Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / JasonNewsted

Go To

OR

Added: 560

Changed: 557

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MisBlamed: Jason is frequently blamed for the LighterAndSofter nineties Music/{{Metallica}} albums, with cries of "Cliff would have never allowed this to happen," being frequent among old-school fans. This is despite all evidence pointing to Jason being the most hardcore metalhead in the band and the fact that James, Lars, and Kirk all credit Cliff as the one who expanded their musical tastes beyond simplistic thrash metal. Not to mention the fact that Jason had one writing credit between the ''Load'' and ''Reload'' albums, and only one on the self-titled album.

to:

* MisBlamed: MisBlamed:
**
Jason is frequently blamed for the LighterAndSofter nineties Music/{{Metallica}} albums, with cries of "Cliff would have never allowed this to happen," being frequent among old-school fans. This is despite all evidence pointing to Jason being the most hardcore metalhead in the band and the fact that James, Lars, and Kirk all credit Cliff as the one who expanded their musical tastes beyond simplistic thrash metal. Not to mention the fact that Jason had one writing credit between the ''Load'' and ''Reload'' albums, and only one on the self-titled album.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
tropes the person, not his music


* IronWoobie: Jason is the epitome of this: Starting off as the AscendedFanboy of Metallica only to be treated like complete trash for the next fourteen years by them ''and'' the fans for being the replacement to the beloved Cliff Burton until he finally quit before the recording of ''St. Anger''. And despite all of that, he still kicks it with the music and he shown to have no resentment towards his ex band mates. And despite constantly being heavily unlucky, he ''[[{{Determinator}} never gives up]]''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IronWoobie: Jason is the epitome of this: Starting off as the AscendedFanboy of Metallica only to be treated like complete trash for the next fourteen years by them ''and'' the fans for being the replacement to the beloved Cliff Burton until he finally quit before the recording of ''St. Anger''. And despite all of that, he still kicks it with the music and he shown to have no resentment towards his ex band mates.

to:

* IronWoobie: Jason is the epitome of this: Starting off as the AscendedFanboy of Metallica only to be treated like complete trash for the next fourteen years by them ''and'' the fans for being the replacement to the beloved Cliff Burton until he finally quit before the recording of ''St. Anger''. And despite all of that, he still kicks it with the music and he shown to have no resentment towards his ex band mates. And despite constantly being heavily unlucky, he ''[[{{Determinator}} never gives up]]''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IronWoobie: Jason is the epitome of this: Starting off as the AscendedFanboy of Metallica only to be treated like complete trash for the next fourteen years by them ''and'' the fans for being the replacement to the beloved Cliff Burton until he finally quit before the recording of ''St. Anger''. And despite all of that, he still kicks it with the music and he shown to have no resentment towards his ex band mates.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fan Dumb & Hate Dumb are now part of Flame Bait. Only in-universe examples are allowed.


* MisBlamed: Jason is frequently blamed for the LighterAndSofter nineties Music/{{Metallica}} albums, with cries of "Cliff would have never allowed this to happen," being frequent among old-school fans. This is [[HateDumb despite all evidence pointing to Jason being the most hardcore metalhead in the band and the fact that James, Lars, and Kirk all credit Cliff as the one who expanded their musical tastes beyond simplistic thrash metal]]. Not to mention the fact that Jason had one writing credit between the ''Load'' and ''Reload'' albums, and only one on the self-titled album.

to:

* MisBlamed: Jason is frequently blamed for the LighterAndSofter nineties Music/{{Metallica}} albums, with cries of "Cliff would have never allowed this to happen," being frequent among old-school fans. This is [[HateDumb despite all evidence pointing to Jason being the most hardcore metalhead in the band and the fact that James, Lars, and Kirk all credit Cliff as the one who expanded their musical tastes beyond simplistic thrash metal]].metal. Not to mention the fact that Jason had one writing credit between the ''Load'' and ''Reload'' albums, and only one on the self-titled album.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SignatureSong: {{Music/Metallica}}'s "Whiplash." Despite the fact that Jason did not play on the album on which it appeared, he made the song his own during his time in the band and still plays it in his own band.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ReplacementScrappy: For effectively all the time he spent in Music/{{Metallica}}.
** AlasPoorScrappy: After he left. In keeping with the band's UnpleasableFanbase, after spending 14 years as the Replacement Scrappy, he left, only for some of those fans to suddenly decide he really was very talented and how terrible it was that the other members mistreated him like they did.
* TheWoobie: Alas, poor Jason Newsted. He had the dubious honor of joining the band immediately after the death of Cliff Burton, and he had to take the brunt of both band and fan angst about the tragedy full on. Poor guy took a lot of Fan Hate simply for ''not being Cliff Burton''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EpicRiff: King of the Underdogs, Soldierhead, Heroic Dose, Long Time Dead, ...As the Crow Flies, Nocturnus, Kindevillusion, The Differents, and the bass solo at the end of Ampossible. The whole of ''Heavy Metal Music'' is a very riff-oriented album.

to:

* EpicRiff: King of the Underdogs, Soldierhead, Heroic Dose, Long Time Dead, ...As the Crow Flies, Nocturnus, Kindevillusion, The Differents, and the bass solo at the end of Ampossible. The whole of ''Heavy Metal Music'' is a very riff-oriented album. Jason also mentions that the riff to Futureality has stuck with him for years before he ever recorded or wrote it down.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EpicRiff: "King of the Underdogs," "Soldierhead," "Heroic Dose," "...As the Crow Flies," "Nocturnus," "Kindevillusion," and the bass solo at the end of "Ampossible."

to:

* EpicRiff: "King King of the Underdogs," "Soldierhead," "Heroic Dose," "...Underdogs, Soldierhead, Heroic Dose, Long Time Dead, ...As the Crow Flies," "Nocturnus," "Kindevillusion," Flies, Nocturnus, Kindevillusion, The Differents, and the bass solo at the end of "Ampossible."Ampossible. The whole of ''Heavy Metal Music'' is a very riff-oriented album.



** AlasPoorScrappy: After he left. In keeping with the band's Unpleasable Fanbase, after spending 14 years as the Replacement Scrappy, he left, only for some of those fans to suddenly decide he really was very talented and how terrible it was that the other members mistreated him like they did.

to:

** AlasPoorScrappy: After he left. In keeping with the band's Unpleasable Fanbase, UnpleasableFanbase, after spending 14 years as the Replacement Scrappy, he left, only for some of those fans to suddenly decide he really was very talented and how terrible it was that the other members mistreated him like they did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MisBlamed: Jason is frequently blamed for the LighterAndSofter nineties Metallica albums, with cries of "Cliff would have never allowed this to happen," being frequent among old-school fans. This is [[HateDumb despite all evidence pointing to Jason being the most hardcore metalhead in the band and the fact that James, Lars, and Kirk all credit Cliff as the one who expanded their musical tastes beyond simplistic thrash metal]]. Not to mention the fact that Jason had one writing credit between the ''Load'' and ''Reload'' albums, and only one on the self-titled album.

to:

* MisBlamed: Jason is frequently blamed for the LighterAndSofter nineties Metallica Music/{{Metallica}} albums, with cries of "Cliff would have never allowed this to happen," being frequent among old-school fans. This is [[HateDumb despite all evidence pointing to Jason being the most hardcore metalhead in the band and the fact that James, Lars, and Kirk all credit Cliff as the one who expanded their musical tastes beyond simplistic thrash metal]]. Not to mention the fact that Jason had one writing credit between the ''Load'' and ''Reload'' albums, and only one on the self-titled album.



* ReplacementScrappy: For effectively all the time he spent in Metallica.

to:

* ReplacementScrappy: For effectively all the time he spent in Metallica.Music/{{Metallica}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArchivePanic: [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_songs_recorded_by_Jason_Newsted He requires a very long page on Wikipedia]] to list how many songs he's been a part of.
* EpicRiff: "King of the Underdogs," "Soldierhead," "Heroic Dose," "...As the Crow Flies," "Nocturnus," "Kindevillusion," and the bass solo at the end of "Ampossible."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MisBlamed: Jason is frequently blamed for the LighterAndSofter nineties Metallica albums, with cries of "Cliff would have never allowed this to happen," being frequent among old-school fans. This is [[HateDumb despite all evidence pointing to Jason being the most hardcore metalhead in the band and the fact that James, Lars, and Kirk all credit Cliff as the one who expanded their musical tastes beyond simplistic thrash metal]]. Not to mention the fact that Jason had one writing credit between the ''Load'' and ''Reload'' albums, and only one on the self-titled album.
*** This is all true about Jason, but Kirk did say something to the effect that ''St. Anger'' was in a sense Jason's vision for where the band would go, but he was the "sacrificial lamb" for that to happen. Presumably, though, he wanted it without the outlandishly terrible sound.
** The lack of bass on ''...And Justice for All'' is often accused of being an act of hazing towards Jason by James and Lars. Producer Flemming Rasmussen, who was not present for the mixing, indeed [[http://www.soundonsound.com/sos/may11/articles/classic-tracks-0511.htm claims the first thing James and Lars demanded on hearing the initial mixes was that the bass be turned down]]. Ultimately, mixers Steven Thompson and Mike Barbiero "scooped" James' guitar tone (cut the middle tones out, leaving only highs and lows), Jason messed up on the bass lines (doubling the guitar parts, rather than following the kick drum as taught in Bass 101), and mixing the bass to normal levels (for Metallica; even before Jason they weren't a bass-heavy band, and switching from a finger bassist to a pick bassist made for louder bass at the same mixer levels) would have drowned out the low part of James's rhythm guitar. The result made Rasmussen joke that "Jason, Toby [Wright, engineer] and I are probably the only people who know what the bass parts actually sounded like on that album." Thankfully, a version that restores the bass can be found online, named ''And Justice for Jason'', although it muddles up the low end, and Jason's pick slapping gets annoying enough after several tracks to think James and Lars may have had a point.
*** Newsted admitted his mistakes when he appeared on the first 2013 episode of ''Series/ThatMetalShow'' and the issue was brought up. He said that he recorded his parts by himself with no input from anyone else, using the same equipment, bass, and engineers that he used in his former band Flotsam and Jetsam. Also, since he wrote the music in F&J and the guitarists took their cues from him, his bass parts on ''Justice'' were too much like a rhythm guitar, and ended up clashing both note-wise and sonically with Hetfield's actual rhythm guitar parts.
* ReplacementScrappy: For effectively all the time he spent in Metallica.
** AlasPoorScrappy: After he left. In keeping with the band's Unpleasable Fanbase, after spending 14 years as the Replacement Scrappy, he left, only for some of those fans to suddenly decide he really was very talented and how terrible it was that the other members mistreated him like they did.
* TheWoobie: Alas, poor Jason Newsted. He had the dubious honor of joining the band immediately after the death of Cliff Burton, and he had to take the brunt of both band and fan angst about the tragedy full on. Poor guy took a lot of Fan Hate simply for ''not being Cliff Burton''.

Top