History YMMV / ThatAnimeShow

** Creator/MicahSolusod sits in the background during Apphia Yu's episode and they all constantly refer to him as their "servant".

** The hosts and Micah Solusod share their opinions of what day in their life they would love to relive. Both the hosts' choices involve each of their parents.

* NauseaFuel: The end of Scott Freeman's episode, which also CrossesTheLineTwice.

* {{Squick}}: Again, the end of Scott Freeman's episode.

* CrowningMomentOfFunny: Too many to list. Chris Cason's episode is a goldmine. Most of the anecdotes shared are quite hilarious.

* CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming: A few, sometimes lampshaded if Terri says it's getting too sweet.
** The hosts and Micah Solusod share their opinions of what day in their life they would love to relive. Both the hosts' choices involve each of their parents.

* HilariousInHindsight: In episode 6 with Creator/AlexisTipton they begin with a discussion on breasts. [[{{Sekirei}} And then Alexis ends up getting a role in a series with the marketing tagline "Boobies For The Win"...]]

* HarsherInHindsight: September and October 2016. Reporters of creepy clowns wandering around the country alone and frequently armed has caused massive online hysteria, including a "Clown Lives Matter" campaign in support of those clowns who are actually harmless people. Tatum's well-known fear of clowns suddenly becomes a lot less funny.

** Tatum's and Brina's improvised sketch as [[BlackButler Sebastian and Ciel]], in response to a fan question.

-->'''Tatum:''' I can "redraw the line!"
-->'''Mike:''' WHAT LINE?!

-->'''Tatum:''' Get me a drink!
-->'''Micah:''' My arms fell off!

* TheWoobie: Switches between Tatum and the engineer Stephen, [[Manga/SgtFrog of course.]] Terri also has a moment in episode 27 recounting her time in high school.

* TheWoobie: Switches between Tatum and the engineer Stephen, [[SgtFrog of course.]] Terri also has a moment in episode 27 recounting her time in high school.

** Watch ''ShikabaneHime'''s finale, then recall that one of the recurring questions of the podcast (which actually comes up in the ''Shikabane''-themed episode 18) is the ZombieApocalypse.

* NightmareFuel: The end of episode 28, with Alexis possibly channeling [[GaReiZero Yomi]].

** BryanMassey's rapid-fire list of porn movie titles. Tatum laughs to tears.

** Creator/MicahSolusud sits in the background during Apphia Yu's episode and they all constantly refer to him as their "servant".

** The hosts and Micah Solusud share their opinions of what day in their life they would love to relive. Both the hosts' choices involve each of their parents.

** MicahSolosud sits in the background during Apphia Yu's episode and they all constantly refer to him as their "servant".

** The hosts and Micah Solosud share their opinions of what day in their life they would love to relive. Both the hosts' choices involve each of their parents.

* HilariousInHindsight: In episode 6 with Alexis Tipton they begin with a discussion on breasts. [[{{Sekirei}} And then Alexis ends up getting a role in a series with the marketing tagline "Boobies For The Win"...]]
** In episode 11, a discussion on Creator/ArnoldSchwarzenegger becomes hilarious when both Bryan and Tatum get to be on ''MyBrideIsAMermaid''...with Tatum playing the Terminator parody that is Lunar's Papa.

** The episode with CheramiLeigh on it features a discussion on cupcakes, with her being a 'cupcake fairy', and ends with Cherami supposedly materalizing a cupcake out of thin air, sweetly asking Tatum to eat it, Tatum refusing, and Cherami ''[[CuteBruiser violently forcing it]] [[MoodWhiplash into his mouth!]]''

** Tatum's fear of clowns, and the mention of BrinaPalencia [[RunningGag milking it to tease him.]]

** MikeMcFarland's episode has a few when they describe how he makes voice-acting fun while in the booth.

** Michal Solusod sits in the background during Apphia Yu's episode and they all constantly refer to him as their "servant".

-->'''Michal:''' My arms fell off!

*** '''Tatum:''' Get me a drink!
*** '''Michal:''' My arms fell off!

*** Michal Solusod sits in the background during Apphia Yu's episode and they all constantly refer to him as their "servant".

** The episode with CheramiLeigh on it features a discussion on cupcakes, with her being a 'cupcake fairy', and ends with Cherami supposedly materalizing a cupcake out of thin air, sweetly asking Tatum to eat it, Tatum refusing, and Cherami ''[[CuteBruiser violently forcing it]] [[MoodWhiplash into his mouth!]]''

** In episode 11, a discussion on ArnoldSchwarzenegger becomes hilarious when both Bryan and Tatum get to be on ''MyBrideIsAMermaid''...with Tatum playing the Terminator parody that is Lunar's Papa.

* TheWoobie: Switches between Tatum and the engineer Stephen, [[SgtFrog of course.]] Terri also has a moment in episode 27 recounting her time in high school.