[004]
BurnoodTakedown
Current Version
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
In series 2, she befriended Sarah Jane Smith after an initially frosty encounter, said of Reinette that the Doctor was right about her (with Reinette admitting to Rose that the Doctor is \
to:
In series 2, she befriended Sarah Jane Smith after an initially frosty encounter, said of Reinette that the Doctor was right about her (with Reinette admitting to Rose that the Doctor is \\\"worth the monsters\\\"), hugged Rita Connolly after she got verbal abuse from her husband, and certainly didn\\\'t express any jealousy about Queen Victoria, the cat nuns or Lady Cassandra. Was she clingy to the Doctor in the Satan two-parter? Kinda, considering she needed sedating to get brought on board the rocket. Was she bitchy to Ida? Not that I could see. The only one I can really think of is Lucy in Rise of the Cybermen.
* This got worse when she re-appeared in Series 4, undermining what a lot of fans felt was a satisfying and emotional departure, Rose continuing to be bitchy to other characters
Just Martha, and even then, she goes \\\"she\\\'s good\\\" regarding her Osterhagen plan. In Turn Left, she repeatedly bigs up *Donna\\\'s* importance to the story arc.
* and overall feeling unnecessary to the story.
Rose repeatedly warns Donna of the coming darkness and helps her save the dark timeline from Turn Left.
* The companions having romantic interactions with the Doctor is also accused of this, including a bizarre scene in \\\"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS31E5FleshAndStone Flesh and Stone]]\\\" where Amy Pond sexually assaults the clearly unwilling 11th Doctor the night before her wedding (which Steven Moffat has since said he deeply regrets).
Accused of what? Also, an unsuccessful heat of the moment affair is not \\\"romantic interaction\\\".
* The Twelfth Doctor tells Clara he had made a mistake by acting like her boyfriend in his previous incarnation. \\\'\\\'However\\\'\\\', as Series 8 progressed there was the Doctor\\\'s rather jealous taunting of Danny Pink due to him being Clara\\\'s boyfriend,
Huh? Wasn\\\'t it because he was a soldier? I thought he was happy about Clara\\\'s new boyfriend when he mistakenly thought it was the guy who resembled Eleven.
* and while TheILoveYouStigma hangs over both their heads, the Doctor and Clara are well and truly in love with each other in Series 9, culminating in [[spoiler: her death and his temporary descent into madness as he tries to bring her back -- and partially succeeds]], which triggered similar complaints to those Rose and Ten\\\'s relationship received.
Who was Clara jealous to after Danny\\\'s death and her relationship with the Doctor changing? How was she redundant to the series 9 story arc? Who continuously praised her? (or Rose for that matter. The mentions in series 3 were mostly about her spotting obvious things staring the Doctor in the face and Martha subtly calling him out for taking her the same places Rose went to.)
* This got worse when she re-appeared in Series 4, undermining what a lot of fans felt was a satisfying and emotional departure, Rose continuing to be bitchy to other characters
Just Martha, and even then, she goes \\\"she\\\'s good\\\" regarding her Osterhagen plan. In Turn Left, she repeatedly bigs up *Donna\\\'s* importance to the story arc.
* and overall feeling unnecessary to the story.
Rose repeatedly warns Donna of the coming darkness and helps her save the dark timeline from Turn Left.
* The companions having romantic interactions with the Doctor is also accused of this, including a bizarre scene in \\\"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS31E5FleshAndStone Flesh and Stone]]\\\" where Amy Pond sexually assaults the clearly unwilling 11th Doctor the night before her wedding (which Steven Moffat has since said he deeply regrets).
Accused of what? Also, an unsuccessful heat of the moment affair is not \\\"romantic interaction\\\".
* The Twelfth Doctor tells Clara he had made a mistake by acting like her boyfriend in his previous incarnation. \\\'\\\'However\\\'\\\', as Series 8 progressed there was the Doctor\\\'s rather jealous taunting of Danny Pink due to him being Clara\\\'s boyfriend,
Huh? Wasn\\\'t it because he was a soldier? I thought he was happy about Clara\\\'s new boyfriend when he mistakenly thought it was the guy who resembled Eleven.
* and while TheILoveYouStigma hangs over both their heads, the Doctor and Clara are well and truly in love with each other in Series 9, culminating in [[spoiler: her death and his temporary descent into madness as he tries to bring her back -- and partially succeeds]], which triggered similar complaints to those Rose and Ten\\\'s relationship received.
Who was Clara jealous to after Danny\\\'s death and her relationship with the Doctor changing? How was she redundant to the series 9 story arc? Who continuously praised her? (or Rose for that matter. The mentions in series 3 were mostly about her spotting obvious things staring the Doctor in the face and Martha subtly calling him out for taking her the same places Rose went to.)
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
In series 2, she befriended Sarah Jane Smith after an initially frosty encounter, said of Reinette that the Doctor was right about her (with Reinette admitting to Rose that the Doctor is \
to:
In series 2, she befriended Sarah Jane Smith after an initially frosty encounter, said of Reinette that the Doctor was right about her (with Reinette admitting to Rose that the Doctor is \\\"worth the monsters\\\"), hugged Rita Connolly after she got verbal abuse from her husband, and certainly didn\\\'t express any jealousy about Queen Victoria, the cat nuns or Lady Cassandra. Was she clingy to the Doctor in the Satan two-parter? To an extent, considering she refused to leave the planet even when the Doctor was assumed dead. Was she bitchy or jealous to Ida or Scooti? Not that I could see. The only one I can really think of is Lucy in Rise of the Cybermen.
* This got worse when she re-appeared in Series 4, undermining what a lot of fans felt was a satisfying and emotional departure, Rose continuing to be bitchy to other characters
Just Martha, and even then, she goes \\\"she\\\'s good\\\" regarding her Osterhagen plan. In Turn Left, she repeatedly bigs up *Donna\\\'s* importance to the story arc.
* and overall feeling unnecessary to the story.
Rose repeatedly warns Donna of the coming darkness and helps her save the dark timeline from Turn Left.
* The companions having romantic interactions with the Doctor is also accused of this, including a bizarre scene in \\\"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS31E5FleshAndStone Flesh and Stone]]\\\" where Amy Pond sexually assaults the clearly unwilling 11th Doctor the night before her wedding (which Steven Moffat has since said he deeply regrets).
Accused of what? Also, an unsuccessful heat of the moment affair is not \\\"romantic interaction\\\".
* The Twelfth Doctor tells Clara he had made a mistake by acting like her boyfriend in his previous incarnation. \\\'\\\'However\\\'\\\', as Series 8 progressed there was the Doctor\\\'s rather jealous taunting of Danny Pink due to him being Clara\\\'s boyfriend,
Huh? Wasn\\\'t it because he was a soldier? I thought he was happy about Clara\\\'s new boyfriend when he mistakenly thought it was the guy who resembled Eleven.
* and while TheILoveYouStigma hangs over both their heads, the Doctor and Clara are well and truly in love with each other in Series 9, culminating in [[spoiler: her death and his temporary descent into madness as he tries to bring her back -- and partially succeeds]], which triggered similar complaints to those Rose and Ten\\\'s relationship received.
Who was Clara clingy to after Danny\\\'s death and her relationship with the Doctor changing? How was she redundant to the series 9 story arc? Who continuously praised her? (or Rose for that matter. The mentions in series 3 were mostly about her spotting obvious things staring the Doctor in the face and Martha subtly calling him out for taking her the same places Rose went to.)
* This got worse when she re-appeared in Series 4, undermining what a lot of fans felt was a satisfying and emotional departure, Rose continuing to be bitchy to other characters
Just Martha, and even then, she goes \\\"she\\\'s good\\\" regarding her Osterhagen plan. In Turn Left, she repeatedly bigs up *Donna\\\'s* importance to the story arc.
* and overall feeling unnecessary to the story.
Rose repeatedly warns Donna of the coming darkness and helps her save the dark timeline from Turn Left.
* The companions having romantic interactions with the Doctor is also accused of this, including a bizarre scene in \\\"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS31E5FleshAndStone Flesh and Stone]]\\\" where Amy Pond sexually assaults the clearly unwilling 11th Doctor the night before her wedding (which Steven Moffat has since said he deeply regrets).
Accused of what? Also, an unsuccessful heat of the moment affair is not \\\"romantic interaction\\\".
* The Twelfth Doctor tells Clara he had made a mistake by acting like her boyfriend in his previous incarnation. \\\'\\\'However\\\'\\\', as Series 8 progressed there was the Doctor\\\'s rather jealous taunting of Danny Pink due to him being Clara\\\'s boyfriend,
Huh? Wasn\\\'t it because he was a soldier? I thought he was happy about Clara\\\'s new boyfriend when he mistakenly thought it was the guy who resembled Eleven.
* and while TheILoveYouStigma hangs over both their heads, the Doctor and Clara are well and truly in love with each other in Series 9, culminating in [[spoiler: her death and his temporary descent into madness as he tries to bring her back -- and partially succeeds]], which triggered similar complaints to those Rose and Ten\\\'s relationship received.
Who was Clara clingy to after Danny\\\'s death and her relationship with the Doctor changing? How was she redundant to the series 9 story arc? Who continuously praised her? (or Rose for that matter. The mentions in series 3 were mostly about her spotting obvious things staring the Doctor in the face and Martha subtly calling him out for taking her the same places Rose went to.)
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
In series 2, she befriended Sarah Jane Smith after an initially frosty encounter, said of Reinette that the Doctor was right about her (with Reinette admitting to Rose that the Doctor is \
to:
In series 2, she befriended Sarah Jane Smith after an initially frosty encounter, said of Reinette that the Doctor was right about her (with Reinette admitting to Rose that the Doctor is \\\"worth the monsters\\\"), hugged Rita Connolly after she got verbal abuse from her husband, and certainly didn\\\'t express any jealousy about Queen Victoria, the cat nuns or Lady Cassandra. The only one I can really think of is Lucy in Rise of the Cybermen.
* This got worse when she re-appeared in Series 4, undermining what a lot of fans felt was a satisfying and emotional departure, Rose continuing to be bitchy to other characters
Just Martha, and even then, she goes \\\"she\\\'s good\\\" regarding her Osterhagen plan. In Turn Left, she repeatedly bigs up *Donna\\\'s* importance to the story arc.
* and overall feeling unnecessary to the story.
Rose repeatedly warns Donna of the coming darkness and helps her save the dark timeline from Turn Left.
* The companions having romantic interactions with the Doctor is also accused of this, including a bizarre scene in \\\"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS31E5FleshAndStone Flesh and Stone]]\\\" where Amy Pond sexually assaults the clearly unwilling 11th Doctor the night before her wedding (which Steven Moffat has since said he deeply regrets).
Accused of what? Also, an unsuccessful heat of the moment affair is not \\\"romantic interaction\\\".
* The Twelfth Doctor tells Clara he had made a mistake by acting like her boyfriend in his previous incarnation. \\\'\\\'However\\\'\\\', as Series 8 progressed there was the Doctor\\\'s rather jealous taunting of Danny Pink due to him being Clara\\\'s boyfriend,
Huh? Wasn\\\'t it because he was a soldier? I thought he was happy about Clara\\\'s new boyfriend when he mistakenly thought it was the guy who resembled Eleven.
* and while TheILoveYouStigma hangs over both their heads, the Doctor and Clara are well and truly in love with each other in Series 9, culminating in [[spoiler: her death and his temporary descent into madness as he tries to bring her back -- and partially succeeds]], which triggered similar complaints to those Rose and Ten\\\'s relationship received.
Who was Clara jealous to after Danny\\\'s death and her relationship with the Doctor changing? How was she redundant to the series 9 story arc? Who continuously praised her? (or Rose for that matter. The mentions in series 3 were mostly about her spotting obvious things staring the Doctor in the face and Martha subtly calling him out for taking her the same places Rose went to.)
* This got worse when she re-appeared in Series 4, undermining what a lot of fans felt was a satisfying and emotional departure, Rose continuing to be bitchy to other characters
Just Martha, and even then, she goes \\\"she\\\'s good\\\" regarding her Osterhagen plan. In Turn Left, she repeatedly bigs up *Donna\\\'s* importance to the story arc.
* and overall feeling unnecessary to the story.
Rose repeatedly warns Donna of the coming darkness and helps her save the dark timeline from Turn Left.
* The companions having romantic interactions with the Doctor is also accused of this, including a bizarre scene in \\\"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS31E5FleshAndStone Flesh and Stone]]\\\" where Amy Pond sexually assaults the clearly unwilling 11th Doctor the night before her wedding (which Steven Moffat has since said he deeply regrets).
Accused of what? Also, an unsuccessful heat of the moment affair is not \\\"romantic interaction\\\".
* The Twelfth Doctor tells Clara he had made a mistake by acting like her boyfriend in his previous incarnation. \\\'\\\'However\\\'\\\', as Series 8 progressed there was the Doctor\\\'s rather jealous taunting of Danny Pink due to him being Clara\\\'s boyfriend,
Huh? Wasn\\\'t it because he was a soldier? I thought he was happy about Clara\\\'s new boyfriend when he mistakenly thought it was the guy who resembled Eleven.
* and while TheILoveYouStigma hangs over both their heads, the Doctor and Clara are well and truly in love with each other in Series 9, culminating in [[spoiler: her death and his temporary descent into madness as he tries to bring her back -- and partially succeeds]], which triggered similar complaints to those Rose and Ten\\\'s relationship received.
Who was Clara jealous to after Danny\\\'s death and her relationship with the Doctor changing? How was she redundant to the series 9 story arc? Who continuously praised her? (or Rose for that matter. The mentions in series 3 were mostly about her spotting obvious things staring the Doctor in the face and Martha subtly calling him out for taking her the same places Rose went to.)
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
In series 2, she befriended Sarah Jane Smith after an initially frosty encounter, said of Reinette that the Doctor was right about her (with Reinette admitting to Rose that the Doctor is \
to:
In series 2, she befriended Sarah Jane Smith after an initially frosty encounter, said of Reinette that the Doctor was right about her (with Reinette admitting to Rose that the Doctor is \\\"worth the monsters\\\"), hugged Rita Connolly after she got verbal abuse from her husband, and certainly didn\\\'t express any jealousy about Queen Victoria, the cat nuns or Lady Cassandra. The only thing I think she really says to or about Ida is in relation to the black hole or the Doctor descending down the pit. The only one I can really think of is Lucy in Rise of the Cybermen.
* This got worse when she re-appeared in Series 4, undermining what a lot of fans felt was a satisfying and emotional departure, Rose continuing to be bitchy to other characters
Just Martha, and even then, she goes \\\"she\\\'s good\\\" regarding her Osterhagen plan. In Turn Left, she repeatedly bigs up *Donna\\\'s* importance to the story arc.
* and overall feeling unnecessary to the story.
Rose repeatedly warns Donna of the coming darkness and helps her save the dark timeline from Turn Left.
* The companions having romantic interactions with the Doctor is also accused of this, including a bizarre scene in \\\"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS31E5FleshAndStone Flesh and Stone]]\\\" where Amy Pond sexually assaults the clearly unwilling 11th Doctor the night before her wedding (which Steven Moffat has since said he deeply regrets).
Accused of what? Also, an unsuccessful heat of the moment affair after Amy nearly dying is not \\\"romantic interaction\\\".
* The Twelfth Doctor tells Clara he had made a mistake by acting like her boyfriend in his previous incarnation. \\\'\\\'However\\\'\\\', as Series 8 progressed there was the Doctor\\\'s rather jealous taunting of Danny Pink due to him being Clara\\\'s boyfriend,
Huh? Wasn\\\'t it because he was a soldier? I thought he was happy about Clara\\\'s new boyfriend when he mistakenly thought it was the guy who resembled Eleven.
* and while TheILoveYouStigma hangs over both their heads, the Doctor and Clara are well and truly in love with each other in Series 9, culminating in [[spoiler: her death and his temporary descent into madness as he tries to bring her back -- and partially succeeds]], which triggered similar complaints to those Rose and Ten\\\'s relationship received.
Who was Clara clingy to after Danny\\\'s death and her relationship with the Doctor changing? How was she redundant to the series 9 story arc? Who continuously praised her? (or Rose for that matter. The mentions in series 3 were mostly about her spotting obvious things staring the Doctor in the face and Martha subtly calling him out for taking her the same places Rose went to.)
* This got worse when she re-appeared in Series 4, undermining what a lot of fans felt was a satisfying and emotional departure, Rose continuing to be bitchy to other characters
Just Martha, and even then, she goes \\\"she\\\'s good\\\" regarding her Osterhagen plan. In Turn Left, she repeatedly bigs up *Donna\\\'s* importance to the story arc.
* and overall feeling unnecessary to the story.
Rose repeatedly warns Donna of the coming darkness and helps her save the dark timeline from Turn Left.
* The companions having romantic interactions with the Doctor is also accused of this, including a bizarre scene in \\\"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS31E5FleshAndStone Flesh and Stone]]\\\" where Amy Pond sexually assaults the clearly unwilling 11th Doctor the night before her wedding (which Steven Moffat has since said he deeply regrets).
Accused of what? Also, an unsuccessful heat of the moment affair after Amy nearly dying is not \\\"romantic interaction\\\".
* The Twelfth Doctor tells Clara he had made a mistake by acting like her boyfriend in his previous incarnation. \\\'\\\'However\\\'\\\', as Series 8 progressed there was the Doctor\\\'s rather jealous taunting of Danny Pink due to him being Clara\\\'s boyfriend,
Huh? Wasn\\\'t it because he was a soldier? I thought he was happy about Clara\\\'s new boyfriend when he mistakenly thought it was the guy who resembled Eleven.
* and while TheILoveYouStigma hangs over both their heads, the Doctor and Clara are well and truly in love with each other in Series 9, culminating in [[spoiler: her death and his temporary descent into madness as he tries to bring her back -- and partially succeeds]], which triggered similar complaints to those Rose and Ten\\\'s relationship received.
Who was Clara clingy to after Danny\\\'s death and her relationship with the Doctor changing? How was she redundant to the series 9 story arc? Who continuously praised her? (or Rose for that matter. The mentions in series 3 were mostly about her spotting obvious things staring the Doctor in the face and Martha subtly calling him out for taking her the same places Rose went to.)
