YMMV / Gentle Giant

  • Awesome Music: Their first eight albums qualify from start to finish. Some people also throw in The Missing Piece, Giant for a Day!, and Civilian. As for live material, Playing the Fool is among the greatest prog live albums ever made.
  • Broken Base: The Gentle Giant fanbase is torn as to which of their eleven albums is considered their best. Popular choices include Acquiring the Taste, Octopus, In a Glass House, The Power and the Glory, Free Hand, and occasionally Interview.
    • The quality of the band's last three albums. Some say that the new-wave influenced direction was the band selling out and putting fame over music, while others say the albums are quite good and reveal a unique side of the band that was never fully explored.
    • Interview. For some, it's the last great Gentle Giant record before their last three pop albums, while for others it's a mess of underdeveloped, derivative songs tied around a silly concept that showed the band struggling to rush an album out to sustain the momentum Free Hand had given them.
  • Ear Worm: For a complex song, "Talybont" can be seen as this.
    • Hell, even "Knots", "Wreck" or "Proclamation" are very catchy, really. Accomplished via slightly unusual tunes. It could be argued that Gentle Giant's one of the more catchy prog bands.
  • Epic Riff: This certainly qualifies.
  • Italians Love Gentle Giant: They were most popular in Italy. This was the case with many prog bands; somehow Italy really took into the genre.
  • Love It or Hate It: Gentle Giant, like many progressive rock bands, has their share of supporters and detractors. Supporters hail them as being one of the genre's most underrated bands with complex musicianship that blows even the genre's major figures like Yes and Genesis out of the water. Others contend that they suffer from the same excess and pretentiousness as those same bands, if not more so, with certain aspects of their music (dissonance, odd vocal harmonies, Derek Shulman's singing, etc.) being either loved or criticized.
  • Nightmare Fuel: The vocal bridge of "Pantagruel's Nativity".
    • Also the spooky "Alucard".
  • Suspiciously Similar Song: The title track off of Interview is often accused of sounding similar to "Proclamation" from The Power and the Glory. Both tracks have a similar keyboard jig feel to them, with similar tempos and vocals.
  • Tear Jerker: "The Moon Is Down", "Think of Me with Kindness", "His Last Voyage"