Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / StrawmanHasAPoint

Go To

[001] Rebochan Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I took off \'\'all\'\' of the Harry Potter examples because none of the examples are Strawmen. Umbridge \'\'might\'\' have had a point if her goal was to remove incompetent staff, but the story never makes the argument that she is doing so. She is a racist purging people she finds unclean.
to:
I took off \\\'\\\'all\\\'\\\' of the Harry Potter examples because none of the examples are Strawmen. Umbridge \\\'\\\'might\\\'\\\' have had a point if her goal was to remove incompetent staff, but the story never makes the argument that she is doing so. She is a racist purging people she finds unclean. Furthermore, the entry actually made the book\\\'s case by accident because firing Trelawny actually put her life in danger. In other words...no. She does not have a point. She is a terrible person.
Top