Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / SuperRobotWarsX

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The World of Revolution, which includes ''Anime/{{Daitarn3}}'', ''Anime/CodeGeass'', ''Anime/AuraBattlerDunbine'', and ''Anime/MobileSuitGundamWingEndlessWaltz'', had a lot of potential for an interesting story addition, but was all unfortunately relegated to PostScriptSeason.

to:

** The World of Revolution, which includes ''Anime/{{Daitarn3}}'', ''Anime/CodeGeass'', ''Anime/AuraBattlerDunbine'', and ''Anime/MobileSuitGundamWingEndlessWaltz'', had a lot of potential for an interesting story addition, but was all unfortunately relegated to PostScriptSeason. ''Code Geass'' only has [[spoiler:Marianne]] as the sole enemy unit to fight from its series while ''Daitarn3'' has no other units from its home series to battle whereas ''V'' at least had one enemy {{Mook}} unit along with Koros making an appearance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: Fans of the [[Anime/MobileSuitGundamF91 F91 Gundam]] were not happy that beam saber animation was changed from the spinning animation the Mass Produced version had in ''[[VideoGame/SuperRobotWarsV V]]'' to a more basic one. It does not help that ''[[VideoGame/SuperRobotWarsT T]]'' followed suit with this animation too. [[Anime/ShinMazinger Mazinger Z]] suffers from a similar issue where its new Breast Fire animation makes it look a bit OffModel compared to the animation in ''V''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** When it came to the main protagonist units, the Xelguard and its mechanics are considered an improvement compared to the [[VideoGame/SuperRobotWarsV Vangray]] and later the [[Videogame/SuperRobotWarsT Tyranado]] and both their upgraded forms. This is because ''X'' focused on having one protagonist unit to have multiple attacks with really good animations compared to making multiple protagonist units with only a few attacks each.

Changed: 87

Removed: 1040

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misuse. These "wasted" tropes are used when an idea or character already present in the work isn't used to its full potential. You can't used for entirely new ideas that were never present in the work in first place.


*** In addition, the entire world they originate from, which also includes ''Anime/{{Daitarn3}}'', ''Anime/CodeGeass'' and ''Anime/MobileSuitGundamWingEndlessWaltz'', had a lot of potential for an interesting story addition, but was all unfortunately relegated to PostScriptSeason.
** Similarly, ''Mashin Hero Wataru'' was heavily integrated into Al-Warth's fantasy setting. Alongside the [[VideoGame/SuperRobotWarsGaiden Cybuster]] as a GuestFighter, some players lamented ''Manga/MagicKnightRayearth'' was excluded from this {{Crossover}} (until its debut in ''VideoGame/SuperRobotWarsT'') when there was potential for an AdaptationOriginConnection (the "[[Manga/MagicKnightRayearth Rune-Gods]]" are [[DubNameChange also called]] {{Anime/Mashin|HeroWataruSeries}} (魔神)[[note]]It can also be [[UsefulNotes/JapaneseRomanization transliterated]] as ''{{Anime/Mazin|gerZ}}'' and yes, the two characters mean "Devil" and "God" respectively.[[/note]] in their anime's original Japanese, and the Cybuster's ElementalPowers are similar to Rune-Gods'); per ContestedSequel, the detached series debuts might have benefitted more in another game. {{Discussed}} by WordOfGod in a radio interview post-''T'' - if B.B. Studio makes a fantasy-oriented ''Super Robot Wars'', ''Wataru'' and ''Rayearth'' will likely be in the same title.

to:

*** In addition, the entire world they originate from, ** The World of Revolution, which also includes ''Anime/{{Daitarn3}}'', ''Anime/CodeGeass'' ''Anime/CodeGeass'', ''Anime/AuraBattlerDunbine'', and ''Anime/MobileSuitGundamWingEndlessWaltz'', had a lot of potential for an interesting story addition, but was all unfortunately relegated to PostScriptSeason.
** Similarly, ''Mashin Hero Wataru'' was heavily integrated into Al-Warth's fantasy setting. Alongside the [[VideoGame/SuperRobotWarsGaiden Cybuster]] as a GuestFighter, some players lamented ''Manga/MagicKnightRayearth'' was excluded from this {{Crossover}} (until its debut in ''VideoGame/SuperRobotWarsT'') when there was potential for an AdaptationOriginConnection (the "[[Manga/MagicKnightRayearth Rune-Gods]]" are [[DubNameChange also called]] {{Anime/Mashin|HeroWataruSeries}} (魔神)[[note]]It can also be [[UsefulNotes/JapaneseRomanization transliterated]] as ''{{Anime/Mazin|gerZ}}'' and yes, the two characters mean "Devil" and "God" respectively.[[/note]] in their anime's original Japanese, and the Cybuster's ElementalPowers are similar to Rune-Gods'); per ContestedSequel, the detached series debuts might have benefitted more in another game. {{Discussed}} by WordOfGod in a radio interview post-''T'' - if B.B. Studio makes a fantasy-oriented ''Super Robot Wars'', ''Wataru'' and ''Rayearth'' will likely be in the same title.
PostScriptSeason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicking Just For Pun


** How certain individual series were handled: while returning entries such as ''Cross Ange'' were generally perceived as well done, as ''X'' showed a greater willingness to experiment with its roster and their respective plots for a {{Crossover}}, the portrayal of ''Reconguista in G'' and ''Anime/BuddyComplex'' has received less positive reception; made worse by how this game was the latter two's debut in ''Super Robot Wars''. [[note]]''Reconguista in G'' ended up having little-to-no changes for its story or to the overall game, and could easily be replaced by a different series if need be. ''Buddy Complex'' is a more [[JustForPun complex]] situation, bordering on BrokenBase.[[/note]]

to:

** How certain individual series were handled: while returning entries such as ''Cross Ange'' were generally perceived as well done, as ''X'' showed a greater willingness to experiment with its roster and their respective plots for a {{Crossover}}, the portrayal of ''Reconguista in G'' and ''Anime/BuddyComplex'' has received less positive reception; made worse by how this game was the latter two's debut in ''Super Robot Wars''. [[note]]''Reconguista in G'' ended up having little-to-no changes for its story or to the overall game, and could easily be replaced by a different series if need be. ''Buddy Complex'' is a more [[JustForPun [[{{Pun}} complex]] situation, bordering on BrokenBase.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** In addition, the entire world they originate from, which also includes ''Anime/{{Daitarn3}}'', ''Anime/CodeGeass'' and ''Anime/MobileSuitGundamWingEndlessWaltz'', had a lot of potential for an interesting story addition, but was all unfortunately relegated to PostScriptSeason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** How certain individual series were handled: while returning entries such as ''Cross Ange'' were generally percieved as well done, as ''X'' showed a greater willingness to experiment with its roster and their respective plots for a {{Crossover}}, the portrayal of ''Reconguista in G'' and ''Anime/BuddyComplex'' has received less positive reception; made worse by how this game was the latter two's debut in ''Super Robot Wars''.

to:

** How certain individual series were handled: while returning entries such as ''Cross Ange'' were generally percieved perceived as well done, as ''X'' showed a greater willingness to experiment with its roster and their respective plots for a {{Crossover}}, the portrayal of ''Reconguista in G'' and ''Anime/BuddyComplex'' has received less positive reception; made worse by how this game was the latter two's debut in ''Super Robot Wars''.Wars''. [[note]]''Reconguista in G'' ended up having little-to-no changes for its story or to the overall game, and could easily be replaced by a different series if need be. ''Buddy Complex'' is a more [[JustForPun complex]] situation, bordering on BrokenBase.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StockFootageFailure: As a LateArrivalSpoiler, [[Anime/CrossAnge Salamandinay]] appears in Enryugo's ''Convergence Cannon "Seiran"'' SuperMovePortraitAttack during the times when she's supposed to be BehindTheBlack. This seems to be an oversight since the cut-in for ''Photon Sword "Tenrai"'' does not appear when she's an enemy unit just like in ''V''.

to:

* StockFootageFailure: As a LateArrivalSpoiler, [[Anime/CrossAnge Salamandinay]] appears in Enryugo's ''Convergence Cannon "Seiran"'' SuperMovePortraitAttack during the times when she's supposed to be BehindTheBlack.BehindTheBlack, her name being listed as '???' along with her character biography being unaccessible by the player. This seems to be an oversight since the cut-in for ''Photon Sword "Tenrai"'' does not appear when she's an enemy unit just like in ''V''.

Added: 505

Changed: 67

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScrappyMechanic: Like ''Super Robot Wars V'', the final attacks for the Nu Gundam, Zeta Gundam, and ZZ Gundam are locked towards their canon Universal Century pilots [[Anime/MobileSuitGundamCharsCounterattack Amuro Ray]], [[Anime/MobileSuitZetaGundam Kamille Bidan]], and [[Anime/MobileSuitGundamZZ Judau Ashta]], respectively, disallowing players from using these machines for anyone else to their full potential.

to:

* ScrappyMechanic: Like ''Super Robot Wars V'', the final attacks for the Nu Gundam, Zeta Gundam, and ZZ Gundam are locked towards their canon Universal Century pilots [[Anime/MobileSuitGundamCharsCounterattack Amuro Ray]], [[Anime/MobileSuitZetaGundam Kamille Bidan]], and [[Anime/MobileSuitGundamZZ Judau Ashta]], respectively, disallowing players from using these machines for anyone else to their full potential. Similarly, the Billbine's strongest attack is locked to Show Zama.


Added DiffLines:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Zabine Chareux from ''Anime/MobileSuitGundamF91'' would have made an interesting addition for the plot of ''Gundam F91'' and ''Manga/MobileSuitCrossboneGundam'', giving Seabook and Cecily a recurring enemy to battle and Tobia relevance by seeing and fighting this past version of Zabine. Instead, the only Crossbone Vanguard enemy fought is Iron Mask while Tobia is left with almost no relevance to the plot outside of meeting the ''F91'' version of Kincaid and Berah.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[Anime/CodeGeass Lelouch]] x Ange is another popular pairing due to the close similarities between them. It helps a lot with how supportive Lelouch is towards Ange throughout the game.

to:

** [[Anime/CodeGeass Lelouch]] x Ange is another popular pairing due to the close similarities between them. It helps a lot with how supportive Lelouch is towards Ange throughout the game.game, and that in the ending Lelouch chooses to stay in Al-Warth (with the ''Cross Ange'' characters being from Al-Warth in this continuity), leading to a lot potential future interactions for the fans to imagine (such as Lelouch visiting Cafe Ange, or helping out rebuilding the Misurugi nation).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[Anime/CodeGeass Lelouch]] x Ange is another popular pairing due to the close similarities between them.

to:

** [[Anime/CodeGeass Lelouch]] x Ange is another popular pairing due to the close similarities between them. It helps a lot with how supportive Lelouch is towards Ange throughout the game.

Changed: 480

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: [[BigBad Ende The Devourer]] is a Divine Beast and [[GodIsEvil the creator of Al-Warth]], populating it with survivors of the war against the [[Anime/TengenToppaGurrenLagann Anti-Spiral]] to [[EmotionEater feed on their emotions]]--developing a taste for negative emotions while seeing positive emotions as mere condiments--while also taking advantage of the ignorance of the AI [[Anime/TheBraveExpressMightGaine Black Noir]] to have it manipulate events for him. Ende also uses his worshippers, the [[MagicalSociety Keepers of Order]] to manipulate events inside Al-Warth while also training sorcerers in hopes to find someone who could become part of Ende's future body. When the Keepers start to summon people from other worlds to bring war to Al-Warth and the creature meant to become his new self escapes, Ende summons more otherworlders to cause more conflict and [[TheCorrupter corrupts]] the sorcerer Celric Obsidian into a unhinged berserker who murders his superior to become The Founder and uses the Keepers of Order to attack people. When X-Cross, a group with many otherworlders, defeats the Anti-Spiral and Black Noir, Ende appears in front of them to tell them that now, he plans to invade their homeworlds to feast on the emotions of its people before [[PlanetEater devouring Al-Warth]] in front of the X-Cross.

to:

* CompleteMonster: [[BigBad Ende The the Devourer]] is a Divine Beast and [[GodIsEvil the creator of Al-Warth]], Al-Warth, populating it with survivors of the war against the [[Anime/TengenToppaGurrenLagann Anti-Spiral]] to [[EmotionEater feed on their emotions]]--developing a taste for negative emotions while seeing positive emotions as mere condiments--while also taking advantage of the ignorance of the AI [[Anime/TheBraveExpressMightGaine Black Noir]] to have it manipulate events for him. Ende also uses his worshippers, the [[MagicalSociety Keepers of Order]] to manipulate events inside Al-Warth while also training sorcerers in hopes to find someone who could become part of a suitable host for Ende's future body. When the Keepers start to summon people from other worlds to bring war to Al-Warth and the creature meant to become his new self escapes, Ende summons more otherworlders to cause more conflict and [[TheCorrupter corrupts]] corrupts the sorcerer Celric Obsidian into a an unhinged berserker who murders his superior to become The Founder and uses the Keepers of Order to attack people. When X-Cross, a group with many otherworlders, X-Cross defeats both the Anti-Spiral and Black Noir, Ende appears in front of them to tell them that now, he plans to invade their homeworlds to feast on the emotions of its people before [[PlanetEater devouring Al-Warth]] in front of the X-Cross.X-Cross. Revived in the [[VideoGame/SuperRobotWarsT New Universal Era]] thanks to [[Manga/MagicKnightRayearth Debonair]]'s machinations, Ende would himself revive and corrupt System Nevanlinna, seeking to drag both the X-Cross and the Earth Fleet Tenku into the New Universal Era so he can devour them for the sake of revenge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been reworked by TRS into Not So Different Remark


** Similarly, ''Mashin Hero Wataru'' was heavily integrated into Al-Warth's fantasy setting. Alongside the [[VideoGame/SuperRobotWarsGaiden Cybuster]] as a GuestFighter, some players lamented ''Manga/MagicKnightRayearth'' was excluded from this {{Crossover}} (until its debut in ''VideoGame/SuperRobotWarsT'') when there was potential for an AdaptationOriginConnection (the "[[Manga/MagicKnightRayearth Rune-Gods]]" are [[DubNameChange also called]] {{Anime/Mashin|HeroWataruSeries}} (魔神)[[note]]It can also be [[UsefulNotes/JapaneseRomanization transliterated]] as ''{{Anime/Mazin|gerZ}}'' and yes, the two characters mean "Devil" and "God" respectively.[[/note]] in their anime's original Japanese, and the Cybuster's ElementalPowers are NotSoDifferent from the Rune-Gods'); per ContestedSequel, the detached series debuts might have benefitted more in another game. {{Discussed}} by WordOfGod in a radio interview post-''T'' - if B.B. Studio makes a fantasy-oriented ''Super Robot Wars'', ''Wataru'' and ''Rayearth'' will likely be in the same title.

to:

** Similarly, ''Mashin Hero Wataru'' was heavily integrated into Al-Warth's fantasy setting. Alongside the [[VideoGame/SuperRobotWarsGaiden Cybuster]] as a GuestFighter, some players lamented ''Manga/MagicKnightRayearth'' was excluded from this {{Crossover}} (until its debut in ''VideoGame/SuperRobotWarsT'') when there was potential for an AdaptationOriginConnection (the "[[Manga/MagicKnightRayearth Rune-Gods]]" are [[DubNameChange also called]] {{Anime/Mashin|HeroWataruSeries}} (魔神)[[note]]It can also be [[UsefulNotes/JapaneseRomanization transliterated]] as ''{{Anime/Mazin|gerZ}}'' and yes, the two characters mean "Devil" and "God" respectively.[[/note]] in their anime's original Japanese, and the Cybuster's ElementalPowers are NotSoDifferent from the similar to Rune-Gods'); per ContestedSequel, the detached series debuts might have benefitted more in another game. {{Discussed}} by WordOfGod in a radio interview post-''T'' - if B.B. Studio makes a fantasy-oriented ''Super Robot Wars'', ''Wataru'' and ''Rayearth'' will likely be in the same title.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
After thinking about it, I actually think this can work if it's reframed a bit.

Added DiffLines:

* CommonKnowledge: While the game's setting is tailor-made for ''[[Anime/MashinHeroWataruSeries Mashin Hero Wataru]]'', and it can be argued that a number of other series [[TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot got the short end of the stick]], the extent to which ''Wataru'' is a SpotlightStealingCrossover is often exaggerated by the game's detractors:
** Even within the ''Wataru''-centric setting, ''Anime/CrossAnge'' fits with very little compromise required and is very well-represented plotwise. ''Code Geass'' is pretty much the only series that gets a PostScriptSeason plot that wasn't already in numerous ''Super Robot Wars'' games by the time ''X'' released. While ''G-Reco'' and ''Buddy Complex'' suffer from having to work around Al-Warth, the most infamous plot change between them ([[spoiler:Embryo starting the ''Buddy Complex'' plot out of pure pettiness]]) can be blamed on ''Cross Ange'', not ''Wataru''.
** Doakdar was on the lower chain of SortingAlgorithmOfEvil, located below [[Anime/TengenToppaGurrenLagann the Anti-Spiral]], [[Anime/TheBraveExpressMightGaine Black Noir]] and [[FinalBoss Ende the Devourer]], all of them using his advance for their own gain, and once Wataru got rid of him, his plotline was basically done and none of the rest of the series BigBad suddenly put their crosshairs on him. It is essentially the opposite of ''Anime/SpaceBattleshipYamato2199''[='=]s treatment in ''VideoGame/SuperRobotWarsV'', which heavily took the spotlight for the beginning and end of the game but fell into the background during the middle of the game.
** While Wataru did start the softening of Ange, it was only at the beginning; Lelouch and Nadia handled the rest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just because the Wataru plot ends five stages early doesn't change that the entire setting of the game was rather blatantly created specifically for it, with almost every other series requiring varying levels on contrivance (arguably moreso than the average Super Robot Wars game) to fit. It still fits the bill for a Spotlight Stealing Crossover.


* CommonKnowledge: Contrary to what many would say about the game, [[Anime/MashinHeroWataruSeries Wataru]] was not the SpotlightStealingSquad of the series. Those who actually played the game would eventually notice that:
** Doakdar was on the lower chain of SortingAlgorithmOfEvil, located below [[Anime/TengenToppaGurrenLagann the Anti-Spiral]], [[Anime/TheBraveExpressMightGaine Black Noir]] and [[FinalBoss Ende the Devourer]], all of them using his advance for their own gain, and once Wataru got rid of him, his plotline was basically done and none of the rest of the series BigBad suddenly put their crosshairs on him. Thus, Wataru's story had more or less similar weight like the rest of the stories.
** While he did start the softening of Ange, it was only at the beginning; Lelouch and Nadia handled the rest.
** The twist was that if this was a normal Isekai genre story, Wataru would've been TheHero (and seeing that ''X'' is a homage to the Isekai genre that was getting popular during its year of release, people would've looked at the more likely Isekai hero character first), but the story designed all along that the one who'd usually be stuck in the supporting guardian/mentor role in a normal Isekai genre story (the main characters Iori/Amari) is the main character of the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CommonKnowledge: Contrary to what many would say about the game, [[Anime/MashinHeroWataruSeries Wataru]] was not the SpotlightStealingSquad of the series. Those who actually played the game would eventually notice that:
** Doakdar was on the lower chain of SortingAlgorithmOfEvil, located below [[Anime/TengenToppaGurrenLagann the Anti-Spiral]], [[Anime/TheBraveExpressMightGaine Black Noir]] and [[FinalBoss Ende the Devourer]], all of them using his advance for their own gain, and once Wataru got rid of him, his plotline was basically done and none of the rest of the series BigBad suddenly put their crosshairs on him. Thus, Wataru's story had more or less similar weight like the rest of the stories.
** While he did start the softening of Ange, it was only at the beginning; Lelouch and Nadia handled the rest.
** The twist was that if this was a normal Isekai genre story, Wataru would've been TheHero (and seeing that ''X'' is a homage to the Isekai genre that was getting popular during its year of release, people would've looked at the more likely Isekai hero character first), but the story designed all along that the one who'd usually be stuck in the supporting guardian/mentor role in a normal Isekai genre story (the main characters Iori/Amari) is the main character of the story.

Added: 1346

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Approved by the thread.

Added DiffLines:

* CompleteMonster: [[BigBad Ende The Devourer]] is a Divine Beast and [[GodIsEvil the creator of Al-Warth]], populating it with survivors of the war against the [[Anime/TengenToppaGurrenLagann Anti-Spiral]] to [[EmotionEater feed on their emotions]]--developing a taste for negative emotions while seeing positive emotions as mere condiments--while also taking advantage of the ignorance of the AI [[Anime/TheBraveExpressMightGaine Black Noir]] to have it manipulate events for him. Ende also uses his worshippers, the [[MagicalSociety Keepers of Order]] to manipulate events inside Al-Warth while also training sorcerers in hopes to find someone who could become part of Ende's future body. When the Keepers start to summon people from other worlds to bring war to Al-Warth and the creature meant to become his new self escapes, Ende summons more otherworlders to cause more conflict and [[TheCorrupter corrupts]] the sorcerer Celric Obsidian into a unhinged berserker who murders his superior to become The Founder and uses the Keepers of Order to attack people. When X-Cross, a group with many otherworlders, defeats the Anti-Spiral and Black Noir, Ende appears in front of them to tell them that now, he plans to invade their homeworlds to feast on the emotions of its people before [[PlanetEater devouring Al-Warth]] in front of the X-Cross.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Only applies to the work causing the tough act to follow. Not those effected by it.


* ToughActToFollow: ''V'' was lauded for its work in the narrative department, but the story-telling quality in ''X'' is [[BrokenBase/SuperRobotWars divided]], whether one believes the LighterAndSofter elements in this game made it inferior to ''V'' or not.
** Likewise, but to a smaller extent, the reception to the Hi-Nu Gundam's animations was very mixed - not out of poor quality or execution, but because it had to follow up on the highly praised "Arios-san"'s Nu Gundam animations from the ''Z series'' and ''V'' with a different artist and animation style, not helped by the fact that both units are present for a back-to-back comparison.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Likewise, but to a smaller extent, the reception to the Hi-Nu Gundam's animations was very mixed - not out of poor quality or execution, but because it had to follow up on the highly praised "Arios-san"'s Nu Gundam animations from the ''Z series'' and ''V'' with a different artist and animation style, not helped by the fact that both units are present for a back-to-back comparison.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The game has a lot of interactions between Ange and Wataru and it's one of the many reasons why Ange mellows down considerably, leading fans to pair them up as an IntergenerationalFriendship type.

to:

** The game has a lot of interactions between Ange and Wataru and it's one of the many reasons why Ange mellows down considerably, leading fans to pair them up as an IntergenerationalFriendship type. Salamandinay is also included due to her fawning over the Savior.

Added: 190

Removed: 182

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{HSQ}}: [[spoiler:The sub-pilot of the OriginalGeneration mecha that has been with players since the beginning of the game becomes the TrueFinalBoss]]. ''No one'' saw that coming.


Added DiffLines:

* ShockingMoments: [[spoiler:The sub-pilot of the OriginalGeneration mecha that has been with players since the beginning of the game becomes the TrueFinalBoss]]. ''No one'' saw that coming.

Top