\'s never met before, so surely it wasn\\\'t a secret. If he was lurking in the shadows to stab when least expected, he certainly wasn\\\'t stealthy about it, and wasn\\\'t very proactive when the time came; what exactly did he \\\'\\\'do\\\'\\\' to \\\'destroy a defending army\\\'?
*** [[FantasticRacism Elves don\\\'t count]].
**** [[PennyArcade I\\\'d love to know why you have a rule for that.]]
*** And Loghain is there to ask the question: do the ends justify the means? If he \\\'\\\'did\\\'\\\' manage to save the country, selling people into slavery still saves thousands of lives, and this was his intent all along.
*** Is Loghain even \\\'\\\'sane\\\'\\\' at the time of Origins? As stated above he makes serious blunders that a master strategist would likely see coming a mile away, he\\\'s so paranoid about Orlais that he completely disregards the historically-proven fact that Grey Wardens are the only ones that can end Blights (even if he considered this Orlesian propaganda, not allowing for the possibility of it being true is just plain stupid). He\\\'s had a hard life detailed in the ExpandedUniverse filled with loss and horrors and the only two things he seems to care about are his daughter and Ferelden, and he takes actions that endanger both of them (mishandling the Blight, causing a civil war and leaving Anora in the care of Arl Howe). Loghain is getting on in years in a world roughly corresponding to the Dark Ages where psychological illness is considered to be a sign of DemonicPossession instead of a medical condition (as shown by the serial killer of elven girls in \\\'\\\'Dragon Age II\\\'\\\'). If Loghain suspected his faculties are deteriorating, he sure wouldn\\\'t admit it for fear of being imprisoned for one reason or another.
*** Alternately, Loghain is what happens when a brilliant military strategist tries to apply his skills to politics, which leads to him treating his allies like subordinates and detractors like enemies. He\\\'s a beast on the battlefield, but nowhere near as savvy as his daughter in the political arena.
*** Many suspect Bann Teagan of sleeping around with his brother\\\'s wife, Isolde, due to the very personal and intimate way they speak with each other--some even claim Connor resembles Teagan more closely than he resembles the Arl. Though given that Eamon and Teagan are brothers, it\\\'s hardly suspicious for Eamon\\\'s son to resemble Teagan. And while Teagan is initially grateful to see Isolde alive since he had been under the impression that everyone in the castle was dead, he quickly gets pissed at her for her part in the mess and stays that way. Frankly, he probably would have been just as relieved to find Owen\\\'s daughter Valena still alive, especially if she could give him news about his family. Though even on the off-chance he was having an affair with Isolde, I hardly think that qualifies him as being gray.
*** Then there\\\'s the Dwarven throne candidates. Is Bhelen a ruthless politician who will do anything to secure power and rules as a tyrant while spitting on Dwarven society, or a WellIntentionedExtremist who [[IDidWhatIhadToDo does what he has to]] to change a society that is slowly dying from its inherent flaws? Is Harrowmont an honorable lord who leads according to Dwarven culture, or a weak old man too wrapped up in tradition to realize the current system doesn\\\'t work?
**** Most likely, Bhelen is a ruthless egomaniac whose politics, while solely motivated to give him dictatorial powers, just happen to be exactly the reforms Dwarven society needs, while Harrowmont is a genuine honorable man, whose well-meant political ideals just happen to entrench his people deeper into failing tradition that are dooming ethem alle. In other words, the Dwarves got the [[IncrediblyLamePun shortstick]].
*** Is Arl Eamon the BigGood of the game or a ManipulativeBastard who desired to turn Cailan and Alistair into a PuppetKing, something that was even lampshaded by Loghain in the game itself. It\\\'s worth noting, Eamon gives up his arling \\\'\\\'only\\\'\\\' if Alistair becomes King, which no longer matters since at now he\\\'s got the King in his pocket. He also threw Alistair, his adopted son into a monastery because of a woman and \\\'\\\'never\\\'\\\' apologises for it.
*** Anora, fittingly, has as many interpretations as her father and shares his love of Ferelden. Is she really as heartless as she seems or is it more a case of IDidWhatIHadToDo considering she has a much clearer picture of the Darkspawn threat than her father? Is she really barren as some suspect or is she deliberately not providing heirs so she doesn\\\'t lose the power she has over the throne?
*** Is Cailan really as big a goof as he seems, or was he ObfuscatingStupidity? While Anora was certainly the brains, Cailan\\\'s overtures to divorce her and marry the Orlesian empress would have given Ferelden a foothold into Orlais and a direct line to inheriting the Orlesian throne through her and Cailan\\\'s heirs. It\\\'s a bit of a Wild Mass Guess, but doing something like this is \\\'\\\'exactly\\\'\\\' what Anora would convince Cailan to try. And while Cailan didn\\\'t take the Darkspawn seriously, neither did Loghain in the long run. And why would he? He had Ferelden\\\'s greatest strategist, a large army and the Grey Wardens on his side.
* With \\\'\\\'VideoGame/DragonAgeII\\\'\\\' we now have even more characters to obsess over. Is Meredith the Only Sane Woman in a town full of rebellious mages that need to be brought to heel and perfectly justified in her actions including [[spoiler: taking over the viscount\\\'s authority after Dumar\\\'s death]]? Is Anders [[spoiler: justified in starting a mage/templar war to free mages from the Chantry\\\'s control, no matter who he has to kill]]? Merrill, idealistic young woman trying to preserve her people\\\'s history or foolish girl with a martyr complex messing with magics and spirits she has no hope of controlling? Fenris, abused former slave with good reason to mistrust mages or {{Jerkass}} who lacks empathy for other oppressed minorities? The list goes on.
** Isabela. LovableRogue who enjoys her freedom in a world of uptight belief systems like the Chantry and the Qun, or selfish BrokenBird whose actions swing up and down the moral spectrum to relieve her guilt over the victims of her crimes? She may [[PetTheDog free slaves and look after Merrill in Kirkwall]], but her [[spoiler: stealing the sacred text of the Qunari caused a war that devastated Kirkwall and she may only return to stop it because Hawke was a good influence on her]], and she\\\'s perfectly willing to let a slave trader walk away free if he gives her a ship and promises to leave her alone. And her chosen career is \\\'\\\'piracy\\\'\\\' when she clearly has the skills to take more legitimate employment. Even if you like Isabela it gets a little uncomfortable when you realize that, while she does have affection for others, she likely places herself and her hedonistic tendencies first.
*** The friendship/rivalry meter banks on this. Isabela for example will be gleefully happy with her new ship if you\\\'ve got a friendly relationship with her [[spoiler: and she\\\'ll be remorseless about letting the slaver walk]], while If you\\\'ve got a rivalry relationship with her she\\\'ll [[spoiler: feel ashamed for letting him walk away in return for the ship]], knowing she could\\\'ve [[spoiler: stopped him]]. The whole point is that while a friendly relationship will make them like you [[spoiler: at the cost of them being irresponsible and selfish]], a rivalry relationship will make them dislike Hawke [[spoiler: but grudgingly admit s/he\\\'s right most of the time and they become less selfish people as a result]].
*** To be fair, [[spoiler: Isabela isn\\\'t incredibly torn up if you\\\'re her friend and kill the slaver instead of taking the ship, because - while still self-centered - she admits it was the right thing to do]]. So at least in that case, the situation can be viewed as less of \\\"being friends = pandering and supporting negative behavior\\\" as much as \\\"being friends = being supportive and non-judgmental, but also influencing said companion to be a better person.\\\"
*** In-universe, Sebastian and Anders argue over Elthina\\\'s merits as Grand Cleric. Sebastian sees her as a mother figure and one of the few sources of moderation in Kirkwall. Anders considers the system she\\\'s trying to preserve inherently unsustainable, and her refusal to openly oppose Meredith the same as condoning all the abuses the Circle Mages suffer.
