Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Blacksad

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Dill's nurse's body lying with cables around her neck. She spent most of ''They All Fall Down - Part Two'' knowing that this is what will happen if she can't keep Dill alive and having breakdowns over it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PopularWithFurries: ''Gee, what were the odds?'' Being a professional, high-quality comic book with anthropomorphic animals, it's no surprise that ''Blacksad'' has a substantial fanbase among the [[UsefulNotes/FurryFandom Furry Fandom]]. Albeit one that's overshadowed by more popular [=IPs.=]

to:

* PopularWithFurries: ''Gee, what were the odds?'' Being a professional, high-quality comic book with anthropomorphic animals, it's no surprise that ''Blacksad'' has a substantial fanbase among the [[UsefulNotes/FurryFandom Furry Fandom]]. Albeit UsefulNotes/FurryFandom, albeit one that's overshadowed by more popular [=IPs.=]

Added: 43

Removed: 43

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%** Kylie, her mother and her grandmother.


Added DiffLines:

%%** Kylie, her mother and her grandmother.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SugarWiki/NoProblemWithLicensedGames: ''Blacksad: Under The Skin'' is a strong adventure game with excellent voice acting, simple but good puzzles, and spot-on portrayals of the characters. It’s only real flaws are it’s fondness for quick-time events and sometimes long loading times.

to:

* SugarWiki/NoProblemWithLicensedGames: ''Blacksad: Under The Skin'' is a strong adventure game with excellent voice acting, simple but good puzzles, and spot-on portrayals of the characters. It’s only real flaws are it’s its fondness for quick-time events and sometimes long loading times.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StrangledByTheRedString: In "Red Soul", Blacksad meets Alma a few times, has sex with her once and then is suddenly planning to run away with her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Part 2 of They All Fall Down frequently gets lambasted for the lack of involvement or arcs in regard to Rachel Zucco or Alma Mayer, with the former [[LockedOutOfTheLoop practically remaining nonexistent to readers until the very end in a plot twist]], and the latter only making small appearances in the comic with a largely unresolved plotline with Blacksad in regards to their romance between them.

Added: 1622

Changed: 652

Removed: 511

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
a number of background characters have tails, it's random


** With Webcomic/{{Lackadaisy}}, a [[TheRoaringTwenties Prohibition-era]] comics where everyone is a fluffy cat. Both also have a black cat as one of the main characters.
** Has minor one with {{WesternAnimation/Zootopia}}.
* GeniusBonus: When explaining why his son couldn't possibly be a child's father in a phony blackmail case, one white tiger businessman in ''Arctic Nation'' points out that he's severely mentally retarded, which Blacksad attributes to inbreeding. Said son is a cheetah, and in real life, cheetahs ''are'' deeply inbred (due to a natural near-extinction event which reduced the population long ago). (Unfortunately, this renders Blacksad's "sometimes mixing isn't such a bad thing" racism metaphor a non-sequitur BrokenAesop, since that would indicate that even if he is married to someone within the same town's gene pool, it's not to another white animal.)

to:

** With Webcomic/{{Lackadaisy}}, ''Webcomic/{{Lackadaisy}},'' a [[TheRoaringTwenties Prohibition-era]] comics where everyone is a fluffy cat. Both also have a black cat as one of the main characters.
** Has minor one with {{WesternAnimation/Zootopia}}.
''{{WesternAnimation/Zootopia}}''.
* GeniusBonus: GeniusBonus:
**
When explaining why his son couldn't possibly be a child's father in a phony blackmail case, one white tiger businessman in ''Arctic Nation'' points out that he's severely mentally retarded, which Blacksad attributes to inbreeding. Said son is a cheetah, and in real life, cheetahs ''are'' deeply inbred (due to a natural near-extinction event which reduced the population long ago). (Unfortunately, this renders Blacksad's "sometimes mixing isn't such a bad thing" racism metaphor a non-sequitur BrokenAesop, since that would indicate that even if he is married to someone within the same town's gene pool, it's not to another white animal.))
** The main antagonist of "They All Fall Down", Solomon, is an industrialist politician who wants to modernize New York at any cost. He's shown as a peregrine falcon, which works not just with the [[BrutalBirdOfPrey vicious bird-of-prey]] image, but because the peregrine falcon is famously a predator that has achieved great success in adapting to hunt and survive in modern cityscapes like New York (as the towering skyscrapers mimic their natural cliff habitats).



* UnintentionalUncannyValley: There are a number of readers which dislike that the female characters (or at least those meant to be conventionally attractive) tend to be designed [[HumanoidFemaleAnimal with a more human-like appearance]] compared to males, which generally lean towards more animal-like or an even balance, as it results in designs which look ''almost'' human, but with weird skin patterns and noses, and seem out of place compared to the more animalistic designs that make up the vast majority.



* UnintentionalUncannyValley: A subtle variation that becomes hard to ignore once you notice it. For the most part, the characters look great... but they all seem to lack tails, despite being fully anthro animals. If you're used to other WorldOfFunnyAnimals settings that have said animals sporting tails, it can come as a shock when ''Blacksad'' has theirs being InexplicablyTailless. Made even more awkward by Huk, the arctic fox from the second book, being the only character to inexplicably ''have'' a tail.



** Kylie, her mother and her grandmother.

to:

** %%** Kylie, her mother and her grandmother.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved to Tear Jerker tab.


* TearJerker:
** Somewhere Within the Shadows: A bonus pic shows Blacksad sitting glumly in the Cypher Club, unaware that Natalia's ghost has her arms around him.
** Arctic Nation: As Blacksad sums up to Jezabel, yes, she got revenge on her father but her sister is dead and her niece is now an orphan.
** Red Soul: John's biggest chance at happiness, ruined by a corrupt senator.
** A Silent Hell: Sebastian dies without ever getting to meet his newborn son and the last time he ever saw Hannah, he yelled at her for telling Faust about "Pizen Blues".
** Amarillo: Neal's death, especially since Blacksad had come to see him as friend just like with Weekly and Neal commenting on how he could've had something with Donna.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SugarWiki/NoProblemWithLicensedGames: ''Blacksad: Under The Skin'' is a strong adventure game with excellent voice acting, simple but good puzzles, and spot-on portrayals of the characters. It’s only real flaws are it’s fondness for quick-time events and sometimes long loading times.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnintentionalUncannyValley: A subtle variation that becomes hard to ignore once you notice it. For the most part, the characters look great... but they all seem to lack tails, despite being fully anthro animals. If you're used to other WorldOfFunnyAnimals settings that have said animals sporting tails, it can come as a shock when ''Blacksad'' has theirs being InexplicablyTailless.

to:

* UnintentionalUncannyValley: A subtle variation that becomes hard to ignore once you notice it. For the most part, the characters look great... but they all seem to lack tails, despite being fully anthro animals. If you're used to other WorldOfFunnyAnimals settings that have said animals sporting tails, it can come as a shock when ''Blacksad'' has theirs being InexplicablyTailless. Made even more awkward by Huk, the arctic fox from the second book, being the only character to inexplicably ''have'' a tail.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UnintentionalUncannyValley: A subtle variation that becomes hard to ignore once you notice it. For the most part, the characters look great... but they all seem to lack tails, despite being fully anthro animals. If you're used to other WorldOfFunnyAnimals settings that have said animals sporting tails, it can come as a shock when ''Blacksad'' has theirs being InexplicablyTailless.

Added: 546

Changed: 735

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NightmareFuel: The trip that Blacksad has when he nearly drowns in ''A Silent Hell'', where he sees anthropomorphic animals dissected in what looks like a slaughterhouse.
* Logan nearly burning the face off of a union worker in ''They All Fall Down - Part One'' for daring to stand up against the don of the local mafia family. Even when he's forced to let go, he does so with a sadistic glee, leaving the poor man to clutch his smoldering face. Later, he nearly stabs Kenneth to death at a subway station. Blacksad is quick enough to stop him, but not quick enough to stop ''another'' hitman from pushing Kenneth into an oncoming train. Not a single drop of blood is shown, but the bystanders' reactions say it all.

to:

* NightmareFuel: NightmareFuel:
**
The trip that Blacksad has when he nearly drowns in ''A Silent Hell'', where he sees anthropomorphic animals dissected in what looks like a slaughterhouse.
* ** Logan nearly burning the face off of a union worker in ''They All Fall Down - Part One'' for daring to stand up against the don of the local mafia family. Even when he's forced to let go, he does so with a sadistic glee, leaving the poor man to clutch his smoldering face. Later, he nearly stabs Kenneth to death at a subway station. Blacksad is quick enough to stop him, but not quick enough to stop ''another'' hitman from pushing Kenneth into an oncoming train. Not a single drop of blood is shown, but the bystanders' reactions say it all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Amarillo: Neal's death, especially since Blacksad had come to see him as friend just like with Weekly and Neal commenting on how he could've had something with Donna.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Please bring to the Complete Monster proposal thrrad


** ''They All Fall Down - Part One'': Logan, the hitman for the mob running the transport workers union. Full stop. When one of the workers stands up to the mob boss, Logan grabs him by the nose and gleefully shoves his face into a pan of ''burning oil.'' He's so sadistic about it that even his own ''boss'' forces him to stop. Which he does. With a ''smile.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Narm}}: Blacksad ripping open [[spoiler:Jezebel's blouse to reveal the black patch on her chest]] was meant to be a DramaticReveal, but it seemingly came out of nowhere and the pure shock on her face made the initial moment into this.

to:

* {{Narm}}: Blacksad ripping open [[spoiler:Jezebel's blouse to reveal the black patch on her chest]] was meant to be a DramaticReveal, dramatic reveal, but it seemingly came out of nowhere and the pure shock on her face made the initial moment into this.



* PopularWithFurries: ''Gee, what were the odds?'' Being a professional, high-quality comic book with anthropomorphic animals, it's no surprise that ''Blacksad'' has a substantial fanbase among the [[UsefulNotes/FurryFandom Furry Fandom]]. Albeit one that's overshadowed by more popular IPs.

to:

* PopularWithFurries: ''Gee, what were the odds?'' Being a professional, high-quality comic book with anthropomorphic animals, it's no surprise that ''Blacksad'' has a substantial fanbase among the [[UsefulNotes/FurryFandom Furry Fandom]]. Albeit one that's overshadowed by more popular IPs.[=IPs.=]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Logan nearly burning the face off of a union worker in ''They All Fall Down - Part One'' for daring to stand up against the don of the local mafia family. Even when he's forced to let go, he does so with a sadistic glee, leaving the poor man to clutch his smoldering face. Later, he nearly stabs Kenneth to death at a subway station. Blacksad is quick enough to stop him, but not quick enough to stop ''another'' hitman from pushing Kenneth into an oncoming train. Not a single drop of blood is shown, but the bystanders' reactions say it all.

to:

** * Logan nearly burning the face off of a union worker in ''They All Fall Down - Part One'' for daring to stand up against the don of the local mafia family. Even when he's forced to let go, he does so with a sadistic glee, leaving the poor man to clutch his smoldering face. Later, he nearly stabs Kenneth to death at a subway station. Blacksad is quick enough to stop him, but not quick enough to stop ''another'' hitman from pushing Kenneth into an oncoming train. Not a single drop of blood is shown, but the bystanders' reactions say it all.



* PopularWithFurries: ''Gee, what were the odds?'' Being a professional, high-quality comic book with anthropomorphic animals, it's no surprise that ''Blacksad'' has a substantial fanbase among the [[UsefulNotes/FurryFandom Furry Fandom]].

to:

* PopularWithFurries: ''Gee, what were the odds?'' Being a professional, high-quality comic book with anthropomorphic animals, it's no surprise that ''Blacksad'' has a substantial fanbase among the [[UsefulNotes/FurryFandom Furry Fandom]]. Albeit one that's overshadowed by more popular IPs.

Added: 1125

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''They All Fall Down - Part One'': Logan, the hitman for the mob running the transport workers union. Full stop. When one of the workers stands up to the mob boss, Logan grabs him by the nose and gleefully shoves his face into a pan of ''burning oil.'' He's so sadistic about it that even his own ''boss'' forces him to stop. Which he does. With a ''smile.''



* HarsherInHindsight: The Arctic Nation is a little too reminiscent of the "Alt-Furry" movement: a very small, but very vocal minority of the [[UsefulNotes/FurryFandom Furry Fandom]] that embraces far-right ideologies.



** Smirnov's police colleagues are mostly dogs, but count among them [[WesternAnimation/{{Zootopia}} one fox with an incredibly smug smile]].
** The Arctic Nation being a KKK-inspired hate group who uses a snowflake as a symbol can come across as funny to modern readers due to the popularity of "snowflake" as an insult in far right circles.

to:

** Smirnov's police colleagues are mostly dogs, dogs but count among them [[WesternAnimation/{{Zootopia}} one fox with an incredibly smug smile]].
** The Arctic Nation being a KKK-inspired hate group who uses a snowflake as a symbol can come across as funny to modern readers due to the popularity of "snowflake" as an insult in far right far-right circles.


Added DiffLines:

** Logan nearly burning the face off of a union worker in ''They All Fall Down - Part One'' for daring to stand up against the don of the local mafia family. Even when he's forced to let go, he does so with a sadistic glee, leaving the poor man to clutch his smoldering face. Later, he nearly stabs Kenneth to death at a subway station. Blacksad is quick enough to stop him, but not quick enough to stop ''another'' hitman from pushing Kenneth into an oncoming train. Not a single drop of blood is shown, but the bystanders' reactions say it all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Somewhere Within the Shadows: A bonus pic shows Blacksad sitting glumly in the Cypher Club, unaware that Natalia's ghost has her arms around him.

to:

* ** Somewhere Within the Shadows: A bonus pic shows Blacksad sitting glumly in the Cypher Club, unaware that Natalia's ghost has her arms around him.

Added: 171

Changed: 519

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The end of album 2. The person behind it all realizes that VengeanceFeelsEmpty, and a little girl has lost her mother.
** And the end of album 3. John's biggest chance at happiness, ruined by a corrupt senator.
** And the end of album 4. The entire fate of the town of Caldonia, in fact. Even the villain dies miserably.

to:

** The end of album 2. The person behind it all realizes * Somewhere Within the Shadows: A bonus pic shows Blacksad sitting glumly in the Cypher Club, unaware that VengeanceFeelsEmpty, Natalia's ghost has her arms around him.
** Arctic Nation: As Blacksad sums up to Jezabel, yes, she got revenge on her father but her sister is dead
and a little girl has lost her mother.
niece is now an orphan.
** And the end of album 3. Red Soul: John's biggest chance at happiness, ruined by a corrupt senator.
** And the end of album 4. The entire fate of the town of Caldonia, in fact. Even the villain A Silent Hell: Sebastian dies miserably.without ever getting to meet his newborn son and the last time he ever saw Hannah, he yelled at her for telling Faust about "Pizen Blues".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** With Webcomic/{{Lackadaisy}}, a [[TheRoaringTwenties Prohibition-era]] comics where everyone is a fluffy cat.

to:

** With Webcomic/{{Lackadaisy}}, a [[TheRoaringTwenties Prohibition-era]] comics where everyone is a fluffy cat. Both also have a black cat as one of the main characters.

Top