Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / PrisonEpisode

Go To

[002] mlaw109 Current Version

23rd Jul '11 at 11:47:34 PM

Changed line(s) 9 from:

n

--if something bad happens in Naruto, it tends to happen to Sasuke. Forget FreudianExcuse, the destruction of his happiness and sanity unfolds on-screen. Counterpoint: it doesn\'t validate wanting to kill everyone. Counter-counterpoint: Declaration of Omnicidal Maniac intent and going through with it are two different things. He -very likely- will not succeed, but whether or not he qualifies will probably boil down to 1. how far he gets 2. whether he\'s stopped solely by an outside force Naruto) or by the force of his own conscience.

to:

--if something bad happens in Naruto, it tends to happen to Sasuke. Forget FreudianExcuse, the destruction of his happiness and sanity unfolds on-screen. Counterpoint: it doesn\\\'t validate wanting to kill everyone. Counter-counterpoint: Declaration of Omnicidal Maniac intent and going through with it are two different things. He -very likely- will not succeed, but whether or not he fits this third criteria will probably boil down to 1. how far he gets 2. whether he\\\'s stopped solely by an outside force (Naruto) or by the force of his own conscience.

[001] mlaw109

23rd Jul '11 at 11:46:12 PM

Changed line(s) 3 from:

to:

Changed line(s) 4 from:

to:

Changed line(s) 6 from:

n

--if something bad happens in Naruto, it tends to happen to Sasuke. Forget FreudianExcuse, the destruction of his happiness and sanity unfolds on-screen. Counterpoint: it doesn\'t validate wanting to kill everyone. Counter-counterpoint: Declaration of Omnicidal Maniac intent and going through with it are two different things. He -very likely- will not succeed, but whether or not he qualifies will probably boil down to 1. how far he gets 2. whether he\'s stopped solely by an outside force Naruto) or by the force of his own conscience.

to:

Changed line(s) 7 from:

to:

--if something bad happens in Naruto, it tends to happen to Sasuke. Forget FreudianExcuse, the destruction of his happiness and sanity unfolds on-screen. Counterpoint: it doesn\\\'t validate wanting to kill everyone. Counter-counterpoint: Declaration of Omnicidal Maniac intent and going through with it are two different things. He -very likely- will not succeed, but whether or not he qualifies will probably boil down to 1. how far he gets 2. whether he\\\'s stopped solely by an outside force Naruto) or by the force of his own conscience.

Changed line(s) 9 from:

n

5. No chance of redemption. No one thinks so but Naruto...but he has a knack for proving everyone wrong. I\'d have to say he doesn\'t fit this one, but only because Naruto leans on the idealistic end of the scale. Whether or not Sasuke\'s redemption would be a KarmaHoudini really has to do with how Kishi handles it. If Sasuke, in his atonement, suffers proportionately to the harm he\'s done--not the harm he says he\'s going to do, the harm he actually succeeds in doing--then it\'s probably averted.

to:

Changed line(s) 10 from:

to:

5. No chance of redemption. No one thinks so but Naruto...but he has a knack for proving everyone wrong. I\\\'d have to say he doesn\\\'t fit this one, but only because Naruto leans on the idealistic end of the scale. Whether or not Sasuke\\\'s redemption would be a KarmaHoudini really has to do with how Kishi handles it. If Sasuke, in his atonement, suffers proportionately to the harm he\\\'s done--not the harm he says he\\\'s going to do, the harm he actually succeeds in doing--then it\\\'s probably averted.

Top