troperville

tools

toys


main index

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
random
Kickstarter Message
TV Tropes Needs Your Help
X
Big things are happening on TV Tropes! New admins, new designs, fewer ads, mobile versions, beta testing opportunities, thematic discovery engine, fun trope tools and toys, and much more - Learn how to help here and discuss here.
View Kickstarter Project
YMMV: The Dispossessed
  • Critical Research Failure: Shevek floors an Urrasti in debate by pointing out that military hierarchy is unnecessary, since, after all, guerrillas manage without such things. Apparently, Ursula K. Le Guin had never troubled herself to learn anything about guerilla warfare, as even a cursory study of the topic would have taught her that guerilla armies do indeed have rank structures, organized units, and hierarchies of command (they are basically just light infantry who are trained in raiding tactics). This was an especially egregious error, given that America was actually involved in a guerrilla war at the time that she wrote this book — with guerrillas who had a very highly developed military hierarchy.
    • To be fair, there are historical examples of guerrillas who didn't use hierarchy, like the POUM militias George Orwell fought with during the Spanish Civil War (read Orwell's Homage to Catalonia for a detailed description). Of course, they lost the war.
  • Debate and Switch: Most of the book can be read as a dramatized debate over the question of whether anarchism, represented by the Odonian philosophy practised on Anarres, or liberal democratic capitalism, represented by the nation of A-Io, is better. Although it is clear that the author's sympathies lie mostly with Odonianism, the question is dealt with subtly, with the increasing majority-backed repressiveness of Anarres being shown, as is the fact that the profit motive as practised on A-Io provides a far better life to most Iotians than Shevek had been led to believe. Then, practically out of the blue, A-Io massacres peaceful protestors by the thousand. Well, duh, Anarresti anarchism is better than that. So, for that matter, is the United States of America in the 1970's, for which A-Io was obviously meant to be a loose analogue. Hell, by the 1970's even the real-world analogue of Thu, the USSR, was not mowing down protestors in such numbers that the closely-packed dead bodies were left jammed in a standing position. The whole philosophical debate is tossed aside and replaced by Baddies Are Bad.
    • In an interesting case, the A-Io's actions are understandable, though not justified - they remember what the last strike led to, and they are all out of moons to bribe dissidents with.
    • It's probably worth noting that, while massacres of striking workers weren't common in 1970s America, they were common in America at the turn of the century, so this could also simply be a case of Anachronism Stew.

random
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy
3901
44