[006]
R.G.
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Marville would be more at home if the humor magazine Crazy had still been published.
to:
Marville would be more at home at the humor magazine Crazy if it had still been published.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I disagree. ThereIsNoSuchThingAsNotability here, and while that's more strict for trope pages I don't see why it can't apply here as well.
to:
I disagree. ThereIsNoSuchThingAsNotability here, and while that\'s more strict for trope pages I don\'t see why it can\'t apply here as well.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
Point A is valid as a fact, but there's plenty of other examples across TV Tropes where the work has no page. I understand that Solarpunk is a genre, not a work, but you can't discredit this one genre on such a narrow basis.
I disagree with Point B, though. Solarpunk is defined just as well as countless other
I disagree with Point B, though. Solarpunk is defined just as well as countless other
to:
Point A is valid as a fact, but there\'s plenty of other examples across TV Tropes where the work has no page. I understand that Solarpunk is a genre, not a work, but you can\'t discredit this one genre on such a narrow basis.
I disagree with Point B, though. Solarpunk is defined just as well as countless other \"genre\" pages on TV Tropes. Take TheWeirdWest, for example. Or even DungeonPunk, which has as much consistency as Solarpunk. Heck, BiblePunk got a page and that\'s \'\'way\'\' sketchier than Solarpunk.
And as far as \"how we define PunkPunk,\" Solarpunk acts as a DeconReconSwitch to the whole idea. Rather than technology as a means to control the public, it\'s used as an enabler for communal cooperation. Solarpunk deliberately finds ways for technology to work \'\'in harmony\'\' with society and nature. And in relation to the very real \"Punk\" subculture, which ignores social norms in loud, proud ways like graffiti and hair dye, Solarpunk does the same thing through urban farming and solar roofs. Basically, Solarpunk is optimistic -- even TheAntiNihilist -- to CyberPunk and SteamPunk\'s nihilism.
Solarpunk is a perfectly valid addition to the PunkPunk page. But if you insist, I\'m already gathering titles that can go on the YKTTW.
I disagree with Point B, though. Solarpunk is defined just as well as countless other \"genre\" pages on TV Tropes. Take TheWeirdWest, for example. Or even DungeonPunk, which has as much consistency as Solarpunk. Heck, BiblePunk got a page and that\'s \'\'way\'\' sketchier than Solarpunk.
And as far as \"how we define PunkPunk,\" Solarpunk acts as a DeconReconSwitch to the whole idea. Rather than technology as a means to control the public, it\'s used as an enabler for communal cooperation. Solarpunk deliberately finds ways for technology to work \'\'in harmony\'\' with society and nature. And in relation to the very real \"Punk\" subculture, which ignores social norms in loud, proud ways like graffiti and hair dye, Solarpunk does the same thing through urban farming and solar roofs. Basically, Solarpunk is optimistic -- even TheAntiNihilist -- to CyberPunk and SteamPunk\'s nihilism.
Solarpunk is a perfectly valid addition to the PunkPunk page. But if you insist, I\'m already gathering titles that can go on the YKTTW.
