Complete Monster Clean Up Compendium

This thread is dedicated to recording and archiving all of the results and verdicts in the Complete Monster Clean Up thread. As such, it is to be considered as a sub-thread. Expect edits a-plenty. Feel welcome to post results from the clean up thread so I can update this archive.

Anime & Manga:

• Puella Magi Madoka Magica
  • Kyubey: No. Well-Intentioned Extremist. Lacks heinousness. Does however cross the Moral Event Horizon in Rebellion.
• Dragon Ball
  • Frieza: Yes
  • Cell: Yes
  • Androids 17/18 (Alternate timeline): No. Show love for each other.
  • Bibadi: No (Offscreen villainy)
  • Babadi: Yes
  • Super Buu: Yes

Comic Books:

• Batman
  • The Joker: Unique case. Heavy on Depending on the Writer
• Infinite Crisis:
• Super Boy Prime: Yes

Film:

• Star Wars
  • Emperor Palpatine: Yes.

Film Animation:

• Toy Story:
  • Lotso. Yes. Never....request....again.
• Hunchback Of Notre Dame:
  • Frollo (movie version): Yes

Literature:

Live-Action Television:

• Power Rangers
  • Banshera: Yes
  • Ivan Ooze: Yes
  • Venjix: Yes
  • Mesogog: No. Fails moral agency.

Table Top Gaming:

• War Hammer 40000: Due to the extreme grim darkness of this setting, only the following characters can ever qualify.
  • Azariah Kyras
  • Abbadon the Despoiler
  • Fabius Bile
  • Honsou
  • Asburdael Vect

Video Games:

• Metal Gear Solid 3:
  • Volkin: Yes.
• Mega Man
  • Dr. Weil: Yes.
  • Omega: No. Fails moral agency.
  • Gemini: Yes
  • Plant Man: No. Fails heinousness.
  • Joker: No. Fails heinousness.
  • Dr. Regal: Yes.
• Tales Series:
  • Cumore: Yes.
  • Ragou: Yes.
  • Alexi: Yes
  • Kvar: Yes
  • Rodyle: Yes
  • Zilva: Yes
  • Barbatos: Yes
  • Vharley: No. Fails heinous standard.
  • Vaclav: Yes
• Sonic The Hedgehog
  • Black Doom: Yes.

Visual Novels:

• Higurashi When They Cry
  • Shion Sonozaki (Alternate Time Line Clause): No. Sympathetic backstory, redeeming traits. Possible corrupted moral agency.
  • Miyo Takano: No. Sympathetic backstory, redeeming traits.
  • Nomura: Yes.
  • Teppei Houjou: Yes. Child abuse normally doesn't count, but its HOW he does it that puts him here.
• Umineko When They Cry
  • EVA-Beatrice: No. Redeeming traits. Symbolic of a culprit theory that's proven false.
  • Erika: No. Sympathetic backstory.
  • Bernkastel: Yes. Note that she's a rare case of Enemy Without with moral agency.

Web Comics:

Western Animation:

• South Park: Due to Black Comedy, nearly impossible for anyone to pass.
  • Eric Cartman: No. Heinousness has been toned down post season 16. Played for Laughs. Never...ask...again.
• Fairly Odd Parents: Kids show + comedy means no one can qualify.
• Sponge Bob Square Pants: Kids show + comedy means no one can qualify.
• Avatar The Last Airbender
  • Ozai: Yes. Has never loved his wife or children.
  • Yakone: No

edited 12th Mar '14 8:06:59 PM by magnum12