YMMV / We Are The In Crowd

• Signature Song: Either Kiss Me Again (their biggest radio hit) or Rumor Mill (the song that closes out their concerts) are the biggest contenders.
  • Both Sides of the Story, for spawning the band's biggest catchphrase "You're Not Quite Satan, But I really Think I Hate You"
• Tear Jerker: Windows in Heaven, written about Tay's late father. If you aren't crying by the last chorus, you will start by then. Especially if you have lost someone when you were young and wondering what they would think of you if they were here today.